Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

any teachers here - is the job unsustainable now

243 replies

teachertetherendof · 09/11/2026 15:11

Hello - career teacher- needing somewhere to rant
I am sick of every child (almost to a fault) arguing that they shouldn't do what you have asked - this is from the tiniest thing to the biggest things
Also today I have been physically shoved which will lead to no more than a day of isolation for the 15 year old that did it
What has happened to young people? We are literally at the point where even if you are warning a student about something dangerous to themselves - they don't listen- instead their default is to argue back first

It's exhausting

Also, I am not a strict or savage teacher- our school does not have lots of stupid rules- this is a really strong societal drift into this constant state. And no, it hasn't always happened- there has been a massive change in the last 8 years

OP posts:
teachertetherendof · 11/11/2026 05:54

FatBottomGirlz · 10/11/2026 22:31

This use of "your"was correct. Your = belonging to you
You're= you are ...
@teachertetherendof

This isn't right unfortunately

OP posts:
jumpingjohnny · 10/11/2026 22:33

FatBottomGirlz · 10/11/2026 22:31

This use of "your"was correct. Your = belonging to you
You're= you are ...
@teachertetherendof

You are welcome not your welcome.

The correction was valid.

FatBottomGirlz · 10/11/2026 22:31

teachertetherendof · 09/11/2026 16:54

you're

This use of "your"was correct. Your = belonging to you
You're= you are ...
@teachertetherendof

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 10/11/2026 22:23

Bonmot57 · 10/11/2026 08:52

An interesting analysis but one that falls victim to the ingrained and incorrect prejudice against Margaret Thatcher's government. She never said there was 'no such thing as society' in the misquoted magazine article. She was actually flagging up that people weren't taking responsibility for themselves and expected the government or 'society' to sort everything for them. Not my problem, mate. It's someone else's problem, etc.

If she were in power now, I would hope that those soft and feckless parents who unashamedly send in school age kids wearing nappies would face charges of neglect. It isn't and should never be a teacher's job to change nappies or make sure their charges brush their teeth!

I always blame Blair and his New Labour government. It was in his times that the economy changed to the rentier buy-to-let economy, giving a complete free hand to both national and globalised wealth with a few handouts to the poorest to win their support, continuing right to buy among other handouts. He began the two tier society and the change away from rewarding those who worked and followed rules and law. At first when it mostly affected working class people trying to work up no one in wider society cared much, proclaiming ‘we’re all middle class now’ and other such inane nonsense. Now the middle class are affected and no work pays for anyone any more, meritocracy is dead and there is little point to education or working hard.

WhyisntitFriday · 10/11/2026 22:04

teachertetherendof · 09/11/2026 17:02

Oh god this must be horrible

It is difficult to apportion time to deal with actual disruptive behaviour, when we have to pick up and log overly minor non-compliances. Some mete out numerous demerits which leads to friction and complaints. Some go the other way, which parents don’t complain about!! The idea works in theory, but in practice also wastes teaching time logging points and addressing non-disruptive behaviour. Meanwhile, the list of potential non-compliances gets longer and more inventive and the benefits of our merit/demerit system become increasingly diluted. I would love a common-sense middle ground!

CypressGrove · 10/11/2026 21:25

Sartre · 09/11/2026 16:21

Why would anyone choose to teach secondary age children? You can select primary when doing the PGCE, or even further education but go with teenagers of all young people?! I’m not sure what you expect.

Threads like this make me think other peoples schools must have been great in the 90/00s. Mine was like Lord of the Flies.

But the solution can't be that we don't have anyone teaching in secondary schools!

CousinBette · 10/11/2026 20:32

Brilliant post @AlertCat

Covid - I taught primary all the way through this and spent hours at home creating lessons for the school website (and parent guides and answer sheets). Also did zoom lessons 3 times a day. Most of our parents did their absolute best to help their children (partly because it was a welcome break from finding bored children things to do). These were often the parents who were fitting in lessons between their own jobs (nurse, shop staff, warehouse staff). However a significant number of parents on furlough just did not bother. Some even said to my face ‘well she didn’t want to do it and you can’t force them, can you?’ about children who would never have dared disobey me in a classroom situation.

… and then, once the schools opened to key workers’ children, or children we felt could not miss any more school (heads had discretion to invite these children in) some even said, ‘Well it’s not fair if not all their friends are going back’ and kept them at home.

There is a huge laziness in some parents these days. Maybe it does stem from smartphones / general disillusionment (suggested by a pp) but to teachers it often looks as if some parents are just too selfish and lazy to do the best they can for their own children. I know it’s a truism on mumsnet that all parents are doing their best, but a sizeable minority really are not.

AlertCat · 10/11/2026 09:57

@Bonmot57 i feel you missed my points in your haste to defend Thatcher (who I didn’t actually criticise).

cattypussclaw · 10/11/2026 09:34

Yup, I’ve just resigned after ten years at a TA. I wasn’t helping anyone learn anything, I was just crowd control.

Bonmot57 · 10/11/2026 08:52

AlertCat · 10/11/2026 08:00

I have an interesting perspective because I am a teacher in one (specialist) setting, and support staff in a mainstream secondary school. I started my teaching career nearly 20 years ago in a fairly challenging school, and I’ve done supply as well.

My theory has a few strands.
first, I think smart phones (and I got my first one about 12 years ago, I wasn’t an early adopter) have done terrible things to us. We are nearly all slightly addicted, and not only does this manifest as a loss or failure to develop concentration and perseverance, but I also think it’s creating a problem in very early childhood where parents are unpredictably responsive, as they might be in other addictions. You see, if a parent is on their phone a lot, the child or baby gets much less interaction, and those are crucial for attachment and brain development. Like in the Still Face experiment. So that strand has a couple of problematic elements.

Then there is the increasing sense of individualisation that started under the Thatcher government. She famously outlined why she felt society doesn’t really exist and why none of us have a responsibility to one another, and that’s so ingrained now. In education we see it in the drive over 20 years or so towards individualised learning plans, which creates a lot of additional work for teachers and also the ground for parents and students to argue that they need more special treatment. While the aim of these is laudable, in practice it makes the job really difficult to do well, partly because of workload and partly because of parents who see one person getting a special thing and demanding it for their kid (even though their kid doesn’t need it). In the specialist unit I work at, we see the same thing, even though all our learners have EHCPs and unique learning plans with inputs tailored to their specific needs. Parent A sees that Child B has SALT, and demands to know why their child doesn’t see the SaL therapist. The answer is almost always that their child doesn’t need that input, but they see something someone else has and they want it too. Same attitude that leads people to resent those who receive PIP or other disability benefits.

Then there is the problem that a pp alluded to. Those of us who grew up in the 80s were essentially left to get on with everything- pastoral care and safeguarding barely existed. For example, in around 1992 a PE teacher saw the self harm marks on my arm and told the deputy head. She asks if there was anything I wanted to talk to her about. I said no. That was it. No-one rang my parents, i was never followed up with. We were determined to do better by our children, and we may, as a generation, have overcorrected. Our kids are rarely left to be bored. Either we play with them, we pay for structured activities, or we let them use smart phones and tablets. But boredom is imperative for creativity and resilience.

In education, we see this in the demand for every lesson to be engaging and entertaining. It isn’t always possible to do this, of course, and sometimes we just have to practise or recite or read. But the expectation is that we don’t allow children to learn like this; I’d never plan an observation lesson with that sort of activity. I’m not arguing for lazy teaching, but the pressure to devise clever, well structured, multi part lessons with student led learning as well as teacher led for every single class is horrendous, and it’s a very draining way of working and very time-intensive at the planning and resource-creation stage. Remember you also have to account for each child’s specific needs in your planning and it’s no longer enough to talk about just three levels or categories of learners as it was when I did my PGCE.

I also feel like we should have ‘education credits’ for those who are so disaffected at 14 that they want to leave. They should be allowed to leave and get a job (if they can) but have the option to return to education if/when they decide they want to, so there’d be colleges for older learners, free at point of use, with classes around working patterns. (Much as there used to be back in the 70s and 80s 🤔) This would mean people could improve themselves for free when they’d grown up a bit, as they hadn’t taken the provision at 14-16.

An interesting analysis but one that falls victim to the ingrained and incorrect prejudice against Margaret Thatcher's government. She never said there was 'no such thing as society' in the misquoted magazine article. She was actually flagging up that people weren't taking responsibility for themselves and expected the government or 'society' to sort everything for them. Not my problem, mate. It's someone else's problem, etc.

If she were in power now, I would hope that those soft and feckless parents who unashamedly send in school age kids wearing nappies would face charges of neglect. It isn't and should never be a teacher's job to change nappies or make sure their charges brush their teeth!

Allrightonthenight1 · 10/11/2026 08:44

Saturdaysfairies · 09/11/2026 21:30

A lot of parents can't.

The ones we were talking about can.

settleyourselfdown · 10/11/2026 08:37

Resilience. A generation of parents seem to lack it, followed by a new generation of children without it completely.

Screen use and instant gratification has created a void around communication. Children don’t know how to be bored without being quickly placated. They lack the skills to articulate conversations, explore worries or insecurities and self esteem is lacking. The final product is that they reject authority as behaviour escalates.

Parenting of under 5’s is where I personally feel it’s won or lost. Long before they reach the secondary socialisation that is education. I take my hat off to teachers, sports coaches and those who volunteer their time to enrich the lives of our kids.

AlertCat · 10/11/2026 08:00

I have an interesting perspective because I am a teacher in one (specialist) setting, and support staff in a mainstream secondary school. I started my teaching career nearly 20 years ago in a fairly challenging school, and I’ve done supply as well.

My theory has a few strands.
first, I think smart phones (and I got my first one about 12 years ago, I wasn’t an early adopter) have done terrible things to us. We are nearly all slightly addicted, and not only does this manifest as a loss or failure to develop concentration and perseverance, but I also think it’s creating a problem in very early childhood where parents are unpredictably responsive, as they might be in other addictions. You see, if a parent is on their phone a lot, the child or baby gets much less interaction, and those are crucial for attachment and brain development. Like in the Still Face experiment. So that strand has a couple of problematic elements.

Then there is the increasing sense of individualisation that started under the Thatcher government. She famously outlined why she felt society doesn’t really exist and why none of us have a responsibility to one another, and that’s so ingrained now. In education we see it in the drive over 20 years or so towards individualised learning plans, which creates a lot of additional work for teachers and also the ground for parents and students to argue that they need more special treatment. While the aim of these is laudable, in practice it makes the job really difficult to do well, partly because of workload and partly because of parents who see one person getting a special thing and demanding it for their kid (even though their kid doesn’t need it). In the specialist unit I work at, we see the same thing, even though all our learners have EHCPs and unique learning plans with inputs tailored to their specific needs. Parent A sees that Child B has SALT, and demands to know why their child doesn’t see the SaL therapist. The answer is almost always that their child doesn’t need that input, but they see something someone else has and they want it too. Same attitude that leads people to resent those who receive PIP or other disability benefits.

Then there is the problem that a pp alluded to. Those of us who grew up in the 80s were essentially left to get on with everything- pastoral care and safeguarding barely existed. For example, in around 1992 a PE teacher saw the self harm marks on my arm and told the deputy head. She asks if there was anything I wanted to talk to her about. I said no. That was it. No-one rang my parents, i was never followed up with. We were determined to do better by our children, and we may, as a generation, have overcorrected. Our kids are rarely left to be bored. Either we play with them, we pay for structured activities, or we let them use smart phones and tablets. But boredom is imperative for creativity and resilience.

In education, we see this in the demand for every lesson to be engaging and entertaining. It isn’t always possible to do this, of course, and sometimes we just have to practise or recite or read. But the expectation is that we don’t allow children to learn like this; I’d never plan an observation lesson with that sort of activity. I’m not arguing for lazy teaching, but the pressure to devise clever, well structured, multi part lessons with student led learning as well as teacher led for every single class is horrendous, and it’s a very draining way of working and very time-intensive at the planning and resource-creation stage. Remember you also have to account for each child’s specific needs in your planning and it’s no longer enough to talk about just three levels or categories of learners as it was when I did my PGCE.

I also feel like we should have ‘education credits’ for those who are so disaffected at 14 that they want to leave. They should be allowed to leave and get a job (if they can) but have the option to return to education if/when they decide they want to, so there’d be colleges for older learners, free at point of use, with classes around working patterns. (Much as there used to be back in the 70s and 80s 🤔) This would mean people could improve themselves for free when they’d grown up a bit, as they hadn’t taken the provision at 14-16.

ilovesooty · 10/11/2026 07:53

friedaklein · 10/11/2026 07:45

I really feel for every teacher here. It's shameful that parents don't parent.

It's also shameful that some heads pander to them so much and bully their staff. Apparently though if your headteacher doesn't like being challenged by the staff and insists appalling behaviour is something you have to suck up it's your fault for not being brave enough.

MyLimeGuide · 10/11/2026 07:53

My school is also full of snakes that are constantly reporting colleagues for every little thing.

MyLimeGuide · 10/11/2026 07:51

Ive been teaching for 17 years now. I think i actually hate it im just counting down till weekends and holidays all the time the kids suck. Im at a SEN school which is way better than working in mainstream IMO but even this now is getting to me, dreading today!! So I feel your pain sista!

friedaklein · 10/11/2026 07:45

I really feel for every teacher here. It's shameful that parents don't parent.

Username1981 · 10/11/2026 06:56

It is becoming unsustainable. I live in constant fear that one of my colleagues or I will lose our job, and a career we have worked so hard for, after making a mistake due to the stress and pressure we are under every day, while trying to meet government data standards in attendance, progress, attainment etc etc. Lack of funding, a focus on pushing all children regardless of need into mainstream and systemic poor parenting for years are taking a serious toll. Parents should be shouting from the rooftops about the poor deal their children are getting.

WarriorN · 10/11/2026 06:05

gonoodleoodle · 09/11/2026 19:33

A few year 1’s in my school are wild. Definitely not all of them.

I’m relaying what fellow teachers in mainstream have said.

Which surprised me; as we all thought it was the covid cohort (current y6 ish) that were having the most issues.

QueenStevie · 10/11/2026 05:48

You only have to look at the thread about children's clothes to see the issue. Apparently children refuse and insist about what clothes they wear from being toddlers and need bodily autonomy. Yes, if course they need to be protected from abuse and inappropriate touching. This is world's part from knowing that the adults are in charge. And no, this isn't a bad thing. Children need security of clear boundaries. That has been lost in recent years. People don't want to make children scared but a certain
amount of fear of consequences has to exist. There are lots of things I don't do because I am scared of the consequences. I don't break the law because I am scared of going to prison. I don't walk on railway lines because we all saw those videos in school in the 80s which scared us. Obviously (or at least it is obvious to me), there is a massive gulf between
abusing a child emotionally or physically and having firm, clear, consistent boundaries with clear and reasonable consequences but I think society has lost that along the way and conflates the two.

WarriorN · 10/11/2026 05:37

Comeondoreen · 09/11/2026 20:55

I have a SEN child in Reception, quite significant SEN to be fair, and if I hear the words “brain break” one more time I will smash my own head in I swear to God. The staff at his school put in a tremendous amount of effort and I am extremely grateful for them, but I am finding myself repeatedly asking them to raise their expectations for him and it just isn’t happening. How will he ever get the message that he needs to behave if he knows there’s an alternative fun activity waiting for him if he misbehaves? I understand more than anyone that the fact he cannot (yet, I hope!!) behave well is not his fault - he has significant SEN, as I say. But the answer to that surely cannot be to just accept it? I feel like if he never has high expectations set and enforced then he’s being doomed to fail.

I know him and what he’s capable of - eg they were excited last week because they got him to draw a circle, the most successful mark making activity they’ve done. At home he writes his name and numbers because he knows when I’m doing an activity with him then he has to do it!!

I absolutely want reasonable adjustments made for my child, of course I do - but I think there’s a difference between adjustments that set a child up for success and just taking the path of least resistance in order to keep the child happy.

Conversely, working in send (originally MLD though we are getting more sld) we have extremely high standards.

we do have more ability to be flexible and more OT equipment but we are constantly raising the bar when appropriate

Sausagemagoo · 10/11/2026 04:46

Sartre · 09/11/2026 16:21

Why would anyone choose to teach secondary age children? You can select primary when doing the PGCE, or even further education but go with teenagers of all young people?! I’m not sure what you expect.

Threads like this make me think other peoples schools must have been great in the 90/00s. Mine was like Lord of the Flies.

Same at my school, one of my classmates burnt the library down!

ilovesooty · 10/11/2026 01:22

Ilovelifeverymuch · 09/11/2026 22:59

What a ridiculous comment.

I read that comment earlier and was disgusted. I'd like to say more but don't want to be banned.

Lavender1974 · 10/11/2026 00:55

There are lovely schools out there. I am in my 26th year of teaching and in the last 5 years sort of accidentally found myself working in the kind of school I never thought I would end up in. Church school/ middle-class area/motivated students. I properly sold out. And it is bliss. I think I have raised my voice maybe a handful of times in 5 years. SLT are fair and wise, students good humoured and respectful and so keen to do well. Of course some trickier students but they are very much diluted as there is a general air of wanting to do well. I can see staying until retirement. Oh and part time if you can possibly afford it (I also do tutoring in the evenings which helps). I have done my years in tougher schools which I loved at the time but could not see myself doing now after seeing what it is like to be able to focus on the teaching and not behaviour management. A couple of my teacher friends have also found similarly lovely schools and we are all pretty relaxed and enjoying our jobs in our mid 50s. It is possible honestly!

Bitsostuff · 10/11/2026 00:08

NewMonsteraLeaf · 09/11/2026 23:54

There was also the 2 years in these kids’ development when the schools kicked them out and sent home about an hour of work a day for them to do by themselves because mum and dad were working… we broke the societal contract with them at an important developmental stage - I’m talking those who are 13-15 now. That is definitely still having an effect.

It wasn't 2 years in England. It was 4 months in 2020 and 2 and a half months in 2021.