Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

any teachers here - is the job unsustainable now

243 replies

teachertetherendof · 09/11/2026 15:11

Hello - career teacher- needing somewhere to rant
I am sick of every child (almost to a fault) arguing that they shouldn't do what you have asked - this is from the tiniest thing to the biggest things
Also today I have been physically shoved which will lead to no more than a day of isolation for the 15 year old that did it
What has happened to young people? We are literally at the point where even if you are warning a student about something dangerous to themselves - they don't listen- instead their default is to argue back first

It's exhausting

Also, I am not a strict or savage teacher- our school does not have lots of stupid rules- this is a really strong societal drift into this constant state. And no, it hasn't always happened- there has been a massive change in the last 8 years

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GremlinsInTheMicrowave · 15/11/2026 10:14

Username1981 · 13/11/2026 20:24

Nearly got smashed in the head today by a ‘dysregulated’ child, it would have been a hospital visit. My fault though according to the email from his mum, ‘I don’t like him’, I’ve literally bent over backwards to support him.

Never felt more like giving up.

Life for teachers sounds awful now. I'm not surprised you are totally fed up.
I don't have kids but see pretty bad behaviour with them running across peoples gardens with no consequence or kicking balls of people's cars.

I was at secondary school in the eighties and for a brief time one of my classes was very unruly due to a very old (but good) teacher who unfortunately couldn't control the class. Kids were shouting at each other across the room and generally misbehaving and nothing was being learnt. That teacher retired and we got a nice, strict teacher and normal learning was resumed. I can't remember any other class being unruly in the presence of a teacher but that experience is etched on my mind. I felt really sorry for the teacher as well who just looked worn out.

How you manage today with this being just normal place (and worse) is beyond me.
Don't think anyone would blame you for wanting to change jobs. Hugs

friedaklein · 14/11/2026 08:43

BitterTits · 14/11/2026 08:36

I can't afford to leave unfortunately.

I get arsey emails from parents most days, all unreasonable and some downright unhinged. I'm so, so sick of it.

Well, of course you can't. Just like bus drivers, tube workers, retail workers, supermarket staff can't afford to leave or retrain.I may sound sanctimonious, but I think it's very important to be polite to people in public facing roles. Everybody really, but especially those in hard jobs that form the backbone of our society.

I understand that safeguarding rules need to be followed for children, but it's gone too far. Adults deserve respect too!

BitterTits · 14/11/2026 08:36

I can't afford to leave unfortunately.

I get arsey emails from parents most days, all unreasonable and some downright unhinged. I'm so, so sick of it.

ThisHazelPeer · 14/11/2026 08:35

PullingOutHair123 · 09/11/2026 16:11

In your opinion, what was the worst cohort?

Genuine interest, not being snarky in case it comes across that way!

The worst parents are the tattoo/leased car brigade. They are in their late 30's. Think their children are "dream" boys/girls. They are loud & chavvy. Common as muck. They are fans of the "live laugh love" & "be kind" slogans but they are nasty people. They don't believe they should be saddled with raising their own children so they allow them to be feral and then label them adhd or some other rubbish so that they can claim benefits for them. Money, money, money and driving around in their hired car is all they are interested in doing.

givemesteel · 14/11/2026 08:32

It's a shame there are not more free schools. My dc are at one and it seems nice, well run, no discipline problems. But the school is able to do several things differently which I think leads to better staff retention and wellbeing.

friedaklein · 14/11/2026 08:25

Username1981 · 13/11/2026 20:24

Nearly got smashed in the head today by a ‘dysregulated’ child, it would have been a hospital visit. My fault though according to the email from his mum, ‘I don’t like him’, I’ve literally bent over backwards to support him.

Never felt more like giving up.

You don't deserve this. If my son was even rude to a teacher, there would be severe consequences.

ISaySteadyOn · 14/11/2026 08:24

Username1981 · 14/11/2026 08:07

Thank you, I was very low last night. I love my job but I’m tired of being hurt or sworn at and it being dismissed as what we should just expect. The class I was teaching at the time were really concerned.

I’m not sure if it has been mentioned on this thread but my largest concern around behaviour in classrooms, is the knock on effect on the other children. I’ve known classes where the behaviour was so awful some other children started to school refuse or show signs of trauma. And those children’s voices are not being heard. I would have hated school as a quiet, bookish, gentle girl, if my daily school experiences included my peers swearing, attacking teachers and other children, and becoming angry and ‘dysregulated’ over just being asked basic requests.

I honestly think this is far more of a problem than a few silly rules at secondary school. I teach secondary but I know it’s endemic in primary and secondary now.

Edited

Thank you for this post and acknowledging the quiet gentle children. This is exactly what happened to mine and they did indeed tip over into school refusal because why would you want to go somewhere where a glue stick gets thrown at you with such force it breaks a computer monitor?

They are in better settings now but putting them back together after that took a long time.

JMSA · 14/11/2026 08:17

Username1981 · 13/11/2026 20:24

Nearly got smashed in the head today by a ‘dysregulated’ child, it would have been a hospital visit. My fault though according to the email from his mum, ‘I don’t like him’, I’ve literally bent over backwards to support him.

Never felt more like giving up.

Parent not taking responsibility? What a shocker 🤬

JMSA · 14/11/2026 08:16

Many parents are shit. Bottom line.

Username1981 · 14/11/2026 08:07

skylarkrise · 13/11/2026 21:23

I don’t know how you stand it

Thank you, I was very low last night. I love my job but I’m tired of being hurt or sworn at and it being dismissed as what we should just expect. The class I was teaching at the time were really concerned.

I’m not sure if it has been mentioned on this thread but my largest concern around behaviour in classrooms, is the knock on effect on the other children. I’ve known classes where the behaviour was so awful some other children started to school refuse or show signs of trauma. And those children’s voices are not being heard. I would have hated school as a quiet, bookish, gentle girl, if my daily school experiences included my peers swearing, attacking teachers and other children, and becoming angry and ‘dysregulated’ over just being asked basic requests.

I honestly think this is far more of a problem than a few silly rules at secondary school. I teach secondary but I know it’s endemic in primary and secondary now.

skylarkrise · 13/11/2026 21:23

Username1981 · 13/11/2026 20:24

Nearly got smashed in the head today by a ‘dysregulated’ child, it would have been a hospital visit. My fault though according to the email from his mum, ‘I don’t like him’, I’ve literally bent over backwards to support him.

Never felt more like giving up.

I don’t know how you stand it

Username1981 · 13/11/2026 20:24

Nearly got smashed in the head today by a ‘dysregulated’ child, it would have been a hospital visit. My fault though according to the email from his mum, ‘I don’t like him’, I’ve literally bent over backwards to support him.

Never felt more like giving up.

Pleasealexa · 13/11/2026 16:48

Parents have to back up teachers but I've seen a decline in parents attitudes to schools.

Notices started appearing 5-10 years ago warning parents that staff won't tolerate abusive behaviour. Why is this needed when it wasn't commonplace a decade ago. What type of parent would be abusive to school staff...would anyone on MN admit to this behaviour?

My experience of independent schools is that they can discipline children/parents effectively as ultimately asking them to leave so behaviour is better than state schools. Where a parent works with the school and supports the sanctions, they can usually turn around behaviour.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 13/11/2026 16:33

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 10:40

Yeah, the difference is that parents in independent schools have sufficient power that they won't tolerate their kids being taught in coercive and emotionally abusive environments.

I think the behaviour is better, because there are expectations on the kids and the teachers from the parents that the children will succeed, and so ultimately anything that gets in the way of that, including excessively bad behaviour, will be clamped down upon. So children who are openly disruptive, as opposed to quietly cheeky and entitled, won't be tolerated.

I don't know any private school parent who would tolerate their child being put in detention for being a minute late or wearing the wrong socks or anything stupid like that. It just wouldn't happen.

The main problem I have with these 'zero tolerance' type schools is that they're conditioning children to accept coercive and abusive behaviour as standard, and normalising being in a permanent state of fear of infringing the rules. They're conditioning their students to accept victimization in future relationships or workplaces.

Edited

But the behaviour isnt better. The kids I taught were often obnoxious, disrespectful and treated teachers like low class servants. They were allowed to do whatever, but rich mummies and daddies would excuse al behaviour (and sometimes were equally appalling). I remember later on I once taight a kid in a state school who was in an independent school before and moved to state after moving cities, did f* all, always late, bullied other kids, brought drugs to school, but entitled parents were rolling in with 'we will get a lawyer and inform Ofsted if he has to sit in a detention". Lucky buggered off to do drugs and bully kids in some independent school some months after. Probably on course to inherit family architect firm.

By the way I hate 'zero tolerance' and the Nazi approach to rules, measuring girls skirts with a ruler, silent corridors, people shouting at kids at the top of their lungs (Mossbourne style) and are they are often set up to teach working class and immigrant children to 'fit in' and keep their heads down. But I also don't think privileged kids are well behaved either; it's a whole new set of behaviour that is different and can be as unpleasant. Kids smirking at you, adapting fake polite voices or telling you their daddy will get you sacked is not that much better in long term.

skylarkrise · 13/11/2026 12:46

Dicedpumpkin · 13/11/2026 12:23

Its sort of the same thing. You only get an ehcp when the education needed is over and above the ordinary offer.

If you make the ordinary offer a bit worse through austerity, you then end up with marginal pupils forced into needing an ehcp in order to access things that used to be more ordinary.

For instance when I started you could literally get speech and language services to come see pupils and offer advice without an ehcp. We paid for it through 'buy backs'. No option during austerity as we had to cut back and LAs also cut back, so they only offered statutory services and we could only really get them via an ehcp.

This was echoed across loads of things. We had a float TA that did reading intervention, a staffed nurture room. It all got cut.

Yes that’s a good point

if they had kept those services going ….

Shinyandnew1 · 13/11/2026 12:28

Dicedpumpkin · 13/11/2026 12:23

Its sort of the same thing. You only get an ehcp when the education needed is over and above the ordinary offer.

If you make the ordinary offer a bit worse through austerity, you then end up with marginal pupils forced into needing an ehcp in order to access things that used to be more ordinary.

For instance when I started you could literally get speech and language services to come see pupils and offer advice without an ehcp. We paid for it through 'buy backs'. No option during austerity as we had to cut back and LAs also cut back, so they only offered statutory services and we could only really get them via an ehcp.

This was echoed across loads of things. We had a float TA that did reading intervention, a staffed nurture room. It all got cut.

Absolutely agree.

The narrower you make the path, the more people fall off.

Dicedpumpkin · 13/11/2026 12:23

skylarkrise · 13/11/2026 12:17

I’m not sure about that, so many more with EHCPs than before 2020.

Its sort of the same thing. You only get an ehcp when the education needed is over and above the ordinary offer.

If you make the ordinary offer a bit worse through austerity, you then end up with marginal pupils forced into needing an ehcp in order to access things that used to be more ordinary.

For instance when I started you could literally get speech and language services to come see pupils and offer advice without an ehcp. We paid for it through 'buy backs'. No option during austerity as we had to cut back and LAs also cut back, so they only offered statutory services and we could only really get them via an ehcp.

This was echoed across loads of things. We had a float TA that did reading intervention, a staffed nurture room. It all got cut.

skylarkrise · 13/11/2026 12:17

thebrowncatisback · 13/11/2026 11:33

That and many years of austerity which has contributed to lack of resources for kids with SEN

I’m not sure about that, so many more with EHCPs than before 2020.

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 12:12

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 12:09

Teachers are adults. They can walk out of abusive environments.

Children cannot. There is no excuse for abusing or not safeguarding children, including in the name of 'discipline' or 'compliance'.

Then we won't have any teachers left. We already don't.
You and I have different definitions of abusive.
But as I said, you don't need to send your kids to Michaela..I can assure you immigrant parents like me don't find that environment abusive or coercive

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 12:09

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 11:53

I am not talking about kids with complex needs, but it also can't be that every damn kids has complex needs to the point that teachers are being attacked, like pp upthread said.
My sympathy is mostly with teachers. And I am not a teacher.

Teachers are adults. They can walk out of abusive environments.

Children cannot. There is no excuse for abusing or not safeguarding children, including in the name of 'discipline' or 'compliance'.

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 11:59

Also those who don't want to go to Michaela type schools needn't. If I had my kids again, I would happily send them.

friedaklein · 13/11/2026 11:53

AlphabetMole · 13/11/2026 11:26

It's not having rules in itself which is abusive, it is the arbitrary and controlling nature of many of the rules (so for instance, requiring students always to visually track the teacher) and the harsh and disproportionate penalties imposed when rules are infringed, even inadvertently. Isolation being used for prolonged periods as a punishment for children with complex needs who can't comply, for example... how can that be appropriate?

I am not talking about kids with complex needs, but it also can't be that every damn kids has complex needs to the point that teachers are being attacked, like pp upthread said.
My sympathy is mostly with teachers. And I am not a teacher.

thebrowncatisback · 13/11/2026 11:35

@LadyMacbethGotABadPress

so sorry ❤️ your daughter sounds like a wonderful teacher. How cruel life is xx

thebrowncatisback · 13/11/2026 11:33

That and many years of austerity which has contributed to lack of resources for kids with SEN

thebrowncatisback · 13/11/2026 11:32

I think millennials have gotten parenting quite wrong !!!