Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely furious at Brand's barrister?

315 replies

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:03

Just reading the live sentencing of Russell Brand and this is what his defence barrister, Ian Wilson KC has come out with, presumably in a hand-wringing attempt to lessen the sentence.

Ian Winter KC told Southwark Crown Court that Russell Brand's rape and sexual assault convictions have caused 'total devastation' to his wife Laura Gallacher – but she is 'standing by him'. He said "they have been 'wrestling with how to explain' to their ten-year-old child what has happened to their father. 🤔

Mr Winter said: 'I'm afraid words are completely inadequate to truly try to convey to your Lordship the total devastation she's experiencing.

'Currently (they) are wrestling with how to exactly explain to a child who's just turned ten what has happened here. It brings home the consequences of this conduct to totally innocent people who have been caught up in it.'

WTF??? Surely the only non-innocent person is Brand. The "innocent people caught up in this" are his victims first and foremost. And as for "what has happened to their father" ???? Well, justice came knocking that's what happened!

I have no idea how to complain about a barrister's conduct but I really want to. This is just appalling.

OP posts:
AmnesiacDream · 09/11/2026 18:42

PopPopHopAbout · 09/11/2026 14:15

I don't think having young children is a very strong argument for leniency as it would apply to everyone convicted of a crime who has children. Unless the children were entirely dependent on the parent and it was a non-serious crime, eg single mother not having a TV licence. But Brand has been convicted of serious crimes against multiple people.

In the case of crimes like rape and violence against the person I think it's generally a strong argument for putting them inside away from the damaging influence they could have on their children.

wheresthediagram · 09/11/2026 18:37

The man is simply doing his job.

EmeraldRoulette · 09/11/2026 18:36

@Bollihobs what you are saying is that the system is fundamentally wrong

I do understand that. I’m not suggesting that a lawyer should be unable to mitigate at the stage of sentencing. However, I would like to move to factual statements rather than story and drama. It’s also pointless. No one is going to stand up there and say “ his wife and child won’t miss him at all probably be better off without him” even though that may actually be true. And to be quite honest with you, I don’t really care. He’s been found guilty and I’m not sure that these personal facts should be used to mitigate a sentence.

If you ever saw Prima Facie with Jodie Comer, that was based on authentic courtroom procedures and was written by a lady who used to be a lawyer.

There is a film coming out, but I would say it’s worth getting hold of the original play script if you can.

The information from that has triggered some reform. I’m not sure how much you know, the fact that you are shocked by this suggests that you may not be aware of how fundamentally flawed the system is if you try and bring these cases to court. It is worth knowing, you may want to join some campaigns, etc

Cantbareit · 09/11/2026 18:33

Sartre · 09/11/2026 14:06

But this is his job… He’s selling the story of Brand as the loving father and how much his young children will miss him to try and persuade the judge to be more lenient in sentencing.

I think barristers have a lot to answer for. They stand up there in their wigs and gowns and perpetuate rape myths in the name of getting a result for their client. I’d like to see a barrister led charge to modernise the law around how rape cases are handled. There are more moral ways to win a case. Ian Winter will have sat down and written his closing speech knowing all eyes were upon him. I get it. It’s his job. Still, he chose a vile set of words.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 18:29

MadameSosotris · 09/11/2026 18:19

Well, hopefully the law is changed so judges are required to explain rape myths to juries prior to deliberations. Then barristers can offer a robust defence and victims can have access to a fair process.

Agreed. I think that's more likely to effect positive change than the usual whining about defence barristers that ensues when someone puts their unpleasant client's case as per their professional duty.

BasiliskStare · 09/11/2026 18:28

One thing I would say as @BeSharpGreenReader referred to The ire should be directed at the people who allowed Brand and other (mostly) men to get away with it for so long."

Are there any pending cases for those who knew / witnessed things albeit not perpetrators themselves ? Not just this case but for others which may come up. There did seem to be a culture where the "talent" was given much leeway and I'm not sure that those who suspected or knew shouldn't be called to proper account , not just stepping away from jobs.
Naive - moi ? 😊

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 18:20

I just hate criminal defence lawyers as a standard, when words leave their mouth it only solidifies the hatred.

We should start a betting pool on how fast you change your tune if you ever have need of one.

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 18:20

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 17:53

Out of interest, what line of questioning/argument would you have used to defend Brand - if you had to do it and do it wholeheartedly, as a barrister would?

I would have looked for and questioned the timings of accusations, (for example, whether the first victim got the dates correct, which he did, rightly, question), whether or not they could have been mistaken.

But I would focus my arguments to accusers more on whether or not Brand could have reasonably construed consent, if they had been mistaken etc. That seems like the most fruitful line of questioning, But NOT by relying on known factually incorrect stereotyped tropes (such as claiming that not kicking or fighting back means you were not "really" raped), which are a shit defence and the jury usually are directed to ignore anyway. I would also have avoided using the outdated language he did ("he may have been beastly but it wasn't rape, was it?). It undermined rather than supported his case,

It is what most barristers who unlike Winter actually have expertise in the area of rape and sexual assault prefer to do.

(Oh, and btw, it isn't just laypeople who are questioning his strategy here, incidentally. Plenty of defence barristers who have expertise in this have also questioned it.)

You seem to think for some reason that I am one of those who don't believe in defence barristers or understand why they do what they do. Not sure why. This isn't my argument. I question his specific strategy and his choice to rely on non factual, misogynistic tropes and victimising the defendants. I would avoid that, just as when defending a white defendant I would not rely on using overtly racist tropes or language about a black accuser.

MadameSosotris · 09/11/2026 18:19

Well, hopefully the law is changed so judges are required to explain rape myths to juries prior to deliberations. Then barristers can offer a robust defence and victims can have access to a fair process.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 18:19

Brand pleaded not guilty to rape and assault.

Brand's barrister has no choice but to proceed on the basis his client is telling the truth.

If there is a 'not guilty' plea to rape there are only two possible defences - 'I did not have sex with her' or 'we had sex but she consented'.

Obviously, we now know that rape took place; Brand would have known this all along, so 'we did not have sexual contact' was never going to be the defence he'd instruct.

Therefore, the barrister's line of questioning was designed to elicit evidence that the plaintiffs' behaviour was consistent with the behaviour of women who had consented to sexual activity with Brand.

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 18:17

Despite it being his job to defend/represent the rapist, you are not at all unreasonable to be livid with his choice of words. Describing the rapist as a victim and putting him in a position of having had all this happen to him is sickening. Absolutely disgusting with such a fragrant disregard of his victims. No wonder people don't often report sexual assault crimes, because who wants to have to sit and listen to this slop in a courtroom after having been assaulted.

I just hate criminal defence lawyers as a standard, when words leave their mouth it only solidifies the hatred.

NoisyViewer · 09/11/2026 18:16

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:03

Just reading the live sentencing of Russell Brand and this is what his defence barrister, Ian Wilson KC has come out with, presumably in a hand-wringing attempt to lessen the sentence.

Ian Winter KC told Southwark Crown Court that Russell Brand's rape and sexual assault convictions have caused 'total devastation' to his wife Laura Gallacher – but she is 'standing by him'. He said "they have been 'wrestling with how to explain' to their ten-year-old child what has happened to their father. 🤔

Mr Winter said: 'I'm afraid words are completely inadequate to truly try to convey to your Lordship the total devastation she's experiencing.

'Currently (they) are wrestling with how to exactly explain to a child who's just turned ten what has happened here. It brings home the consequences of this conduct to totally innocent people who have been caught up in it.'

WTF??? Surely the only non-innocent person is Brand. The "innocent people caught up in this" are his victims first and foremost. And as for "what has happened to their father" ???? Well, justice came knocking that's what happened!

I have no idea how to complain about a barrister's conduct but I really want to. This is just appalling.

He’s doing his job, but you are aware you’re talking about a 10 yo child whose life has just been upended. That child is a victim of this. This child will face consequences of their father’s actions. Whilst I agree this blame falls at the the feet of brand it’s still right in what he’s said

Bountyhunter888 · 09/11/2026 18:14

Im sure brand is pretty pissed off with him too and wifely wont stay with.him and sadly its aweful for the kids but it probably will be better for them that hes not there preaching, its amazing that men still blame women, but men get raped too which is horrendous and weirdly that has nothing to do with high heels and a short skirt...

Imaginingdragonsagain · 09/11/2026 18:13

Jk987 · 09/11/2026 14:51

How do your come across as a great person when you’re defending a sex crime? He’s doing his job not increasing his popularity.

I meant in terms of having a go at the reporter outside the court room.

Brickiscool · 09/11/2026 18:12

Oh for goodness sake. A barrister represents you. They are paid to be on your side. And let's face it, he can't argue the conviction, he can't really say he's a lovely person never been in trouble before, or that he's very sorry. There's basically nothing he can say except how upset his family is.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 09/11/2026 18:09

It is literally his job to do and say these arguments.

PyongyangKipperbang · 09/11/2026 18:09

PrincessofWills · 09/11/2026 18:00

The two are not mutually exclusive- you can have immense sympathy for the victims and his children.

Exactly.

He committed the crimes but his children will suffer the consequences for the rest of their lives. They will always be the kids of "convicted rapist Russell Brand", thats a hell of a burden to carry. School for them will be awful now. If I was their mother I would probably change their surname. His wife has a choice, she can divorce him and not be his wife any more, but they have no choice at all.

Wadsworthy · 09/11/2026 18:07

The barrister is doing his job. It's a nasty job sometimes, but EVERYONE deserves a defence.

Even scumbags.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 18:07

The system allows for that sort of bullshitting, cod psychology and the like. A real victim would do X, an innocent person would do Y. I find it pretty concerning but as long as it's permitted, clients are allowed to instruct their barristers to make those arguments. Realistically the better way to stop that kind of thing would be at the structural level.

BeSharpGreenReader · 09/11/2026 18:06

Horrible though this is, it is not up the the barrister to decide on guilt/innocence or the sentence. They are required to do their best for their client and let the system work through the process.

The ire should be directed at the people who allowed Brand and other (mostly) men to get away with it for so long.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 18:01

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:55

It's not just "arguments I disagree with". Not sure why you're directing this at me personally either.

It's objectively false information I'm concerned about, as others have said.

And as I stated, the judge did intervene on occasion, for example, when Winter asked Laura Brand for her opinion. He said "no, no, no" and stopped it. There were, iirc, a few other occasions.

The barrister did not present objectively false information.

A theory that is outdated is still only a theory.

PrincessofWills · 09/11/2026 18:00

CaptBirdsEar · 09/11/2026 15:52

OP I get what you’re saying, and yes as some people have said it’s his job, but bugger his wife/kids/family, it’s the victims who I’m sympathetic to 100% - any assault, no matter how long ago.never leaves you.

The two are not mutually exclusive- you can have immense sympathy for the victims and his children.

AbsoluteHoot · 09/11/2026 17:57

I don’t see anything he said worthy of complaint, quite the opposite. He was making a legitimate point about the human consequences of the case, particularly the impact on people who have been caught up in the events - ie his innocent family.

Brand’s barrister isn't there to express moral approval or disapproval of their client. He is there to ensure his client receives proper representation within the law.

His wife and children deserve compassion, regardless of who their father is.

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:55

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 17:50

I've just looked at the bar standards board and they will not look into cases of barristers using arguments you disagree with.

https://www.barstandardsboard.org.uk/for-the-public/problems-with-a-barrister/reporting-a-concern.html

It's not just "arguments I disagree with". Not sure why you're directing this at me personally either.

It's objectively false information I'm concerned about, as others have said.

And as I stated, the judge did intervene on occasion, for example, when Winter asked Laura Brand for her opinion. He said "no, no, no" and stopped it. There were, iirc, a few other occasions.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 17:53

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 17:45

Of course everyone deserves a fair, objective and robust defence. But many defence lawyers in this area do NOT in fact rely on those outdated rape myths and yet still manage to be objective and robust. Winter's line of questioning stood out to a lot of people, largely because, as someone whose specialism is not sex assault and rape cases, because they consisted mostly of long debunked stereotypes and victim-blaming most of us thought died out decades ago. And it didn't seem at all objective from his behaviour; quite the opposite.

Would a "robust defence" of a white defendant versus a black accuser allow the defence barrister to use false racist stereotypes about black people from decades ago, for example, or would that rightly be avoided? I don't think robust defence necessarily means "anything goes".

Out of interest, what line of questioning/argument would you have used to defend Brand - if you had to do it and do it wholeheartedly, as a barrister would?