Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely furious at Brand's barrister?

315 replies

Bollihobs · 09/11/2026 14:03

Just reading the live sentencing of Russell Brand and this is what his defence barrister, Ian Wilson KC has come out with, presumably in a hand-wringing attempt to lessen the sentence.

Ian Winter KC told Southwark Crown Court that Russell Brand's rape and sexual assault convictions have caused 'total devastation' to his wife Laura Gallacher – but she is 'standing by him'. He said "they have been 'wrestling with how to explain' to their ten-year-old child what has happened to their father. 🤔

Mr Winter said: 'I'm afraid words are completely inadequate to truly try to convey to your Lordship the total devastation she's experiencing.

'Currently (they) are wrestling with how to exactly explain to a child who's just turned ten what has happened here. It brings home the consequences of this conduct to totally innocent people who have been caught up in it.'

WTF??? Surely the only non-innocent person is Brand. The "innocent people caught up in this" are his victims first and foremost. And as for "what has happened to their father" ???? Well, justice came knocking that's what happened!

I have no idea how to complain about a barrister's conduct but I really want to. This is just appalling.

OP posts:
Hydrangeblueeyes · 09/11/2026 19:34

It's his job. He had the right to a fair trial and any other representation from his counsel. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad he is behind bars.

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:33

BasiliskStare · 09/11/2026 19:24

@worldshottestmom "I still hate criminal defence lawyers"

All of them ?

I hate anyone that has defended a dangerous criminal so they get a fat payout, yes.

stillhiding1990 · 09/11/2026 19:33

You think his Ian Wilson shouldn’t be on his side? How would that work OP

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:32

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 19:14

Thing is, it's hard not to condescend to someone who has such poor understanding of the subject at hand. You genuinely thought saying you're not a rapist was a reason why you'd never need a criminal defence lawyer. I mean, talk about cringe.

You totally will change your tune if you ever need one, though, and judging by the way you keep trying to swerve the point I suspect you've realised that. I hope you have, actually.

My point was that being condescending and making pathetic comments like "awwww!!" just makes you come across as very childish and pathetic. Your latest comment only confirms that you have the mental age of about 14 since you can't communicate in any other way. If you want to genuinely make someone understand a topic then you communicate like an adult. Unfortunately, you're just a very nasty person who is looking to throw out insults to make themselves feel better, only further conveying your teen-like mental state and literally confirmed by your mess of a comment about how easy it is to be condescending. "Talk about cringe".

I never said that saying I'm not a rapist would be a criminal defence and would mean I never need a criminal defence lawyer. I simply said I'm not a rapist and don't plan on becoming one. I never commented on being falsely accused of rape, though I deem it highly unlikely that I ever would be.
Maybe if you spent more time reading the comments that you're replying to instead of thinking of how many insults you can spew out, you might be able to have a coherent conversation and not embarass yourself further.

I must say, you seem very adamant that I will be accused of a crime in future. Almost as if you are wishing that I am, so you can chant from the rooftops that you are right. Again, very childish, wanting nothing more than to be "right" and to have "won" a non-argument. I still hate criminal defence lawyers, if I ever need one I will still hate them because they defend the worst types of people. Perhaps you may need one soon for online hate speech? Before you defend yourself, don't forget that you still may need one even if falsely accused. Careful there.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 19:24

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:11

May I ask why you talk like a teenage girl? With pathetic mocking insults and condescending language? Do you think it makes you look more intelligent? Because it actually has the opposite effect. I have secondhand embarrassment from reading your comment. Maybe try communicating like an adult in future, you might get taken more seriously.

Also if you don't know how to quote users, you type the '@' symbol and then their username, it is really very simple. No need to resort to more condescending comments to try and brush it under the rug, there is no shame in asking for help.

@ symbol and username will tag the poster, but it won't automatically quote them. You need to use the quote function to have the post itself included in your reply. Tagging should be sufficient in most cases unless the poster has made multiple posts in quick succession.

BasiliskStare · 09/11/2026 19:24

@worldshottestmom "I still hate criminal defence lawyers"

All of them ?

Undahpressurah · 09/11/2026 19:22

Interesting that the children were brought in as a mitigating factor for a lesser sentence. The man’s a sex offender, and they’ve had their lives upended as well. If anything else, lock him up for longer so they can heal without him, poor kids.

Not sure that’s possible with their dimwit mother, who will no doubt waste her life waiting for him. But I do feel sorry for the children, and I hope they never have to see him again.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 19:16

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:13

Yeah you're having to make up a bunch of hypothetical scenarios to "prove me wrong", but I still hate criminal defence lawyers, I still hate them even more when they start yapping. If I do ever get falsely accused of a serious crime, I will come back and update everyone so you can all have a jolly good laugh about it since you don't seem to have an awful lot better to do. You could always try getting a hobby?

One hypothetical isn't a bunch of, can you not count?

Also, we're all on an internet forum arguing. Anyone attempting a better things to do argument is doomed to fail. Better to embrace it!

Redbags · 09/11/2026 19:14

I think the use of rape myths throughout the trial has been appalling, but appaling because it so often works in persuading a jury. If that's a tactic that often works, he's duty bound to use it.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 19:14

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:11

May I ask why you talk like a teenage girl? With pathetic mocking insults and condescending language? Do you think it makes you look more intelligent? Because it actually has the opposite effect. I have secondhand embarrassment from reading your comment. Maybe try communicating like an adult in future, you might get taken more seriously.

Also if you don't know how to quote users, you type the '@' symbol and then their username, it is really very simple. No need to resort to more condescending comments to try and brush it under the rug, there is no shame in asking for help.

Thing is, it's hard not to condescend to someone who has such poor understanding of the subject at hand. You genuinely thought saying you're not a rapist was a reason why you'd never need a criminal defence lawyer. I mean, talk about cringe.

You totally will change your tune if you ever need one, though, and judging by the way you keep trying to swerve the point I suspect you've realised that. I hope you have, actually.

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:13

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 19:09

Literally nobody has done that. Are you familiar with the concept of hypotheticals?

Yeah you're having to make up a bunch of hypothetical scenarios to "prove me wrong", but I still hate criminal defence lawyers, I still hate them even more when they start yapping. If I do ever get falsely accused of a serious crime, I will come back and update everyone so you can all have a jolly good laugh about it since you don't seem to have an awful lot better to do. You could always try getting a hobby?

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:11

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 19:03

I quoted the part of your post I was replying to, and clearly you managed to identify and reply to it, so it worked well.

That's absolutely adorable that you think only rapists and people who don't plan to commit crime ever need criminal defence barristers. Bet you think you live in a country where no miscarriages of justice ever happen too. Awww!

Your last paragraph is made up, and the fact that you've had to invent things to swerve the point speaks for itself. Do actually employ the services of a criminal barrister if the issue ever arises btw, better to be a raging hypocrite that people on MN would laugh at if they found out than be unrepresented.

May I ask why you talk like a teenage girl? With pathetic mocking insults and condescending language? Do you think it makes you look more intelligent? Because it actually has the opposite effect. I have secondhand embarrassment from reading your comment. Maybe try communicating like an adult in future, you might get taken more seriously.

Also if you don't know how to quote users, you type the '@' symbol and then their username, it is really very simple. No need to resort to more condescending comments to try and brush it under the rug, there is no shame in asking for help.

Redbags · 09/11/2026 19:10

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 18:19

Brand pleaded not guilty to rape and assault.

Brand's barrister has no choice but to proceed on the basis his client is telling the truth.

If there is a 'not guilty' plea to rape there are only two possible defences - 'I did not have sex with her' or 'we had sex but she consented'.

Obviously, we now know that rape took place; Brand would have known this all along, so 'we did not have sexual contact' was never going to be the defence he'd instruct.

Therefore, the barrister's line of questioning was designed to elicit evidence that the plaintiffs' behaviour was consistent with the behaviour of women who had consented to sexual activity with Brand.

He didn't have to abuse the reporter who originally brought it all to light, outside the court though.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 19:09

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:07

So everyone's decided my future sees me accused of a serious crime that I haven't committed. MN really is the new cesspit of the Internet, isn't it. Christ

Literally nobody has done that. Are you familiar with the concept of hypotheticals?

Redbags · 09/11/2026 19:07

What struck me is either he's not very good at his job, trying to use mitigation that would lose RB any sympathy the judge might have had, or that the system is ridiculous. Why on earth should the fact that he has a 10yo make any difference, but presumably the experience of this experienced lawyer is that it does or can?

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 19:07

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 19:03

Er ... but that's exactly when people do need one! When they are innocent and prosecuted for something they haven't done!

So everyone's decided my future sees me accused of a serious crime that I haven't committed. MN really is the new cesspit of the Internet, isn't it. Christ

hihelenhi · 09/11/2026 19:07

TheGreatDownandOut · 09/11/2026 18:59

I think the OP is getting confused. Maybe she thinks it’s a similar thing to when that judge made those comments about ‘not ruining their bright futures’ when he didn’t hand down a custodial sentence to those teenage boys for gang raping and filming those girls. Except the OP doesn’t realise that’s extremely different to a defence barrister making those comments.

I don' t think the OP is "getting confused" at all. Perhaps you are.

As I've said, there are plenty of defence barristers who, unlike Winter, actually specialise in the area of rape and sexual assault cases who are questioning Winter's strategy specifically. Sorry, but once again, this is not about failing to understand the job of defence barristers' or not understanding that even wrong uns need robust defence.

The judge did step in on a few occasions. I've no idea why someone who, while an experienced KC, did NOT have expertise in this specialist area ,was chosen for such a high profile case. And I'm not at all surprised that his defence tactics, which sounded like something from about 30 years ago, are being questioned, including from those who DO have that expertise.

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 19:03

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 18:54

Well quoting me would have been helpful, but I don't imagine I will need one given that;

  • a.) I'm not a rapist, and certainly don't plan on becoming one
  • b.) I'm not a criminal, have never committed crime (beyond littering when I was like 5 and shoplifting a Terry's chocolate orange when I was 9) and don't plan on doing so in the future, as I was raised better than that.

But you go off about how criminal defence lawyers are such great people, just doing God's work. I mean, the one in this case is a testament to their objectivity and humility.

I quoted the part of your post I was replying to, and clearly you managed to identify and reply to it, so it worked well.

That's absolutely adorable that you think only rapists and people who don't plan to commit crime ever need criminal defence barristers. Bet you think you live in a country where no miscarriages of justice ever happen too. Awww!

Your last paragraph is made up, and the fact that you've had to invent things to swerve the point speaks for itself. Do actually employ the services of a criminal barrister if the issue ever arises btw, better to be a raging hypocrite that people on MN would laugh at if they found out than be unrepresented.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 19:03

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 18:54

Well quoting me would have been helpful, but I don't imagine I will need one given that;

  • a.) I'm not a rapist, and certainly don't plan on becoming one
  • b.) I'm not a criminal, have never committed crime (beyond littering when I was like 5 and shoplifting a Terry's chocolate orange when I was 9) and don't plan on doing so in the future, as I was raised better than that.

But you go off about how criminal defence lawyers are such great people, just doing God's work. I mean, the one in this case is a testament to their objectivity and humility.

Er ... but that's exactly when people do need one! When they are innocent and prosecuted for something they haven't done!

BasiliskStare · 09/11/2026 19:03

I'll just say - there are better defence barristers and worse ones. However , to dismiss all of them , is imho ill-judged. Criticise the individual by all means but not the entire cohort. A general point not directed at any particular poster.

That's my opinion , others are available.

TheGreatDownandOut · 09/11/2026 18:59

I think the OP is getting confused. Maybe she thinks it’s a similar thing to when that judge made those comments about ‘not ruining their bright futures’ when he didn’t hand down a custodial sentence to those teenage boys for gang raping and filming those girls. Except the OP doesn’t realise that’s extremely different to a defence barrister making those comments.

Toomanyhats88 · 09/11/2026 18:54

carkey26 · 09/11/2026 14:55

No, I feel the same as you, and I'm from a family of solicitors (some who specialise in criminal work).

Some of the things Brand's defence presented as 'fact' during the trial was disgusting. "Rapists don't give out their email address. Rapists don't kiss their victims goodbye."

Barristers can't just do and say whatever they want to help their client. There are still rules. For example, if they admit to their barrister they're guilty, they can't allow them to enter a not guilty plea. And they aren't allowed to mislead the jury (which I personally would argue the statements above are verging on...)

His Barrister has actually had to refer himself to the standards board as a result of his conduct on this case, but not because of what he said in the trial.

I felt the same about the comments regarding what rapists don’t do. He put these across as facts which is damaging to the victims and perpetuates rape myths in a very public trial. I was surprised he wasn’t stopped.

worldshottestmom · 09/11/2026 18:54

Flipperthepriest · 09/11/2026 18:20

I just hate criminal defence lawyers as a standard, when words leave their mouth it only solidifies the hatred.

We should start a betting pool on how fast you change your tune if you ever have need of one.

Well quoting me would have been helpful, but I don't imagine I will need one given that;

  • a.) I'm not a rapist, and certainly don't plan on becoming one
  • b.) I'm not a criminal, have never committed crime (beyond littering when I was like 5 and shoplifting a Terry's chocolate orange when I was 9) and don't plan on doing so in the future, as I was raised better than that.

But you go off about how criminal defence lawyers are such great people, just doing God's work. I mean, the one in this case is a testament to their objectivity and humility.

MeridianB · 09/11/2026 18:52

I agree, OP.

So we know it’s his job. But really? These are the words he chose?

Regarding the rape, Winter said: “We invite (you) to conclude that this was fully consensual vaginal intercourse that (the victim) went to the defendant’s house to experience. “Therefore what the defendant should be sentenced for is really quite a short, momentary total failure to respect her consent in two areas.”

’really quite a short, momentary’ is superfluous but he chose to add them. His behaviour in and out of court has shown him for the person he is.

rwalker · 09/11/2026 18:42

It wouldn’t even register with my it’s a standard angle they’ll go from

just the same as saying a murder is remorseful