Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that's not what vulnerability at work means?

239 replies

ToeSucker · 08/11/2026 21:51

I am really having trouble getting past an interaction I had with my manager last week. I've been on this team for about 8 months.

We were having a meeting and she said she had something she needed to talk to me about. Then she said she wanted to ask me to try to he more vulnerable at work.
I was a bit taken aback so I asked what she meant and long story short (she went on quite a monologue) she said she didn't feel I was sharing enough of what upset me and making that visible. I asked for an example and she mentioned a time when we had numerous unplanned/curveball tasks coming at us and I laughed about it and made a "flippant remark" (specifically I said "here it goes again"). Apparently this is an unnatural response and at the time she had to take an afternoon off due to the stress (I did remember this). Essentially the bottom line was I "make staff feel uncomfortable by not showing a normal range of emotions". She also mentioned that she had not seen me cry in all my time there.
I asked if anyone else complained and she wasn't specific. The only person there for that conversation was her!!
I asked what I needed to do and she said come back with a reflection.

What is a normal range of emotions?? Before this job I was under the impression "vulnerability at work" was supposed to mean owning up to your failures etc, not full on bawling every time something gets challenging.

I am quite bothered by this to me honest. Not sure what's expected of me. AIBU for thinking this is odd? I'm not new to the working world.

OP posts:
OCDmama · 09/11/2026 10:20

Honestly, follow up with an email clarifying what was said in the meeting.

And also send an email now to HR. She's being completely unreasonable, and her comments about you going mad are absolutely inappropriate. Document, document and document.

Sannabay · 09/11/2026 10:20

Daisymintjulep · 09/11/2026 10:11

I've cried at work, but discreetly and raised the concerns that led to it with my manager and Occ Health.

I didn't tell other people to cry, and certainly not my direct reports.

That's what's batty.

Umm I'm out of this thread now. Coz so much to do.

But management did not tell Op to cry.

Right I'm gone. It's Monday I gotta get to work!! Pip pip

Daisymintjulep · 09/11/2026 10:11

Sannabay · 09/11/2026 09:31

I have cried at work admittedly I'm not a manager.

Does this make me batty, mad, mad as a proverbial, nuts, insane etc.

Just saying.

I've cried at work, but discreetly and raised the concerns that led to it with my manager and Occ Health.

I didn't tell other people to cry, and certainly not my direct reports.

That's what's batty.

ToeSucker · 09/11/2026 10:04

I had another incident come to mind which was a few months ago.
I had a large task to do and it was taking several days.
She kept asking if I needed a break, and was I going crazy. I said no it's fine, I'm enjoying it.
Then she said I think you're going a bit crazy. I said honestly I'm fine. She kept repeating that I was going crazy. I felt uncomfortable but stayed polite. I was entirely calm and composed. Then eventually she said she was giving me another task that was higher priority.

I didn't understand why she didn't just say the new task was higher priority and instead insisted I was losing my mind?

OP posts:
lottiegarbanzo · 09/11/2026 09:57

She thinks you make her look bad. That your calm, can-do response conflicts with her openly stressed response.

She wants you to act as part of some sort of cheerleader chorus for her. That’s silly. You’re there to work for the company, not to boost her career. Having said that, being part of a team includes showing suitable levels of sympathy to colleagues. It also works best when a team consists of different types with different strengths, like you and her. It’s great you’re able to plough on when she’s having a wobble, she should be delighted as this benefits team and company.

But you’re different people and she’s the manager, so her level of responsibility and experience of the same event is different.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 09/11/2026 09:33

@Thepeopleversuswork in case you are in the UK (and for anyone else who is and who might have this unfair clause in their contract), here's are your rights on union membership. https://www.gov.uk/join-trade-union/trade-union-membership-your-employment-rights

Joining a trade union

Joining a union and getting recognition for collective bargaining and agreements - legal rules about membership, union reps and your rights

https://www.gov.uk/join-trade-union/trade-union-membership-your-employment-rights

Sannabay · 09/11/2026 09:31

I have cried at work admittedly I'm not a manager.

Does this make me batty, mad, mad as a proverbial, nuts, insane etc.

Just saying.

Sannabay · 09/11/2026 09:29

Daisymintjulep · 09/11/2026 09:28

Very true.

Op didn't mention routinely crying.

Op said 80 percent of the time she is fine.

Daisymintjulep · 09/11/2026 09:28

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/11/2026 09:23

That would have some validity if she herself had any emotional maturity but she sounds utterly emotionally incontinent herself.

A person in a management role who routinely cries in the office and shares details of her sex life is in no position to request emotional intelligence from anyone else.

Very true.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 09/11/2026 09:27

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/11/2026 08:49

I’m a big supporter of unions but it really isn’t that simple. A lot of private sector companies are actively hostile to unions and not only would a union not be recognised but you could be in breach of the terms of your employment contract.

If you’re public sector or third sector (or a progressive private sector company) I would wholeheartedly support joining a union but I think a lot of people in union friendly environments don’t realise its off limits for a lot of us.

What country are you in?

In the UK you have an absolute legal right to join (or not join) a union. Your employment contract cannot prevent you doing so.

C152 · 09/11/2026 09:26

Your manager is an incompetent nut case. Watch your back. I would do as others said and keep a record but, personally, I would go to HR and have a conversation about the inappropriate comments and suggestions by your manager.

Wordsmithery · 09/11/2026 09:24

She sounds nuts and she really shouldn't be a manager. She's actively looking for a work culture where people cry? Wtf. I'd record the conversation and go to HR because I'd be most uncomfortable working with a manager who said this. And the one night stands... She is terribly unprofessional.

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/11/2026 09:23

Daisymintjulep · 09/11/2026 09:17

She sounds either bonkers, manipulative and/or a poor manager.

Keep everything in writing - summarise conversations in a follow-up email.

She may be cack-handedly asking you to show more emotional intelligence in work, which is worth you reflecting on. But that's about picking up on other people's differences and reacting appropriately and professionally.

I was always counselled NOT to be inappropriately emotional at work. You certainly don't need to cry!

That would have some validity if she herself had any emotional maturity but she sounds utterly emotionally incontinent herself.

A person in a management role who routinely cries in the office and shares details of her sex life is in no position to request emotional intelligence from anyone else.

DelphineFox · 09/11/2026 09:21

BooMooShriekinsandStilettos · 08/11/2026 21:56

Would she ask a man that?
Sounds very weird/projecting I.e. she crashes out but doesn't like that you appear to stay calm/flippant at worst.

Good question

Daisymintjulep · 09/11/2026 09:17

She sounds either bonkers, manipulative and/or a poor manager.

Keep everything in writing - summarise conversations in a follow-up email.

She may be cack-handedly asking you to show more emotional intelligence in work, which is worth you reflecting on. But that's about picking up on other people's differences and reacting appropriately and professionally.

I was always counselled NOT to be inappropriately emotional at work. You certainly don't need to cry!

Tamtim · 09/11/2026 09:17

Sounds like she might be intimidated by your ability to cope and get on with the job. Bizarre and a bit unhinged.

Sannabay · 09/11/2026 09:13

To ask

Sannabay · 09/11/2026 09:12

TheGoddessFrigg · 09/11/2026 08:55

Oh my word do you have my manager? She actually brought up that I didn't use a 'friendly' emoji in an email to her, and she was upset as she thought I was upset with her. I was like 'Erm I'm not 12? ...'

Actually how did you deal with this? Sorry forgot ask.

Sannabay · 09/11/2026 09:11

TheGoddessFrigg · 09/11/2026 08:55

Oh my word do you have my manager? She actually brought up that I didn't use a 'friendly' emoji in an email to her, and she was upset as she thought I was upset with her. I was like 'Erm I'm not 12? ...'

Is this requirement in your job description 😇

BoredZelda · 09/11/2026 09:02

ToeSucker · 08/11/2026 22:20

I laughed really light heartedly. Is every laugh in response to a negative situation automatically passive aggressive? Are you just saying the only appropriate response is no response at all?

Sometimes absolutely nothing is the right response. Not every thought must be expressed every time. With my team, if there is a stressful time coming, I’d go for a humorous positive comment rather than a negative one. Your boss may be well out of line with her comments to you, but it’s always good to look and see if your reactions are appropriate when challenged. A change may be required, even if it isn’t the change she is asking for.

LancsMa · 09/11/2026 08:59

BooMooShriekinsandStilettos · 08/11/2026 22:01

What is HR like where you work?
Are you part of a union?
Watch yourself.
Keep a log.
My DP was told about his "aggressive use of silence" once in an appraisal.
He was and has always has been of the "least said, soonest mended" mindset.
No idea what the issue here is but probably a personality clash.
I'd take advice from union rep or HR and don't write anything in a reflection that either undermines you or can be used against you at a later date.

Yes to all this, plus I'd probably ask for the feedback in writing so that I could 'reflect' on it fully (and show it to HR).

SockPlant · 09/11/2026 08:55

Are you in a Union? You don't have to tell anyone you're in one. In my last job they were anti union but were happy to take my "advice from an employment expert" to rewrite my redundancy letter.

People are so woefully under informed about the benefits of union membership it's ridiculous.

One caveat these days would be if you raise a grievance about single sex spaces.

TheGoddessFrigg · 09/11/2026 08:55

Oh my word do you have my manager? She actually brought up that I didn't use a 'friendly' emoji in an email to her, and she was upset as she thought I was upset with her. I was like 'Erm I'm not 12? ...'

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/11/2026 08:49

SockPlant · 09/11/2026 08:43

Pretty much anyone can join a union. They don't have to be recognised in your workplace for you to benefit from membership.

I have been a union member since I started work and they have been very helpful helping me to word things when I have raised concerns, provided an experienced lawyer (at no extra cost than my subs) when unfairly dismissed, helped me assess and successfully rework a redundancy package ( that everyone in the company benefitted from) and lately helped me reword redundancy notice so that I wasn't blocked from unemployment money due to a small okay off for that.

Additionally I have done H&S training that benefits my employer and management training.

I’m a big supporter of unions but it really isn’t that simple. A lot of private sector companies are actively hostile to unions and not only would a union not be recognised but you could be in breach of the terms of your employment contract.

If you’re public sector or third sector (or a progressive private sector company) I would wholeheartedly support joining a union but I think a lot of people in union friendly environments don’t realise its off limits for a lot of us.

SockPlant · 09/11/2026 08:43

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

Pretty much anyone can join a union. They don't have to be recognised in your workplace for you to benefit from membership.

I have been a union member since I started work and they have been very helpful helping me to word things when I have raised concerns, provided an experienced lawyer (at no extra cost than my subs) when unfairly dismissed, helped me assess and successfully rework a redundancy package ( that everyone in the company benefitted from) and lately helped me reword redundancy notice so that I wasn't blocked from unemployment money due to a small okay off for that.

Additionally I have done H&S training that benefits my employer and management training.