Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that's not what vulnerability at work means?

239 replies

ToeSucker · 08/11/2026 21:51

I am really having trouble getting past an interaction I had with my manager last week. I've been on this team for about 8 months.

We were having a meeting and she said she had something she needed to talk to me about. Then she said she wanted to ask me to try to he more vulnerable at work.
I was a bit taken aback so I asked what she meant and long story short (she went on quite a monologue) she said she didn't feel I was sharing enough of what upset me and making that visible. I asked for an example and she mentioned a time when we had numerous unplanned/curveball tasks coming at us and I laughed about it and made a "flippant remark" (specifically I said "here it goes again"). Apparently this is an unnatural response and at the time she had to take an afternoon off due to the stress (I did remember this). Essentially the bottom line was I "make staff feel uncomfortable by not showing a normal range of emotions". She also mentioned that she had not seen me cry in all my time there.
I asked if anyone else complained and she wasn't specific. The only person there for that conversation was her!!
I asked what I needed to do and she said come back with a reflection.

What is a normal range of emotions?? Before this job I was under the impression "vulnerability at work" was supposed to mean owning up to your failures etc, not full on bawling every time something gets challenging.

I am quite bothered by this to me honest. Not sure what's expected of me. AIBU for thinking this is odd? I'm not new to the working world.

OP posts:
JLou08 · 09/11/2026 14:36

TheFriendlyPotato · 09/11/2026 14:29

I am not saying it is right or wrong.

Though I think a human approach free from "managers must be solid and steady" may be helpful. Unless we assume managers arent people with things going on.

I manage people and we look after each other. I do the formal stuff but we are a team, not me dictating and being the guru with all the solutions.

There's a big jump between not being a dictator and thinking you have all the answers to asking people to be vulnerable to meet your own emotional needs.

MimiGC · 09/11/2026 14:31

ToeSucker · 08/11/2026 22:12

While we're on unprofessional, she keeps telling me all about her one night stands. I do not want to know.

The next time she tells you about her one night stands (?!), start to cry and say you are feeling upset because you’re jealous/you’re religious -delete as appropriate. No seriously, she sounds crazy and completely OTT asking you to come back with a ‘reflection’.

TheFriendlyPotato · 09/11/2026 14:29

JLou08 · 09/11/2026 14:19

I don't think managers should be looking to their subordinates to meet their emotional needs. Managers should be stable and steady leaders. If they need emotional support they should go to their own line manager/friends/therapy.
If this was the other way round and the OP was the manager I'd have more sympathy for the person asking for vulnerability but for a manager to ask that is really inappropriate.

I am not saying it is right or wrong.

Though I think a human approach free from "managers must be solid and steady" may be helpful. Unless we assume managers arent people with things going on.

I manage people and we look after each other. I do the formal stuff but we are a team, not me dictating and being the guru with all the solutions.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 09/11/2026 14:24

If work is making you cry then it’s either the wrong job for you or you need to take time out because it just isn’t healthy

Skyflier · 09/11/2026 14:23

Good god. I’ve worked in the same unit for 25 years (high paced medical environment) snd I have never cried at work. I’d be mortified. I wouldn’t judge anyone else for crying but it’s not me. Sounds like your coping skills are making her feel inadequate

JLou08 · 09/11/2026 14:19

TheFriendlyPotato · 09/11/2026 14:12

@ToeSucker Sounds like a rather unique situation!

Try to find compassion amongst the unionising, meticulous note taking, assuming that she wants you fired and other er helpful suggestions given here. She is a human being.

I am sadly unsurprised at how little people (on here) are concerned about this poor woman's emotional wellbeing.

I suspect that she doesnt trust her own emotions and reactions, and needs others to validate them by also being (?overly) emotive. It can be mighty unnerving when one is ultra stressed and others seem relaxed. If may come off as lacking in interest or care about the outcome. This often happens when people come from dramatic, highly emotionally expressive families. Of course it is becauee you have a good degree of emotional control and resilience. I think maybe she sees that as a lack of caring.

For example, I know several people who believe that worrying shows one cares. "If I dont worry then I dont care about X". They typically come from families that are highly dramatic with a lot of "oh my god!!!" type responses to stress.

This is also a psychological tendency especially in generalised anxiety disorder. People with GAD often believe worry = being competent, caring etc. It would also track as she gets upset and tearful/stressed a fair bit.

I am very calm and people have misinterpreted my calmness when in high stress situations as being laisse faire and disinterested. That is so far from reality.

So try to being compassion to her. She clearly has low impulse control (e.g. sexualised talk at work) and possibly really strong beliefs about emotional expression.

Sounds like you are an excellent employee with high stress tolerance and she may find that unnerving. She isnt going to get you fired for not crying at work. Maybe verbalise that you "get" her emotional responses a bit more. That may take off the edge.

Good luck! And look after yourself..

Edited

I don't think managers should be looking to their subordinates to meet their emotional needs. Managers should be stable and steady leaders. If they need emotional support they should go to their own line manager/friends/therapy.
If this was the other way round and the OP was the manager I'd have more sympathy for the person asking for vulnerability but for a manager to ask that is really inappropriate.

TheFriendlyPotato · 09/11/2026 14:12

@ToeSucker Sounds like a rather unique situation!

Try to find compassion amongst the unionising, meticulous note taking, assuming that she wants you fired and other er helpful suggestions given here. She is a human being.

I am sadly unsurprised at how little people (on here) are concerned about this poor woman's emotional wellbeing.

I suspect that she doesnt trust her own emotions and reactions, and needs others to validate them by also being (?overly) emotive. It can be mighty unnerving when one is ultra stressed and others seem relaxed. If may come off as lacking in interest or care about the outcome. This often happens when people come from dramatic, highly emotionally expressive families. Of course it is becauee you have a good degree of emotional control and resilience. I think maybe she sees that as a lack of caring.

For example, I know several people who believe that worrying shows one cares. "If I dont worry then I dont care about X". They typically come from families that are highly dramatic with a lot of "oh my god!!!" type responses to stress.

This is also a psychological tendency especially in generalised anxiety disorder. People with GAD often believe worry = being competent, caring etc. It would also track as she gets upset and tearful/stressed a fair bit.

I am very calm and people have misinterpreted my calmness when in high stress situations as being laisse faire and disinterested. That is so far from reality.

So try to being compassion to her. She clearly has low impulse control (e.g. sexualised talk at work) and possibly really strong beliefs about emotional expression.

Sounds like you are an excellent employee with high stress tolerance and she may find that unnerving. She isnt going to get you fired for not crying at work. Maybe verbalise that you "get" her emotional responses a bit more. That may take off the edge.

Good luck! And look after yourself..

JLou08 · 09/11/2026 14:09

It may be a way of her saying that you are 'cold' and she wants to be able to form a close relationship with you but can't. Or that she wants you to show empathy for her when she is struggling with changes. Which in my opinion is unprofessional, she as the manager should be keeping her calm and reassuring staff, not the other way round. You also don't owe anyone at work your 'vulnerability' if you just want professional relationships rather than friendships there is nothing wrong with that.
It may also be that she is feeling inferior to you because you are more resilient than her.

Elep · 09/11/2026 14:09

Your manager is completely batshit OP.

As are a number of the responses on here trying to pick holes in your wonderfully resilient response to a bit of work stress.

SweetnsourNZ · 09/11/2026 14:03

Sounds like something the contestants on a dating show like The Batchelor/Bachelorette say. I'd be pissing myself laughing if a manager said that to me quite frankly.

Loopsy123 · 09/11/2026 13:56

I think she is deflecting her own issues at you. I would definitely write back the conversation in her words. It’s normal for people to say here we go again, but understand that now it’s been said maybe something less flippant would be better. But the crying comment is mad. I would be saying you’re very resilient and that you are completely comfortable with hard work and pressure. Re the oversharing of her one night stands I would definitely also tell her that this is making you uncomfortable and would appreciate that it stops, this would / could actually be sexual harassment due to creating a degrading/uncomfortable environment for you. It’s a less obvious example but case law shows examples where this has won in an ET.

whatsit84 · 09/11/2026 13:51

I have been at my job for 19 years. It’s quite stressful at times. People might cry in the loos or in an office one on one but are people crying all the time at your work?! I think I’ve seen someone cry in the middle of the office once !

Justanothermum42 · 09/11/2026 13:44

Feels to me she is struggling to be a manager /doesn’t understand how to be one.
I would document everything.
Send her an email to follow up on your most recent conversation and ask for a specific examples. She will need to reply to you - option 1. She brushes the whole thing under the carpet. 2. She will give you that example and then you can respond to it.
is she on the spectrum at all? That might explain some of the behavior.
No one should be crying at their place of work. Ever. For her to want you to cry shows immaturity and very little professionalism.

wheresthediagram · 09/11/2026 13:38

Bizarre. I am in my sixties and have cried at work twice. Both times someone had died.

ThreeLocusts · 09/11/2026 13:17

OP, this may seem a very far-fetched comparison to you, but what you describe reminds me of a psychiatrist who was involved in my child's care at a point when said child was very much in crisis and the psychiatrist kept underestimating the severity of the situation.

The point of the comparison is that this woman, too, tried to manage her own confusion, frustration and inability to judge the situation correctly by showing a lot of concern about 'how I was doing', 'how I managed to stay upright', etc etc. She wasn't altogether incompetent or ill-meaning, but she desperately needed an 'out' that made somebody else the problem in a way that allowed her to persuade herself she was still a nice person (hence all the 'concern').

The point being, people don't have to be especially mean or incompetent to become very toxic in specific work-related relationships. I would be very, very wary of this manager and take all the advice on documenting the issue and making higher-ups aware of it - where at all possible in ways that don't embarrass her.

It's a pain having to work around someone else's sensitive ego. Here's hoping you get offered an alternative job without even trying....

MabelsCatMabel · 09/11/2026 12:06

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 21:56

She sounds insane

She took the afternoon off with stress because you weren't performatively upset by something?

This.

She sounds hard work.

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/11/2026 12:00

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 09/11/2026 11:53

It's not 'legally borderline', it's illegal. And it cannot be a condtition of an employment contract as you claimed.

Legally yes that’s correct. I misspoke on that point.

But it is the case that unions are frowned upon in my industry.

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/11/2026 11:59

Springtimeinsunshine · 09/11/2026 11:39

Additionally it's frowned upon so joining a union would mark you out as being a troublemaker and people would consider it as an act of attention seeking at best or worst trying to start fights.
How would anyone know you've joined unless you shout about it?

My colleagues teased me about being a lefty because I had a (lapsed) union membership and I was advised not to tell people by a previous supervisor.
Oh... you shouted.

Joining a trade union is similar to having life or house insurance. It's important to have but you don't need to talk about it until/unless you need to use it.

I didn’t “shout” (?). I mentioned to a couple of colleagues that I had previously belonged to a union in another sector when I first joined nearly 15 years ago. It was made clear that it’s not really the done thing and a senior person recommended that I didn’t talk about it.

I don’t disagree with the sentiment but if you are a member of a union which isn’t supported by your employer or recognised in your industry and has no relevant network or expertise in your vertical its just not really “important to have”. Its money you are paying regularly for something which is very unlikely to help you when the shit hits the fan and for which membership is a barrier to advancing at work.

As I say I wish it wasn’t like this but in the sector I work in union membership is at best an irrelevance.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 09/11/2026 11:53

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/11/2026 10:56

I know that I have a right to join a union. But in some environments (private sector) it's pointless shading to negative. In my sector there is no relevant union so there's no one in that union who would know the landscape or the issues well enough to advocate for you. Additionally it's frowned upon so joining a union would mark you out as being a troublemaker and people would consider it as an act of attention seeking at best or worst trying to start fights.

I know this because when I joined my current company I was a member of a union in an adjacent sector. My colleagues teased me about being a lefty because I had a (lapsed) union membership and I was advised not to tell people by a previous supervisor.

You can't be fired for it but it will mark you out as being "not one of them", "a bit left/woke" and "not management material". It's the kind of thing which will be raised at appraisals etc.

It's shit/legally borderline etc but I'm not alone here. For a large chunk of private sector workers at the moment it just isn't worth the grief.

It's not 'legally borderline', it's illegal. And it cannot be a condtition of an employment contract as you claimed.

CheeseMakesMeFart · 09/11/2026 11:50

She's insane and possibly dangerous. Your instincts sound good.

As others have said, document everything. And be prepared for it to escalate further.

ByDreamyMember · 09/11/2026 11:45

This is absolutely mental.
Please don't let yourself be gaslit by this woman. Nothing about this is normal. It doesn't matter the industry, none of what she said is professional.

Let me guess, it's NHS?
I cannot believe the shit some women have to put up with in female-dominated workspaces.

Springtimeinsunshine · 09/11/2026 11:39

Additionally it's frowned upon so joining a union would mark you out as being a troublemaker and people would consider it as an act of attention seeking at best or worst trying to start fights.
How would anyone know you've joined unless you shout about it?

My colleagues teased me about being a lefty because I had a (lapsed) union membership and I was advised not to tell people by a previous supervisor.
Oh... you shouted.

Joining a trade union is similar to having life or house insurance. It's important to have but you don't need to talk about it until/unless you need to use it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 09/11/2026 10:56

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 09/11/2026 09:33

@Thepeopleversuswork in case you are in the UK (and for anyone else who is and who might have this unfair clause in their contract), here's are your rights on union membership. https://www.gov.uk/join-trade-union/trade-union-membership-your-employment-rights

I know that I have a right to join a union. But in some environments (private sector) it's pointless shading to negative. In my sector there is no relevant union so there's no one in that union who would know the landscape or the issues well enough to advocate for you. Additionally it's frowned upon so joining a union would mark you out as being a troublemaker and people would consider it as an act of attention seeking at best or worst trying to start fights.

I know this because when I joined my current company I was a member of a union in an adjacent sector. My colleagues teased me about being a lefty because I had a (lapsed) union membership and I was advised not to tell people by a previous supervisor.

You can't be fired for it but it will mark you out as being "not one of them", "a bit left/woke" and "not management material". It's the kind of thing which will be raised at appraisals etc.

It's shit/legally borderline etc but I'm not alone here. For a large chunk of private sector workers at the moment it just isn't worth the grief.

bardabunga · 09/11/2026 10:52

I agree with others. Being encouraged to show your vulnerability at work will open up a chink in your armour. Your manager can then use that as leverage.

The only three occasions I can ever remember crying at work in my entire career are: receiving a phone call in the office to tell me that a family member had died; coming into work knowing that DH was taking our beloved cat to be put to sleep that morning; and when they presented me with flowers and a leaving gift on the day I retired.

I have never cried at work about work.

mamaof4losingmymind · 09/11/2026 10:31

Thats insane I've worked in my job for 20 years and only cried twice and I have bpd. I wouldn't expect an average mentally healthy person to cry at work at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread