Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find discussing money vulgar?

103 replies

CleverTealGoose · 08/11/2026 16:48

I’ve always found discussing money rather vulgar, particularly when it comes to gifts, salaries and personal finances.

I don’t want to know the monetary value of gifts people give me nor do I want people calculating how much I’ve spent on them. I don’t particularly care to know what other people earn and I don’t disclose my own salary either.

To me, money is a private matter and I find there’s something rather distasteful about attaching monetary values to everything or openly discussing what things cost.

I appreciate that others are much more comfortable talking about money but I personally prefer a bit of discretion.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Wildfairy · 08/11/2026 18:24

Katemax82 · 08/11/2026 18:09

My husband! He happily tells everyone the ins and outs of our finances it's humiliating

Why is it humiliating? That’s a strong word.

GoodGirlFaith · 08/11/2026 18:25

I’m with you on this, OP. I dislike those kinds of conversations too.

Whentherainsetin101 · 08/11/2026 18:27

I’m a bit torn on this one op. I agree it is definitely not polite dinner party conversation but speaking very generally, I think the main group of people who find discussing money “vulgar” are those who have plenty of it.

Wildfairy · 08/11/2026 18:31

WrylyAmused · 08/11/2026 18:13

Given how many women are left high and dry when husbands leave/lose a job/develop a gambling issue etc., or take on the whole burden of the family costs because they didn't grow up talking about finances, haven't had those conversations, and don't have a clear picture of what's been happening, I would rather money was talked about more.

Given how many women (and people in general) are underpaid for the same job, and how many young adults entering the workplace lack knowledge about expected pay over their careers which would be very useful info to help them choose their careers etc, again I think we could very much do with thoroughly breaking this taboo.

Financial literacy in this country is very low, de-mystifying it & making it an everyday conversation would help a lot. Investments, pensions, finance products, cost of loans and credit cards, what kind of purchases are good value, relative risk levels etc.

Household items could go either way - could be boastful or helpfully sharing a bargain.

Asking about gifts, yes, that's often impolite.

But I find it is a good general rule that people in positions of power in whichever dimension you're speaking about tend to benefit the most by that topic not being discussed, so in this as in most things I'm in favour of as much honest and open discussion as possible, shine light into things and improve general levels of knowledge and education around them.

As much as demystifying it is valid, I see that more as educating people on how to manage money, not everyone talking about it and sharing personal finances, and the reason for that is judgment and envy is common place.

i find the ops predicament unusual. Like many on here I’ve never been asked how much I earn by someone I’m not close to, where even there it’s a mutual discussion. I d never been asked how much my home cost by some random or loose acquaintance either,

discussing how much we spend on gifts and how much Xmas costs I find quite common place, but not telling someone how much their own gift costs.

i do go back to the ops use of the word vulgar though, it’s such a dated word and smacks a bit of hyacinth bucket, anyone taking that view I would assume feels a sense of embarrassment about it , either as they are very wealthy, or they are much poorer than they wish people to know.

karrapo · 08/11/2026 18:31

Some know the price of everything and the value of nothing. Thank you Mr. Wilde. 😊

Trottersup · 08/11/2026 18:33

I talk about investments, pensions etc in a vague sense but I'd never tell anyone how much I had. It's a sizeable amount.

Abitlosttoday · 08/11/2026 18:33

CleverTealGoose · 08/11/2026 16:55

People who discuss their salaries, ask others what they earn, volunteer how much they’ve spent on gifts, comment on what things cost or speculate about other people’s finances. I’m referring to everyday social conversations, not suggesting that everyone engages in them.

Working for a small advertising company around 15 years ago, the finance director told me that it wasn't part of the culture to discuss salaries with colleagues. He implied it was vulgar, in fact. Turns out that all the men on my team were paid £6K to £10K more than me, the only women, similar level of seniority. I will keep talking about money.

CleverTealGoose · 08/11/2026 18:34

Cranx · 08/11/2026 18:11

Do you think it is maybe just your friends’ attitudes? Nobody has ever asked my salary. My family don’t present me with gifts and tell me how much they have spent on me. They’ve never discussed how much I have spent on them either. Sorry, but your friends sound a bit odd.

I’m not sure why you’ve assumed I’m referring specifically to my friends or that these are behaviours I’ve necessarily experienced within my own social circle. I’m expressing a general view about discussing personal finances and the monetary value of gifts. The fact that you haven’t encountered these conversations doesn’t mean they don’t occur in other social settings.

OP posts:
Octavia64 · 08/11/2026 18:36

There’s money and money.

a certain amount of education about personal finance - what credit cards are, mortgages, interest etc is on the school curriculum and yes people do need to know this.

countries where salaries are transparent have much lower gender pay gaps. It genuinely is one thing I hate about job adverts with no salary and you’ve got to guess what it is. At least in education (my area) they have scales.

one of the good things about glass door is you can see salaries.

parents should talk about money much much more with their kids.

honeylulu · 08/11/2026 18:42

My natural instinct is to feel it's crass and vulgar. My parents were always very clear about that and I don't think i can "unlearn" it now.

My husband is also discreet but has pointed out that this English coyness is an advantage to employers who can pay different salaries for the same jobs to different people while keeping them in the dark. So there's something to be said for more transparency. Not necessarily going as far as the "considerably richer than yow" Harry Enfield character.

Hermione101 · 08/11/2026 18:44

Women should 100% be discussing salaries, investing, financial independence, savings, etc…

HRTQueen · 08/11/2026 18:48

it doesn’t bother me I do not ask someone how much they earn as I know it’s not the done thing in the UK but not bothered if people ask me or how much something costs and so on

I love telling people I have got a bargain and how much I have saved must be the Asian in me 😆

FizzyPopLove · 08/11/2026 18:50

If everyone where open about salaries then it would be harder for employers to get away with paying women less, for example.

Fridgemanageress · 08/11/2026 19:01

The second, people start declaring prices etc is the second my husband generally starts kicking me under the table to wake up!

im happy in my own skin, with my house, bank balances and achievements, that may sound selfish, but life is way too short to worry!

TheBers · 08/11/2026 19:04

SleepZealot · 08/11/2026 16:58

Have to say, I’m a huuuuge fan of women discussing finances.

Agree. It’s part of the patriarchy.
Worth as a person being related to earnings and wealth. Women are still at a disadvantage given their bodies have 9 months of being given over to another human and all that entails afterwards. It’s not a level field, hence all the laws around women needed to match up our disadvantage when it comes to earnings.
When the richest people in the world are 50/50 men and women then job done.

notspringingback · 08/11/2026 19:21

Do you ever give any thought to why you feel this way? Objectively, what’s wrong with people talking about how much they earn? Do you ever spend any time reflecting on your attitude to this subject?

Quine0nline · 08/11/2026 19:33

DelilahSong · 08/11/2026 16:53

The people who are uncomfortable discussing money are the only ones that make it seem vulgar and awkward. It’s not something I have the energy to be uptight about.

No.

"Look at my wad, I've got loadsa money"

"My wife has noticed that we appear to be much richer than you"

CalledIt · 08/11/2026 19:38

CleverTealGoose · 08/11/2026 16:55

People who discuss their salaries, ask others what they earn, volunteer how much they’ve spent on gifts, comment on what things cost or speculate about other people’s finances. I’m referring to everyday social conversations, not suggesting that everyone engages in them.

Well, maybe you need to change everyone you spend time with? I don’t think I’ve ever had a conversation about salary or ‘personal finances’, far less how much a present cost.

I do have the odd conversation with fellow-writers about advances and film/ tv options, but that’s absolutely voluntary on everyone’s part.

Freshrain · 08/11/2026 19:45

I voted YABU because of the all encompassing nature of your statement.

Whereas I was brought up in a time it was considered unwise to discuss 'money, politics, or religion', I have to agree with so many others that secrecy around salaries (and 'renumeration packages' as a whole) is not a good thing to encourage. It has led to much discrimination, and also, in part to the now HUGE disparities between the haves and the have nots.
I think salaries should be very transparent in advertisements and workplaces, although it would also be very crass in a social situation to start boasting bout what you earn.

I also think we, as society, should talk more about finances and budgeting and how much more you pay for all sorts of things when you are poor, than people who have more money have to - from prepayment meters charging more for electricity, to people on the bones of their arses' only option for a loan being at ridiculous interest rates, to people without money not being able to afford a month's bus / train pass (making travel a LOT cheaper than people who have to pay daily) to people who don't have the money in their account to buy the 'buy one get 2nd half price' offers, or 'buy in bulk discounts' etc. etc. etc.
We should encourage chatter about how much everyone else is paying for broadband or car insurance or utilities, and how credit cards work, and so forth, so that people who never had a good financial education can learn and benefit from other people's knowledge.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 08/11/2026 19:47

FreshInk · 08/11/2026 16:57

I suspect those who find discussions about money vulgar are often fortunate enough never to have been in a position where discussing it wasn’t a choice, but a necessity.

This!

Generally I avoid the 'gossip' style money convos...

BUT had I not been frank, when asked my close colleagues, about the anount I managed to negotiate for a( low level) NHS post, others would not have been confident in trying to negotiate hard.

It keeps women at the bottom of the pile.

Structurally, society relies on people not knowing details of others' financial positions, and it makes women, specifically, lose out.

Cruisinforcroissant · 08/11/2026 19:48

I think it’s a good thing to talk about money confidently- if we had been doing this in the past the gender and pension pay gaps wouldn’t be as stark IMO

brownbootsandhats · 08/11/2026 19:50

I can’t vote as the circumstances matter

someone telling you their salary - husband that’s necessary , a friend saying that she can’t afford to do something becuase of it - you should respect that confidence, someone wanting some advice from you - again necessary and sometimes I think people need to be a little more open about their finances especially if you have children so they can understand and talk without feeling awkward

tit for tat gift analysis - very poor form

showing you a new bag or whatever and talking about its cost rather than how much she loves it - very poor form

how much or how little something cost - I don’t really want to know

Greenmouldycheese · 08/11/2026 19:51

Ive always wondered why people feel the way you do, particularly about salaries. I dont discuss money but if I was asked what my salary was or how much something costs, I would just say. Is it because you dont want people to know you live beyond your means?

Snoken · 08/11/2026 19:54

I live in Sweden when money talk isn’t taboo or seen as vulgar. I know how much all of my friends earn, what their homes are worth, we discuss our savings/investments etc. Income and value of homes are both public information, so are criminal convictions, pet ownership, name changes and probably other things I have forgotten about. To me the British are unusually easy to offend and I am glad that I live in a more open society.

latetothefisting · 08/11/2026 20:03

I would think it depends? 'money' is a very wide topic. Transparency around salaries etc. can often be a good thing, particularly for women.

Discussing bargains, mortgages etc. can sometimes be helpful between friends and family although I wouldn't want it to be a majority of my conversations.

Bragging about how much you paid for something, yes that's usually a bit cringe, and, to be honest, boring.