I’m interested to know what your personal experience is as you sound very cold and also like you haven’t lost someone you loved to dementia. Maybe you have but you don’t acknowledge the complexities of how the personality would likely change the desire to die.
For example, I lost my mum to dementia. As a fit and well person, she would have agreed with you, she always said that she would hate to lose her mind and would rather die. Reality was, once she was showing significant symptoms, enough for a diagnosis, she had a new normal. Yes it was messy and confusing an often chaotic but if you’d have asked her at that point if she wanted to end her life, she would not have said yes. In fact, when she was much further down the line and actually dying she was frightened and didn’t want to.
Also, you’re expecting dementia patients to remember they’ve made this massive choice and be consistent in their decision. Reality is, they won’t remember and could come up with an entirely different response on another day.
Re the legalities, I would also think it would be open to significant abuse. Greedy and/or heartless relatives who coerce vulnerable people into choices that they shouldn’t be making.
It a no from me. Yes, it was tough when my mum was suffering and I guess it was a burden but her feeling that she should end her life to stop being that burden would have broken me more than caring for her.