Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Merryvell · 08/11/2026 17:08

Lots of posters talking about' sundown' panic attacks. There is some hope that ADHD drugs used to calm neurodivergent people will have a positive effect on those with dementia. The trials have started.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:08

An offer would be one thing, and probably helpful to the patient, but I don't see how it would be possible to guard against possible coercion, and/or abuse of assisted dying for budgetary or other logistical reasons.

Themaghag · 08/11/2026 17:10

I was always in favour of assisted dying until I joined Mumsnet, but after a few years of reading some of the really vile and spiteful posts that have appeared on threads relating to disability and benefits, I've changed my mind. I think the sick and disabled would be subjected to the most dreadful pressure to end their lives before they were ready to do so. Accordingly, I've voted that you are being very unreasonable indeed OP.

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 08/11/2026 17:10

Dontbesonosy · 08/11/2026 17:07

We should be doing everything to prevent people from feeling that they are a burden.

“The bad news is - you have dementia. The good news is - you can choose to die early and not inconvenience your loved ones. Just sign here”
This is not a civilised society.

This in spades. We seem to be going backwards as a society in the way illness and disabilities are viewed.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:12

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 15:40

I suspect you had a more fixed view from the outset than you suggest.

Do you not think it's a good thing for people to have firm opinions about a topic as massive as this?

Anyahyacinth · 08/11/2026 17:12

Just a horrible thread...at diagnosis?!!

What a way to add to the terror. Lots of people have years of happy life after diagnosis. This is a dangerous way to think about life and its value.

DisappearingGirl · 08/11/2026 17:14

There is dementia in my family, as well as Parkinson's which isn't particularly nice either. Unfortunately it's combined with being otherwise physically healthy so not much else to kill you off.

I would love to be able to sign something now too say "If I get dementia and reach x point I'd like to be euthanised". I understand the decline is variable but I still think we could estimate a sensible point. It would give me great peace of mind.

Bunnycat101 · 08/11/2026 17:15

It is difficult because people can have some good years even with dementia and the decline can be gradual.

my husband’s grandma had dementia for many years but I would say has a good quality of life for the first few, there was then a grey middle area where she was happy but causing lots of issues for his parents and then a very hard 18 months in assisted living and then care. If you had a crystal ball you’d have wanted to end it before the last 18 months. His other grandmother deteriorated rapidly and was in a home for a couple of months but didn’t really last long. I don’t know which trajectory I’d rather have tbh.

My own mum is actively being kept alive in her care home and I would 100% rather be dead than live like she is. As callous as it sounds we’re waiting on an infection to end her suffering. She’s on a constant low dose antibiotics as each time she gets a UTI she becomes very aggressive and awful to manage so god knows what will eventually kill her as she’s had Covid, flu jabs etc as well as the antibiotics. I am going to put in my own advanced directive not to consent to vaccinations if I’m in with dementia.

Monty36 · 08/11/2026 17:15

I do not think anyone with experience of it would want to endure it. YANBU.
And endure is what it is.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:18

Anyahyacinth · 08/11/2026 17:12

Just a horrible thread...at diagnosis?!!

What a way to add to the terror. Lots of people have years of happy life after diagnosis. This is a dangerous way to think about life and its value.

To go by this and other recent threads, many think life doesn't have value if it's not being lived in a state of optimal health and productivity. It's harrowing.

Society is poised at the top of a very slippery slope indeed.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:18

DisappearingGirl · 08/11/2026 17:14

There is dementia in my family, as well as Parkinson's which isn't particularly nice either. Unfortunately it's combined with being otherwise physically healthy so not much else to kill you off.

I would love to be able to sign something now too say "If I get dementia and reach x point I'd like to be euthanised". I understand the decline is variable but I still think we could estimate a sensible point. It would give me great peace of mind.

And if at that point the person feels differently and wishes to continue?

HappyMamma2023 · 08/11/2026 17:19

I recommend reading Christine Bryden's 'Dancing with Dementia'. She wrote this after being diagnosed with dementia. Not everyone is affected the same with dementia and many dementia clients I meet everyday still enjoy important and meaningful occupations. I think OP's view is very short-sighted.

TheCabbageMerchant · 08/11/2026 17:21

HappyMamma2023 · 08/11/2026 17:19

I recommend reading Christine Bryden's 'Dancing with Dementia'. She wrote this after being diagnosed with dementia. Not everyone is affected the same with dementia and many dementia clients I meet everyday still enjoy important and meaningful occupations. I think OP's view is very short-sighted.

Sure, they do for a while. Not everyone has the same rate of decline. But ultimately unless something else kills you first, your death from dementia will still be the same undignified, inhumane experience it is for everyone else.

Whatalunatic · 08/11/2026 17:22

Is it not too late once there is a diagnosis? I am not comfortable with foistingbthat on someone who is so very, very vulnerable.

I do think that around the age of 50 we should be allowed to seek a psychological assessment and then make a living will which is lodged somewhere the NHS can find it. That could include instructions on euthanasia in certain circumstances - dementia is the obvious one. It could also include 'resuscitate me to the bitter end' instructions if you feel that way inclined. Needs to be something your next of kin can't override. Your wishes, not someone else's.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 17:25

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:18

To go by this and other recent threads, many think life doesn't have value if it's not being lived in a state of optimal health and productivity. It's harrowing.

Society is poised at the top of a very slippery slope indeed.

You don't have the authority to lecture other people on what they ought to want

And dementia isn't just sub optimal health, it is the loss of your self and soul

OP posts:
RachelDuffy · 08/11/2026 17:27

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 14:50

And anyone who IS keen on killing people for a living, is probably not someone you'd want to be doing it.

Is this how you feel about vets?

EwwSprouts · 08/11/2026 17:28

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 16:41

I have reached the stage where I believe this to be a "line to take" circulated by pro life activists. "I can see where you're coming from but..." You cannot see where I'm coming from - the two risks are not evenly matched

The risks are even and light on safeguards is utterly irresponsible. Have you read the case of Baroness Jane Campbell who doctors wanted to write off as having no quality of life? It's not that long since Shipman. The statistics from Canada and the Netherlands show the effects of the slippery slope in action.

Take two prominent campaigners, Terry Pratchett with Alzheimers and Esther Rantzen with cancer. Both vocal in their support of right to choose. Yet when it came to it neither did. Whatever their reasons they never took that step when they could. Hope for a few more weeks prevails in many cases.

There is also a lot of evidence that even when spouses have agreed to tell doctors eg pneumonia is a time to let the husband/wife go, they can't do it. It's a transference of a different burden on to others.

I am not ignorant nor ill-informed nor religious. MIL had a rubbish few years in a care home by my standards but she seemed to have a strong will to live. DH & BIL a couple of times followed doctors advice that it might be kinder not to treat something and prepare to say goodbye and then she would rally. They would have really struggled to say pump her full of morphine because she was not showing distress.

DisappearingGirl · 08/11/2026 17:28

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:18

And if at that point the person feels differently and wishes to continue?

Well that's a very interesting moral question! What if I'm certain as an adult with full capacity that I want euthanasia at a specific point of dementia, but then once I have dementia I say no I don't want it? I agree it's a big problem.

I think I would want my current self to be able to override my later self with dementia. I guess you'd have to sign that at the time.

Marieb19 · 08/11/2026 17:30

There are worse diseases than dementia, such as MND. I am 100% pro assisted dying but absolutely against it being offered or suggested by medical professionals or family. It is an area fraught with safeguarding issues and should only be requested by the patient.

PigletJohn · 08/11/2026 17:32

Loveofeclairs · 08/11/2026 13:43

I voted YABU. I’m leaning towards legalising assisted dying but I don’t think it should be automatically offered on any diagnosis. People might feel pressured into it because they don’t want to be a burden and that shouldn’t really be a consideration at all.

Offering gives choice

Withholding the offer denies that choice.

kitex · 08/11/2026 17:32

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:18

To go by this and other recent threads, many think life doesn't have value if it's not being lived in a state of optimal health and productivity. It's harrowing.

Society is poised at the top of a very slippery slope indeed.

People in the past generally died much quicker than people do today. This slow decline is problematic.

Mossyfox · 08/11/2026 17:34

No I absolutely disagree with assisted dying. But I disagree with keeping people alive. Let nature take it's course with all necessary pain relief.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:36

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 17:25

You don't have the authority to lecture other people on what they ought to want

And dementia isn't just sub optimal health, it is the loss of your self and soul

I am not 'lecturing', I am contributing to a discussion, as is normal in discussion forums. If you wanted an echo chamber of agreement you should have said so at the outset

DisappearingGirl · 08/11/2026 17:38

I also think the discussion of cost and being a burden is interesting.

For me it's the balance between cost and quality of life. This is what the NHS looks at for new medical treatments.

While I don't think anyone should be talked into being killed off just to save money, for me personally the cost does come into it. If I'm a shell of myself with very little quality of life, then even if I'm not actively suffering, I don't think that kind of life is worth £70,000 a year in a care home. I'd much rather that money either went to my children or was spent on someone else in society who will actually benefit from it.

Interestingly the NHS will pay for a new treatment if the cost is up to £25-35,000 per extra year of life in full health (or the equivalent e.g. 2 years with a quality of life half that of full health). I'm pretty sure that nursing care for someone with advanced dementia would not reach this threshold so would not be considered cost-effective. But with no assisted dying, we have no choice but to pay for it.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:38

kitex · 08/11/2026 17:32

People in the past generally died much quicker than people do today. This slow decline is problematic.

It is, but no one has the right to start killing people because they consider them to have lived too long.