Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Thelnebriati · 15/11/2026 19:49

Describing victims of coercive control as 'weak' is victim blaming.

CurdinHenry · 15/11/2026 19:41

Gloriia · 15/11/2026 14:47

Do it then just stop trying to get it on the NHS as part of some kind of end the burdens action plan.

Or... You could just not be so weak and make decisions for yourself. Choice doesn't mean compulsion (as with abortion rights).

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 15/11/2026 19:37

aptlynamed · 15/11/2026 19:25

All this just give me the CHOICE stuff - just shouting that at people isn't going to change anyone's mind when the thing you just want the CHOICE to do can have negative consequences for other people. In this case because to give it to you, a whole system for state-assisted dying would have to be set up, and that has implications for more than just you.

If your individual CHOICE to die didn't require a system that will affect by its mere existence other people like those who may end up being coerced, and those health professionals who would have to be involved in your death, then there wouldn't be any issue with it. But it does, so it just isn't that simple.

I think you should accept that you and everyone you love will die as a starting point, that's inevitable. Whether or not they die in terror and agony is a choice.

OP posts:
aptlynamed · 15/11/2026 19:25

All this just give me the CHOICE stuff - just shouting that at people isn't going to change anyone's mind when the thing you just want the CHOICE to do can have negative consequences for other people. In this case because to give it to you, a whole system for state-assisted dying would have to be set up, and that has implications for more than just you.

If your individual CHOICE to die didn't require a system that will affect by its mere existence other people like those who may end up being coerced, and those health professionals who would have to be involved in your death, then there wouldn't be any issue with it. But it does, so it just isn't that simple.

Thelnebriati · 15/11/2026 18:36

People are uncomfortable with oversharing because of the safeguarding and consent issue, not because the disease is unpleasant.

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2026 18:22

No one needs any more awareness we all know it's a terrible condition.

Some people obviously need reminding when they think sufferers should just man/woman up and develop “resilience” and “learn to live with massive challenges”. Obviously people sharing their experiences makes uncomfortable viewing for some people because it destroys their argument.

Gloriia · 15/11/2026 16:43

When we talk about lack of dignity for those with Alzheimer's I tell you what annoys me, relatives who 'raise awareness'/overhare on tv or in woe is me memoirs.

I've lost count of the amount of articles I've read about John Suchet chatting about his poor late wife Bonnie's deterioration and how he met his new wife in the very care home where their stricken spouses were suffering <only romantically involved post spouses deaths but very close friends before>. His new wife says how her previous dh used to urinate everywhere and throw food.

Julie Goodyear's 'dh' posting very unflattering pictures of Goodyear. Ditto Fiona Phillip's dh describing at length her inability to do anything for herself and how awful it is. He then posts an unflattering picture that an ex celebrity like Phillips wouldn't ever want circulating.

We get it. We know it's awful but fgs please let these people have some privacy and stop describing their every deficit it great detail. Protect them! No one needs any more awareness we all know it's a terrible condition.

Neuronimo · 15/11/2026 16:10

I have a Farther in the advanced stages of dementia and several other life limiting illnesses. His quality of life is pretty rubbish but I have voted YABU. This is because of two things. Firstly, both Mum and Dad have been harangued and harrassed into signing DNR forms, to the point that someone has been to the house. Both are firm in not wanting this, so I think that Dad still has the will to soldier on.

The second is that I think on a bad day, even at the beginning, he'd have agreed or requested this, but on good days, he still had some enjoyment in life. I'd worry that people lacked the capacity to make an informed decision, when they are already mentally prepared. We occasionally still have meaningful discussions and we as a family value his life. I am already thinking about what I'd want in advance of any such diagnosis. The bad times are truely awful for the whole family.

Gloriia · 15/11/2026 15:00

SinisterBumFacedCat · 15/11/2026 11:44

Comparing Rob Burrows to a dementia sufferer is like comparing a cat to Ford Focus. There is no robotic voice that can articulate what a dementia sufferer is seeing, thinking or the pain and fear they are feeling. There is no computer you can hook up to a dementia sufferers brain to explain that you are just washing them or taking them to the toilet and not assaulting them.

The suffering endured is not a competition but I'd suggest a young man in his prime absolutely suffered more than many even with a 'robotic voice'.

Chronic illnesses are not easy, severe degenerative illnesses are awful we all agree on that but living with them is what we should be supporting and encouraging. Having suicide pills available opens up a massive ethical minefield and again, 'wearing' as it is to keep having to say it provides an opportunity for relatives sick of caring for their 'loved one' to start putting pressure on.

Gloriia · 15/11/2026 14:47

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2026 11:24

It’s so wearing, isn’t it? Maybe we don’t want to live with massive challenges. Maybe we just want to slip away quietly. The end of life shouldn’t be an endurance test.

Do it then just stop trying to get it on the NHS as part of some kind of end the burdens action plan.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 15/11/2026 11:44

Comparing Rob Burrows to a dementia sufferer is like comparing a cat to Ford Focus. There is no robotic voice that can articulate what a dementia sufferer is seeing, thinking or the pain and fear they are feeling. There is no computer you can hook up to a dementia sufferers brain to explain that you are just washing them or taking them to the toilet and not assaulting them.

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2026 11:24

kitex · 15/11/2026 08:13

“Maybe look at someone like Rob Burrows and his family and friends as a lesson on living with massive challenges.”

You really don’t get it! Just because he lived with MND other people can’t and they choose to go to Switzerland. Not everyone can afford that. For the very last time, give people a CHOICE!!!

It’s so wearing, isn’t it? Maybe we don’t want to live with massive challenges. Maybe we just want to slip away quietly. The end of life shouldn’t be an endurance test.

Tumbleweed101 · 15/11/2026 09:49

I’ve looked after dementia patients- thankfully, not within my family so far - and agree it can be an awful way to go.

People can get angry and suspicious of those caring for them. One lady called the police daily after her morning care because she genuinely thought they’d stolen her handbag. Another forgot how to use cutlery. Many wandered trying to find an old home. Most forgot their loved ones and looked for past loved ones. Some became sexually inappropriate and exposed themselves.

Later, many were bed bound, in a lot of pain and confusion. It was awful to witness and try to care for them without upsetting them more. Trying to convince someone to eat now, when she’ll eat with her husband later, after he’d passed many years ago, without having to give her the reminder he’d died again and again which for her was fresh news could be hard.

I agree that it does get to a point it would be far kinder to let someone pass peacefully but it’s knowing the point this is in each individual that would be hard to legislate.

kitex · 15/11/2026 08:13

Gloriia · 15/11/2026 07:39

The answer is support, symptom control, research into slowing disease progression, explaining to relatives that their loved one hasn't 'died' as they can't remember their name etc etc.

Advocating pts as if we were animals is not the solution.

If people choose to do so independently that is up to them, I'm sure there is plenty of weird stuff online to point them in the right direction so relatives are not distressed at having to find their body. Trying to have it as some kind of action plan available on the NHS opens the door to coercion, pressure, mad rels wanting their hands on properties before care homes grab assets etc.

Chronic illness is of course very unpleasant and apparently relatives struggling are a dreadful burden for some on here. Let's look after our loved ones rather than trying to speed up their demise.

Maybe look at someone like Rob Burrows and his family and friends as a lesson on living with massive challenges.

Edited

“Maybe look at someone like Rob Burrows and his family and friends as a lesson on living with massive challenges.”

You really don’t get it! Just because he lived with MND other people can’t and they choose to go to Switzerland. Not everyone can afford that. For the very last time, give people a CHOICE!!!

Gloriia · 15/11/2026 07:39

The answer is support, symptom control, research into slowing disease progression, explaining to relatives that their loved one hasn't 'died' as they can't remember their name etc etc.

Advocating pts as if we were animals is not the solution.

If people choose to do so independently that is up to them, I'm sure there is plenty of weird stuff online to point them in the right direction so relatives are not distressed at having to find their body. Trying to have it as some kind of action plan available on the NHS opens the door to coercion, pressure, mad rels wanting their hands on properties before care homes grab assets etc.

Chronic illness is of course very unpleasant and apparently relatives struggling are a dreadful burden for some on here. Let's look after our loved ones rather than trying to speed up their demise.

Maybe look at someone like Rob Burrows and his family and friends as a lesson on living with massive challenges.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 14/11/2026 22:46

Gloriia · 14/11/2026 19:59

Oh no no no you aren't listening silly billy.

Apparently those living a 'shit show' aka having a chronic medical illness should be allowed to off themselves when it all gets a bit much. Having this suicide pill available will in no way mean anyone will feel pressured into doing so because their rels are sick of the 'shit show'. Or some such simple, naive ad nauseam argument.

Thankfully most people recognise that it would be a slippery slope, that people are not dogs that we put to sleep and the answer is disease management and symptom control plus some resilience for all concerned.

I absolutely agree with you. However, just as a question, what about those with debilitating neurological conditions like MS, MND, Parkinson's etc? The people may be doing all they can to be comfortable in body and sound of mind, but it isn't always a case of the person being resilient and controlling symptoms.

Sometimes these chronic illnesses are dreadful, progressive, and an absolute horror for the person living with them.

I have had a decade of horrible, traumatic health problems after three concussions and a chronic neurological involuntary movement disorder, thankfully not progressive, but horribly shitty nonetheless.

To be honest, if I'd been unfortunate enough to have something profoundly awful and progressive like MND, I'd think that an option to be able to end it would be ok.

QiBengong · 14/11/2026 22:46

kitex · 14/11/2026 21:30

If having a social conscience means that people who want to die can’t, you can keep your social conscience!

You have absolute autonomy over your body, and as long as you are physically and mentally capable of carrying out the act, can choose to end your life at any time. We quite rightly, as a society have abandoned the religious and social judgement of this, now try and show compassion and support rather than judgement to individuals with suicidal ideation and to people and families affected by suicide - but we do not make it easier for people or sanction/condone it.

But demanding assistance in dying will automatically involve others. This makes comments like 'I am not responsible for other adults' astonishingly ironic, given what you are fundamentally asking for is that the state, society, and yes, individual workers will take responsibility by providing a mechanism to assist in your death. Its pretty hypocritical to deny the need for you to have a social conscience and consider others, while relying on other people having a social conscience in their dealings with you.

Provision of a mechanism by which an adult can their life will necessarily involve other individuals. On this thread many people described perfectly valid feelings when seeing a relatives suffering, or forcing an unsuspecting person to discover your body if considering suicide, but don't seem to consider that assisted dying demands others are involved in the mechanism of their death. I strongly suspect many individuals in the legal and health professions, no matter how caring and committed to relieving suffering, would conscientiously object and refuse to be involved in providing this service, as it fundamentally changes the nature of what is being asked of them and the responsibility they are being asked to bear.

It is a weighty matter, and many would understandably have difficulty taking on the role (witness how many people would struggle to take on the much lesser responsibility of providing physical care), and it would be inappropriate to force anyone's involvement in the system, against their judgement or conscience. I am even more worried that the sort of people showing enthusiasm for the role, or seeing it as just a neutral, mechanistic task, might be the absolutely wrong individuals to be providing the service.

dreamiesformolly · 14/11/2026 22:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

kitex · 14/11/2026 21:54

dreamiesformolly · 14/11/2026 21:50

Even if it means people who don't want to die have to?

I am not advocating for people to die against their wishes. I am advocating for letting people die if they want to.

I’m just repeating myself time and time again. I’m going to leave this thread now.

dreamiesformolly · 14/11/2026 21:50

kitex · 14/11/2026 21:30

If having a social conscience means that people who want to die can’t, you can keep your social conscience!

Even if it means people who don't want to die have to?

dreamiesformolly · 14/11/2026 21:49

kitex · 14/11/2026 21:35

How is it frightening to give people a choice to end their life if they’ve had enough?

For those of us who care about other people besides ourselves I'd have thought the answer was obvious: the prospect of someone changing their mind and having their wishes overridden because they're not deemed to have capacity.

Uberella · 14/11/2026 21:35

As long as it can be proven that at the time the person has 100% capacity to make that decision for their future self who no longer has the capacity to understand the decision then yes.

I have extensive personal and professional experience with dementia and it is an horrific condition;I wouldn’t want to end up in the condition I’ve seen those with dementia in.

I’ve lost someone very close to me to early on set dementia;they died in their mid sixties:the energetic,vibrant person they were would have been horrified at the shell of a person they became in the end.

My neighbour also committed suicide as they had early stage dementia,they decided they were leaving the world on own terms rather than let themselves decline.

kitex · 14/11/2026 21:35

dreamiesformolly · 14/11/2026 21:32

Completely agree. This thread is plain frightening in parts.

How is it frightening to give people a choice to end their life if they’ve had enough?

dreamiesformolly · 14/11/2026 21:32

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/11/2026 20:30

What would you do about the risk of non-consensual killing?

I'm aware you've asked this twice, @dreamiesformolly, and finding it sadly predictable that there's been no answer beyond "I'm not responsible"

There's more than one kind of "shit show" and I'd suggest another would be if few cared about AD's potential negatives, but I'm still very grateful for such views being expressed so openly

They show us - even if inadvertently - exactly what we need to guard against

Completely agree. This thread is plain frightening in parts.

dreamiesformolly · 14/11/2026 21:31

Datingwoess · 14/11/2026 20:54

Deleted

Edited

I think you should have let that stand, it was a good point. People have been incorrectly placed on the Liverpool Care Pathway due to misdiagnosis of dementia.