Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ShouldBeSeenNotHeard · 08/11/2026 15:53

Didn’t Christina Pike survive execution by Nembutal (aka Pentobarbital)?
And aren’t there huge shortages of Pentobarbital?
So even if morally it was ok, then practically it wouldn’t work?

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 15:52

HPFA · 08/11/2026 15:38

Perhaps we should bear in mind the Nazis started with "mercy killings".

I genuinely don't know where I stand on assisted dying but seeing all these people so convinced that other people's lives aren't worth living is maybe shifting me off the fence.

Say someone has said they wanted to die when they no longer revognise family but when that time comes the person is actually quite happy? Does the doctor go ahead and kill them?

Yes, I've read about cases in the Netherlands, I'll try & find the article, where elderly people resisted the doctor lethally injecting them, but they had asked for it before they developed dementia.

ReturnsAdministrator · 08/11/2026 15:52

100% agree.
I used to do dementia care and it is one big money making scheme (as are most care homes).
People are treated like machines., sleep, feed, toilet, repeat.

Ensuring nutrition and medication is taken prolongs life, but there is rarely any quality of life unless the person is still to some degree independent.
I know which option I would choose if there came a time when I couldn’t look after myself.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 15:51

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 15:44

I think a person should be able to do it themselves in their own homes. Involving a medic, if anything, enhances the risk of undue influence.

I really don't think that would be safe. I completely understand the principle - in your own home, in your own time and way - that would be ideal - but it's too open to abuse to have people walking round with that kind of medication.

It might easily fall into the hands of unscrupulous family member/ 'friend'/ neighbour to sell or use nefariously - bearing in mind that the person it's prescribed to for dementia may well have lost their judgement by the time they come to take the medication.

I don't see how involving a HCP in the administration of the dose increases the risk of undue influence. At worst, the risk is no greater than it would be for self-administration. The HCP isn't just going to turn up, syringe in hand - the person would have to summon them, there could be an inbuilt mandatory 'cooling off period' between requesting the dose and receiving it, there could be a process where two doctors had to be involved - it would be much easier to put in place safeguards.

SiegfriedSassoon · 08/11/2026 15:51

Loveofeclairs · 08/11/2026 13:48

And that’s why I said I’m in favour of it, but not it being automatically offered. A patient shouldn’t be put in a position to have to refuse being be euthanised. That conversation should only ever be initiated by the patient imo.

I agree with this.

Merryvell · 08/11/2026 15:50

@CurdinHenry
So many eloquent posts about the horrors of dementia. Yet, it is still a stock punishment recommended for erring MILS. Trick them into believing they have dementia by hiding things or gas lighting them. I complained about just such a thread last week.
Joking about someone having dementia is never funny .

HPFA · 08/11/2026 15:50

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 15:40

I suspect you had a more fixed view from the outset than you suggest.

No, not really - someone in great pain, of course I understand it.

But do you really not understand the difference between a mentally capable person deciding their own life isn't worth living and you and others on this thread deciding that other people's lives aren't worth anything.?

Neverendingstory111 · 08/11/2026 15:50

It would have to be asked before a diagnosis, unfortunately when you have a diagnosis of dementia it would be very difficult to be seen to be of sound of mind to be able to ask to have assisted dying.

When would it be the right time to die?

Also many people with dementia when it came down to it (even if given consent) would be Extremely distressed to actually have this done.
Or would it be done without them knowing while they were asleep?

My mum has dementia and is extremely upset with any medical procedures even an injection so most of the time it can not be done.
Also she has a lot of other health conditions and unless its life threatening (has dnr) like antibiotics minor things that can help they will not do anything to keep her alive.

Im not against or for it just do not no how it could be implemented.

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 15:50

@CurdinHenryI'm interested to know your thoughts on what I asked earlier. Would this only be applicable for elderly people who have 'lived their lives' or also for people with early-onset dementia and children with MPS3 (described as childhood dementia).

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 15:50

kitex · 08/11/2026 15:46

How will it change? If people don’t want to become carers, what then? People have more care needs than ever before. The job is HARD!

We HAVE to change it somehow. Maybe Japan's idea of robot carers is partly the way to go. The robots are not ideal at the moment as they require carers to operate them a lot but once they can work more autonomously the idea is that they could do the heavy lifting to support human carers so they could focus on emotional support.

As I've said, I also think those who don't want to live with dementia need to write official documents making it clear if they get it they want DNR and only palliative care.

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 08/11/2026 15:49

I think there are a lot of factors. I also think guessing at what it is like or going to be is very different to living it through a close relative for example. So for those without this knowledge, kindly you really don’t have any idea.

The difficulty is when. Dementia can be very long and progress can be slow and then decline fast then a plateau etc. People with dementia can live years and years and be ‘okay’ before the horrible decline.

It can also be a case of good days and bad days until again that horrible decline - so the question is again when.

This shouldn’t be limited to dementia but to anyone who wants the choice with a life altering disease to have say over their own body and mortality without consequence.

cocoonscriticupgrading · 08/11/2026 15:49

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:44

Taking it is the rational choice in that situation, though. Everyone is free to be irrational but the sane should not be denied an escape from the horror.

I find that use of language to be offensive. Somebody with dementia is not insane.

If you (not a personal 'you') are diagnosed with dementia then there is nothing stopping you from legally killing yourself whilst you are fit and able. If you do not want to do it whilst fit and able, at what point do you want legalised euthanasia administered by somebody else to happen? The point when you walk into a room and can't remember what you went in for? The point at which you can't remember the name of a song? Who makes that decision - uh oh, he can't remember aunty Flo's name - said with a knowing nod and slicing movement to the throat.

Nobody should be coerced into dying just because relatives voice the opinion that they find the individual's condition to be a 'horror'.

WannaSweetie · 08/11/2026 15:48

Having Seen my mums decent into dementia I can honestly say she would not have wanted to live like that, I grieved her loss while she was still alive & would not want my DD to face that with me.
However the offer of assisted dying is really tricky IMO as once the dementia is diagnosed if it’s at the start the person will be in denial & if it’s advanced the person wouldn’t legally have capacity surely.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 08/11/2026 15:47

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 14:02

There is nothing (nothing) worse than dying of dementia so I'm happy to go light on safeguards personally.

I’m sorry that your relatives had such terrible experiences. However, not every dementia patient dies in distress.

I’ve lost three relatives to dementia and there was no screaming. In fact, I’m not aware of any screaming from any of them at any point in their illnesses. They passed peacefully away in their beds after becoming ill with infections.

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 15:47

BrilliantBetty · 08/11/2026 15:44

Yes to assisted dying. As soon as possible once you’re incapable of managing ordinary tasks and living a somewhat enjoyable life. If you’re in pain, if you’re scared, if you’re unable to manage anything yourself and don’t recognise your family - it’s over. Peace and dignity should be a basic human right.

Does this mean anyone who needs stuff like being fed, having their teeth brushed, maybe toilet help, automatically has a 'life unworthy of living'? If so, that has worrying implications for many disabled children and adults.

kitex · 08/11/2026 15:46

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 15:40

That's true, and must change, but pressuring people to kill themselves once they reach a certain stage is not the change we need.

How will it change? If people don’t want to become carers, what then? People have more care needs than ever before. The job is HARD!

Janetwin · 08/11/2026 15:45

Iwannamarryharry · 08/11/2026 15:41

My father tried to take his own life after his diagnosis. But he was found and “saved”.

His nosedive into dementia was fast - it was 8 months from still tutoring A level students in Maths at the age of 82, to sitting in a chair staring ahead in silence and occasionally screaming.

”Saving” him meant 4 year of living hell for him trapped in his own head and being abused in two care homes.

I made the mistake once of telling a stupid social worker, who said, “thank god his neighbor found him, you’ve had these extra years with him” that no, I wished his suicide attempt had been successful, he wouldn’t have wanted to sit dribbling in a chair and having moments when he was so distressed he was crying and begging for his long dead mother. Those extra years were torture for him and me.

I was banned from being alone with him for 6 months after I’d said that, incase I tried to help him do it again.

(Actually, if I hadn’t had young children at the time, I would have offed us both. Taken the dementia from him and the hell of fighting for him after the abuse he endured in care homes from me, it’s left me with horrendous mental health issues).

Edited

I’m so very sorry. For some, it is a disease worse than death.

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 15:45

I do think one thing people who think like this should do is write down clearly that if they get dementia they want to be DNR and don't want infections etc treated, just to receive palliative care. That would ensure the suffering would not go on too long for those who feared it.

It's also worth noting Boomers have worse health on average than the Silent Generation, so many may not live as long, which is sad if they are enjoying life but could lessen the agony of some.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 15:44

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 15:42

Would that not be hugely open to abuse, though? Both from people with suicidal ideation - possibly young people who are influenced/groomed by social media and need support, not enablement - and people who want to commit murder, whether for their own benefit or because they want to impose 'euthanasia' on someone who may or may not want it.

There are people who would pay a lot for medication that would enable a quick and painless death. I understand that morphine can be stockpiled to lethal levels and an overdose of many medications might be lethal in sufficient quantities, but there's always going to be potential for error if someone is guessing at a fatal dose. A guaranteed 'fatal dose' medicine would sell for a lot under the counter.

If we are saying assisted death should be easily available - which I don't disagree with in principle - I do think we need to keep in place a strict control that the medication is administered by a registered and specifically qualified and licensed doctor.

I think a person should be able to do it themselves in their own homes. Involving a medic, if anything, enhances the risk of undue influence.

OP posts:
BrilliantBetty · 08/11/2026 15:44

Yes to assisted dying. As soon as possible once you’re incapable of managing ordinary tasks and living a somewhat enjoyable life. If you’re in pain, if you’re scared, if you’re unable to manage anything yourself and don’t recognise your family - it’s over. Peace and dignity should be a basic human right.

GintyMcGinty · 08/11/2026 15:44

Appalling suggestion

ownedbymydogs · 08/11/2026 15:43

I was quite ambivalent when the parliamentary debate over the assisted dying bill was happening, but having read through this thread (and coming from a family of medics) I couldn’t be more relieved it didn’t get through.

And as for @CurdinHenry , genuinely, have you considered some sort of therapy for you self acknowledged anger issues?

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 15:42

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 15:33

I think it should be something we can pick up in the chemist (just as we can pick up morphine in some circumstances).

Would that not be hugely open to abuse, though? Both from people with suicidal ideation - possibly young people who are influenced/groomed by social media and need support, not enablement - and people who want to commit murder, whether for their own benefit or because they want to impose 'euthanasia' on someone who may or may not want it.

There are people who would pay a lot for medication that would enable a quick and painless death. I understand that morphine can be stockpiled to lethal levels and an overdose of many medications might be lethal in sufficient quantities, but there's always going to be potential for error if someone is guessing at a fatal dose. A guaranteed 'fatal dose' medicine would sell for a lot under the counter.

If we are saying assisted death should be easily available - which I don't disagree with in principle - I do think we need to keep in place a strict control that the medication is administered by a registered and specifically qualified and licensed doctor.

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 15:42

HPFA · 08/11/2026 15:38

Perhaps we should bear in mind the Nazis started with "mercy killings".

I genuinely don't know where I stand on assisted dying but seeing all these people so convinced that other people's lives aren't worth living is maybe shifting me off the fence.

Say someone has said they wanted to die when they no longer revognise family but when that time comes the person is actually quite happy? Does the doctor go ahead and kill them?

Yes, to me it feels a bit like when people began to listen to the more extreme proposals of some TRAs and realised to many it wasn't simply about 'live and let live'. Some people advocate assisted dying with good motives but some do not.

As they say, when someone shows you who they are, believe them.

Janetwin · 08/11/2026 15:41

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 15:31

How would it work? Both my parents have dementia, but at different stages. My mum can't do anything anymore but she doesn't seem unhappy as such, just locked in some odd world of her own. My dad is still functioning but he's at the stage where he asks you the same question (no exaggeration) up to twenty times in a row.

I will doubtless go the same way but I'm not sure what my cut-off for dying would be - perhaps when I lost continence? It's a catch 22 in that by the time you have completely lost touch with reality you are no longer capable of knowing whether you want to go on living or not.

That catch 22 is exactly the problem with dementia and assisted dying. The point at which the disease taken the last of your memory and personality, is the very point where you don’t have the “capacity” to make decisions.