Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
eatreadsleeprepeat · 08/11/2026 17:05

Mableandable · 08/11/2026 13:45

I didn’t vote because it’s just not that simple. There are many illnesses that are equally as brutal in different ways - cancers, degenerative diseases, chronic illnesses, disabilities caused through accidents etc.

Dementia is hideous but should not be singled out.

Indeed but it is already made different by a couple of important facts.
If you have dementia you lose the person you were, you lose agency and capacity. If you have cancer or many degenerative diseases you can be cared for in a hospice or will have access to nurses who can visit at home. If you have dementia you have to find and fund your care.
I have watched both parents and one PIL suffer long declines with dementia. I don’t want my dc to have that as their last relationship with me. I want the right to choose, it makes me sad that I might feel the need to act sooner than ideal so that I avoid having to have help.

TriciaA1991 · 08/11/2026 17:05

It isn't so simple. Many dementia patients are relatively happy and where do you draw the line?? Who decides when they should be "put down" like an animal??

ArabellaFishwife · 08/11/2026 17:04

Seagulldancing · 08/11/2026 14:06

My DM now has dementia. And despite having spent her life saying she'd rather die than end up like her aunt, she has now totally changed her mind.
Discussions in abstract can't deal with the reality of a diagnosis, especially when your decision making skills are already impaired.
Its a nightmare and without being willing to kill off old people as a society, its nearly impossible to fix.

Edited

Exactly this. My MIL worked with dementia patients, and always insisted that if she ever got it, she'd resort to pills and a bottle of whisky. She was never going into a home. In reality, the version of dementia that she suffered was apparent to everyone but her. And yes, she had a horrible couple of years before her death. During that time, though, she was terrified of dying, not living. How do you deal with that?

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 17:03

I've been trying to think through how this might work and, in an alternative world where a process existed, how I would feel in relation to my mum.

Supposing at some point when my mum had full capacity, she had signed a 'euthanasia request' form. I imagine it would be worded along these lines - this is vastly simplified as the real thing would require medical and legal caveats, but along these lines:

"I, Mrs Duck, request that euthanasia be performed on me when all of the following thresholds have been met:

  • I have lost all continence
  • I no longer recognise my immediate family members - Mr Duck, Ms Duck1 and Ms Duck2.
  • I can no longer feed myself
I authorise my daughters, Ms Duck1 and Ms Duck2 to request euthanasia on my behalf. Both parties must consent to this.

I understand that two appropriately qualified doctors must confirm the above thresholds have been met and that the final decision to administer euthanasia rests with the two doctors.

I understand that I can withdraw consent for euthanasia at any time before the above thresholds have been met."

The thing is, even if she had signed that - there is now no doubt that she is beyond the above example thresholds - I do not know if I could bring myself to invoke the process. I wish she would meet a peaceful and natural end, but bringing that about myself - I am not sure I could ever do it.

SmudgeButt · 08/11/2026 17:02

I don't think assisted dying in any sense should be mentioned at the point of diagnosis for anything. Too often people are in a state of shock. The shock may become depression that then pushes them to a death that they might not otherwise want.

I do think it should be an option at a later point although obviously with dementia having been diagnosed would a statement that one wanted to die sooner rather than later even be valid? You've already been assessed as being without all your faculties.

HPFA · 08/11/2026 16:59

godmum56 · 08/11/2026 16:06

when the future is a few months or less it bloody well is.

Except that's not what this thread is talking about.

W0tnow · 08/11/2026 16:57

Women are no doubt deeply upset at an abortion being offered or suggested in some circumstances. It doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be presented as an option on the table.

That said, it’s a difficult one. I have a beloved, and I mean beloved, family member who has Alzheimer’s. They still know who everyone is, and is looking forward to Christmas Day as they know it will be the last ‘lucid’ one. Still, there are times in the night where they don’t recognise their spouse of 50+ years. In this case I would 100% support their spouse making the decision when the time came. But of course this can’t be. This disease doesn’t seem to progress at a predictable rate. I would prefer to ‘pull the trigger’ so to speak, at the point where I didn’t know my family. But of course there are good days and bad days.

On balance though, I support it in the case of dementia when death could be years away.

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 08/11/2026 16:56

I believe that one of the safeguards put into the bill (rightly so, in my opinion) was that a doctor was specifically not allowed to offer or suggest it, as,that could present an element of pressure/coercion - I know I certainly would feel that in such circumstances. And as pp have said, the dementia journey can be long and not easy to plot.

Lifeomars · 08/11/2026 16:45

I am assuming that this is a philosophical question given that the recent Assisted Dying bill (which would only have applied to people with 6 months or less to live to be able to end their lives ) was not passed into law. I agree with assisted dying in principal and was disappointed that the bill did not become law. Dementia is complex though and not like other illnesses in that it destroys the person before it destroys the body. Someone i knew in my younger years was recently diagnosed and currently she does have a reasonable quality of life but if the OP's suggestion was an option how could there be an assurance that family weren't putting pressure on her to end her life.

BlueFlyCheetah · 08/11/2026 16:43

I cared for a family member with this. We were eventually offered support from a decent GP in the form of medication. It made my family member sleep most of the time, which was the safest place for them as they were very confused, scared and lashing out without it. It was also very dangerous as they couldn’t grasp that they were unable mobilise so would stand and fall (even with constant supervision), resulting in hospital admissions every time. They would get skin tears which wouldn’t heal, infections from the open wounds and being unable to clean themselves (lots of UTI’s too) and we couldn’t get close to do it for them because they would attack us whenever we tried, so the medication was absolutely necessary.

One nurse visited and was horrified, made me feel awful for giving them the “chemical cosh” and said not to give it anymore. Although that nurse was nowhere to be found when we were trying to calm an extremely distressed person down and keep them safe.

Dementia can also be very difficult to fully demonstrate as they often go into hostess mode and appear ok in front of drs and nurses. I had to record them to show the medical professionals what was actually happening to me and the carers when it was just us there. They were unable to feed or clean themselves and attacking anyone trying to help.

I’ve told my family that if I get that way to medicate me to eyeballs without an ounce of guilt. I don’t want to be in that state, put anyone I love through it or have anyone make them ever question themselves for doing so. I would rather stay peacefully asleep until I pass away.

EdnaTwatkins · 08/11/2026 16:43

I agree with you OP.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 16:42

AcrossthePond55 · 08/11/2026 16:31

@CurdinHenry

My mother had severe dementia. It was an 8 year 'journey' I wouldn't wish on my worst enemy. BUT, my mum would never have chosen assisted dying. It would have been against her religious beliefs. She would have been deeply upset if she had been offered 'that way out' when she was diagnosed as she would have felt that she was being urged to choose it. When my dad was diagnosed with a progressive neurological condition (which he died from) he would have felt the same. I don't feel the way they do, but I respected their choices.

Where I live (and my parents lived) MAiD (Medical Assistance in Dying) is legal. If a doctor wants to provide a pamphlet or material that includes it as part of 'options for care', fine. But no, I don't think a doctor should say "Do you want MAiD?" or words to that effect.

I mean absolutely fair enough not to take it by being "deeply upset to have it offered" isn't a reason not to offer! I'm deeply upset that it isn't.

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 16:41

FFSItsTooHot · 08/11/2026 16:25

I can see where you're coming from with this,but I honestly do not think it is a good idea. I think some people would feel obliged to accept the offer,or worse still,be put under pressure from relatives to accept it.

I have reached the stage where I believe this to be a "line to take" circulated by pro life activists. "I can see where you're coming from but..." You cannot see where I'm coming from - the two risks are not evenly matched

OP posts:
BackJustToSay · 08/11/2026 16:36

Mableandable · 08/11/2026 13:45

I didn’t vote because it’s just not that simple. There are many illnesses that are equally as brutal in different ways - cancers, degenerative diseases, chronic illnesses, disabilities caused through accidents etc.

Dementia is hideous but should not be singled out.

The difference with dementia is that once you get past a certain point, you would not be judged to have the capacity to make the decision to choose assisted dying. It's also not really possible to ever definitively say you are within 6 months of the end (or whatever the time period was under any eventual law). I think that is why the OP is saying it should be offered upon diagnosis, whereas other conditions would not have the elegibility issue down the line (if we legalized).

WestwardHo1 · 08/11/2026 16:36

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/11/2026 14:00

I agree in principle, but I think we need to make the case system iron clad first.

No one should be doing this just so as not to be a burden, I don’t think it’s a fully free choice as things stand.

I think i would choose it so I'm not a burden. I have no children or husband. I wouldn't expect nieces and nephews to look out for me (they'll have their own elderly parents, probably).

Why on earth would I want to sit in a chair with no coherent thoughts if I could choose otherwise?

InterestedDad37 · 08/11/2026 16:35

My neighbour is rapidly declining through dementia. The woman who had an excellent career in industry, advised politicians on policy, showed me how to sort my garden out when I moved in, chatted with me over a cuppa every so often is now someone who knocks on my door at 11pm, standing crying in the rain, wondering where everyone has gone, and why it's gone dark.
It's such a pity to witness. Her only son feels helpless, and he himself is in bits as he tries to work out what to do and how to do it. He lives an hour away, and works full time.
I intend to never let that happen to me. I don't want my children to have to deal with that. Any vote in favour of assisted dying gets my complete support.

AcrossthePond55 · 08/11/2026 16:31

@CurdinHenry

My mother had severe dementia. It was an 8 year 'journey' I wouldn't wish on my worst enemy. BUT, my mum would never have chosen assisted dying. It would have been against her religious beliefs. She would have been deeply upset if she had been offered 'that way out' when she was diagnosed as she would have felt that she was being urged to choose it. When my dad was diagnosed with a progressive neurological condition (which he died from) he would have felt the same. I don't feel the way they do, but I respected their choices.

Where I live (and my parents lived) MAiD (Medical Assistance in Dying) is legal. If a doctor wants to provide a pamphlet or material that includes it as part of 'options for care', fine. But no, I don't think a doctor should say "Do you want MAiD?" or words to that effect.

FarriersGirl · 08/11/2026 16:31

My DM has dementia but few other serious health conditions so we will no doubt have to cope with her very long slow decline, battling a hopelessly underfunded social care system. Care costs in the future will almost certainly be huge. There is nothing positive in this disease, no 'good' news. Would I want this for myself in future absolutely no way and nor would I want to inflict it on my loved ones.

Koolaidhighlights · 08/11/2026 16:27

My beautiful dear mum is now in the advanced stages of Alzheimer’s. It’s been a dreadful experience over the last 8 years with mum getting a breast cancer diagnosis 3 years ago and fracturing her neck last year also and multiple dreadful A&E visits.

My mum can no longer talk and is double incontinent. She has carers in three times a day to clean her up, which is costing her almost £4k per month. There is no joy in her life, none in my poor dad’s nor my sister’s or mine, we live in the same village and help all the time. Mum just sits in her recliner chair all day staring into space. Every day for mum and all of us is exactly the same, we are trapped in a depressing Groundhog Day.

It is a wicked, evil, insidious disease which rips out the life force of all who are unfortunate to succumb to its clutches. When mum could speak she would tell me every day that she wanted to die and there was sod all I could do to help her. I cry every night when I go to bed, for my lovely mum.

AND I will now live in constant fear of this disease coming knocking on my door, it genuinely terrifies me and has darkened my life.

So the answer to your question is YES, there are no good outcomes from seeing this disease out to the bitter end (which unfortunately I think will be my dear mum’s fate).

FFSItsTooHot · 08/11/2026 16:25

I can see where you're coming from with this,but I honestly do not think it is a good idea. I think some people would feel obliged to accept the offer,or worse still,be put under pressure from relatives to accept it.

Catgotyourbrain · 08/11/2026 16:24

INeverReallyLovedYouAnyway · 08/11/2026 13:56

Here’s another thing I’d stop. Invasive, expensive operations and treatments to lengthen the life of 90+ year old dementia sufferers who have absolutely no quality of life in the first place. I have several recent examples of this.

If I’m 95 with advanced dementia and I need cancer treatment or a hip replacement…please just don’t bother. Just make me comfortable and let me slip away.

Agree. We do need to have a good think about what we are dragging frail elderly relatives to hospital for (and they will go if offered because the feel they ought to), for unpleasant and exhausting but utterly pointless appointments for issues that won’t cause a problem until the person is long dead.

Also there is dementia and dementia… my DF had Lewy Bodies Dementia and I wouldn’t wish the sort of things he was experiencing on anyone (murders in the room next door, hordes of rioters trying to get into the house, hundreds of naked bodies in the room, telling us he’d hurt and killed people). There is no one moment when one thinks ‘now is the time’ though, especially as is the case with dementia and someone else will be calling that moment. It’s just not practical.

i would however have welcomed some kind of intervention after DF had reached the end, was on a palliative care morphine pump, and was a living corpse for nearly two weeks. This was so horrific for us all. The healthy human body can only survive a short time without food and water, but a body whose metabolism has slowed down to an almost -stop isn’t using much energy, and it can take weeks to die after water is stopped. This I would like to have been sped up.

Spaniels4Eva · 08/11/2026 16:20

Having worked in a nursing home and in community home care, I wouldn't want to die from dementia. And totally agree that assisted dying should be offered while the person still has capacity because once that is lost, there is no escape route.

I can't get my head around anyone being against assisted dying having worked in the field. It's so ignorant and ill informed.

AInightingale · 08/11/2026 16:18

The issue is not assisted dying, it's assisted (protracted) living.

Unfortunately, so many people in the oldest generation now were unaware that advanced directives to refuse treatment existed, so they are now enduring the torment of a failing brain in a body that can be kept ticking over. They also enjoyed decent healthcare over their lifetimes, may have survived cancer, maybe gave up smoking - fantastic at the time, less wonderful when dementia was their ultimate fate.

Frail old people would not be able to overcome chest and UT infections without antibiotics. They would be felled very quickly by flu and Covid, if not vaccinated. Covid actually demonstrated that - it decimated the population of care homes before a vaccine was developed. All of these treatments and preventative measures can be refused under a directive, and no doctor should ever be allowed to override it.

I think it should be routine to complete directives even before a diagnosis, say when you reach pension age, but I could see resistance from care home companies, it's one of the few growth industries in the UK.

Lugol · 08/11/2026 16:15

I personally think it's a really slippery slope if an offer of assisted dying came upon diagnosis of dementia.

People could be manipulated into ending their own life when there are lots of things that get misdiagnosed as dementia. It's almost a blanket term.

That would have such widespread applications for abuse and issues.

Happyholidays78 · 08/11/2026 16:13

I agree to a point, some people 'live well' with dementia for a while but there is definitely a tipping point where distress, agitation, fear etc kicks in & by that time it is usually too late to make a decision about ending one's life. Who knows what the answer is? I visit care homes a lot as part of my job (Social Worke) & it never stops being upsetting, I just hope & pray these poor people have had a good life xx

Swipe left for the next trending thread