Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 21:28

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 21:20

Yes, I wish people wouldn't make animal analogies even if it's well-meant. We sell animals and control who they can mate with- we don't do that to people.

*any more. We don't do that to people any more..

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 21:28

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:02

We had that bill. It went through the Commons then a tiny group of unelected members of the Lords filibustered it out of time.

And there’s no hyperbole in my post. I said some people are talking as if it would be compulsory. And they are.

The people who put that bill forward refused lots of sensible protective amendments, so I didn't trust them.

Moreover, while the Lords are unelected, the bill was not in any manifesto which it arguably should have been for people to have a say. It is a huge issue to be introduced without a manifesto

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 21:27

sprigatito · 08/11/2026 21:15

My dad doesn’t usually know who I am any more. He thinks I’m his aunt, or his dead partner. He feels safe with me though, he knows I love him and that I’m his family, he knows I’m there to help him express himself at medical appointments, take him out on trips, help him choose from menus etc. There is still a great deal of joy in his life. It’s hard for me, but I consider him worth it.

some dementia patients sexually assault any woman who comes near them (nurse or family member)

Some are uncontrollably violent and shout horrific things and have to be drugged for the safety of those around them

Just because you think your situation is worth it (worth what? You're not the one paying the worst price, he is) doesn't mean it's the same for everyone.

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 21:23

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 21:20

Yes, I wish people wouldn't make animal analogies even if it's well-meant. We sell animals and control who they can mate with- we don't do that to people.

That's the point

We think we are better than animals yet we make our parents suffer in ways we never would a dog

OP posts:
Scattery · 08/11/2026 21:23

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 21:11

One issue is that some people seem to have a rose-tinted view of dementia - the example upthread of people singing and clapping along to the TV is a perfect example.

It isn't like that at the end stages, or certainly not for everyone. If end stage dementia were universally like a sitcom idea of old people in a care home singing along to Beatles tribute bands and having amusingly incoherent conversations, we wouldn't need this debate at all.

Completely agree with this.

End stage dementia can be a horrible thing to witness. And no two experiences are quite the same. Aggression in a person with dementia vs. no aggression. Dementia in a physically capable person vs. dementia in a mostly bedbound person.

I wish we would, as a society, have more conversations around death/dying. And caring/carers. And probably consent, too, or what constitutes the lack of it.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 21:22

Icanthinkformyselfthanks · 08/11/2026 21:04

@CurdinHenry , if you could meet my (born again Christian) brother and his selfish money grabbing offspring I hope you’d reconsider your suggestion.

I wouldn't want to suffer death by madness just to keep hold of my pennies a few years longer

What use are they in that scenario

OP posts:
Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 21:20

TriciaA1991 · 08/11/2026 17:05

It isn't so simple. Many dementia patients are relatively happy and where do you draw the line?? Who decides when they should be "put down" like an animal??

Yes, I wish people wouldn't make animal analogies even if it's well-meant. We sell animals and control who they can mate with- we don't do that to people.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 21:19

kitex · 08/11/2026 21:14

If we had a good system, no one would be killed against their will.

What would that look like? That's a genuine question btw, I'm interested because I struggle to see how that can be achieved while still granting AD to those who want it.

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 21:17

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:04

How would you struggle against drinking a dose of barbiturates?

kicking out, scratching, pulling my face away from them, clamping my mouth shut... followed by crying, screaming, begging them not to kill me, saying "I've changed my mind", "would you hold your own mother down and kill her", "murderers, you just like killing old ladies", "please, please don't kill me, I don't want to die....", "help me..."

Might cause a bit of distress to the person who is expected to just get on with it.

sprigatito · 08/11/2026 21:15

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 08/11/2026 21:08

The relatives I'm thinking of were doubly incontinent and didn't know who anyone was, so might have met the criteria of some people on this thread.

For example, one of my grandmothers referred to my mum as "that nice lady who helps me". My mum was very taken aback as she thought her mum knew she was her daughter. No, she just knew that she was a familiar person whom she liked.

My dad doesn’t usually know who I am any more. He thinks I’m his aunt, or his dead partner. He feels safe with me though, he knows I love him and that I’m his family, he knows I’m there to help him express himself at medical appointments, take him out on trips, help him choose from menus etc. There is still a great deal of joy in his life. It’s hard for me, but I consider him worth it.

kitex · 08/11/2026 21:14

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 21:08

Even if it means their choice will lead to some people being killed against their will? Are they just collateral damage, then?

If we had a good system, no one would be killed against their will.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 21:13

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 21:09

Fair comment. I do feel sceptical that processes would run smoothly and without error, though.

Yes, I agree, that is a very reasonable reservation to have.

MermaidMummy06 · 08/11/2026 21:12

So we have assisted dying in Australia. Hasn't been around long & this came up recently. There's two problems:

  1. It's not allowed to be offered, has to be asked for. Lots of criteria and due diligence before it is allowed.
  1. As for dementia, once diagnosed, you can't consent to assisted dying as no longer considered capable. No one can can consent on your behalf. Even if it's in a legal health directive document, it simply can't become actioned once you get that diagnosis.
DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 21:11

One issue is that some people seem to have a rose-tinted view of dementia - the example upthread of people singing and clapping along to the TV is a perfect example.

It isn't like that at the end stages, or certainly not for everyone. If end stage dementia were universally like a sitcom idea of old people in a care home singing along to Beatles tribute bands and having amusingly incoherent conversations, we wouldn't need this debate at all.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:10

WaynesWhirled · 08/11/2026 21:09

What an absolutely dreadful post. I’m in favour of legalising assisted dying but this sort of comment makes me wonder whether the antis have a point.

And this kind of post makes me doubt that you support assisted dying.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 21:09

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 21:00

@dreamiesformolly @Puzzledandpissedoff And that's why it needs tight safeguards, not, as has been suggested, being able to go to the chemist and get a euthanasia prescription filled.

People wouldn't be assessed against thresholds on a single day - they'd have to demonstrate sustained and consistent deterioration. If someone with dementia has been sitting/lying in silence for the last month, doing nothing other than being spoon fed and being changed, they are not suddenly going to be singing and clapping to the television or starting conversations.

Fair comment. I do feel sceptical that processes would run smoothly and without error, though.

WaynesWhirled · 08/11/2026 21:09

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:52

It isn't sane to want to foist that version of yourself on them once the balance tips. If you loved them more than yourself.

What an absolutely dreadful post. I’m in favour of legalising assisted dying but this sort of comment makes me wonder whether the antis have a point.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 08/11/2026 21:08

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 20:45

If they were still at the stage of being able to watch TV and clap along, or have conversations with people, nonsensical or otherwise, they wouldn't meet the 'deterioration' thresholds that would need to be crossed before euthanasia was invoked.

Edited

The relatives I'm thinking of were doubly incontinent and didn't know who anyone was, so might have met the criteria of some people on this thread.

For example, one of my grandmothers referred to my mum as "that nice lady who helps me". My mum was very taken aback as she thought her mum knew she was her daughter. No, she just knew that she was a familiar person whom she liked.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 21:08

kitex · 08/11/2026 21:04

I’ve said all along, give people the choice.

Even if it means their choice will lead to some people being killed against their will? Are they just collateral damage, then?

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 21:07

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 21:03

I could not be happy causing distress to another human being in that way. Expecting someone to kill you whilst you struggle against their ministrations as you are no longer of sound mind, is simply horrifying.

Why need it be like that? They can inject me while I'm asleep.

Icanthinkformyselfthanks · 08/11/2026 21:04

@CurdinHenry , if you could meet my (born again Christian) brother and his selfish money grabbing offspring I hope you’d reconsider your suggestion.

kitex · 08/11/2026 21:04

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 20:56

That really isn't an argument for enforced euthanasia without consent. You sound like you think that since everyone has to die a person should be willing to bring it forward if others deem it convenient. Presumably that's not what you actually think?

I’ve said all along, give people the choice.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:04

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 21:03

I could not be happy causing distress to another human being in that way. Expecting someone to kill you whilst you struggle against their ministrations as you are no longer of sound mind, is simply horrifying.

How would you struggle against drinking a dose of barbiturates?

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 21:03

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 20:20

I want to die on my own terms when the time comes. I have no younger relatives so the question of being a burden on anyone doesn't apply to me. I have no-one to care what happens to me but myself. If my capacity has disappeared, I don't want to be kept alive because some unrecognisable version of myself with a mostly destroyed brain isn't able to consent to my own death anymore.

I could not be happy causing distress to another human being in that way. Expecting someone to kill you whilst you struggle against their ministrations as you are no longer of sound mind, is simply horrifying.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:02

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 20:49

I'm not sure hyperbole adds anything to the discussion, Blossomtoes
Certainly posters have mentioned worries about coercion and potential cuts in support services which could nudge people towards AD, but if anyone's actually stated it would be compulsory I must have missed it

For those who'd like this option for themselves, perhaps the answer is to campaign for a bill with proper safeguards which could stand a chance of being passed because it's acceptable to a majority, rather than bemoaning the failure of a clearly inadequate one

We had that bill. It went through the Commons then a tiny group of unelected members of the Lords filibustered it out of time.

And there’s no hyperbole in my post. I said some people are talking as if it would be compulsory. And they are.