Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
fridakahlosmoustache · 08/11/2026 22:28

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

Alternatively, you could look up the modifiable risk factors for dementia and make some lifestyle changes, as can anyone. It's not occult information.

Pedant61 · 08/11/2026 22:26

I couldn't agree more, OP. After all, death is most definitely not the worst thing that can happen to a person.

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 22:26

Te next step is no cancer treatment for the over 75s as if it gets too bad, they can go for assisted dying.

XenoBitch · 08/11/2026 22:24

Why dementia?
Why not offer newly diagnosed cancer patients the option of AD? Or people with MS, MND, heart failure etc the list could go on forever.

It is almost as if you think people with dementia are somehow less worthy of life once that diagnosis is in their records. That they will all suffer and die horribly (not all do). That they are a burden on their loved ones (and that right there is not a reason for AD).

BriarTime · 08/11/2026 22:23

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:18

If this attitude had prevailed in the sixties, abortion would still be illegal in the UK. I know a lot of people would also prefer that to be the case.

Thank God they didn't get their way.

There is a massive difference between the rights of living people and the rights of foetuses, though. I know some extremists don’t accept that, but it is objectively true.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 22:21

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:14

I also find it incomprehensible that old people should be encouraged to stay alive because being a burden on their kids is fine

"Nobody is forced to care for them" ok but how many people will decline to do so knowing what's happening to them

(I know we all know people who do just refuse and their parents, usually mothers, live grim and scary lives at the end but most people feel too guilty)

Are you seriously saying it makes more sense to you that they be encouraged to be killed rather than be a 'burden'? After bringing their kids into the world, raising them, making sacrifices for them?

I have no words. Oh no, hang on, actually I do have one - duty. Ever heard of that? It's in the dictionary, quite close to 'dystopia'.

BriarTime · 08/11/2026 22:20

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:05

I mean whatever, life is finite and we're all going to die fairly soon in the geological sense. If you want to experience hell on earth beforehand by all means go for it but you shouldn't be allowed to decide for me.

In my previous post I made very clear that I don’t object to assisted dying when considered in a vacuum. I have no religious or histrionic convictions about the right of people to take their own lives. But it won’t take place in a vacuum, and we all need to stop pretending it will. This is not an abstract topic. We’re talking about the real world.

I don’t want to ‘experience hell on earth’. Nor do I want to decide for you. I just don’t want to spend my entire life living in fear that a law will be brought in that will be weaponised to try to persuade (or even force) me to cut short my own life because society has decided I fall into the ‘burden’ demographic and ‘if I loved my family I’d do it’.

We’re told it won’t happen. But it’s being advocated for right here on this thread. You’ve even said yourself that you’re willing to trade the safeguards that would protect people like me if you could be sure to get death on your own terms. It isn’t unreasonable of me to disagree that your right to your choice of death is more important than my right to life.

The problem is that our concerns are being dismissed as fallacious, emotional, and illogical, even though there’s evidence right here on this thread that they’re not.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:19

Being alive is not good for everyone and some diagnoses are worse than a death sentence

Ending your life safely and with dignity is hard to do

The policy speaks for itself

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:18

WaynesWhirled · 08/11/2026 22:16

I’d like to see this as a proper government bill with all the policy work that entails upfront. It’s far too difficult and complex for a private member’s bill.

If this attitude had prevailed in the sixties, abortion would still be illegal in the UK. I know a lot of people would also prefer that to be the case.

Thank God they didn't get their way.

OP posts:
Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 22:18

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 22:17

We always get to this, don’t we? It’s tediously predictable.

Yes and unfortunately it is extremely valid.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 22:17

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 22:15

Right and who else do we kill who is a burden? Disabled children right?

We always get to this, don’t we? It’s tediously predictable.

WaynesWhirled · 08/11/2026 22:16

I’d like to see this as a proper government bill with all the policy work that entails upfront. It’s far too difficult and complex for a private member’s bill.

mybiggreenfrog · 08/11/2026 22:16

It is, but only if you can afford to go to digitas

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:16

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 22:15

Right and who else do we kill who is a burden? Disabled children right?

An adult facing a death of the worst kind imaginable is able to choose for themselves

OP posts:
Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 22:15

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:14

I also find it incomprehensible that old people should be encouraged to stay alive because being a burden on their kids is fine

"Nobody is forced to care for them" ok but how many people will decline to do so knowing what's happening to them

(I know we all know people who do just refuse and their parents, usually mothers, live grim and scary lives at the end but most people feel too guilty)

Right and who else do we kill who is a burden? Disabled children right?

PencilsInSpace · 08/11/2026 22:14

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:46

And I’m accused of hyperbole.

If someone was actively trying to kill me against my will I would be doing as much hyperbole as I was capable of. I would scream murder because that is what it would be.

From earlier posts you seem to think that AD is always a self-administered drink. It's not. Countries such as Belgium and NL allow euthanasia - IV lethal injection administered by a medic.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:14

I also find it incomprehensible that old people should be encouraged to stay alive because being a burden on their kids is fine

"Nobody is forced to care for them" ok but how many people will decline to do so knowing what's happening to them

(I know we all know people who do just refuse and their parents, usually mothers, live grim and scary lives at the end but most people feel too guilty)

OP posts:
QiBengong · 08/11/2026 22:13

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:02

We had that bill. It went through the Commons then a tiny group of unelected members of the Lords filibustered it out of time.

And there’s no hyperbole in my post. I said some people are talking as if it would be compulsory. And they are.

No, we had a dogs dinner of a bill that was all big on principle and statements without any serious consideration of how it would be implemented, work in reality tie in with existing laws and protections. A huge number of groups and people who would be most affected, or expected to carry out the process of assessment and implementation of assisted dying had issues with supporting that particular bill, even if they were supporters of assisted dying.

The Lords debates and discussions were very comprehensive and informative, a sort of buffer of serious politics against a half-arsed bill of ' we want this, make it happen now' and ' its the only form of compassion/right side of history' attitudes of the bills most ardent supporters. It was fabulous to see and hear all sorts of real world issues getting examined and discussed, from the issues of coercion and abuse, social pressure, attitudes to disability to the practicalities of ' so who would do this, where, when and how, and how would we regulate and train them?, to the more abstract ' is this how society should best deal with these issues?. The debates were exactly what was needed and took a long time because there was so much to debate and consider, given the bill was a list of lobbying points that hadn't really been tested and tempered by discussion with other affected groups. I felt really encouraged by the discussions in the Lords - where across party lines and loyalties, and bringing in expertise from many areas, a group of serious people looked at as many angles and perspectives as possible to see how the bill might really work. I want my elected and appointed representatives to be able to try and test ideas, rather than blindly trotting through the lobbies because its the party line, or they promised their celebrity mate that they would vote for it.

To bring the bill back unaltered, in an attempt to force it through via an obscure parliamentary rules was a supremely arrogant move and I am glad it backfired. Having the bill raised and the subsequent debates was great though, as it forced MPs. the Lords and many other people to really deal with difficult topics - ageing, illness, palliative care, death and how we best deal with these, rather than the glib presentation of the original bill which seemed to think the whole thing would be easy. Hopefully this increased focus might lead to some improvements eg in palliative care provision and funding and potentially to any future proposals for assisted dying being better drafted and more considered.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 22:13

TeethAreImportant · 08/11/2026 22:11

Well I'd say the sane right IS afforded to humans, because we already have assisted dying in reality, its just restricted to those who are rich and can afford to go to Switzerland.

It isn’t. Dignitas is only if you’re terminal and have capacity. It excludes dementia.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 08/11/2026 22:13

With my family history, it's quite likely that I'll get dementia. I don't want someone to put a pillow over my face. But if I were suffering, I wouldn't want to be treated for every infection or other complication (unless not treating them could cause greater suffering).

I suspect that the doctors involved in my relatives' care knew when it would be appropriate to admit them to hospital and administer IV antibiotics (or treatment for other conditions they had) and when it would be kinder to offer them palliative care in their own beds.

HPFA · 08/11/2026 22:11

sprigatito · 08/11/2026 22:05

I think you’re projecting your fear of your own mortality onto dementia sufferers, and your posts have been crass and deliberately cruel. We all have our opinions 🤷🏻‍♀️

Either the OP has some really serious issues or they're a troll.

While I'm not sure safeguards could ever be good enough for something like dementia I can understand people who've seen their relatives suffer wanting AD.

But the OP now seems to think even those whose dementia isn"t causing them suffering are better off dead.

TeethAreImportant · 08/11/2026 22:11

DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 08/11/2026 14:18

I am likely genetically disposed to early onset alzheimers. If I get it, I will prioritise getting my affairs in order (they mostly are already to be fair, but will tie up loose ends) and then commit suicide while still cognitive. I have seen what it does and I am not living through it if I have the choice.

It is an outrage that family pets and animals can be put out of their misery when their owners decide the time is right, but the same is not afforded to humans.

Well I'd say the sane right IS afforded to humans, because we already have assisted dying in reality, its just restricted to those who are rich and can afford to go to Switzerland.

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 22:11

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 22:07

You're quite right. I say that as someone who has just come to bed wiped out after a day of helping to look after my mother who has dementia and lives with me and who has had a bad day today (meaning, consequently, that mine's not been great either!). But she still has good days too, and in a way I think that's partially informing my reservations about AD. Admittedly she's not at end stage, so it's not exactly the same scenario as you describe, but in general terms applying AD to a dementia patient while they still have some quality of life left is an absolute moral/ethical minefield imo.

Additionally, given how hard it is caring for a relative with dementia, I also worry that relatives could pressure a person into signing something while still of sound mind because they don't want to end up caring for that person further down the line. Hopefully it's unlikely, but I don't think it's impossible given all the talk of people being a 'burden' that always gets bandied around on threads such as this one.

Absolutely this.

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 22:11

kitex · 08/11/2026 21:28

A person would explicitly and voluntarily request assisted dying. A person would be able to change their mind and withdraw their request at any point in the process.

Including if they had dementia?

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:10

Men and women by the way. Very common for old ladies to shriek very detailed sexual stuff. Nurse friend of mine wonders if it's stuff they did (or abuse they suffered?) or just fantasy coming to the surface as the brain deteriorates.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread