Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
mafiacat · 09/11/2026 03:34

SixAndJuliet · 09/11/2026 03:21

You wouldn’t though, because by the time you got your diagnosis, you would be highly unlikely to
a) agree with your diagnosis
b) accept your diagnosis
c) remember your diagnosis on a day to day basis
d) have the organisational and memory to make the appropriate plans.
e) have the memory to remember you’d made those plans, communicate them and execute them.
f) feel suicidal in that moment.
g) remember that taking yourself to Switzerland to kill yourself upon diagnosis was what you wanted to do.

Edited

This is a good point.

SixAndJuliet · 09/11/2026 03:21

mafiacat · 09/11/2026 02:59

Yes. If I got a dementia diagnosis I'd be taking myself off to Switzerland tout suite

You wouldn’t though, because by the time you got your diagnosis, you would be highly unlikely to
a) agree with your diagnosis
b) accept your diagnosis
c) remember your diagnosis on a day to day basis
d) have the organisational and memory to make the appropriate plans.
e) have the memory to remember you’d made those plans, communicate them and execute them.
f) feel suicidal in that moment.
g) remember that taking yourself to Switzerland to kill yourself upon diagnosis was what you wanted to do.

mafiacat · 09/11/2026 02:59

Yes. If I got a dementia diagnosis I'd be taking myself off to Switzerland tout suite

Daysgo · 09/11/2026 02:47

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:44

And there is no greater burden than being a dementia patient. I think it's immoral not to care about that tbh.

Amazingly though not everybody will share your view on assisted dying. Also, not everyone diagnosed with dementia will necessarily have competency to agree to assisted dying, or not.

Interesting idea though, I wonder how much would be saved in the health service by euthanizing dementia patients, and really anyone diagnosed with any terminal illness I presume? Could save a lot on medical care, wages etc. Could free up lots of nursing home spaces for other uses etc. And as opting for assisted dying becomes more common and expected, no doubt those with burdensome mental health conditions or issues, those with addictions etc would feel the pressure to kill themselves too...

A brave new world....

SixAndJuliet · 09/11/2026 02:32

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 00:14

I think "new normal" is a horror phrase much enjoyed by people who loved COVID restrictions too. "We just have to get used to our new normal".

It's like wearing a badge that declares the wearer an empathy free zone.

If that is what you took from what I said, it is very evident that you have no experience of dealing with a loved one with dementia first hand.

You don’t actually address any of my points about the legalities or practicalities about consent, changes of heart or abuse.

This thread isn’t about assisted dying, it’s about murdering elderly people. In fact it’s a perfect example of why such a bill isn’t ready to be passed and definitely not in cases of dementia.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 02:07

XenoBitch · 08/11/2026 19:24

What HCP would be happy with forcing a lethal injection into someone who is resisting and saying no, regardless of what papers they may have signed years before.
The very thought of it is chilling.

Yes, this is what legally happened in the Netherlands.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/doctor-netherlands-lethal-injection-dementia-euthanasia-a7564061.html

Doctor who asked dementia patient's family to hold her down while administering euthanasia injection is cleared

Panel finds the doctor acted 'in good faith' in controversial case

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/doctor-netherlands-lethal-injection-dementia-euthanasia-a7564061.html

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 02:06

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 19:31

It’s not the cost, it’s that you have to have capacity to do it.

I don’t know why injections are being discussed. Assisted dying in other countries is achieved by drinking barbiturates.

In those cases you need to be physically able to drink though.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 02:05

Thelnebriati · 08/11/2026 19:02

The reason we don't have a choice now is because people who claimed to be in favour of assisted dying sabotaged chances of getting a bill passed by refusing to include proposals for safeguarding.
When you are posting on social media that safeguarding is not needed, or people should feel responsible for being a burden, you are the ones sabotaging assisted dying.
It should be a choice; it should not be possible to coerce anyone into it.

This.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 02:00

Becuriousnotjudgemental1980 · 08/11/2026 20:22

My friend was really angry when they didn’t pass the assisted dying bill. She said ‘well if they’d had to wash, dress, feed and change their mothers whilst being physically assaulted for 8 years of utter hell they’d change their minds’ no way on earth would she or I put our kids through that. Hope you son is ok? I’m sorry you all had to go through that ❤️❤️

I'm really sorry for your friend, but the bill didn't simply not pass due to disagreement with AD. Sensible amendments to protect vulnerable people werr repeatedly refused, calling into question the mentality of Leadbeater & others driving the bill.

It's arguably also such a key issue, revolving around life and death, that it should be in a manifesto.

It's also worth noting that that bill would not have applied to dementia. You would need to be of sound mind and estimated to have around 6 months to live.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 01:57

SinisterBumFacedCat · 09/11/2026 01:52

I think the majority of people in the UK are in favour of assisted dying, mainly through the trauma of watching helplessly while their loved ones died in extreme distress and pain over a prolonged period of time, years, even decades. It’s not because they are Nazi’s who believe some lives are not worth living.

I know most people who support it aren't Nazi supporters or anything like that. The same in other places where it's legal like Belgium, France, Switzerland, Netherlands etc etc

My point is that in both countries some initially supported milder forms of eugenics/euthanasia until it got dangerously out of control. Canada is a modern example of it being handled dangerously. There have however been other disturbing cases in other countries which allow it.

And it's worth noting some posters on this thread have used language implying lives aren't worth living if people are unable to feed themselves, and perform other actions, which seems worrying even if they are well-intentioned.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 09/11/2026 01:52

I think the majority of people in the UK are in favour of assisted dying, mainly through the trauma of watching helplessly while their loved ones died in extreme distress and pain over a prolonged period of time, years, even decades. It’s not because they are Nazi’s who believe some lives are not worth living.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 01:41

VerifyYouAreHuman · 08/11/2026 20:10

In January 2010, English novelist Martin Amis triggered a major public controversy by suggesting that street-corner "euthanasia booths" should be installed to handle an aging population. He warned of a demographic "silver tsunami" of elderly and demented individuals, predicting potential generational conflict or a "civil war" between the young and the old...

So what's your point? That we should listen to him?

You might think having written Time's Arrow (based on Dr Mengele's life) would make him more aware of the problems but apparently not...

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 01:38

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 19:49

There is work being done to treat dementia. Do you think that work would continue wirh the same drive and urgency if people are offered death as soon as they are diagnosed? What a cheap, effective, easy solution to incurable illness. In fact why bother with any research to develop treatment and cures for any illness we dont already have cures for. Just offer anyone with an incurable illness , intant desth and make rhem feel selfish and guilty if they want to choose to live a bit bit longer as a "burden"

Same goes for palliative care, @bumblingbovine49; what's the point in hoping for any improvement if we could just get rid of patients instead?

Reading the comments of some AD advocates you can just foresee the conversations: "I'm afraid there aren't the resources to offer you any further care, but here's a suggestion ..."

Yes, the above-mentioned 'lives unworthy of living program' in Germany (Nazi but also somewhat predated) focused heavily on the cost to the German taxpayer. So did the US eugenics movement, which was disturbingly huge at the time.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 01:36

SinisterBumFacedCat · 09/11/2026 01:31

I voted yabu in principle, but in practice it would be near impossible, most people when they get a diagnosis are already in the throes of dementia, they won’t believe it and being face with an opinion for assisted suicide they will either not understand, be in denial or think it’s a conspiracy to get their money etc.
I think there are ways, having advanced directives set up where you could choose the specific point when you could die, eg: when I loose continence or when I no longer recognise my family, therefore giving people a good few years of early to middle stage dementia when many people are still able to live relatively independently and continue to enjoy life. There is already talk of a blood test to diagnose dementia, and those who are genetically at risk, this could mean you could make those arrangements decades before your judgment is impaired.
What a lot of us are dealing with now is complex PSTD for witnessing our parents and grandparents long and terrifying decline. I’ve been through it myself with both parents over a period of 21 years, nearly half my life. Everyone has different experiences but the common thread is the helplessness we felt and the fact that the nhs and care system are woefully lacking when it comes to managing even the basics of dementia care, not to mention the most challenging parts. Social services and care homes are still working to a template of physical disabilities and decline rather than mental, the only people benefiting from expensive care homes are the owners, at the expense of families who live through the repeated trauma of generations of dementia. It’s horrendous to go through dementia but to also spend decades dreading it is added torture. I hope one day we will be given the choice but I doubt because there is a vocal minority who aren’t affected by dementia and are opposed to even discussion of assisted dying.

This is what I think. There are ways people can control their own life and death without euthanasia. A lot of these dementia patients live so long in hugely severe conditions due to antibiotics and other treatment, not simply robust physical health.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 01:34

Some people should check the language in a chapter of German history about 'lives unworthy of living'. I'm sure the OP means well but this kind of thing can escalate dangerously.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_unworthy_of_life

The Story of Dr Harry Haidelsen, who 'euthanized ' several disabled babies without punishment in the US in the 1910s is also a disturbing one. He was supported be several figures including even Helen Keller.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_J._Haiselden

Life unworthy of life - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_unworthy_of_life

SinisterBumFacedCat · 09/11/2026 01:31

I voted yabu in principle, but in practice it would be near impossible, most people when they get a diagnosis are already in the throes of dementia, they won’t believe it and being face with an opinion for assisted suicide they will either not understand, be in denial or think it’s a conspiracy to get their money etc.
I think there are ways, having advanced directives set up where you could choose the specific point when you could die, eg: when I loose continence or when I no longer recognise my family, therefore giving people a good few years of early to middle stage dementia when many people are still able to live relatively independently and continue to enjoy life. There is already talk of a blood test to diagnose dementia, and those who are genetically at risk, this could mean you could make those arrangements decades before your judgment is impaired.
What a lot of us are dealing with now is complex PSTD for witnessing our parents and grandparents long and terrifying decline. I’ve been through it myself with both parents over a period of 21 years, nearly half my life. Everyone has different experiences but the common thread is the helplessness we felt and the fact that the nhs and care system are woefully lacking when it comes to managing even the basics of dementia care, not to mention the most challenging parts. Social services and care homes are still working to a template of physical disabilities and decline rather than mental, the only people benefiting from expensive care homes are the owners, at the expense of families who live through the repeated trauma of generations of dementia. It’s horrendous to go through dementia but to also spend decades dreading it is added torture. I hope one day we will be given the choice but I doubt because there is a vocal minority who aren’t affected by dementia and are opposed to even discussion of assisted dying.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 01:27

MistressoftheDarkSide · 09/11/2026 00:21

You don't get to say that the people I love are burdens. You don't get to say that about any living being. You just don't. It's offensive in the extreme.

This!

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 01:27

RachelDuffy · 08/11/2026 17:27

Is this how you feel about vets?

Animals are not equal to people .as I said above, you can legally sell and breed animals, you can't do that to people. Killing an animal is illegal at least to some extent, but it is not seen as murder.

I love animals but too many people now seem to view them as fully equal to people.

feellikeanalien · 09/11/2026 00:36

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 00:30

Given that resources are finite, do you think it's great for send children that dignified dying isn't allowed for dementia patients?

What are you suggesting? That if you euthanise dementia patients that will free up resources for SEN children?

That is highly unlikely.

If you are not suggesting that then I don't see the connection.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 00:30

feellikeanalien · 09/11/2026 00:26

If you look at some of the posts from OP on other threads you will see that she is not particularly keen on children with SEN either.

Given that resources are finite, do you think it's great for send children that dignified dying isn't allowed for dementia patients?

OP posts:
feellikeanalien · 09/11/2026 00:26

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 22:15

Right and who else do we kill who is a burden? Disabled children right?

If you look at some of the posts from OP on other threads you will see that she is not particularly keen on children with SEN either.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 09/11/2026 00:21

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 00:19

I mean obviously those things were burdens - the fact you chose them doesn't change that.

You don't get to say that the people I love are burdens. You don't get to say that about any living being. You just don't. It's offensive in the extreme.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 00:19

MistressoftheDarkSide · 08/11/2026 23:31

I've been following this thread having cared for my MIL in our home for 18 months before her dementia meant we couldn't keep her safe. It was hard, it impacted our lives hugely, but she wasn't "a burden". Neither was my mother who spent the last month of her life dying from ovarian cancer in our home during Covid. Nor was my DF who died last year as his health abruptly deteriorated over the previous 12 months in the wake og a series og unfortunate events in his domestic circumstances at the age of 85. My frankly horrid SM has vascular dementia on top of long term mental illness and contributed to the stress that impacted my Dad hugely - she has cut me off but I would have cared for her too given the chance. Not because I'm a saint - far from it - but because it'd the decent and humane thing to do.

I'm actually quite concerned for you OP. Are you being made to feel like a burden? Because you seem to have absorbed a very nihilistic view of life, and I say that as someone with dark and negative thoughts and feelings and passive suicidal ideation that I struggle with every day and hide in order not to be a burden to my loved ones, ironically enough.

And alot of my despair stems from seeing the world regressing to a much darker and less compassionate place than I expected at 57.

As for AD, I am massively conflicted in some regards - however, I wouldn't trust any modern state to legislate on it given the current zeitgeist if the main selling point is to avoid being a burden.

If people want to end their own lives due to illness / suffering that is already their choice. Euthenasia is a different thing and yes, slippery slopes and economics make me balk at it frankly.

Honestly, the tone of some posts on here has made me wonder what is the point of it all anyway.

I mean obviously those things were burdens - the fact you chose them doesn't change that.

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 00:14

SixAndJuliet · 08/11/2026 23:24

I’m interested to know what your personal experience is as you sound very cold and also like you haven’t lost someone you loved to dementia. Maybe you have but you don’t acknowledge the complexities of how the personality would likely change the desire to die.

For example, I lost my mum to dementia. As a fit and well person, she would have agreed with you, she always said that she would hate to lose her mind and would rather die. Reality was, once she was showing significant symptoms, enough for a diagnosis, she had a new normal. Yes it was messy and confusing an often chaotic but if you’d have asked her at that point if she wanted to end her life, she would not have said yes. In fact, when she was much further down the line and actually dying she was frightened and didn’t want to.

Also, you’re expecting dementia patients to remember they’ve made this massive choice and be consistent in their decision. Reality is, they won’t remember and could come up with an entirely different response on another day.

Re the legalities, I would also think it would be open to significant abuse. Greedy and/or heartless relatives who coerce vulnerable people into choices that they shouldn’t be making.

It a no from me. Yes, it was tough when my mum was suffering and I guess it was a burden but her feeling that she should end her life to stop being that burden would have broken me more than caring for her.

I think "new normal" is a horror phrase much enjoyed by people who loved COVID restrictions too. "We just have to get used to our new normal".

It's like wearing a badge that declares the wearer an empathy free zone.

OP posts: