Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 09:03

While I am very glad that some people's experience of end-stage dementia in their loved ones is peaceful and happy, that unfortunately doesn't change things for people whose experience is anything but.

I would like to see an AD process based on specific symptoms rather than timescales. If I am happy and at peace, by all means let me die naturally. If I am not, I don't want to continue living.

kitex · 09/11/2026 09:01

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 08:58

My grandma was diagnosed n her mid 80s, lived at home with minimal support for a further 5 years then went into a home in her early 90s. She wasn’t incontinent and was able to feed herself until the last few weeks of her life, She was very happy and in many ways reverted back to childhood. She died in her sleep at 101.
At what point should she have been euthanised?

“At what point should she have been euthanised?”

No one is advocating for involuntary euthanasia. It’s about giving people the choice of when to die.

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 08:59

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 08:58

My grandma was diagnosed n her mid 80s, lived at home with minimal support for a further 5 years then went into a home in her early 90s. She wasn’t incontinent and was able to feed herself until the last few weeks of her life, She was very happy and in many ways reverted back to childhood. She died in her sleep at 101.
At what point should she have been euthanised?

What did her advanced directive say?

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 08:58

My grandma was diagnosed n her mid 80s, lived at home with minimal support for a further 5 years then went into a home in her early 90s. She wasn’t incontinent and was able to feed herself until the last few weeks of her life, She was very happy and in many ways reverted back to childhood. She died in her sleep at 101.
At what point should she have been euthanised?

kitex · 09/11/2026 08:57

Gloriia · 09/11/2026 08:54

Its appalling isn't it. So many illnesses cause prolonged suffering for patients and their families, suicide is not the solution. It is a slippery slope you're absolutely right.

You can’t conjure up carers if people don’t want to do it.

NightHeron · 09/11/2026 08:57

NRTFT, but I feel it’s all too much to cope with at once! People need time to get over the shock of the diagnosis first, before they can make a decision about their future! We are not sure we believe in assisted dying, because we have a disabled daughter with a life threatening condition, and we can see it being extended to her, when she doesn’t have mental capacity; but she does love life!

The care home has asked us to do advance planning for her, in her 30s. She hasn’t got a terminal condition! We said, we’ll do it, in conjunction with her consultant, when she has a terminal diagnosis!

We are in our late 60s, and were insulted when our GP practice invited us to a talk on advanced planning, by someone working at a hospice! If I wanted advice, I’d ask the GP in our family about what he’s seen!

kitex · 09/11/2026 08:55

@Gloriia “We as a society need to all develop the resilience and capability to care for our relatives and encouraging suicide is not it.”

Caring for relatives when you don’t want to is a burden, and it makes you resentful.

Gloriia · 09/11/2026 08:54

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 08:44

But it IS a slippery slope, you just made it one. The law that was proposed in parliament was for terminal illnesses and now you want it extended to the degenerative disease you fear most yourself. For someone else it would be MS. In the Netherlands it was used for depression.

I empathise with the fear of dementia, truly I do. But decisions about whether and on what basis someone chooses their death cannot be made one disease at a time.

On the plus side there have been some really hopeful advances later in treatment of dementia that nobody on this thread has mentioned. So there is hope.

Its appalling isn't it. So many illnesses cause prolonged suffering for patients and their families, suicide is not the solution. It is a slippery slope you're absolutely right.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 08:53

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 08:44

But it IS a slippery slope, you just made it one. The law that was proposed in parliament was for terminal illnesses and now you want it extended to the degenerative disease you fear most yourself. For someone else it would be MS. In the Netherlands it was used for depression.

I empathise with the fear of dementia, truly I do. But decisions about whether and on what basis someone chooses their death cannot be made one disease at a time.

On the plus side there have been some really hopeful advances later in treatment of dementia that nobody on this thread has mentioned. So there is hope.

Alzheimers is a terminal illness, there is no question of 'extending' here. I'm sorry to sound blunt but if you don't understand that basic fact about what we are discussing, it would be a good idea to do some research before commenting.

Of course we can all hope for medical advances in the treatment of terminal conditions, but that isn't a reason to shelve discussion of how we cope with them while they are still terminal.

If I follow my parents' trajectory, medicine has 20 years to find a cure, that is, assuming a cure would be effective once symptoms had manifested themselves. That is not a long time for something like this and my feeling is that if a solution is found it will involve preventative treatment in genetically disposed people much earlier than the stage where symptoms manifest themselves.

BIossomtoes · 09/11/2026 08:50

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 08:44

But it IS a slippery slope, you just made it one. The law that was proposed in parliament was for terminal illnesses and now you want it extended to the degenerative disease you fear most yourself. For someone else it would be MS. In the Netherlands it was used for depression.

I empathise with the fear of dementia, truly I do. But decisions about whether and on what basis someone chooses their death cannot be made one disease at a time.

On the plus side there have been some really hopeful advances later in treatment of dementia that nobody on this thread has mentioned. So there is hope.

There isn’t hope. Dementia is now the biggest cause of death in the UK. It’s a terminal disease. No amount of new treatment can prevent the horrible end that faces every dementia sufferer. There is no cure, the best anyone can hope for is a slowing down of its progression, ie prolonging the agony. By all means put safeguards in place but stop minimising it, there are people here with first hand experience you’re just not listening to.

BusyGreySnail · 09/11/2026 08:46

Not RTFT. But no, i don't think it should come with an offer of assisted dying. That would be incredibly insensitive to the patient. i agree with you, it would be one of the worst ways to go but not everyone feels like that and it's essentially saying "here's your diagnosis, you ought to kill yourself" which not a judgement for a medical professional to make.

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 08:44

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 06:40

The thread is in danger of being derailed by strawman arguments about conditions other than dementia. We are not talking about other disabilities and conditions, lifelong conditions or children with SEN. We are talking about the specific condition of end-of-life dementia.

I understand that people affected by other life-limiting conditions feel that AD for dementia patients could be a slippery slope, but that doesn't mean it is helpful to conflate the two when we are still at a stage, in this country, where AD is not lawful for any type of condition at all.

It is not my place to opine on whether AD should be an option for conditions of which, by the grace of God, I have no experience.

I do feel justified in having an opinion on whether it should be available for dementia patients. It is too late for my parents, but the laws of genetics mean I will almost certainly succumb to the same disease unless something else kills me at a younger age.

I have no children, nieces, nephews or other younger family members I am in touch with, my husband is older than I am and my sister is a similar age and in line for the same genetic inheritance - so the question of being a burden on anyone does not come into it for me, there is no-one to take my old age burden.

I want the option of AD for myself, to be able to choose it when I am still of sound mind and be confident it will happen when my quality of life has deteriorated beyond a level I myself will stipulate.

Not while am happily in a care home singing along to Nirvana or Wham or whatever they will offer when Gen X get to care home age. Not if I'm still babbling nonsense happily to other residents, or making collages, or watching TV, but when I'm at the stage when I can do nothing but lie there, like my mum, or if I have the type of symptoms of aggression, anger and constant distress that I have seen in other patients.

I do not want that to be my end, and I think I should have the right to reject it.

But it IS a slippery slope, you just made it one. The law that was proposed in parliament was for terminal illnesses and now you want it extended to the degenerative disease you fear most yourself. For someone else it would be MS. In the Netherlands it was used for depression.

I empathise with the fear of dementia, truly I do. But decisions about whether and on what basis someone chooses their death cannot be made one disease at a time.

On the plus side there have been some really hopeful advances later in treatment of dementia that nobody on this thread has mentioned. So there is hope.

Gloriia · 09/11/2026 08:43

'Burdens'as you put it come in all shapes and forms from those with addictions, draining mental health issues, incurable diseases and of course dementia.

We as a society need to all develop the resilience and capability to care for our relatives and encouraging suicide is not it.

That said I do think when people have advanced illnesses hcps should stop treating such things as utis and just let nature take its course. I knew of a 90yr with advanced dementia in a care home and they kept given them antibiotics or bumping her to a&e if she seemed more altered. It seemed crazy, just keep them calm and comfortable in familiar surroundings.

HaggardRagingTired · 09/11/2026 08:35

In a recent discussion with my GP about HRT, we went through the cancer risks (slightly higher for me as I have a family history of it), and I decided to go ahead with the HRT. As I said to him, in my family it’s either cancer or dementia that gets you and I’d rather be taken out by cancer before the dementia hits me. He looked at me like 🤔, but I have watched family members with dementia suffer for years and it’s the most awful, scary, undignified, prolonged death. I don’t mean to sound flippant about cancer and I don’t particularly want that either but if I HAD to choose…

If only there was a way that we could go quietly, painlessly and peacefully without suffering.

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 08:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LetMeButterYourParsnips · 09/11/2026 07:38

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 06:35

You seem to be confused about what you are arguing for.

I agree with advance directives. Doctors go-to is usually to prolong life and sometimes they need a piece of paper telling them to stop.

But saying people have a duty to die because they are a burden? Get to fuck, eugenicist.

It’s not about a duty, it’s about a free will decision made when one is still capable of taking one.

Personal attacks show you don’t understand that.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 09/11/2026 06:40

The thread is in danger of being derailed by strawman arguments about conditions other than dementia. We are not talking about other disabilities and conditions, lifelong conditions or children with SEN. We are talking about the specific condition of end-of-life dementia.

I understand that people affected by other life-limiting conditions feel that AD for dementia patients could be a slippery slope, but that doesn't mean it is helpful to conflate the two when we are still at a stage, in this country, where AD is not lawful for any type of condition at all.

It is not my place to opine on whether AD should be an option for conditions of which, by the grace of God, I have no experience.

I do feel justified in having an opinion on whether it should be available for dementia patients. It is too late for my parents, but the laws of genetics mean I will almost certainly succumb to the same disease unless something else kills me at a younger age.

I have no children, nieces, nephews or other younger family members I am in touch with, my husband is older than I am and my sister is a similar age and in line for the same genetic inheritance - so the question of being a burden on anyone does not come into it for me, there is no-one to take my old age burden.

I want the option of AD for myself, to be able to choose it when I am still of sound mind and be confident it will happen when my quality of life has deteriorated beyond a level I myself will stipulate.

Not while am happily in a care home singing along to Nirvana or Wham or whatever they will offer when Gen X get to care home age. Not if I'm still babbling nonsense happily to other residents, or making collages, or watching TV, but when I'm at the stage when I can do nothing but lie there, like my mum, or if I have the type of symptoms of aggression, anger and constant distress that I have seen in other patients.

I do not want that to be my end, and I think I should have the right to reject it.

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 06:38

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:45

You've put your finger on the problem. Why aren't people starting threads about how care of the living in this country needs to improve, rather than about whether it's OK to kill them to save money and resources?

It's not as simple as that at all. My father had the best care and it didn't stop him having a miserable, degrading decline and drawn out death from Alzheimers. Its the nature of the disease.

Forgotthebins · 09/11/2026 06:35

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 14:03

And why should people expect to be a burden? I don't want to be one (and I don't want my family to be one on me when they won't be enjoying life at all anyway).

You seem to be confused about what you are arguing for.

I agree with advance directives. Doctors go-to is usually to prolong life and sometimes they need a piece of paper telling them to stop.

But saying people have a duty to die because they are a burden? Get to fuck, eugenicist.

morbiddest · 09/11/2026 05:51

It should absolurely not be offered. Even if legal, offering would be cruel and awful - scaring the patient to death, and making them feel pressured into doing it.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 04:06

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 17:45

You've put your finger on the problem. Why aren't people starting threads about how care of the living in this country needs to improve, rather than about whether it's OK to kill them to save money and resources?

This!

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 04:04

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 17:50

Animals really are different because you can't know their wishes, you can only estimate whether they are in pain, it is doubtful they have a concept of death in relation to themselves.

I have had two pets euthanised in old age when their pain and unhappiness was obvious; another pet died naturally in old age, having been active and healthy until the last.

I expect vets have to become hardened to seeing animals die, otherwise they'd be constantly depressed.

Yes, and no matter how much we love them, we still do treat them fundamentally differently to people. We legally own animals and can visit breeders to buy a puppy or kitten, which we of course could not do to people.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 03:59

Dixie81 · 08/11/2026 17:41

I’ve always been strongly pro assisted dying but reading this thread has started to make me doubt myself. It didn’t take long at all for the slippery slope to show, suggesting anyone who is a ‘burden’ should be encouraged to take this option, and that old age has no value. In fact, some of the comments from OP are so vile, I’m wondering if they’re trolling or if it’s actually anti-assisted dying propaganda, designed to turn us against it. Which it’s doing very successfully!

Edited

This

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 03:54

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 00:30

Given that resources are finite, do you think it's great for send children that dignified dying isn't allowed for dementia patients?

How far could that go? Would there be pressure to euthanize others living with other terrible conditions to free up space?

Dangerous logic to succumb to.

Thecatspantaloons · 09/11/2026 03:40

I'm caring for my mum with this condition knowing that I'll have no one to care for me because I'm child free by choice. I know people will judge me for my choices and say that I brought this on myself, but I would rather suffer alone in old age than subject myself and my nonexistent hypothetical children to a crappy life of potential suffering.
Put me to sleep FFS 🤣.