Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Dancingsquirrels · 10/11/2026 08:50

I think it will come in, but for all the wrong reasons

Economic necessity, but dressed up as compassion / autonomy

Be very afraid. Robust initial safeguards will be watered down in a few decades. (See also, terminating pregnancy, previously only legal in extreme circumstances, now at the mother's wish)

Gloriia · 10/11/2026 08:43

x2boys · 10/11/2026 08:36

Some people do appear happy and contented
You can think what you like but i worked in Dementia care on and off for years
For some people its a terrible condtion and they are tormented and distressed by it day and night but for others
They are oblivious and appear contented albeit in their own world
Also its not one illness there are many difftent forms of Dementia and they can manifest in different ways.

Exactly. Everyone is different.

What hcps need to do is educate and support relatives to manage expectations. No, don't keep repeating 'I'm your son John I've just told you!' or 'I've told you Dad is dead'. Just live day to day and accept their altered state.

I hate those alzheimer 'awareness' ads 'mam died 3 times, the first time when she couldn't cook her legendary roast'. No, she didnt die she had declining cognitive ability so just go with it and forget the roast fgs.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 10/11/2026 08:37

CurdinHenry · 10/11/2026 08:20

I am not convinced by the happy old lady in the care home trope - I think it probably entails a fair bit of ageist othering ("of course I wouldn't like it but THEY are fine")

No two patients are alike, and the same patient can change drastically as they go through different stages of the disease.

At one stage, my mum could enjoy things like tribute acts, which they have in her care home, but she is beyond that now.

Some patients sadly never pass through a stage where they can enjoy things like that - each case is different; there are different types of dementia and a patient can have more than one (my mum has two) so different combinations - it all adds up to a complex picture.

But I do agree that the happy old lady in a care home trope is annoying. I actually switch off TV programmes that go down that route - it's a surprisingly common cliche. In real life is it never everyone singing happily along to the band, you have half of the people not responding at all, and at least one person upset about something and shouting.

x2boys · 10/11/2026 08:36

CurdinHenry · 10/11/2026 08:20

I am not convinced by the happy old lady in the care home trope - I think it probably entails a fair bit of ageist othering ("of course I wouldn't like it but THEY are fine")

Some people do appear happy and contented
You can think what you like but i worked in Dementia care on and off for years
For some people its a terrible condtion and they are tormented and distressed by it day and night but for others
They are oblivious and appear contented albeit in their own world
Also its not one illness there are many difftent forms of Dementia and they can manifest in different ways.

CurdinHenry · 10/11/2026 08:20

tartyflette · 10/11/2026 00:40

Dementia can manifest in different ways. My late DM, who was a bit of a spiky character, was completely changed by her dementia. It softened her into a very sweet and easy going old lady who was happy all the time, loved company and was very popular with the staff at her care come.
She didn’t remember me as her daughter and thought we were just old friends but was always delighted to see me (and everyone else who visited her. )

I am not convinced by the happy old lady in the care home trope - I think it probably entails a fair bit of ageist othering ("of course I wouldn't like it but THEY are fine")

OP posts:
QiBengong · 10/11/2026 07:12

Notonthestairs · 09/11/2026 18:32

No assisted dying legislation will ever pass until the safeguarding concerns are explored and dealt with. I think there is a suspicion on this thread that safeguarding concerns are the product of an overactive imagination. They are not.

I refer to this letter to the BMJ from assorted senior judges-
“What is striking is not simply what the letter says, but what it omits. It makes no acknowledgement of the substantial evidence submitted to Parliament by the medical Royal Colleges, other professional bodies, legal experts, disability organisations, ethicists and clinicians who identified those concerns, nor of the complexity involved in creating legislation that is safe, equitable and capable of commanding public confidence.
In this respect, the letter illustrates one of the central problems that contributed to the bill’s failure. Rather than engaging with the difficult questions raised during scrutiny, supporters presented assisted dying law reform as a largely settled matter, with concerns raised by professional and expert bodies too often minimised, misrepresented or denied. Yet the scrutiny process revealed the opposite: that fundamental questions remain unresolved about safeguards, oversight, coercion, capacity assessment, clinical responsibilities and the relationship between assisted dying and healthcare.
The bill did not fail because its critics were unwilling to engage with reform. It failed because too many of its supporters were unwilling to engage with the complexity of developing a law that is genuinely safe, equitable and compassionate. Any future attempt at legislation must begin with a serious assessment of these challenges and a willingness to address them, rather than denying that they exist.”
https://www.bmj.com/content/393/bmj.s810/rr-3

Sorry, I wrote a post and ended up quoting the wrong thing to reply to.
Will try again

Bitsostuff · 10/11/2026 01:13

tartyflette · 10/11/2026 00:40

Dementia can manifest in different ways. My late DM, who was a bit of a spiky character, was completely changed by her dementia. It softened her into a very sweet and easy going old lady who was happy all the time, loved company and was very popular with the staff at her care come.
She didn’t remember me as her daughter and thought we were just old friends but was always delighted to see me (and everyone else who visited her. )

My dad was like this for a number of years too. Didn't stop the final months of his life being degrading and awful. Maybe your mother didn't mind losing control of her bodily functions, choking on food, not knowing where he was but my father did. He died weighing 6 stone and covered in bed sores despite all the cleaning and turning and special mattress etc etc

tartyflette · 10/11/2026 00:40

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:49

Dementia takes your will away fast is the difference. I would like the option offered with absolutely everything in the same terminal category and I find it frustrating that it can't happen because other people can't foresee what's coming for them (ie a fate worse than death and then death anyway). But dementia is particularly inexcusable. You're gone before your body is, potentially a long time before. A madman left in control of your animated corpse.

Dementia can manifest in different ways. My late DM, who was a bit of a spiky character, was completely changed by her dementia. It softened her into a very sweet and easy going old lady who was happy all the time, loved company and was very popular with the staff at her care come.
She didn’t remember me as her daughter and thought we were just old friends but was always delighted to see me (and everyone else who visited her. )

XenoBitch · 10/11/2026 00:26

INeverReallyLovedYouAnyway · 10/11/2026 00:26

So they won’t uphold my AD of no measures to keep me alive either?

AD and not treating someone are totally different things.

INeverReallyLovedYouAnyway · 10/11/2026 00:26

XenoBitch · 10/11/2026 00:24

Because having dementia, you could have no recollection of ever having agreed to AD at a particular point.
You can not consent to something you can't remember agreeing to.

So they won’t uphold my AD of no measures to keep me alive either?

XenoBitch · 10/11/2026 00:24

INeverReallyLovedYouAnyway · 10/11/2026 00:15

So if I put in place an advanced directive saying that if I have dementia I don’t want any special measures and just let me go…they will listen to that? If that’s the case, why do they take that on board and not an advanced directive about assisted suicide? The end result is the same?

Because having dementia, you could have no recollection of ever having agreed to AD at a particular point.
You can not consent to something you can't remember agreeing to.

TownClown59 · 10/11/2026 00:15

Completely agree. My Mum is only 68 and hers is progressing really rapidly. I had this conversation with my brother, that if she could see herself now, that’s what she’d want. It’s truly heartbreaking. I guess each individual case is different though. My mum’s quality of life throughout her illness has been extremely poor, pretty much from the beginning. Whereas I know that some people can live reasonably well for a time, given the right support.

INeverReallyLovedYouAnyway · 10/11/2026 00:15

So if I put in place an advanced directive saying that if I have dementia I don’t want any special measures and just let me go…they will listen to that? If that’s the case, why do they take that on board and not an advanced directive about assisted suicide? The end result is the same?

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 23:48

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 19:38

Yes I was aware of the BMJ letter, from the judges, Notonthestairs, and while agreeing with the points it makes I wouldn't expect it to be welcomed by those it called out for refusing to engage on a very complex subject

You'd think the passage "The bill did not fail because its critics were unwilling to engage with reform. It failed because too many of its supporters were unwilling to engage with the complexity of developing a law that is genuinely safe, equitable and compassionate" would encourage them to do better if and when this comes up again, but frankly I'm not confident

Edited

This

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 23:47

Cheese55 · 09/11/2026 18:45

What is the purpose of knowing? If you're worried about developing and then living with it, make your wishes known and get LpoA in place.
Some years ago I worked in a hospital and the older people with dementia were routinely 'left comfortable and died. There was very little 'aggressive treatment' quite the opposite.

This

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 23:46

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 09/11/2026 18:15

I appreciate everyone feels differently but personally I would rather an assisted death than just existing for the sake of it when I reach that point. I am disappointed that I don't have the choice. It seems my body my choice only extends to those who are fit and healthy. I would trust my children to make the decision knowing my wishes when the time came.

I can understand what you mean re feeling only the healthy have my body, my choice. However, a fit and healthy person who is very depressed would not be allowed AD either here- and I think that would be very risky potentially.

NewMonsteraLeaf · 09/11/2026 23:46

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:44

And there is no greater burden than being a dementia patient. I think it's immoral not to care about that tbh.

Agree.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 23:42

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/11/2026 17:35

This is a moral minefield and if we get it wrong then we fail to safeguard our most vulnerable

As the thread has made clear this is one of the major points for many of us, @Wordsmithery, but unfortunately there are some who simply don't care about the measure's potential effect on anyone else as long as they get what they want

I realise this attitude is becoming ever more common with all manner of issues, but it really isn't my idea of how a civilised society should work

This. I believe there are measures people can take short of AD : writing DNR and that a certain point they only want palliative care, for two.

Jane3212 · 09/11/2026 23:41

Rootsinmydreamland · 09/11/2026 22:36

For those trying to dismiss those of us who have grave concerns for what the assisted dying bill could have meant for the safety, dignity, comfort and general quality of life of disabled people as being hysterical, over-emotive, deluded or disingenuous, it is important to recognise that, when it comes to AD, the slippery slope argument is extremely valid. We have several stark contemporary real-world examples which offer ample justification for our concerns. The situation in countries like Canada and the Netherlands, which initially allowed assisted dying in cases of terminal illness but which now allow it for a range of non-terminal cases, give an alarming indication of not just what could happen in this country were assisted dying to be legalised but what is likely to happen.
The number of posters on this thread who already seem to be agitating for assisted dying to be expanded far beyond the remit of the failed recent bill, which, let us not forget, was only supposed to apply to those with under six months to live, is another grim reminder of the dangers inherent in enacting such legislation. The fact that what many posters also seem to be agitating for deliberate killing by a third party, which is quite a different thing to the assisted dying alternative that was on offer.
Leaving aside the sinister and likely malign OP who considers the lives of the sick and disabled to be worthless and burdensome, and who seems fixated on the idea of callously killing off anyone who encounters poor health at the first chance, I realise most of the posters on here are likely arguing from a place of compassion, but I do not think many of them are truly willing to consider what this legislation could mean to the lives of disabled people.

This. There have been worrying oversteps imo not just in Canada, which is usually cited, but Netherlands as you say, Spain, Belgium, among others. Others like France have only recently legalised so too early to say.

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 23:15

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 22:26

Do you think you're not callous? When you insist I must sit in my own shit, mad and terrified?

A call for caution on this matter is not the same thing as 'insisting' anything of the sort.

But if we're going to talk about terror, and seeing as you seem to think everyone gets dementia in the end, do you really think it'd be any less terrifying for a person with dementia to be held down and forcibly killed?

Rootsinmydreamland · 09/11/2026 22:36

For those trying to dismiss those of us who have grave concerns for what the assisted dying bill could have meant for the safety, dignity, comfort and general quality of life of disabled people as being hysterical, over-emotive, deluded or disingenuous, it is important to recognise that, when it comes to AD, the slippery slope argument is extremely valid. We have several stark contemporary real-world examples which offer ample justification for our concerns. The situation in countries like Canada and the Netherlands, which initially allowed assisted dying in cases of terminal illness but which now allow it for a range of non-terminal cases, give an alarming indication of not just what could happen in this country were assisted dying to be legalised but what is likely to happen.
The number of posters on this thread who already seem to be agitating for assisted dying to be expanded far beyond the remit of the failed recent bill, which, let us not forget, was only supposed to apply to those with under six months to live, is another grim reminder of the dangers inherent in enacting such legislation. The fact that what many posters also seem to be agitating for deliberate killing by a third party, which is quite a different thing to the assisted dying alternative that was on offer.
Leaving aside the sinister and likely malign OP who considers the lives of the sick and disabled to be worthless and burdensome, and who seems fixated on the idea of callously killing off anyone who encounters poor health at the first chance, I realise most of the posters on here are likely arguing from a place of compassion, but I do not think many of them are truly willing to consider what this legislation could mean to the lives of disabled people.

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 22:26

dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 21:56

Well obviously not for someone who's going to take the sort of overly simplistic and utterly callous position you've adopted on this thread.

Are you trying to suggest safeguards aren't needed? Oh, and BTW if you're going to bandy around terms like 'the pro-life script' I take it you won't mind being referred to as being pro-killing?

Do you think you're not callous? When you insist I must sit in my own shit, mad and terrified?

OP posts:
dreamiesformolly · 09/11/2026 21:56

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 20:58

It isn't REALLY complicated. The status quo condemns many (most?) of us to a bad end over which we have no control. That's something I think you'd have to be very religious to accept.

The pro life script is always the same

"Oh I see your point but

Safeguards (unspecified) are needed!

I was with you up until (insert thing here)

Very complicated"

It isn't complicated

Well obviously not for someone who's going to take the sort of overly simplistic and utterly callous position you've adopted on this thread.

Are you trying to suggest safeguards aren't needed? Oh, and BTW if you're going to bandy around terms like 'the pro-life script' I take it you won't mind being referred to as being pro-killing?

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 21:29

XenoBitch · 09/11/2026 21:27

Unless you are the person experiencing dementia, you don't get to say what they are going through.

If only people with dementia get to dictate policy there will be no policy. I guess you don't think it will be you or that it won't be that bad if it is.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 09/11/2026 21:27

CurdinHenry · 09/11/2026 21:25

No, to spare me the person who doesn't want my mind and dignity completely violated because some people are too slow to anticipate horror.

Unless you are the person experiencing dementia, you don't get to say what they are going through.

Swipe left for the next trending thread