Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just put my three year and four month old back in nappies after eight months

123 replies

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:02

I just cannot take the shit any more.

I know I’m going to get the usual bingo responses here about ERIC (useless) constipation, GPs and all the rest of it and that’s not what I’m about. I’ve been trying to solve this issue for months now and just - cannot.

I am done with it. I just kicked the potty outside with a sense of satisfaction (yes, I know MN hate potties but ERIC recommend them for children with toileting problems for poo,)

I just cannot take another pair of shit filled pants.

OP posts:
SuddenDaredJelly · 08/11/2026 20:39

Nb the "inconvenient times" of accidents is because shes holding it, which causes impaction which stretches the bowel and leads to reduced sensation and control.

I'd use nappies for a few weeks to check her bowel is recovering. If in nappies over a few weeks she returns to a normal pattern of solid poos 1-3 times daily after meals, you know the withholding was the issue rather than a broader constipation problem.

Iloveeverycat · 08/11/2026 20:39

Stelladid · 08/11/2026 20:10

Are you one of the parents who will send their child into school in nappies, so the teachers can do the job? My kids are all grown-up now, but won’t yours start Reception class in a matter of months?

They are only 3 there is plenty of time for them to be ready. You can't force potty training. They shouldn't of started 8 months ago if they weren't showing that they might be ready to start. When ready they pick it up quickly.

MissingMeadow · 08/11/2026 20:39

It really does sound like she's impacted though. My DS was exactly the same.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:43

I really think that’s best for the GP to device @MissingMeadow .

@SuddenDaredJelly oh come on, there is no medical condition in the land that only kicks in when you’re late, or when you’re about to get in the shower, or when you’ve sat down for the first time since breakfast!

Anyway, it’s turned into an advice thread which I didn’t want, not because I’m in the habit of being an arse but because I end up having to say ‘look, we’ve explored this’ and then people get annoyed because they think you’re ignoring kindly meant advice and the thread just descends into bickering and peevishness which I really don’t want!

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 08/11/2026 20:56

My eldest was similar and had to have a nappy on to poop, and eventually it became a nappy over the potty, until he was ok. My nephew is 4 and at school and has similar issues. He is constipated and on a lot of sachets, and teachers will clean him up (part of a plan he has, not EHCP, but similar). They did suspect he was autistic, but now don’t, bur he continues to have issues and was late potty training full stop, but now just poop issues and they put a nappy on him to poop. Don’t beat yourself up, she will get there.

RavenLaw · 08/11/2026 21:09

No advice but solidarity from the other side of this - mine went back into pull-ups (on the advice of the specialist continence team) and it gave all of us, DC particularly, some breathing space and relief from the anxiety it was creating. Mine got there eventually (mostly) and so will yours.

Nothing invites judgement quite like parenting a child with continence problems.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 21:25

You are so right about that @RavenLaw .

OP posts:
Sleepster · 09/11/2026 06:21

What happens if she is on a play date? Does she still have accidents?

BlackeyedSusan · 09/11/2026 10:12

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 21:25

You are so right about that @RavenLaw .

Abso-fucking-lutely! And some people do go on about it endlessly.

Everyone being less stressed about shit cleaning (not a judgement, shit cleaning isn't fun,) because of the nappy moves get help training, if not, then you are still cleaning less shit, so win win.

ScaryM0nster · 10/11/2026 09:22

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:21

Eric are not tremdendously helpful to be honest @ScaryM0nster . I spoke to them when ds was struggling and I found them very judgemental.

You keep saying they’re no help. And yet what you’re deciding to do is pretty much what they advise……

wouldyouactuallydothat · 10/11/2026 09:24

Right so …? 😂

OP posts:
Cakeandcoffee445332 · 10/11/2026 10:12

The fact her brother had the same difficulties suggests the problem is the parenting, not the child. Your language around this is terrible. Poor child is stressed and constipated. Have some empathy.

If it makes you feel better to kick the potty and have a vent, do so, we all have low moments. But take the opportunity to calm down and decide on a new strategy in a few days.

Rainallnight · 10/11/2026 22:21

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:02

I quite resent the implication there @Kingdomofsleep

I’m sorry, OP, but I’m with @Kingdomofsleep here. Your posts show that you don’t actually understand the different medications and what could help. Macrogols (the sachet ones) simply draw water into the bowel, softening the poo. They don’t change the actual bowel activity at all and people don’t become reliant on them.

Stimulant laxatives are stronger but again, people generally don’t become reliant on them and may be what your DD needs to get her going properly.

I know it’s not what you want to hear but you have been fobbed off by the GP and have a child with untreated encopresis (I think, by the sounds of things).

drspouse · 11/11/2026 09:38

I have no idea @wouldyouactuallydothat why you are ruling out impaction. The GP will not be able to diagnose that as they don't have an ultrasound to see what's going on. It can still look like soft poo or even diarrhoea. If the GP hasn't referred to the continence nurse, what have you got to lose by asking for a referral? Your dignity if you are proved wrong? A couple of additional appointments if you are right?

My DD had a lot of soft poos, great diet, exercise and lots of water, and turned out to have impaction. In her case it also affected her bladder as she couldn't distinguish the sensations/it was pushing on her bladder. Movicol sorted her out but after de impaction she had a long road to re learn her own signals.

Pinadaqx2 · 11/11/2026 09:42

You can buy liners for the washable pants OP. Maybe nappy on a night?

endofthelinefinally · 11/11/2026 09:55

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:46

@Kingdomofsleep I’m not saying that to be rude. It is just that after eight months of difficulties I’ve explored extensively all of the obvious (and not so obvious!) solutions and just keep hitting a brick wall. I was just trying to avoid lots of ‘have you contacted ERIC op’ sort of replies.

I may change my mind tomorrow but she is in a pull up now. I just cannot take any more of it for now. Shit fatigue is real.

I know she tries to hold them in and so then of course eventually out they come but because she’s holding them in it’s in lots of little messy oozes throughout the day - ugh.

Everyone else I know just potty trained so easily and seamlessly and it’s hard not to think about why meeee!

Classic witholding, impaction with overflow. Sorry, I know you don't want to hear it.

justtosay26 · 11/11/2026 09:57

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:38

Ten a day? That sounds crazy to me but I am obviously not an expert. But my concern is that treating a child for constipation who is not constipated is going to result in the body becoming reliant on them.

@lanthanum it would make sense if she’d do it!

That’s not how it works.

PPs are right - your daughter needs Movicol. She is impacted. So she can’t/won’t poo and the cycle continues.

Mosaic80 · 11/11/2026 10:12

Gosh, I think you are totally reasonable to revert to pull ups for a bit. Would she be willing to eventually ask for a nappy when she needs a poo? Or at least go to the potty or loo for wees?

My DD was 3 years and 9 months when she finally potty trained (while we were on holiday - always on her own schedule!). We tried and tried but she just held the wee in then weed all down her legs, really upset when she couldn't hold it any more. Luckily nursery were really lovely about it and just said wait till she's ready.

My older DS had been 2 years 2 months and got it really easily so it was something of a shock that DD (no SEN or other delays at all) didn't get it.

MN isn't very sypmathetic towards later potty trainers though and you get a lot of "what if she goes to school in nappies" hand wringing. Trying everything like you have been doing is vastly different to just not being arsed with it. And, like you said 10 months is a lot of time (approx 1/4 of her whole life at this point) so I'd just give you all a break and stop the stress as that might be compounding the whole situation and a couple of months break might make all the difference. You could also go straight to the toilet at that point (with a stool? We have a fold up one from amazon that is good, it's slightly higher than the usual box ones) to ring the changes and emphasize the "big girl" aspect.

ETA reading some of the recent replies, it does sound like impaction is also worth a really thorough look at.

drspouse · 11/11/2026 10:21

My DD didn't go to school in nappies but she was still struggling with poo and consequently wee. It happens, they knew it was a knock on effect of the previous impaction. It was Y1 before a week without accidents was more common than a week with accidents. She's 12 now and still a bit grumpy about being told to go to the loo and has a toilet pass at school.

endofthelinefinally · 11/11/2026 10:22

Witholding, impaction with overflow has a huge psychological, anxiety related component. Everything going on around the child influences it. A 3 year old doesn't have the insight or vocabulary to explain it or discuss it.
There is no quick fix.
I know you have said you don't want advice OP, but it is hard to read this without at least trying to help.
If you don't like ERIC, there is a very good video on you tube that only takes about 20 minutes of your time to watch. It is called The Poo Nurses and it is worth watching right to the end.
GPs are often not good at dealing with this. There isn't enough time in a ten minute appointment.

Soontoomuch · 12/11/2026 20:24

What about a "musical potty"? Not sure if they are still available though.

Granville82 · 13/11/2026 05:03

Iloveeverycat · 08/11/2026 13:21

If she is only 3 and 4 months maybe she wasn't ready months ago. My first was definitely still in nappies at 3 years 2 months. I started when I thought they were ready I didn't force it. What is ERIC. I don't see the need to see a Dr about this at such an early age. What's the thing about not using potties I used one for all my 4.
Can't you just use pull ups until she's ready.

Edited

There's no such thing as "ready". This is myth. The NHS has since removed this concept from their advice because it's just not applicable and was giving people the wrong idea. Potty learning/training is a gradual skill taught and facilitated by parents and you can start from any age, including birth, in one form or another. It's commonplace all over the world and historically for kids to be out of nappies by 1 and very common by 18 months.

Whoddathoughtit · 13/11/2026 06:28

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 20:43

I really think that’s best for the GP to device @MissingMeadow .

@SuddenDaredJelly oh come on, there is no medical condition in the land that only kicks in when you’re late, or when you’re about to get in the shower, or when you’ve sat down for the first time since breakfast!

Anyway, it’s turned into an advice thread which I didn’t want, not because I’m in the habit of being an arse but because I end up having to say ‘look, we’ve explored this’ and then people get annoyed because they think you’re ignoring kindly meant advice and the thread just descends into bickering and peevishness which I really don’t want!

How refreshing to read about a parent taking control of an issue in a way that is best for their own family, the unfortunate side order we get from social media is complete strangers judging us and in turn we kind of judge ourselves then too.
this poop situ will be a distant memory in the future won’t it, your daughter absolutely won’t be wearing nappies forever by the sounds of it.
everyone just relax!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page