Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just put my three year and four month old back in nappies after eight months

123 replies

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:02

I just cannot take the shit any more.

I know I’m going to get the usual bingo responses here about ERIC (useless) constipation, GPs and all the rest of it and that’s not what I’m about. I’ve been trying to solve this issue for months now and just - cannot.

I am done with it. I just kicked the potty outside with a sense of satisfaction (yes, I know MN hate potties but ERIC recommend them for children with toileting problems for poo,)

I just cannot take another pair of shit filled pants.

OP posts:
wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:20

And every so often, once in a blue moon, she’ll randomly go to the potty and produce a perfect poo! And I think - aha! Our struggles are over. Until next time 😂

OP posts:
ScaryM0nster · 08/11/2026 14:19

I’m guessing you haven’t read the whole Eric guide to toilet training. They're generally recognised as the experts, as they are not at all pro the all or nothing approach that seems to be rife on the parenting world of social media.

Their advice recognises that learning can be done while wearing pull ups, that theres different contexts and can adjust to match eg pants at home and pull ups when out. Encouragement to keep pull ups dry. Putting kitchen paper inside to avoid the not feeling wet tactic. Keep the potty in an easy access position (they might like it in the garden, ours lived there for a while).

Not at all unreasonable to take step to make cleaning up shit in public easier.

Bitsostuff · 08/11/2026 14:19

If you need a break, take a break. My only comment for when you try again is "try bribery". My neice potty trained at 4 for Smarties (one for every successful use if the loo) after many failed attempts. I went straight to bribery with sweeties at 2 and got a surprising amount of cooperation per jelly tot.

Dobedobedobedo · 08/11/2026 14:18

There are lots of reasons why some children just don't get it at the average age and sometimes persevering can just worsen the problem by causing anxiety to child and parent.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:18

@drspouse i am not ‘telling’ anyone anything, I’m just trying to be clear it’s not an advice thread.

OP posts:
Iloveeverycat · 08/11/2026 14:18

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:12

I have said, I am just venting. I am really upset with both her and myself and typing here makes me feel a bit less alone with it and also stops me blowing a fuse at DD, which would be awful when it’s not her fault.

Why anyone has an issue with that I don’t know but MN is a funny place sometimes! But you do get a lot of ‘have you contacted your HV / here’s a helpful link to ERIC / how about Poo Goes To Pooland / here’s ERIC’s phone number / what about blowing bubbles on the toilet / here’s some contact details for ERIC’ otherwise!

But if they are not ready they are not ready none of this advice will work.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:17

@Neverendingstory111 i have tried to talk to her about it but don’t really get anywhere to be honest, I’ve asked her if she’s scared to go and she says no, but I think she probably is because she will often poo in her nappy just before she goes to bed (she isn’t consistently dry overnight.)

OP posts:
drspouse · 08/11/2026 14:17

Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 13:39

I know you're dismissing this as a "usual bingo response" but this situation is often because they're impacted and need movicol/laxido. It happened to my toddler and has happened to many others. Have you tried that? If you are so desperate, surely you have

I would second this. The continence nurse was a godsend for us. We saw her on and off for about 3 years all told. She was able to give DD a scan, check for impaction and distended bowel, and oversee medication.
If you haven't tried this then don't tell us what not to suggest.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:16

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 14:14

If just venting - chat or parenting probably better

Well, I’m not reposting it now! I’d get indignant squawks of this has already been posted 😂

It really doesn’t matter!

OP posts:
Neverendingstory111 · 08/11/2026 14:15

I had the same with my youngest son (he does have sen though).
Is she frightened to go? Why do you think she holds it in?
My son went days without pooing because he was petrified of the toliet and potty.
I would have a few days of as its quite clear you are stressed and need a break and its not achieving anything.
I had to do the same and literally just before school he just did it!

You need to get to the bottom (literally) of why she is holding it in and go from there.

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 14:14

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:12

I have said, I am just venting. I am really upset with both her and myself and typing here makes me feel a bit less alone with it and also stops me blowing a fuse at DD, which would be awful when it’s not her fault.

Why anyone has an issue with that I don’t know but MN is a funny place sometimes! But you do get a lot of ‘have you contacted your HV / here’s a helpful link to ERIC / how about Poo Goes To Pooland / here’s ERIC’s phone number / what about blowing bubbles on the toilet / here’s some contact details for ERIC’ otherwise!

If just venting - chat or parenting probably better

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:13

Yes, her brother is six next month.

OP posts:
Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 14:13

Sounds very difficult. At this age, she will very soon become aware of being the only one of her peers still in nappies and that might be a motivation. Does she have any older siblings?

CordwainerBird · 08/11/2026 14:12

Just adding to the success stories where we were still struggling after 3, having been trying since 2.4ish. They all get there in the end. It was hard though, I feel for you. Don’t let people whose kids were perfectly trained by 2 get to you, it can’t happen for everyone.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:12

Ilikethatusername · 08/11/2026 14:08

I know I’m going to get the usual bingo responses here about ERIC (useless) constipation, GPs and all the rest of it and that’s not what I’m about.

so why start a thread in AIBU?

I have said, I am just venting. I am really upset with both her and myself and typing here makes me feel a bit less alone with it and also stops me blowing a fuse at DD, which would be awful when it’s not her fault.

Why anyone has an issue with that I don’t know but MN is a funny place sometimes! But you do get a lot of ‘have you contacted your HV / here’s a helpful link to ERIC / how about Poo Goes To Pooland / here’s ERIC’s phone number / what about blowing bubbles on the toilet / here’s some contact details for ERIC’ otherwise!

OP posts:
Luddite26 · 08/11/2026 14:11

Hey one dgs managed to start weeing from about 3.5y but poo was only in a nappy. He asked for one putting on. Then one day at about 5.5 he just came home and pooed on the toilet. He's PDA and likes to keep holding it in.
Sympathy to you.

Iloveeverycat · 08/11/2026 14:09

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:35

She isn’t four until midsummer. It is very late but I do think I’ll have to wait for it to come from her.

Initially I wasn’t concerned but as the months have gone by and nothing has changed, it’s become more and more frustrating. It’s horrible to deal with especially when out and about in small public toilets.

I have just reached a point of complete and utter shit fatigue I think.

It isn't very late though who said to start months ago. Every child is different. I wouldn't be worried at this age.

Ilikethatusername · 08/11/2026 14:08

I know I’m going to get the usual bingo responses here about ERIC (useless) constipation, GPs and all the rest of it and that’s not what I’m about.

so why start a thread in AIBU?

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 14:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:05

I feel like I can constantly smell it and can never relax my god yes. My nose is FILLED with the smell. It’s all around the house.

OP posts:
wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 14:05

She obviously can’t go school in nappies or soiling herself, but I do have options where that’s concerned. Ten months is a long time in a child’s life though. That said, we’ve made no progress in eight.

OP posts:
Twinkletoes8474 · 08/11/2026 14:04

Just wanted to post to give you my sympathy. It’s so awful when you’re in the thick of poo issues, with my eldest it went on for actual years. It’s such a tricky thing for some children. My middle two children were totally fine and now my youngest has issues. He’s four and still not fully toilet trained. I know he will get there eventually but 100% solidarity with just being fed up of shit. I feel like I can constantly smell it and can never relax. But then also know that I have to be relaxed or it’ll make the issue worse. I started potty training my youngest at 3 and have had lots of poo issues and have gone back to nappies several times. He finally seems to be getting somewhere now but I was paranoid about impaction as my eldest struggled a lot with withholding and I think had some damage from that which took a long time to recover from. So I say it’s ok to take the pressure off and use nappies or offer nappies for poos if that helps you both

Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 14:03

I was also determined to get it sorted well before my ds goes to school because problems like this are much harder to deal with once they are at school and can lead to school refusal. For that reason alone i would honestly consider giving it a try because you only have about a year.

Kingdomofsleep · 08/11/2026 14:01

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:56

@Kingdomofsleep this is going to come across as more shirty than intended but I’m not dragging her around different GPs to get answers you want 🤷🏼‍♀️ Laxatives aren’t a magic bullet, as the post above shows. I don’t even think she’s constipated. If you hold on to your poo eventually it will come out but that’s not the same thing.

It's ok,I get it, you think i am being unhelpful, but i am just passing on the wisdom i got from MN myself. It was a magic bullet for my son, but you have to get the dosage right - the first gp I spoke to (an inexperienced one) suggested half a sachet a day which did nothing. The second gp said up to 8 initially then taper down. It worked in weeks. Perhas the pp also needs to increase the dose, i don't know.

Laxido is not a laxative - this convinces me you haven't read Eric in spite of dismissing it. It's a stool softener.

I must have been more desperate than you are, because I didn't dismiss any advice I was given. My ds is about to turn 3 now and is pooing one solid poo in the potty everyday, and I'm so grateful for the many mn movicol threads I read. I'm just paying that forward now. It's ok if this advice doesn't appeal to you, it'll work for others reading

wouldyouactuallydothat · 08/11/2026 13:56

@Kingdomofsleep this is going to come across as more shirty than intended but I’m not dragging her around different GPs to get answers you want 🤷🏼‍♀️ Laxatives aren’t a magic bullet, as the post above shows. I don’t even think she’s constipated. If you hold on to your poo eventually it will come out but that’s not the same thing.

OP posts: