Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to things my husbands ex wife needs to accept that we are now one family.

697 replies

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 11:36

I've been with my husband for five years. He has two children from his previous marriage and we welcomed our baby together in August.

Ever since we announced I was pregnant,his ex has been noticeably upset about the situation. I do understand that it might have been an adjustment for her, but equally, we weren't having a baby to upset anyone. It was simply the natural progression of our relationship and something we wanted together. I’m not getting any younger, I’m in my late 30s, we plan to have another child but again I am in my late 30s so not sure about that. I think 5 years with someone is enough to have a child. We’ve bought a house together, we’ve had time and believe it was part of being together and having a child was something we both wanted.

The thing is, the children absolutely adore the baby. They always want to see their dad, spend time at our house and be involved in family life here. I have always made an effort to makethem feel welcomeand included. They have their own bedrooms, their own belongings and their own space here. This is their home too.

I actually thought it would be a positive thingfor their mum that I have a good relationshipwith herchildren. Surely it's better that they feel comfortable and happy in their dad's home,rather than feeling like visitors or outsiders?

I would never try to replace their mum, and I have no desire to interfere with her relationship with them.But I also don't think we should have to make our family smaller or pretend the baby doesn't exist to make her feel more comfortable.

My husband is still their dad, they are still very much part of his life, and now they have a little brother s too.

AIBU to think she needs to accept that this is the reality now and that the children having another happy, loving home to go to is a good thing? Or am I being naive how difficult this must be for her?

His children are old enough to form their own opinions and decide if they want a relationship with their sibling and they’ve chosen to have a relationship. Surely that is a good thing.

OP posts:
ItalianoSl · 08/11/2026 19:57

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:28

There’s more to the conversations that he’s had with then individually and together and the ones I’ve been in. I don’t have alarm bells ringing. He has asked them countless of times what they want, where they want to stay, they’re not going to say because they know it’ll upset their mum, the youngest himself said he doesn’t want to upset her but he doesn’t like being there, he has asked them why they’re acting that way, their answer is the same every single time, it has not changed, he’s the one that sorted out the counselling and everything else I think he does care about them based on what I’ve seen the last 5 years.

And this is why even great teenagers can benefit for their mature, adult parents setting down rules. So many conversations!
Many households wouldn’t be able to manage all this spontaneous turning up and taking back home - they need to know who is where and when.
It’s perfectly ok to set down expectations - even with adult children still at home. It’s about respect and consideration.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:56

StockingsByTheFire · 08/11/2026 19:53

She's changed her story repeatedly throughout the thread.

You'll get told to "ignore the post if you have that perspective which you are entitled too"

Or something similarly nonsensical entirely deflecting from the fact that she changes her story every time someone points out that the kids just aren't that interested in her and her baby, this is about other things.

I didn’t say the children were ever interested in me I don’t think they care. I do think they do like having a little brother. The older one can’t wait to teach him how to cycle and wants to get him his first bike…he won’t be but has offered. He is still their sibling regardless and they can want to also spend time with him. They’re not wanting to spend time with me. They want time with their father and also their sibling

OP posts:
NovemberMorn · 08/11/2026 19:55

More info is being drip fed into this thread the longer ot goes on....and I have been out for a meal and back and STILL it goes on.

It started that the husband’s 2 teens wanted to spend more time at his house because they were besotted with the new baby.
Then the husband felt the kids wanted to live there because they didn't want to spend much time with their mum.
Then we learn they have had counselling at school and even wanted to board there ... yet the children say there is nothing wrong at home ... and it seems the husband hasn't really gone into that.

The OP has said a couple of times that she hates to see her husband upset. Has it not occurred to her that the woman he once loved, who bore him two children, is being edged out of her childrens life?
If he has any feelings and empathy...of course he will be upset.
My sympathies lie with the first wife....and I say that as a second wife.

renovationchoas · 08/11/2026 19:55

If your DH was always the primary carer and (by your account) basically both the provider and the better parent, why are they not already living with him?

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:54

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:49

Can't possibly have been for long based on the account you have given.
Either way, it can't simultaneously be passing novelty and they've always wanted to live with dad.

How long then ? I’m confused with the assumptions. I said I wasn’t there I only know what I’ve been told by people in his life including his ex wife when we had the discussion about their behaviour she said he was the primary parent for a while when they first divorced because they always wanted to be at dads or with dad.

OP posts:
StockingsByTheFire · 08/11/2026 19:53

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:38

So is it new baby novelty, or theyve actually always wanted to live with dad? It's really hard to keep track of this stuff. It can't be both.

She's changed her story repeatedly throughout the thread.

You'll get told to "ignore the post if you have that perspective which you are entitled too"

Or something similarly nonsensical entirely deflecting from the fact that she changes her story every time someone points out that the kids just aren't that interested in her and her baby, this is about other things.

dobedowaaaa · 08/11/2026 19:51

I could have been typing this 20 years ago. Same situation. My Step sons adored their new baby brother but as they got older teens, they had their own lives and despite spending time together as a family, my DS was pretty much raised as an only child as they lived with their mother (until they had their own partners/wifes/children). My DH's ex threw some spanners in the works along the way, very petty things to try and turn them against us but the boys worked it out for themselves, I stayed out of it, and that it my advice to you. Nurture your relationship to your husband and step children but dont rise to any unpleasantness from the ex. and of course never bad mouth her to your step children, or for them to hear. All that done and dusted, and my DS has an amazing relationship with his brothers and the ex is insignificant to me and my (now ex) husband. Good luck - its a long road of patience and compromise being a mum and step mum!!

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:49

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:45

Definitely agree I wasn’t there but I do know he was the primary caregiver based on the account of everyone, the kids, ex wife, even his parents can account for that. I’m not sure they’d all be lying about who was the main household at the time but I do not know I wasn’t there.

Can't possibly have been for long based on the account you have given.
Either way, it can't simultaneously be passing novelty and they've always wanted to live with dad.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:49

redskyAtNigh · 08/11/2026 19:45

I find it interesting that you keep talking about "sitting them down" and talking to them with respect to your stepchildren. This generally isn't a very good way of getting honest and serious views out of teenagers as it feels very confrontational. Perhaps a different approach could be taken?

What other approach could we take ? Besides talking to them about it. If there’s any others we haven’t thought of let me know

OP posts:
QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:48

TomHanksIsMyHero · 08/11/2026 19:45

Just to add, my ex claims to be primary caregiver. I was a SAHM then worked 2 days a week term time only while he worked long hours, often away.

Don’t believe everything DP tells you, from one (ex)SM to another

His ex wife has said ? I don’t think that’s something his ex wife or even his family would lie about. Again I wasn’t there I can only go by what I’ve been told.

She has never been a SAHM and I am never going to be one either. We have future school fees to pay.

OP posts:
redskyAtNigh · 08/11/2026 19:45

I find it interesting that you keep talking about "sitting them down" and talking to them with respect to your stepchildren. This generally isn't a very good way of getting honest and serious views out of teenagers as it feels very confrontational. Perhaps a different approach could be taken?

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:45

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:41

Also worth remembering that you weren't there at that stage. Men trying to impress aren't always the most reliable narrators.

Definitely agree I wasn’t there but I do know he was the primary caregiver based on the account of everyone, the kids, ex wife, even his parents can account for that. I’m not sure they’d all be lying about who was the main household at the time but I do not know I wasn’t there.

OP posts:
TomHanksIsMyHero · 08/11/2026 19:45

Just to add, my ex claims to be primary caregiver. I was a SAHM then worked 2 days a week term time only while he worked long hours, often away.

Don’t believe everything DP tells you, from one (ex)SM to another

TomHanksIsMyHero · 08/11/2026 19:42

People are replying and you’re just further justifying your position.

If there is an agreement in place about contact; that should be facilitated regardless of the new baby.

Look at your baby and think how you’d feel if he was choosing not to be with you. Look at your DH and imagine how he’d feel if his teens chose to keep staying at mums.

It’s lovely you’re a family. That’s can happen without ever being together all of the time. Teens shouldn’t get to call and say im coming for tea, you don’t know that’s affecting what mum has planned for them.

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:41

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:39

They got over that as they got older, that seemed to be a childhood phase that they both navigated together. Then now a similar phase but they’re older.

Also worth remembering that you weren't there at that stage. Men trying to impress aren't always the most reliable narrators.

lucodaze · 08/11/2026 19:40

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:31

That’s the thing he has told them no. Taken them home when they’ve turned up unannounced then gets texts saying they don’t want to be there etc. It’s not as though when he gets a text like that he goes over to them up or tells them to make their way here.

I am not sure how you know their parenting dynamic previous to us even moving together. When they first separated he was the primary caregiver because they did not want to go home to their mother, they outright kept refusing so there was an arrangement made. I would say he has had experience being the primary caregiver they’re his children. Just because they’re divorced doesn’t mean he hasn’t parented them.

So from the ages of about 7 and 9 at most, they’ve been allowed to call the shots on where they spend their time?

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:39

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:38

So is it new baby novelty, or theyve actually always wanted to live with dad? It's really hard to keep track of this stuff. It can't be both.

They got over that as they got older, that seemed to be a childhood phase that they both navigated together. Then now a similar phase but they’re older.

OP posts:
FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:38

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:31

That’s the thing he has told them no. Taken them home when they’ve turned up unannounced then gets texts saying they don’t want to be there etc. It’s not as though when he gets a text like that he goes over to them up or tells them to make their way here.

I am not sure how you know their parenting dynamic previous to us even moving together. When they first separated he was the primary caregiver because they did not want to go home to their mother, they outright kept refusing so there was an arrangement made. I would say he has had experience being the primary caregiver they’re his children. Just because they’re divorced doesn’t mean he hasn’t parented them.

So is it new baby novelty, or theyve actually always wanted to live with dad? It's really hard to keep track of this stuff. It can't be both.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:34

Calliopespa · 08/11/2026 19:29

I think this is probably the best post on this thread OP - and if you only listen to one, make it this one.

Like @LoudWriter I am not really sure what you were seeking from the thread and think it is better to just focus on your baby right now.

I also agree with her take on how the boys are behaving, and I just don't think you need to be digging into it right now, other than to be aware they may be feeling a bit threatened by the new baby, even if they don't say it.

I agree but he said years before I even came into the picture they did not want to go home to their mum and preferred being at his with him. They have always just been closer to their mum from the sounds of it. Even when he’d drop them off to their grandparents, the grandparents have told me they’d always preferred their dad which is why they’re not surprised. They’re just surprised at the behaviour towards their mother but previously their father was the main caregiver as the children were having issues and always wanting to go to their dads.

OP posts:
Millytante · 08/11/2026 19:32

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:14

He has sat then done plenty of times and asked them if there’s anything wrong, what they’re unhappy with and all they have said is they just prefer being at dads. He cannot sit then done everytime he says them to ask them why they say they’d rather be at his all the time. It’s not every single time but quite a few times when they’re about to go back home to their mums they say that they wish they could just stay here. He has sat down with them and their mum to find out what’s going on. All the relevant people that see them often have said their behaviour has not changed. Only towards their mother and he’s not sure why or how to navigate that he is trying his best but sadly it’s not working. There is only so much he can say, he’s told them countless of times that they need to also spent time with their mum, the youngest is more understanding but the older one just says why?what if I don’t want to, you can’t force me etc, they’re both grumpy at mums but when they’re here they’re not so we get different stories all the time, mum says one thing, school says they’re acting the same, grandparents say they’re the same, hockey club says they’re the same. We are confused. They’re acting the same with all of us but different at their mums.

Whatever about your part in the discussion, your husband needs to bloody well get a grip and act like their father, rather than feeling he can chuck in the towel in the face of a need for firmness and guidance.
Surely they are testing his limits, and the power of their maturing.
These kids will swiftly turn into right young terrors if they are allowed to enjoy the rewards of bad behaviour left unchecked by their dad.
He owes this much to his ex, I think.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:31

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:22

He shouldn't be letting them act like this at all. Teaching them to be considerate is an important part of parenting. He needs to tell them no sometimes, he needs to enforce that they stick with plans and he and they need to communicate well with her so she knows what is happening.
He's getting away with passive parenting because he hasn't been the primary parent until now. You need to wise up before your baby gets older.

Edited

That’s the thing he has told them no. Taken them home when they’ve turned up unannounced then gets texts saying they don’t want to be there etc. It’s not as though when he gets a text like that he goes over to them up or tells them to make their way here.

I am not sure how you know their parenting dynamic previous to us even moving together. When they first separated he was the primary caregiver because they did not want to go home to their mother, they outright kept refusing so there was an arrangement made. I would say he has had experience being the primary caregiver they’re his children. Just because they’re divorced doesn’t mean he hasn’t parented them.

OP posts:
Calliopespa · 08/11/2026 19:29

LoudWriter · 08/11/2026 19:19

Ooooooof this was a tough read, OP. You're postpartum aren't you, so I'd suggest you take a breather- you're responding to everything and really this is not a healthy thing to be fixated on when you've got a baby.

It's hard to tell why you've posted at all to be honest. You're not unhappy with the situation, neither does your husband seem to be, you're unwilling to listen to anyone's posts about feeling any empathy for the kids mum, and I'm not sure we ever found out anything about what exactly that poor woman is supposed to have done other than express some displeasure that her children are being led away from her with you and your husband acting as pied pipers with your blissful, emotionally stable, 'we don't even need to ask them, they just seem to want to do chores and never eat takeaway' household.

Just so you know, children (yes, even teens) save their worst behaviours and demands for their closest attachment figure. If they act up at home with their mother, then toe the line when they spend all their time with your husband and you then actually the most likely scenario is that they feel some degree of wobbly attachment now your husband has started a new family and so are making sure to appease him, whilst taking out those complex feelings on the person they feel most comfortable with...their mum. No idea if this is the case with your situation, but it's fairly likely.

I think this is probably the best post on this thread OP - and if you only listen to one, make it this one.

Like @LoudWriter I am not really sure what you were seeking from the thread and think it is better to just focus on your baby right now.

I also agree with her take on how the boys are behaving, and I just don't think you need to be digging into it right now, other than to be aware they may be feeling a bit threatened by the new baby, even if they don't say it.

Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 19:28

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:19

That’s good to hear she is their mother she should be their safe space that’s what we all want. We’ve told them this plenty of times. He has sat down with them individually they don’t seem to want to engage in fixing this. They can’t act out forever which is why I think the novelty will wear off. They test him when they’re at their mums asking to come back saying they don’t want to be there etc and he tells them to stay what else can be done ? Surely at a point we just let them get bored as it’s an act. Everywhere else they’re acting normal, with friends at school, at sports clubs they’re still engaging in everything.

Interesting. So your stance has moved from blaming their mother to now blaming the kids? If this is what you think, why didn't you say that in your OP instead of saying she needs to accept it? It sounds like the kids need help accepting and adjusting to this and be taught respect, consideration and collaboration by example from your husband. He needs to work with their mother and support her effectively. How he does that is between them.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:28

Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 19:23

So, he hasn't outright asked them if they want to move in?
And he is happy enough with just not knowing why they say they 'wish they could just stay' or why they treat their mother like shit? That would be ringing alarm bells for me as a parent no matter their ages.

There’s more to the conversations that he’s had with then individually and together and the ones I’ve been in. I don’t have alarm bells ringing. He has asked them countless of times what they want, where they want to stay, they’re not going to say because they know it’ll upset their mum, the youngest himself said he doesn’t want to upset her but he doesn’t like being there, he has asked them why they’re acting that way, their answer is the same every single time, it has not changed, he’s the one that sorted out the counselling and everything else I think he does care about them based on what I’ve seen the last 5 years.

OP posts:
Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 19:23

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:14

He has sat then done plenty of times and asked them if there’s anything wrong, what they’re unhappy with and all they have said is they just prefer being at dads. He cannot sit then done everytime he says them to ask them why they say they’d rather be at his all the time. It’s not every single time but quite a few times when they’re about to go back home to their mums they say that they wish they could just stay here. He has sat down with them and their mum to find out what’s going on. All the relevant people that see them often have said their behaviour has not changed. Only towards their mother and he’s not sure why or how to navigate that he is trying his best but sadly it’s not working. There is only so much he can say, he’s told them countless of times that they need to also spent time with their mum, the youngest is more understanding but the older one just says why?what if I don’t want to, you can’t force me etc, they’re both grumpy at mums but when they’re here they’re not so we get different stories all the time, mum says one thing, school says they’re acting the same, grandparents say they’re the same, hockey club says they’re the same. We are confused. They’re acting the same with all of us but different at their mums.

So, he hasn't outright asked them if they want to move in?
And he is happy enough with just not knowing why they say they 'wish they could just stay' or why they treat their mother like shit? That would be ringing alarm bells for me as a parent no matter their ages.