Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?

725 replies

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 10:51

And this is one of the nicer ones. I feel like with the NHS people appreciate that the problems with the service aren’t the fault of the ground level staff, but with local authorities it seems absolutely fine to be highly abusive. People seem to be egging each other on. I think it’s disgraceful. I’m seeing it more and more.

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
EHCPerhaps · 08/11/2026 21:43

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:00

To problem is.... And I say this as a mum of three children who have been through the mill with their SEND needs (placement breakdown, severely delayed EHCPs, long wait for suitable placeme, mental health difficulties as a result etc)... Their right to provision does not out weigh someone else's right to do their job without being abused.

And I think that this is what the OP is getting at.

At what point did I say it did?!

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 21:43

SaturdayNext · 08/11/2026 21:37

Sorry, yes, I did misunderstand your post. You are right, these tales of parents demanding luxury provision are, at the very best, wildly exaggerated. I've never seen it happen either.

Choose whether you believe it or not.
All things equestrian are incredibly common in EOTAS...

But that does not fit the narrative that all SEND parents are martyrs mistreated by the evil LA.

User5667887765544331 · 08/11/2026 21:44

SaturdayNext · 08/11/2026 21:35

They don't. The problem with local authority educational psychology reports is that they are not allowed to spend enough time on them, and therefore they don't do basic stuff like cognitive tests. Sometimes they haven't even met the child but base reports purely on teachers' reports and a quick chat with the parents. Also they rarely advise on quantified and specific provision (which the law requires) because their employers don't want to have to put it into EHCPs - it makes them much to easy for parents to enforce. Because of the time constraints they quite frequently contain mistakes and misinformation.

No EP report can be undermined before a tribunal unless there is good reason to undermine it, either by demonstrating clear errors or producing other evidence which shows up the inadequacies and errors in LA reports. Tribunal panels are made up of people with expertise in SEN and SEND law, they really do expect to see evidence to justify everything that parents are asking for.

There has been a rise in tribunals principally due to the rise in bad decision making by local authorities, as demonstrated by the success rate of appeals.

Edited

This with bells on, every Ed Psych, SALT , OT etc that I have met doing private work has left the NHS and LA due to not being allowed to act in the interests of the child under their care.

User5667887765544331 · 08/11/2026 21:48

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 21:43

Choose whether you believe it or not.
All things equestrian are incredibly common in EOTAS...

But that does not fit the narrative that all SEND parents are martyrs mistreated by the evil LA.

There is a huge difference in animal therapy and “parents demanding ponies” which is what you said implying that parents are demanding pet ponies funded by the LA together with expensive private members clubs.

SaturdayNext · 08/11/2026 21:50

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 21:17

You are not grasping it.

Most LAs are at the stage of begging central government for every scrap of funding they can get for SEND.

They cannot afford to give every child the provision they require, they simply can't.

When government do give LAs grants and funding streams it is always with strings attached, 9/10 to reduce the spend. The LA have to show government that they are following their side of this.

This means that it almost works out better for a LA to be directed by tribunal on provisions and placements. Then the LA can say we did not agree this, we were directed to do this. It shows government they have attempted to reduce the spend. They know 9/10 when they will lose at tribunal, our LA has very specific signs when they are confident they will win (and usually are right on these). If they concede too early they are in the wrong in the eyes of central government for not challenging hard enough.

They need to show they are doing their utmost to follow the strings for funding or they simply will not be given anymore funding.

It is all political bollocks.

I have said repeatedly that this is an issue that is greater than even LAs. They cannot afford to follow the law for every child, they just cant.

Most LAs are at the stage of begging central government for every scrap of funding they can get for SEND.

Not true. Many LAs have very recently been happily announcing the High Needs Stability Grants they have been awarded as a pat on the head for producing SEND reform plans in compliance with the White Paper proposals which haven't even been put into the form of a proposed bill yet. They have also been given extra funding as part of those reform proposals. It's not particularly generous, and frankly if the government think it will cover the cost of the so-called reforms they are deluded, but actually LAs are currently better funded for SEND than they have been for several years.

I suspect your LA is one of those currently losing 98%+ of tribunals. So are they confident they they will only win 1% of cases? If so, why bother putting anything into defending the rest?

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 21:58

ChivesandCheeze · 08/11/2026 21:22

@Qb2654 I agree with you, this really is an issue and councils are incentivised to cut their SEND spending. However, on the flip side, you have councils spending more on defending decisions using counsel and barristers to attempt to defend decisions they can never win. I’ve seen legal counsel be used where the cost of defending surpassed the amount of provision needed, it was ludicrous. The council then lost more money by dealing with the inevitable complaints and further court cases due to their initial lack of action. They could have saved thousands by just following the law in the first place.

This is commonplace.

It may seem obscene, but these tactics do save them money. Only around 1 in 10 families challenge at all. Around half of those only do mediation. It being known an LA will use barristers tend to deter even more families. A couple of high cost placements prevented pays the barrister bill for the whole LA.

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 21:58

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 21:27

👏👏👏👏👏

I don’t know why people are sticking their fingers in their ears and saying ‘lalala we can’t hear you’

So what do you expect? That parents should simply roll over and accept that their children won't receive the support and provision they're legally entitled to? That they should just shut up, go away and get on with it?

Parents have every right to fight for their children's rights. Some parents, unfortunately, aren't in a position to fight as hard or navigate the system. Their children risk becoming another statistic, missing out on the support they desperately need and 'hooray!' also means it saves the LA money.

The real question is why is the system is so underfunded and failing so many children, not why parents are refusing to accept that failure.
Or are we really suggesting that children who don't have parents able to fight their corner should simply go without? Because that's pretty grim, no?

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 22:03

Gym and sometimes gym/swim/courts membership is common in EOTAS packages. It fulfils the role of PE/physical activity. It can also help with things such as emotional regulation, sensory differences, motor skills, accessing the community, social interaction, etc. For some DC, cheap gyms cannot provide a suitable service e.g. they may too noisy and busy, they may only offer very limited hours for children/teens, they may not offer any/many groups for children, etc. which is why some DC have more expensive gyms funded.

Providers such as specific gyms shouldn’t be named in F. Until earlier this year there was case law showing providers shouldn’t be named in F at all. Earlier this year there was some case law which showed in some cases it can be lawful to name the provider in F, although in many cases it still won’t be. This case law was about a hub at a school. It wasn’t intended for provision such a gym. So if SENDIST actually Ordered David Lloyd be named in F, rather than just a description of the provision in F, it is surprising the LA didn’t challenge the decision.

While equine assisted learning, equine assisted therapy and riding lessons are common, and not just for those with EOTAS, Ordering a pony is not.

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 22:07

SaturdayNext · 08/11/2026 21:50

Most LAs are at the stage of begging central government for every scrap of funding they can get for SEND.

Not true. Many LAs have very recently been happily announcing the High Needs Stability Grants they have been awarded as a pat on the head for producing SEND reform plans in compliance with the White Paper proposals which haven't even been put into the form of a proposed bill yet. They have also been given extra funding as part of those reform proposals. It's not particularly generous, and frankly if the government think it will cover the cost of the so-called reforms they are deluded, but actually LAs are currently better funded for SEND than they have been for several years.

I suspect your LA is one of those currently losing 98%+ of tribunals. So are they confident they they will only win 1% of cases? If so, why bother putting anything into defending the rest?

Ive literally been working on this work. The commitments LAs have had to make to get there write offs agreed was exactly the point I was making. Our LA know they have no chance in hell of meeting demand or recruiting the required professionals.

The 98% loss is a huge misleading stat. If a parent appeals section B, F and I and get even one word changed it counts as a parental win. Placement in our LA its much more around 50% parental win, and even then more and more are just named by type. Section F a parent may get a must instead of a should but none of the actual provision they want and it still counts as their win.

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 22:08

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 21:58

So what do you expect? That parents should simply roll over and accept that their children won't receive the support and provision they're legally entitled to? That they should just shut up, go away and get on with it?

Parents have every right to fight for their children's rights. Some parents, unfortunately, aren't in a position to fight as hard or navigate the system. Their children risk becoming another statistic, missing out on the support they desperately need and 'hooray!' also means it saves the LA money.

The real question is why is the system is so underfunded and failing so many children, not why parents are refusing to accept that failure.
Or are we really suggesting that children who don't have parents able to fight their corner should simply go without? Because that's pretty grim, no?

No, what to expect is what is happening. The law will be changed and it made much harder for parents.

Dreadingtheday · 08/11/2026 22:11

@Apotofrealcoffee how many people are you seeing posting this stuff?

EHCPerhaps · 08/11/2026 22:23

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 22:07

Ive literally been working on this work. The commitments LAs have had to make to get there write offs agreed was exactly the point I was making. Our LA know they have no chance in hell of meeting demand or recruiting the required professionals.

The 98% loss is a huge misleading stat. If a parent appeals section B, F and I and get even one word changed it counts as a parental win. Placement in our LA its much more around 50% parental win, and even then more and more are just named by type. Section F a parent may get a must instead of a should but none of the actual provision they want and it still counts as their win.

Can I ask, since you mentioned it. How is it better for children for the LA to increasingly just name by type in section I? These aren’t typically families who can enrol their kids to any mainstream school and find that the kids’ needs can be met there.
Why do LAs want to do that?

LottaQ · 08/11/2026 22:26

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 08/11/2026 21:30

It does terrify what other laws schools choose to ignore, if they pick and choose, due to lack of funds. Food safety in the kitchen? Fire extinguishers? MOTs for the school minibus? DBS checks for staff? It odd that people can so happily ignore the law if it applies to SEN children.

Edited

well that obviously comes down to cost, comparing DBS and Minbus MOT is a drop in the ocean to the ever growing and absolutely unsustainable cost of proving thousands of children in each borough with specialised provision.

DontLikeTheTruth · 08/11/2026 22:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DontLikeTheTruth · 08/11/2026 22:37

P.s not saying they should be mistreated. Just have more sensible amounts spent on them to reflect their limitations.

User5667887765544331 · 08/11/2026 22:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ok lets just dump them in institutions or better still
euthanize. Would that be ok for you troll?

User5667887765544331 · 08/11/2026 22:43

By the way @DontLikeTheTruth a huge cohort of doctors, scientists and engineers with brilliant minds are on the autistic spectrum.

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 22:44

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 22:08

No, what to expect is what is happening. The law will be changed and it made much harder for parents.

Making it harder for parents to secure support doesn't make children's needs disappear. It just leaves more children without the help they need. Changing the law to make challenging decisions harder isn't fixing a broken system. Children shouldn't be paying the price for failures in funding and provision, should they?

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 22:45

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 22:07

Ive literally been working on this work. The commitments LAs have had to make to get there write offs agreed was exactly the point I was making. Our LA know they have no chance in hell of meeting demand or recruiting the required professionals.

The 98% loss is a huge misleading stat. If a parent appeals section B, F and I and get even one word changed it counts as a parental win. Placement in our LA its much more around 50% parental win, and even then more and more are just named by type. Section F a parent may get a must instead of a should but none of the actual provision they want and it still counts as their win.

Which begs the question why are parents having to appeal to get a word changed from should to must at all?

DontLikeTheTruth · 08/11/2026 22:47

User5667887765544331 · 08/11/2026 22:41

Ok lets just dump them in institutions or better still
euthanize. Would that be ok for you troll?

Just because you disagree with me does not make me a troll.
I didn’t say anything about institutions or euthanasia. I said be looked after at home by their parents.

Christmasiscoming26 · 08/11/2026 22:52

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 22:45

Which begs the question why are parents having to appeal to get a word changed from should to must at all?

Because they have legal meaning. Must means Local authority legally has to do it and can be bought to account if not. Should is less onerous.

DontLikeTheTruth · 08/11/2026 22:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 22:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

If this is a genuine comment and not simply written to provoke outrage, it's absolutely disgusting.

If all children with SEN were kept at home, what happens to the jobs of teachers, teaching assistants, SEN specialists, therapists and other support staff? That's thousands of jobs potentially affected, not to mention the impact on parents having to leave employment to become full-time carers. Fewer people working, less tax revenue and greater pressure on the economy and public services.

A child's worth isn't measured by their future earning potential, and suggesting they should be excluded from education to save council money is foul.

SaturdayNext · 08/11/2026 22:58

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 22:07

Ive literally been working on this work. The commitments LAs have had to make to get there write offs agreed was exactly the point I was making. Our LA know they have no chance in hell of meeting demand or recruiting the required professionals.

The 98% loss is a huge misleading stat. If a parent appeals section B, F and I and get even one word changed it counts as a parental win. Placement in our LA its much more around 50% parental win, and even then more and more are just named by type. Section F a parent may get a must instead of a should but none of the actual provision they want and it still counts as their win.

True up to a point, but that doesn't account for the stats on refusal to assess and refusal to issue appeals, and the success rate on schools is also high - where parents only succeed in getting a type of school named it is not because the tribunal finds they have failed to prove their case, but because of the failure of governments and LAs to arrange sufficient specialist educational provision.

Additionally in my experience it is virtually impossible not to improve section F provision, because LAs habitually draft this so badly and fail to secure the right expert evidence.

User5667887765544331 · 08/11/2026 22:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Well my DS did get lego therapy and is now doing a degree apprenticeship at a blue chip tech company, harder to secure than Oxbridge. Interestingly my DH did a PHD at Cambridge and reckons most of his colleagues were on the autistic spectrum and are now either in the City or top
academics. Some of them no doubt enjoyed lego too.