Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?

725 replies

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 10:51

And this is one of the nicer ones. I feel like with the NHS people appreciate that the problems with the service aren’t the fault of the ground level staff, but with local authorities it seems absolutely fine to be highly abusive. People seem to be egging each other on. I think it’s disgraceful. I’m seeing it more and more.

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:12

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:09

This is already done routinely and has been for a very long time, since the EHCPs came in in 2014.
I'm sorry to hear you had to fight for this.

Edited

Right, so you finally acknowledge TAs/LSAs/HLTAs can be, and sometimes are, paid more (hourly rate, not because of the number of hours).

Yes, I know it can be done. Sadly, all too often it only happens when parents start down the enforcement action route.

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:14

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 18:10

My claim was that during recruitment they are often offered a wage that doesn't reflect the experience and quals needed to fulfill the role required. I then asked you if a TA with GCSEs would get paid the same as a TA trained in sign language to be a 1-1. Funnily you haven't responded. Perhaps because you know they would in fact be paid differently and this would be perfectly normal and because your claim all TAs get the paid the same is nonsense.

Edited

I missed your post. They would already been in different TA scale points due to this (TA 1/2/3 HLTA).

The sign language role would only exist in a HI base or special school anyway, and they would automatically be on one of the higher scale points to reflect this.

Qb2654 · 08/11/2026 18:15

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 17:57

How does one determine which child 'needs it more'? If they both have EHCPs indicating the need for the support of that specialist place, they both need the support of that specialist place. What makes one child more worthy than the other?

Generally there are a number of factors that are considered for prioritisation

Factors considered
Children out of education and not receiving appropriate AP
Children out of school but settled in good AP/receiving education
LAC children
Children at risk of exploitation
Children at risk of inpatient admission/higher tiers of CAMHs input
Children closest to PEX
Phase transfer ages

Two children may both have specialist agreed but it is unusual for both to be in exactly the same position circumstances wise

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:16

Roles with significantly different responsibilities and skill requirements would already sit on different scale points. (I think I have made this point about 4 times now!)

To think aggression toward local authorities is getting out of hand?
Trottersup · 08/11/2026 18:16

'I feel like with the NHS people appreciate that the problems with the service aren’t the fault of the ground level staff'

One of the reasons I left the NHS was the absolutely disgusting way patients spoke to me. Sworn at, yelled at, blamed for everything. The general public are vile.

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:16

The sign language role would only exist in a HI base or special school anyway

Not always. There are DC who use sign language who are not in an ARP or SS.

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:16

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:16

The sign language role would only exist in a HI base or special school anyway

Not always. There are DC who use sign language who are not in an ARP or SS.

It would be rare.

And they would be on an appropriate scale point (none of which are high enough for the work they do)

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 18:18

Trottersup · 08/11/2026 18:16

'I feel like with the NHS people appreciate that the problems with the service aren’t the fault of the ground level staff'

One of the reasons I left the NHS was the absolutely disgusting way patients spoke to me. Sworn at, yelled at, blamed for everything. The general public are vile.

I agree but anyone posting online saying to punch nurses in the throat, or that they’re c*nts, would not be clapped and supported.

OP posts:
hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:18

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:16

It would be rare.

And they would be on an appropriate scale point (none of which are high enough for the work they do)

Edited

It isn’t that rare.

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 18:18

CoffeeAndACroissant · 08/11/2026 18:01

Everyone you're spot on. LA worker here. We're all just sat on piles of cash in the office and spend our days coming up with more and more elaborate ways to keep you, the public, from getting hold of it.

We all go home at the end of the day celebrating our success in keeping little Joe from getting his SEN funding or Doris her care package. It's what we signed up for after all!

Well you definitely don't have to spend your day on suicide watch for Joe because the LA refuse to abide by the law that's for sure. If you're not coming up with elaborate ways to withhold funds then why do so many lie to parents telling them they're not entitled to the support the law says they are?

No one at the LA is saying 'yes Joe does need that and that yes we must provide it, but we won't due to lack of funding' do they. If that's the truth why don't you just say that instead of gaslighting families?

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:21

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:18

It isn’t that rare.

Read the rest of the post. In that scenario, the TA would already be on a scale point that reflected that.

My opinion is that all theTA scale points pay too little, but they are already differentiated by role.

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:22

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:21

Read the rest of the post. In that scenario, the TA would already be on a scale point that reflected that.

My opinion is that all theTA scale points pay too little, but they are already differentiated by role.

Reading the rest of the post doesn’t change the fact it isn’t that rare.

It also doesn’t change the fact that some TAs/LSAs/HLTAs are paid more than the figures in your post. DS3’s LSA was. I know other DC whose 1:1s are paid more than the figures you quote too. Because that is what it takes for the LA to fulfil their duties.

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 18:24

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 18:18

Well you definitely don't have to spend your day on suicide watch for Joe because the LA refuse to abide by the law that's for sure. If you're not coming up with elaborate ways to withhold funds then why do so many lie to parents telling them they're not entitled to the support the law says they are?

No one at the LA is saying 'yes Joe does need that and that yes we must provide it, but we won't due to lack of funding' do they. If that's the truth why don't you just say that instead of gaslighting families?

Because they can’t! It would be unprofessional and their jobs would be at risk. You can’t be this naive surely?!

OP posts:
BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 18:24

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 17:44

It can be done with wider and more long term damage to the SEN system as they rob Peter to pay Paul, yes. But that’s what EHCPs are being ditched now.

EHCPs aren't being ditched.

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:28

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:22

Reading the rest of the post doesn’t change the fact it isn’t that rare.

It also doesn’t change the fact that some TAs/LSAs/HLTAs are paid more than the figures in your post. DS3’s LSA was. I know other DC whose 1:1s are paid more than the figures you quote too. Because that is what it takes for the LA to fulfil their duties.

I don't know if that is an up to date payscale. I was just showing that it exists and it's structure. There are also bolt on allowances in the existing structure.

A quick Google tells me that 2 %of children with HI rely on BSL and that equates to around 700 nationally.

So even if non of them when to HI RPs or special schools, it would still be rare.
And to be honest (I say this as a mum of kids with SEND who have major struggles, and who works for the LA? Your children's right to provision doesn't out weight the right to fair pay and conditions (i.e. salary based on the nature of the role not whether a parent is kicking off about provision) of the TA workforce.

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 18:31

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 18:24

Because they can’t! It would be unprofessional and their jobs would be at risk. You can’t be this naive surely?!

And ignoring the laws you must abide by every day isn't unprofessional? But yes, we can't have someone's job at risk for not blindly following LA instructions to ignore the law. Our kids literal lives however, well who cares! What's a dead child compared to someone's job.

i imagine op has mentioned BSL as I used that as an example of where a TA would be required to have additional training.

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:32

Yes, there is a pay scale that many are on, but that doesn’t mean some aren’t paid more. Some are. Other employees pay isn’t relevant to the requirement for LAs to comply with the law. Their duty is absolute. Enforcing provision is not kicking-off.

I wasn’t talking about the absolute numbers using BSL. I was talking about the proportion of that small group that aren’t in an ARP or SS. It isn’t that rare, particularly in some areas, when you look at it as a proportion of the cohort.

BluebellBeth · 08/11/2026 18:35

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:22

Reading the rest of the post doesn’t change the fact it isn’t that rare.

It also doesn’t change the fact that some TAs/LSAs/HLTAs are paid more than the figures in your post. DS3’s LSA was. I know other DC whose 1:1s are paid more than the figures you quote too. Because that is what it takes for the LA to fulfil their duties.

Indeed. One of mine also had full time 1-1 plus someone to cover breaks. No they don't fund more hours, they funded the wages needed to secure someone with the appropriate qualifications and training required as set out in the EHCP.

i imagine op has mentioned BSL as I used it as an example of where a TA may require additional training and experience (thus pay!) vs other TAs.

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 18:40

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 17:18

There is already a payscale which reflects the different roles.

TA 1/2/3 and HLTA

The poster I was responding to was suggesting that when a school is struggling to recruit a TA they should offer more money (than the existing staff) so that they can attract candidates, not because the role has more responsibility and requires greater skills. This is what I am saying the unions would implode at.

This is what I am saying schools cannot do.

The pay (either through the burgundy book conditions or whatever a MAT has adopted instead) can only reflect the role and it's responsibility, not the recruitment market and how easy it is to hire.

And if that has been done at MAT behind the backs of loyal, long serving TAs that would definitely be a case of dodgy dealings.

I'm certainly not suggesting paying someone more for doing exactly the same job. I'm talking about different roles with different responsibilities and job descriptions.

In London, there are pay scales starting at Scale 1 and upwards that apply across various support roles (for TAs also), not just TA1/2/3 or HLTA. So it's not as black and white as you're suggesting.

And there's nothing dodgy about creating different roles or advertising them internally and allowing existing staff to apply if they have the right qualifications and experience.

Again, I agree TAs deserve better pay and recognition, but that doesn't mean schools can't create different roles to meet specific needs. Both things can be true.

Also I said mainstream school, SEN school and LA. I didn't specify MAT.

Arewethereyetarewe · 08/11/2026 18:41

I don’t think anyone should be spoken to or about in this way. Awful.

Individuals would not agree for anyone in healthcare to spoken about/to in this way. Why social care?

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:45

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:32

Yes, there is a pay scale that many are on, but that doesn’t mean some aren’t paid more. Some are. Other employees pay isn’t relevant to the requirement for LAs to comply with the law. Their duty is absolute. Enforcing provision is not kicking-off.

I wasn’t talking about the absolute numbers using BSL. I was talking about the proportion of that small group that aren’t in an ARP or SS. It isn’t that rare, particularly in some areas, when you look at it as a proportion of the cohort.

What is your point ?
That you think the LAs do have enough resources to enforce the provision for all plans and the multi million pound deficits/ shortage of places/ general crisis doesn't exist?

Or that if something is an absolute duty it can be magical delivered whether or not there are resources available to do so?

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:50

My point is TAs can and are funded at a higher rate where that is necessary to fulfil the LA’s duty. Parents don’t have to accept unlawful behaviour. They can enforce their DC’s EHCP and a lack of funding, resources, staffing, other DC with SEN not getting provision they need, other employees getting a lower rate of pay, etc. are irrelevant to the LA’s absolute and non-delegable duty to provide the SEP in F.

All DC should receive the provision in their EHCPs. All parents should be supported to enforce that. I am a firm believer in that, that is why I have supported countless parents to do just that over many years. But other DC not receiving the support they need is not the fault of those who enforce their DC’s EHCP.

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:52

PeasOff · 08/11/2026 18:40

I'm certainly not suggesting paying someone more for doing exactly the same job. I'm talking about different roles with different responsibilities and job descriptions.

In London, there are pay scales starting at Scale 1 and upwards that apply across various support roles (for TAs also), not just TA1/2/3 or HLTA. So it's not as black and white as you're suggesting.

And there's nothing dodgy about creating different roles or advertising them internally and allowing existing staff to apply if they have the right qualifications and experience.

Again, I agree TAs deserve better pay and recognition, but that doesn't mean schools can't create different roles to meet specific needs. Both things can be true.

Also I said mainstream school, SEN school and LA. I didn't specify MAT.

That wasn't what I was responding to in the post you quoted.

I was responding to a poster who suggested that schools should offer higher salaries when they are struggling to attract applicants to a role.

The implication being that this is justifiable if the result of that is that it secures a child's provision which currently can't be because of a lack of staff.

At no point had anyone suggested that support staff carrying out different roles with different levels of responsibility should not be paid differently to reflect this.

This came off the back of a discussion about the fact that even when schools are given more money by the LA for TA support, they are struggling to fill the roles because TAs pay and conditions are poor and it is difficult to attract candidates.

User5667887765544331 · 08/11/2026 18:53

CoffeeAndACroissant · 08/11/2026 18:01

Everyone you're spot on. LA worker here. We're all just sat on piles of cash in the office and spend our days coming up with more and more elaborate ways to keep you, the public, from getting hold of it.

We all go home at the end of the day celebrating our success in keeping little Joe from getting his SEN funding or Doris her care package. It's what we signed up for after all!

Well if you google Mark Small SEN lawyer he made a lucrative living out of doing just this acting on behalf of LA’s. Is it any wonder that so many SEN parents feel the way they do? I am not saying that you do this but it hardly builds a relationship when your emails and calls are constantly ignored and you have to threaten Judicial Review to get your child’s EHCP usually 6 months later than statutory timeframes.

Stressedandgrey · 08/11/2026 18:53

hibernatinghedgehog · 08/11/2026 18:50

My point is TAs can and are funded at a higher rate where that is necessary to fulfil the LA’s duty. Parents don’t have to accept unlawful behaviour. They can enforce their DC’s EHCP and a lack of funding, resources, staffing, other DC with SEN not getting provision they need, other employees getting a lower rate of pay, etc. are irrelevant to the LA’s absolute and non-delegable duty to provide the SEP in F.

All DC should receive the provision in their EHCPs. All parents should be supported to enforce that. I am a firm believer in that, that is why I have supported countless parents to do just that over many years. But other DC not receiving the support they need is not the fault of those who enforce their DC’s EHCP.

No on is disputing this is what should happen and what everyone wants. What do you think the LAs need to do, that is within their current remit, to achieve this?