Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men who watch pornography don’t respect women generally?

131 replies

RealNavyEagle · 08/11/2026 09:31

I don’t think a man can genuinely respect women while regularly consuming pornography, particularly given the objectification, degradation and exploitation of women within parts of the industry.

Can a man separate the way he views women sexually from the way he views and treats women in everyday life? Or does what he chooses to consume sexually say something about his underlying attitudes towards women?

OP posts:
TheLastSilverSaint · 08/11/2026 12:30

DaisyJohnson · 08/11/2026 12:07

On one of the major websites, around 40% of viewers are women. There are a lot of different types of porn. Some are unquestionably abusive. Some are a husband and wife filming themselves having romantic and gentle sex - there's a lot of that online, too, not just the degrading stuff.

If we assume that all people who watch porn are bad regardless of what type they're watching, we're just descending further into the kind of puritanical attitude that puts people off from actually listening to us.

Absolutely this.

There are obviously some appalling types of porn out there and some of it is unquestionably dangerous and misogynistic and exploitative. But there are a hell of a lot of people on Mumsnet who have a hugely skewed and inaccurate notion of what porn actually encompasses. For example, I often see people insisting on here that ‘most porn shows women being strangled’ which is just wildly inaccurate. I don’t think any porn should include anyone being strangled, and I’m pleased it’s now illegal in the UK. But it’s not a reason to ban all porn.

There are absolutely concerns to be raised and addressed about porn and its availability and production, but wild hyperbole and spreading disinformation will not help to deal with those problems. At all.

And yes, loads of women watch porn.

Anyway. I personally don’t believe that all men who watch porn lack respect for women. It’s certainly not my experience, or the experience of other women I’ve discussed the issue with in real life. I also think that men who don’t watch porn are no more likely to respect women than those who do.

In general, there are some issues on which the prevailing - or at least, the most expressed - view on Mumsnet is very out of step and a lot more extreme than the prevailing view of women in the wider population. Porn is one of them. Transgender issues are another. I suspect ‘screens’ and UPF are also in that category.

BlueSherbet · 08/11/2026 12:29

RealNavyEagle · 08/11/2026 09:31

I don’t think a man can genuinely respect women while regularly consuming pornography, particularly given the objectification, degradation and exploitation of women within parts of the industry.

Can a man separate the way he views women sexually from the way he views and treats women in everyday life? Or does what he chooses to consume sexually say something about his underlying attitudes towards women?

Yes I tend to agree, pornography will obviously affect how its users view others and view sex.

Like drugs, pornography seems to require to constantly get "harder" (no pun intended) to maintain the same thrill. This seems to be why it becomes degrading or even violent.

I would support pornography being banned. It seems to have become largely unrestricted around the time when protestant christianity collapsed in the UK, but what good has it ever done? Nothing.

Im led to believe some women watch it too, and certainly many women have done well financially out of participating in it, though you wonder at what personal cost.

I dont think its ever a benign thing. People are objectified and sex is portrayed as a consequence-free toy.

While some people do well financially from it, its never going to be a major pillar of the economy and so there is obviously some other agenda why it should be legal and ubiquitous. Maybe as some kind of pacifier, distraction, drug for people?

I have daughters and its very concerning to think they could meet a guy whose attitudes have been formed by pornography, or even (less likely) that they could see these celebrity women becoming rich off porn and even be attracted to that.

We should ban it.

DaisyJohnson · 08/11/2026 12:07

On one of the major websites, around 40% of viewers are women. There are a lot of different types of porn. Some are unquestionably abusive. Some are a husband and wife filming themselves having romantic and gentle sex - there's a lot of that online, too, not just the degrading stuff.

If we assume that all people who watch porn are bad regardless of what type they're watching, we're just descending further into the kind of puritanical attitude that puts people off from actually listening to us.

ginasevern · 08/11/2026 11:52

You're assuming that most men respect women anyway. I personally don't think they do. And given that the majority of men watch porn on some level, it kind of speaks for itself.

cariadlet · 08/11/2026 10:38

Men who enjoy watching pornography but claim to love women remind me of pet owning meat eaters who claim to be animal lovers.

They manage to compartmentalise, to separate the individuals they care about (wives, daughters, mothers, pets) from the wider, exploited class (women and animals).

They don't want their enjoyment to be sullied by an examination of an industry which provides bodies for their enjoyment.

The inherent degradation of pornography has become increasingly forefront and mainstream since the advent of the Internet. It both reflects men's attitudes to women and helps to shape them.

Anyone who thinks it's possible to use pornography and still respect women should read Pornocracy by Jo Bartosch and Rob Jessell.

RealNavyEagle · 08/11/2026 10:29

RJMacReady · 08/11/2026 10:20

They'll tell you everyone does it; it's totally normal and it doesn't affect their view of women. I wonder how they would feel if their daughter started working in the porn industry? Then you would see their true feelings about it!
They actually hate the women they see in porn - if they didn't then how could they stand to watch them be abused like that? To be aroused by it?

I agree with your point about how some men might react if their own daughter entered the pornography industry. It raises the question of why certain men might be comfortable consuming and deriving pleasure from material involving women they would never want a woman they personally care about to participate in. There’s also a double standard there, where women are considered deserving of dignity and protection when they’re someone’s daughter, wife or sister, but that same consideration doesn’t necessarily extend to the women they’re watching.

I also find the argument that porn is simply normal and therefore harmless rather unconvincing. Something being widespread doesn’t automatically make it ethically unproblematic.

OP posts:
sprigatito · 08/11/2026 10:28

Of course men who consume porn don’t and can’t respect women. The reason there is always so much defensive pushback against that observation is simple: it lays bare the truth that the vast majority of ordinary, unremarkable men are misogynists who see women as a commodity.

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 10:26

baileys6904 · 08/11/2026 10:14

Depends what you mean as porn, doesn't it.

Theres plenty of porn thats just sex. To demonise watching that is ridiculous and at danger of sending women back to the "you must not enjoy sex, you must just endure it, with all the atrocities that brings.

The you look at the 50 shades phenomenon (not my thing but certainly many women bought into that one). But why should women not enjoy it?

Then if women can enjoy that, do we villify then for it too. And what gives us the right to judge what people enjoy if its consensual and legal

"Just sex" could still be rape due to an actor being coerced or pressured, and you'd never know. Do you like maybe getting off to rape?

I don't know what watching two strangers having sex (potentially rape) on a screen has to do with you enjoying actually having sex with a partner? The two seem completely unrelated.

RJMacReady · 08/11/2026 10:20

They'll tell you everyone does it; it's totally normal and it doesn't affect their view of women. I wonder how they would feel if their daughter started working in the porn industry? Then you would see their true feelings about it!
They actually hate the women they see in porn - if they didn't then how could they stand to watch them be abused like that? To be aroused by it?

baileys6904 · 08/11/2026 10:14

Depends what you mean as porn, doesn't it.

Theres plenty of porn thats just sex. To demonise watching that is ridiculous and at danger of sending women back to the "you must not enjoy sex, you must just endure it, with all the atrocities that brings.

The you look at the 50 shades phenomenon (not my thing but certainly many women bought into that one). But why should women not enjoy it?

Then if women can enjoy that, do we villify then for it too. And what gives us the right to judge what people enjoy if its consensual and legal

RealNavyEagle · 08/11/2026 10:14

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 08/11/2026 10:08

How can his porn use and sexual preferences NOT go hand in hand with his day to day attitudes towards women? Ultimately seeing women just as sexual objects is bound to be reflected in his everyday interactions and attitudes.

Exactly. I think people sometimes conflate treating women politely in everyday interactions with genuinely respecting women as human beings.

A man can outwardly behave respectfully towards women while privately consuming material that reduces them to sexual objects. I don’t think those two things are necessarily incompatible in practice but I do question whether that outward behaviour reflects genuine respect. It’s difficult to believe someone’s attitudes towards women in a sexual context exist in complete isolation from their broader perceptions of women.

OP posts:
Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 08/11/2026 10:08

RealNavyEagle · 08/11/2026 09:45

Yeah, it’s a contradiction. If a man derives sexual gratification from watching women being degraded, humiliated or subjected to violence, I struggle to see how that can be reconciled with genuinely respecting women.

What I find particularly interesting is how readily people accept the idea that a man’s sexual preferences and consumption habits exist entirely separately from his broader attitudes towards women. I’m not convinced that distinction is as clear-cut as some would like to believe.

How can his porn use and sexual preferences NOT go hand in hand with his day to day attitudes towards women? Ultimately seeing women just as sexual objects is bound to be reflected in his everyday interactions and attitudes.

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 10:06

81Claire81 · 08/11/2026 09:51

I don't watch it, but there's probably women out there that watch it, not just men. How does it reflect on them?

Poorly. Internalised misogyny is an ugly thing.

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 10:03

RealNavyEagle · 08/11/2026 09:45

Yeah, it’s a contradiction. If a man derives sexual gratification from watching women being degraded, humiliated or subjected to violence, I struggle to see how that can be reconciled with genuinely respecting women.

What I find particularly interesting is how readily people accept the idea that a man’s sexual preferences and consumption habits exist entirely separately from his broader attitudes towards women. I’m not convinced that distinction is as clear-cut as some would like to believe.

Yes, it's strange. If, for instance, a man liked watching dog fights, I think most people would find it quite difficult to believe he respected dogs.

RealNavyEagle · 08/11/2026 09:56

81Claire81 · 08/11/2026 09:51

I don't watch it, but there's probably women out there that watch it, not just men. How does it reflect on them?

Women consuming pornography raises questions about their attitudes towards women too, particularly where the material involves objectification, degradation or exploitation. I don’t think being a woman automatically makes someone immune to internalised misogyny or incapable of participating in the objectification of other women.

However, my question is specifically about men and whether their sexual consumption habits reflect their broader attitudes towards women. The fact that some women watch pornography doesn’t really address that question.

OP posts:
MarysSilverBells · 08/11/2026 09:56

The problem with porn is that nobody knows if what they are watching is truly consensual or if (and seemingly much more likely) it involves trafficked or coerced women who have no real choice. To me this means that no porn is 'good' porn. Porn-watching men don't seem to care either way, so no, of course they don't see the women they're watching, and by extension all women, as equal.

Mischance · 08/11/2026 09:53

What I find particularly interesting is how readily people accept the idea that a man’s sexual preferences and consumption habits exist entirely separately from his broader attitudes towards women. I’m not convinced that distinction is as clear-cut as some would like to believe.

I don't think the distinction exists at all - if they are prepared to see women degraded then they have a faulty attitude to women - end of.

If you ask them if they would want their own DDs to be involved they would be horrified, but are prepared not to be horrified on behalf of someone else's. That tells you all he needs to know about their attitude to women - prepared to objectify some and treat them as lesser being, unworthy of respect.

Porn is so destructive in every way - of those involved and those who watch.

81Claire81 · 08/11/2026 09:51

I don't watch it, but there's probably women out there that watch it, not just men. How does it reflect on them?

Ilikethatusername · 08/11/2026 09:50

You. Again.

Get a hobby

MightyGoldBear · 08/11/2026 09:48

Yes I agree and my husband agrees too. I think most men if truly honest and willing to accept the uncomfortable truth would also agree. There is the separation they don't want the woman they Care for or benefit from to "be like woman in porn" i think if they really examined that they would agree. Even that double standard isn't born out of respect for "their" women but control.

Hugasaurusrex · 08/11/2026 09:47

I don’t think all men use porn but I think nearly all men do.

I think all men have grown up in a very misogynistic culture and that has affected all men to a great or lesser degree but all men are impacted.

I think both of the above issues affect each other for sure.

I hate porn, it is degrading to women.

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 09:45

AlertCat · 08/11/2026 09:42

No. As I said above.

But my DP is unusual in other respects too, the main one being that he sees women as people just as much as men. Most men I’ve known (certainly most young men; some older ones with long marriages have been more like my DP maybe because they’ve spent their lives with a woman) don’t see women as people of the same personhood as they see men. Once I understood that, it explained everything to me. Patriarchy is like racism; it relies on the oppressed group to be seen as lesser.

This is very much my experience too.

RealNavyEagle · 08/11/2026 09:45

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 08/11/2026 09:40

Of course they don't respect women.
The majority of porn includes violence and humiliation of women.
How could a man who respects women get gratification from seeing women abused and degraded?
Imo men who use porn are overwhelmongly misogynists.

Edited

Yeah, it’s a contradiction. If a man derives sexual gratification from watching women being degraded, humiliated or subjected to violence, I struggle to see how that can be reconciled with genuinely respecting women.

What I find particularly interesting is how readily people accept the idea that a man’s sexual preferences and consumption habits exist entirely separately from his broader attitudes towards women. I’m not convinced that distinction is as clear-cut as some would like to believe.

OP posts:
AlertCat · 08/11/2026 09:42

Fleetheart · 08/11/2026 09:36

I do think they all do it. Don’t you?

No. As I said above.

But my DP is unusual in other respects too, the main one being that he sees women as people just as much as men. Most men I’ve known (certainly most young men; some older ones with long marriages have been more like my DP maybe because they’ve spent their lives with a woman) don’t see women as people of the same personhood as they see men. Once I understood that, it explained everything to me. Patriarchy is like racism; it relies on the oppressed group to be seen as lesser.

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 08/11/2026 09:40

Of course they don't respect women.
The majority of porn includes violence and humiliation of women.
How could a man who respects women get gratification from seeing women abused and degraded?
Imo men who use porn are overwhelmongly misogynists.