Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents faking poverty and not buying dc gifts

338 replies

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 08:17

for some reason approx 6 years ago my parents decided to stop all gifts for birthday Easter and Christmas. They said they just didn’t have the money to do them for the GC. Fine.

Excpet it’s 1. Not true that they can’t afford it and 2. They still buy gifts etc for both my sisters dc???

Everytime I go to see them they openly show me expensive new things, tell me about the cruises and holidays booked and talk finances (positively) then in the same visit they’ll say they have no money so sorry there’s no cake to have with coffee and reiterate that’s why they don’t do gifts anymore???

I have found out that they have still given gifts to all their other GC (I have 2 sisters) and I’m shocked ? When I asked them about it all they said they would not be speaking to me anymore as I was ‘money grabbing’ ? They haven’t spoken to me for 3 months now.

We hadn’t fallen out prior to this I genuinely believed when they first started this that they had just decided no more gifts ? I have 2 dc, my sisters have 6 between them.

OP posts:
riceuten · 08/11/2026 16:05

I'd be cutting contact to a minimum personally. There's obviously some kind of prejudice involved, and life's too short to play their pathetic games.

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:04

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:58

Clearly the relationship with the sisters is also awful otherwise she’d have surely known at some point in the last 6 years about the chairman’s present situation. Obviously there is an enormous amount of information missing

Chairman should read Christmas!!

AnotherAnnie · 08/11/2026 16:03

Junglejune · 08/11/2026 15:19

It absolutely does the opposite of protecting the kids. You seem to think children aren’t sentient beings who notice things. They most certainly are and they will see how they and their mum are treated differently to their aunts and cousins. That is definitely not healthy.

My suggestion was to accept the low contact the parents have already imposed, not to expose the children to that toxicity. I apologise that it wasn't well expressed.

My experience as a parent was that children do what they see, particularly when they become adults. Showing them massive family dust ups and teaching them that it is a thing to disown people can become a rod for our own backs. I am suggesting taking the controls away from the toxic family and quietly setting the terms.

By showing strength and kindness in adversity, we are helping children become resilient. If they grow up to be graceful while preserving their own space the kids might be better prepared for adult life.

In the US, the cultural mores can be very different. In much of the UK reciprocity can be complex. Even returned presents may create a trail of caring sometimes. In the UK, trying to force someone to face how they have hurt you may be surprisingly counterproductive. My dad said people become what we tell them they are.

Perimama · 08/11/2026 16:03

I'm sorry OP. What a horrible way to be treated by your parents.

CurtainTV · 08/11/2026 15:59

C8H10N4O2 · 08/11/2026 15:26

If someone took out my children in my car and found it needed petrol then I would offer to reimburse them even if they declined my offer.

I find it odd to hear someone talk about relationships entirely as financial transaction measures. The OP has mentioned nothing about any other aspect of relationships but has dropped in several non-relevant points guaranteed to create a negative impression of the parents.

I know this is MN where every grandparent is a Reform voting millionaire going on 25 cruises a year whilst stealing their children's blood but IME its rare, even on here, to hear someone talk about a relationship so completely and solely in terms of relative financial benefits.

But the car didn’t need petrol 🤯 ; the number of people on MN who struggle with comprehension just baffles me.

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:58

Soreenmaltloaf23 · 08/11/2026 15:48

You still haven't said what your relationship with your sisters is like away from your parents. What do they say when you ask them what this is all about? Why are you not included? Surely they might give you some idea.

Clearly the relationship with the sisters is also awful otherwise she’d have surely known at some point in the last 6 years about the chairman’s present situation. Obviously there is an enormous amount of information missing

TigerJoy · 08/11/2026 15:55

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 08:42

Yes but I think because I’m the oldest by 10 years so it always felt different as they were so much younger than me

Reading your post i wanted to ask if you were the eldest

Nothing as extreme as you, but ive been treated differently by my parents with money, and Im the eldest.

All other siblings given more in house deposits (that hurt). No wedding present. It's odd. Ive also been the one to earn the least, single for most of my adult life (only one to buy a property alone, yet siblings "needed" it more).

In my case my mum acts like my sister sometimes.

I think you won't get a straight answer out of your parents, and it's not really about money.

I feel really sorry for your kids, but i don't think you can change them.

I recommend therapy. Just try and get it sorted in your head, and understanding it will hopefully take a bit of the sting out of it

Seajaye · 08/11/2026 15:55

I can understand how the inequality hurts more than the lack of gifts . But how old the the grandchildren? My parents, dispite being comfortably off, stopped buying gifts for birthday for all grandchildren when they reached 18, so on the face of it there were years when some grandchildren got gifts and others didn't. It's was a bit brutal but at 18 my children accepted the situation and as they only spent about £10.00 each gift it wasn't really a big deal to the children..

It was simply that my parents had never been big gift givers in their own families or to each other, or for us as children. All gifts to use as children were modest and all stopped at age 18, which relieved my mother of the burden of getting gifts

I still buy a gift for my mother as I feel I shouldn't let any mean spirited tendancies affect me. She still tells me off for buying my adult children gifts as if her way is the right way to treat people. .

Soreenmaltloaf23 · 08/11/2026 15:48

You still haven't said what your relationship with your sisters is like away from your parents. What do they say when you ask them what this is all about? Why are you not included? Surely they might give you some idea.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 08/11/2026 15:47

C8H10N4O2 · 08/11/2026 15:26

If someone took out my children in my car and found it needed petrol then I would offer to reimburse them even if they declined my offer.

I find it odd to hear someone talk about relationships entirely as financial transaction measures. The OP has mentioned nothing about any other aspect of relationships but has dropped in several non-relevant points guaranteed to create a negative impression of the parents.

I know this is MN where every grandparent is a Reform voting millionaire going on 25 cruises a year whilst stealing their children's blood but IME its rare, even on here, to hear someone talk about a relationship so completely and solely in terms of relative financial benefits.

Firstly the car DID NOT need petrol, it was half tank but her dad prefers it full tank so he decided to top it up.

He had his own car and asked to use OPs car because it was bigger. She never asked him to take the kids out, he offered.

Secondly it is very very very cheap and tightfisted as a grandparent to offer to take your grandchildren on a day out then send an invoice for petrol to your daughter especially when they can obviously afford it with all their cruises etc.

Again OP did not ask them to take the kids out, they offered to take them out then asked if they can use OPs car instead of their own car.

Sending an invoice to your own daughter for petrol to take your own grandchildren out of absolutely stingy and cheap. I can understand if they couldn't afford it but that's not rey case here and OP did not ask them or demand that they take the kids out or even ask that they refill her tank. If he returned the card quarter tank OP would probably have moved on not send an invoice to him to get it back to half tank.

Frankly good riddance, they sound like horrible people who don't see anything wrong treating not only their children but grandchildren differently. Really they are too poor to buy a birthday present for their grandchildren yet they continue to buy for the others. They are too poor to offer cake with tea yet continue to post pictures on social media of tea with cake with their other daughters and you are trying to justify all this because of the petrol situation.

If OP paid for the petrol are you saying every thing else that'd happening is ok because you seem to be focusing on the petrol situation.

Rhaidimiddim · 08/11/2026 15:45

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 08:42

Yes but I think because I’m the oldest by 10 years so it always felt different as they were so much younger than me

This provides an interesting insight. You and your sisters would have been raised almost as two separate families.i've seen this them-and-us dynamic in the children in my blended family, but they outgrew it.

I think they've ganged up and are pressuring your parents to squeeze you out.

You need to think how this toxic situation is affecting your children andvthen do what you can to mitigate it.

You also need to give serious thought to how you navigate the decline of your parents into their old age. I expect you have already been written out of any will. But how are you going to handle a situation where your sisters expect you to contribute time or money for care ( and configure it between them so that you bear an unfair share of the burden)?

Personally, I'd tell them all to do one. I hope you don't buy presents forvany of them!

C8H10N4O2 · 08/11/2026 15:44

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:33

The poster has a point insofar as the OP presents her parents as unequivocally from root to tip awful people.

and yet… has been very happy leaving her children alone with them

Yes, its rare for people to be quite so one dimensional. Its also not me equating love with money here:

Buying gifts for some GC and not others has nothing to do with money. It's about effort, love, inclusion and fairness

Since the OP has only talked about money we have no idea what effort, love and inclusion the DGPs show in other ways. I disagree with the premise that you can't show love without spending money and ensuring that money is equal to the last penny.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/11/2026 15:40

Ncagainagainandagain · 08/11/2026 14:55

I take my grandchildren out regularly FOR my daughter and other times for my enjoyment but I would never ask for any costs to be covered! Pretty sure that’s the case for everyone I know 🤷‍♀️Fair enough if they are struggling financially but OP parents don’t sound if they are short of a few quid!
OP ,I personally would have it out with them because you have nothing to lose.

The OP hasn't said they are struggling either.

I don't ask for costs to be covered if I do anything for/with DGC but DC offer if its at their request. When my DP did stuff with DC to help us I would offer costs and they would usually decline just as I do. However neither we nor our children have ever taken it for granted as an entitlement. However I know families where they do things a bit differently financially. Every family is a bit different.
The OP has stressed her parents are not short of money (the MN cruise, sibling house deposits) but OTOH there is nothing in the posts to suggest the OP is short of money either.

The OP has said nothing about the emotional relationships, time spent together, whether the GDC enjoy time with their DGPs, whether they support in non financial ways - the only point of discussion here is how much money they spend on the OP's family. I find that an odd way to describe a relationship.

If there was an unexpected change in a relationship at a point in time I would normally suggest be direct and ask about it but we know nothing about this relationship beyond money.

Allseeingallknowing · 08/11/2026 15:37

Boomer55 · 08/11/2026 15:33

Best treat all kids and grandchildren the same. 😉

Yes, that really helps the OP!

Ponderingwindow · 08/11/2026 15:34

My father made a big statement about cutting off the flow of gifts for his ungrateful grandchildren now that they were 18. They weren’t. He claimed they were bleeding him dry. They weren’t. He has millions.

My sister and I just rolled our eyes and got on with our lives. It helps that this is standard behavior for him, he is an equal offender, and we have one another for support.

I’m telling you about this only slightly related story because we did manage to figure out the trigger. My father was still mad at my sister for disagreeing with him during a discussion about taxes. She took the position that we are economically privileged and should be paying our share. He was so offended that she thought he should pay taxes and that she was willing to pay taxes, that he disparaged all his progeny both in that moment and in perpetuity.

Just a conversation about being responsible members of society. He is a narcissist. I suspect your parents have their own problems and this is just one in a long line of problems you have with them. You have to get to the point where you just learn to roll your eyes at them.

TheVelvetCell · 08/11/2026 15:34

The cake comment is truly bizarre. Despite hard times, the vast majority of people can afford a supermarket cake, and certainly people with nice houses and going on cruises can. How can they say this with a straight face?

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:33

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · 08/11/2026 15:31

Stop talking bollocks.

Buying gifts for some GC and not others has nothing to do with money. It's about effort, love, inclusion and fairness. Even if they were fab parents in every other way this would be cruel and strange.

Yet the parents are saying it's because they're skint - so money IS relevant here.

The poster has a point insofar as the OP presents her parents as unequivocally from root to tip awful people.

and yet… has been very happy leaving her children alone with them

Boomer55 · 08/11/2026 15:33

Best treat all kids and grandchildren the same. 😉

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · 08/11/2026 15:31

C8H10N4O2 · 08/11/2026 15:26

If someone took out my children in my car and found it needed petrol then I would offer to reimburse them even if they declined my offer.

I find it odd to hear someone talk about relationships entirely as financial transaction measures. The OP has mentioned nothing about any other aspect of relationships but has dropped in several non-relevant points guaranteed to create a negative impression of the parents.

I know this is MN where every grandparent is a Reform voting millionaire going on 25 cruises a year whilst stealing their children's blood but IME its rare, even on here, to hear someone talk about a relationship so completely and solely in terms of relative financial benefits.

Stop talking bollocks.

Buying gifts for some GC and not others has nothing to do with money. It's about effort, love, inclusion and fairness. Even if they were fab parents in every other way this would be cruel and strange.

Yet the parents are saying it's because they're skint - so money IS relevant here.

diddl · 08/11/2026 15:29

As you insist on continuing to hurt me, I'm going to remove myself. Bye.

They probably wouldn't care but would probably complain that you no longer see them & they have no idea why.

hattie43 · 08/11/2026 15:28

Your parents are very odd : grim and I think I’d take my kids away from that environment. How are they supposed to process that when they realise their cousins all had gifts but they didn’t .

C8H10N4O2 · 08/11/2026 15:26

CurtainTV · 08/11/2026 14:36

She didn’t want petrol put in the car. Are you happy for people to buy things on your behalf that you didn’t ask for, and demand money back? That’s odd.

If someone took out my children in my car and found it needed petrol then I would offer to reimburse them even if they declined my offer.

I find it odd to hear someone talk about relationships entirely as financial transaction measures. The OP has mentioned nothing about any other aspect of relationships but has dropped in several non-relevant points guaranteed to create a negative impression of the parents.

I know this is MN where every grandparent is a Reform voting millionaire going on 25 cruises a year whilst stealing their children's blood but IME its rare, even on here, to hear someone talk about a relationship so completely and solely in terms of relative financial benefits.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 08/11/2026 15:26

I think this is an entrenched family fanatic that the OP is only now seeing properly as it has started affecting her children. In a healthy family, if one person accused another of money grabbing because they questioned why their kids were the only ones left out, the others would not get involved / try and sort it out / at least ask some questions to try and make sense of it. The fact the sisters have just completely cut off contact at the same time on the basis of what their mum told them, without hearing the OPs side, suggests that ganging up on the OP is something they're used to and happy with.

Once you realise that, its very difficult to go back. I'd seriously consider cutting them off. Someone who can treat their grandkids like that just aren't worth bothering with, even if they're family.

It wasn't that your sisters had their first children around then was it? So yours were sidelined?

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:25

PinkyFlamingo · 08/11/2026 15:23

You keep saying you're confused, but whatever the reason you and your children are being treated differently and ate unlikely to find out why. I would not expose my childten to this at all.

This Op seems happy to use them for childcare. All so strange

PinkyFlamingo · 08/11/2026 15:23

You keep saying you're confused, but whatever the reason you and your children are being treated differently and ate unlikely to find out why. I would not expose my childten to this at all.