Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents faking poverty and not buying dc gifts

338 replies

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 08:17

for some reason approx 6 years ago my parents decided to stop all gifts for birthday Easter and Christmas. They said they just didn’t have the money to do them for the GC. Fine.

Excpet it’s 1. Not true that they can’t afford it and 2. They still buy gifts etc for both my sisters dc???

Everytime I go to see them they openly show me expensive new things, tell me about the cruises and holidays booked and talk finances (positively) then in the same visit they’ll say they have no money so sorry there’s no cake to have with coffee and reiterate that’s why they don’t do gifts anymore???

I have found out that they have still given gifts to all their other GC (I have 2 sisters) and I’m shocked ? When I asked them about it all they said they would not be speaking to me anymore as I was ‘money grabbing’ ? They haven’t spoken to me for 3 months now.

We hadn’t fallen out prior to this I genuinely believed when they first started this that they had just decided no more gifts ? I have 2 dc, my sisters have 6 between them.

OP posts:
watchingthishtread · 08/11/2026 22:11

So something changed 6 years ago that made them act like they think you have lots of money compared to them.

Could there be a future inheritance coming your way from another relative that they found out about and are not happy about?

Do your inlaws have a lot of money or give the impression of having a lot of money?

Could they be under the misguided impression that you won the lottery or somehow came into money that they think you're keeping hidden from them?

There is a misunderstanding of some sort behind it. The way that they have handled is so awful that I think your kids might be better off without their influence anyway.

AutumnLover1999 · 08/11/2026 21:42

To be honest the ages of children is irrelevant. I'd be focusing on finding out why op is being excluded in everything and the real reason they couldn't even afford a cheap cake or a packet of biscuits, and feigned shock saying I didn't know things were financially bad for them? Why is that? Too many holidays? 🙄😁

Bellie710 · 08/11/2026 21:22

What age are the children?

rainingsnoring · 08/11/2026 21:13

localnotail · 08/11/2026 20:48

Whatever reasons everyone is trying to come up with make no sense as if there was a valid reason, Op's parents could have told her that! instead, they weirdly lie. Which makes me think they themselves know their reason is bonkers and they prefer to hide it.

Exactly. A normal, functional family would have communicated, not played favourites in such a hurtful way, even to the extent of involving the grandchildren, and pitting the sisters against each other.
I think this has been a long standing dynamic and the OP has only really noticed it since having her own DC. She is better off far away from them!

localnotail · 08/11/2026 20:48

Whatever reasons everyone is trying to come up with make no sense as if there was a valid reason, Op's parents could have told her that! instead, they weirdly lie. Which makes me think they themselves know their reason is bonkers and they prefer to hide it.

Saddaughter999 · 08/11/2026 20:29

localnotail · 08/11/2026 09:02

WTF did I just read...

I could write a book about my ex husband's family. Weirdest people on planet earth 😁

rainingsnoring · 08/11/2026 19:57

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:49

The previous 6 years since petrol-gate

Where does it say that they provide regular childcare for the OP? They took the DC out on ONE occasion and then presented her with an invoice because they decided to fill up her car with petrol, despite it being unnecessary.

JuliaAgrippina · 08/11/2026 18:11

It sounds like a family label they've applied at some point - you care about money so best to withold it. No logic will impact it.

The other option is 6 years ago another relative -sister started- stiring - and this is the result.

Most likley this is a long standing pattern who notcie much more as it's your kids afffected - we tend to have great tolerance when it's ourselves and make more excuses.

I suspect your kids already know they are not favour DGC- I think less they are in their orbit and that shoved in their faces better TBH. It's partly why I was pleased to move away from my family - it's a fact that has little impact on them - less so than us - me and siblings - who got to hear about it every week.

CatSquirrelDuck · 08/11/2026 17:36

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 08:58

I think so because I do feel I look a bit like my dad ! I asked once about the big age gap as my sisters have just 2 years between them and I got told not to ask about people’s medical history !

Edited

Can you quietly do a DNA test? People see what they want to see; doesn't mean it's actually 'there' ... and this could explain the differential treatment. Which is horrible by the way. Your parents are awful, and so are your siblings for enjoying their side of it.

PigletJohn · 08/11/2026 17:35

You might consider entertaining yourself by taking a cake every time you go, and loudly saying "you told me you couldn't afford cake so I've brought you one. "

Especially in front of other visitors.

Retrogamer · 08/11/2026 17:27

This is sad, I understand why this would be hurtful. Do you think one of your sisters may have said some untruths about you? I agree with PP in that you need to directly ask them what has happened 6 years ago. Call them up and ask on the spot.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 08/11/2026 17:14

Ive seen families exactly like this.

The question you have to ask yourself is
"Do I need to keep going back for more of the same?"

You asked them what was going on and instead of telling you, the accused you of being money grabbing. They will never change. I was sad to read that your sisters are also following suit.

Sad though it is for you @FakeFinances they have been out of contact to punish you (for pointing out that they were punishing your DC) for the last three months. Don't chase them. Don't keep going back for more.

Spend the money you would have spent on them this Christmas on YOUR DC... make it up to them. I wouldn't tell them too much but make your own family traditions. You might find it a comfort to reflect on the fact that YOU would never treat your children like that, so you are a much better parent than they ever had been .

Let's face it, they know this behaviour is unpleasant. Its consciously unequal. Probably gives them bit of a kick to inflict that kind of hurt.
You don't need this in your life. You have your DH and your DC that's the most important thing in the world to focus on .
Life is too short to let people keep hurting you like this. Spend time with people who treat you well.

Marieb19 · 08/11/2026 17:12

I'm sorry you are being treated this way by your family. I would be removing myself from their orbit and building other social groups for you and your children. I would also suggest that as your parents have instigated a no gifts regime, that should be reciprocal.

Friendlygingercat · 08/11/2026 17:10

If your parents no longer speak to you then you may have dodged a bullet. Be sure they will come whingeing when they need you.

Parents who treat their children unequally will eventually reap what they sow.

When I was in my 20s my sister had already given birth to two boys whereas I had made it clear that I never intended to have children. My parents announced openly that as she had "given" them two grandchildren 2/3 of the estate was going to her. They did say that they would alter their will if I "changed my mind" and had a child.

In other words a woman is only of value as a breeder. Yeah, right.

I never changed my mind or wanted a child. Of course my parents were at liberty to leave most of their estate to the golden princess. The result was that I gradually withdrew from them, went to live in another city, and was very difficult to contact when family emergencies arose.

WhereYouLeftIt · 08/11/2026 17:07

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 14:03

I’m 99.9% sure he’s my dad as I look like him !
I can’t think of anything (except Covid) that happened 6 years ago.

Since you're sure your dad is your dad - how sure are you that your mum is your mum? Or does your dad have a brother/cousin?

It does sound as if you have always been treated differently - the family Scapegoat. Children being scapegoated often goes hand in hand with a parent who is a narcissist.

Are your grandparents still alive? Any aunts and uncles you could ask questions of?

Newkicks · 08/11/2026 17:04

This is awful, i'm sorry your family are treating you so badly!

MoodyMargaret11 · 08/11/2026 16:50

OP, your parents are ENTIRELY in the wrong here, regardless of their "reasons". They must know this, surely as they are effectively taking it out on their grandchildren, who they supposedly love and care about?
I know PPs have been asking what you "could have done" etc. But I'm wondering if they may have something against your children instead... Maybe they dont like how they behave or things they've said, or resent looking after them?
Again, completely horrible and wrong, but just throwing it in for consideration.

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:49

AutumnLover1999 · 08/11/2026 16:48

I don't see that as the op says she hadn't heard from her parents in a while,3 months wasn't it?

The previous 6 years since petrol-gate

AutumnLover1999 · 08/11/2026 16:48

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:25

This Op seems happy to use them for childcare. All so strange

I don't see that as the op says she hadn't heard from her parents in a while,3 months wasn't it?

MoodyMargaret11 · 08/11/2026 16:41

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:33

The poster has a point insofar as the OP presents her parents as unequivocally from root to tip awful people.

and yet… has been very happy leaving her children alone with them

Family relationships are complex, in case you didnt know. What a horrible comment.
OP clearly struggles with the dynamics, but I'm guessing was trying to keep the peace still and to do what she thought was best for her children - not deprive them from their grandparents. There was no indication her parents were unkind as grandparents, until 6 yrs ago when they started excluding OPs children.

Uricon2 · 08/11/2026 16:28

However the OP has only talked in terms of monetary relationship and that is only one factor and probably the least important when it comes to family relationships. You can have a great relationship with children and grandchildren without money (except on MN where its a dominating factor) - we have heard nothing about the other aspects of their relationships with the GDC or DC, only the monetary relationship.

It isn't about the money itself I don't think but the inequity, especially as shown to OPs children. That isn't OK. No grandchildren get presents, fine (if TBH odd) Selected grandchildren get presents in a situation where there is (was) no estrangement? What parent isn't going to be upset by that when it involves their kids?

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:24

AnotherAnnie · 08/11/2026 16:18

TLDR; be kind so your kids might learn to be, and dont let cruel people control the narrative people will uncover later. If in the UK,

sorry for edits, dyslexic and really working hard on spellchecks.

Edited

I mean - even shortened it’s an odd post in relation to this situation

AnotherAnnie · 08/11/2026 16:18

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:05

A lot of words…

TLDR; be kind so your kids might learn to be, and dont let cruel people control the narrative people will uncover later. If in the UK,

sorry for edits, dyslexic and really working hard on spellchecks.

AcrossthePond55 · 08/11/2026 16:15

@FakeFinances

I'm just going to raise two points to think about.

1-Political. I'm in the US and I can tell you that there were plenty of Democrats and Republicans within families who got along just fine until Trump and MAGA raised its ugly head. Now many of those families (and friendship groups) are splintered and no longer speak to each other. My estranged DH lost his best friend to MAGA. And many of the 'schisms' happened during Covid as a result of the restrictions and MAGA denial. So think back those 6 years as to whether a rise in right-wing ideology happened then and whether your parents bought into it. Covid denial, 'immigrants brought Covid, and the 'deep state' was a real thing.

2-Paternity. You say you look like your dad. Well, I'm adopted and I as a child I was a dead ringer for one of my maternal aunts (she's not my mum, she couldn't have children either). Now that I'm old(er) I look very much like my late mum. So much so that people who don't know I'm adopted remark on it. I did the Ancestry DNA test as I was curious about my genetic history and it turns out that my biological ancestry is very similar to my mum's, so that may be why there is a similarity in our looks. So don't discount that you might have a different father, especially as it appears your mum was unhappy you raised the issue in some way.

If no one is speaking to you about the specific cause, you may just have to find peace with knowing that you'll never know. And IMHO you are better without them in your life. You'd never have peace and happiness when you and your DC are being treated unfairly.

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 16:05

AnotherAnnie · 08/11/2026 16:03

My suggestion was to accept the low contact the parents have already imposed, not to expose the children to that toxicity. I apologise that it wasn't well expressed.

My experience as a parent was that children do what they see, particularly when they become adults. Showing them massive family dust ups and teaching them that it is a thing to disown people can become a rod for our own backs. I am suggesting taking the controls away from the toxic family and quietly setting the terms.

By showing strength and kindness in adversity, we are helping children become resilient. If they grow up to be graceful while preserving their own space the kids might be better prepared for adult life.

In the US, the cultural mores can be very different. In much of the UK reciprocity can be complex. Even returned presents may create a trail of caring sometimes. In the UK, trying to force someone to face how they have hurt you may be surprisingly counterproductive. My dad said people become what we tell them they are.

A lot of words…