Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents faking poverty and not buying dc gifts

338 replies

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 08:17

for some reason approx 6 years ago my parents decided to stop all gifts for birthday Easter and Christmas. They said they just didn’t have the money to do them for the GC. Fine.

Excpet it’s 1. Not true that they can’t afford it and 2. They still buy gifts etc for both my sisters dc???

Everytime I go to see them they openly show me expensive new things, tell me about the cruises and holidays booked and talk finances (positively) then in the same visit they’ll say they have no money so sorry there’s no cake to have with coffee and reiterate that’s why they don’t do gifts anymore???

I have found out that they have still given gifts to all their other GC (I have 2 sisters) and I’m shocked ? When I asked them about it all they said they would not be speaking to me anymore as I was ‘money grabbing’ ? They haven’t spoken to me for 3 months now.

We hadn’t fallen out prior to this I genuinely believed when they first started this that they had just decided no more gifts ? I have 2 dc, my sisters have 6 between them.

OP posts:
diddl · 08/11/2026 09:45

Op re the deposits-presumably they were in a better position to help your sisters, but how did the comment about you not needing it come about?

Did they just say it or did you ask?

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 08/11/2026 09:44

Without wanting to sound too 'conspiracy theory' about all this, I did wonder if six years ago something came to light that had either been forgotten or buried and it has become 'attached' to you by default? Something like Dad having an affair and only agreeing to stay if Mum had more children - something that made it a 'life before and life after' very distinct difference. You then became the scapegoat for everything that went wrong and this has transferred to your children?

trapdooragain · 08/11/2026 09:42

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 08/11/2026 08:40

Honestly just get into therapy.

Best advice on any thread ever

RaspberryCoffeePot · 08/11/2026 09:42

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 08:17

for some reason approx 6 years ago my parents decided to stop all gifts for birthday Easter and Christmas. They said they just didn’t have the money to do them for the GC. Fine.

Excpet it’s 1. Not true that they can’t afford it and 2. They still buy gifts etc for both my sisters dc???

Everytime I go to see them they openly show me expensive new things, tell me about the cruises and holidays booked and talk finances (positively) then in the same visit they’ll say they have no money so sorry there’s no cake to have with coffee and reiterate that’s why they don’t do gifts anymore???

I have found out that they have still given gifts to all their other GC (I have 2 sisters) and I’m shocked ? When I asked them about it all they said they would not be speaking to me anymore as I was ‘money grabbing’ ? They haven’t spoken to me for 3 months now.

We hadn’t fallen out prior to this I genuinely believed when they first started this that they had just decided no more gifts ? I have 2 dc, my sisters have 6 between them.

Why dont you write a letter stating what you feel and saying since you are treated differently and you dont know why you will not be seeing them again. Anyone who can behave like that isnt worth it. It's just nasty.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 08/11/2026 09:40

The lack of equality in their decision is very strange. Are your kids a lot older than your sisters so they are giving them presents up to the age when they stopped giving them to yours?

Did your children act ungrateful to the presents they got?

muggart · 08/11/2026 09:40

any chance they thought your dc were rude? not appreciative of the gifts, no thank you card, something like that?

or do your siblings help them out with hospital visits etc and they are holding a secret grudge against you??

It’s still outrageous tbh especially that they helped your siblings with deposits.

i would give up on them and pull back entirely. my guess is they treat you badly in othee ways too, which you have normalised.

Terrribletwos · 08/11/2026 09:39

Bountyhunter888 · 08/11/2026 09:15

I would say expecting them to fill up the car with petrol and pay for it is a starting point, ik guessing the parents said oh we filled up the car with petrol then paid to get in the farm and pay for drinks etc this could easiy be £100 and OP didnt offer the money so the parents sent an invoice

Yes, I wonder about this. Did you pay the "invoice" @FakeFinances . But also if it was that then the op would have been able to point to that as the time when things changed and she hasn't.

TillyGoat · 08/11/2026 09:39

Anonyhouse · 08/11/2026 09:37

From your posts I do wonder if they have fallen quite far down the reform rabbit hole? I’ve seen a lot of hatred online towards “woke lefties”. Do your sisters share your parents views? How old are your kids? Could the farm day have been some sort of attempt to brainwash them that didn’t work and they’ve resigned you all as “the enemy”? Or were they very young? Of course this is wild speculation, it’s just all I can read to go on. Regardless of the reasons, previous poster was right in saying this is how it is so you can either accept it or confront them to understand, but I don’t see how you can move past how they have treated you. I’m so sorry, it must be really hurtful.

Agree!
A lot of them seem to binge watch GB News and lack critical thinking.

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 09:39

They are treating you badly.
But I wonder if you treat them simply as grandparents, rather than asking them about their life and showing concern about their lives?

Anonyhouse · 08/11/2026 09:37

From your posts I do wonder if they have fallen quite far down the reform rabbit hole? I’ve seen a lot of hatred online towards “woke lefties”. Do your sisters share your parents views? How old are your kids? Could the farm day have been some sort of attempt to brainwash them that didn’t work and they’ve resigned you all as “the enemy”? Or were they very young? Of course this is wild speculation, it’s just all I can read to go on. Regardless of the reasons, previous poster was right in saying this is how it is so you can either accept it or confront them to understand, but I don’t see how you can move past how they have treated you. I’m so sorry, it must be really hurtful.

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 09:36

Your family are cruel. It doesn't even matter if you did something wrong 6 years ago, firstly that shouldn't be taken out on your children and secondly they should be honest and upfront about their problem. You're their daughter/sister not some acquaintance they can just quietly distance themselves from.
They're not worth any more of your time.

TillyGoat · 08/11/2026 09:36

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 08:20

Also for context many many years ago there was a slight disagreement when they helped both of my sisters with deposits and I was told I already had a house so I didn’t need the help. I was then given an invoice for ONE occasion when they had taken the dc out for me in my car filled up with petrol and got lunch out and farm park entrance and then afterwards billed me for it ! So there is a weird history of financial inequality

That is nuts.

They're being complete arseholes.

I suspect they won't change so you might have to accept it but when they brag about expensive purchases I might be tempted to challenge them on it in the moment.

What do your sisters think about it all?

Perhaps they see your sisters as completely helpless so feel they have to help them more.

Regardless there's no reason for no presents. No matter how poor,! They could make a small gift or bake a cake or even take the kids to the park for a few hours if they were really hard up.

Boomers are a different breed. MIL buys GC baby toys from Lidl costing about £2 for birthdays for my children who aren't babies. She's not hard up, is mortgage free and never worked, and we hear endlessly all the expensive things she's doing while we work full time and can't afford lots of treats.

Invoicing for taking their own grandchildren out for the day is horrible as though they have to be paid to spend time with them.

I would keep them at arms length if they get back in touch.

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2026 09:36

Why are you wasting your emotions on them?

They are taking some sort of beef they have with you, on your kids. That is reason enough to not make any effort whatsoever with them.

Let them come to you. If they can't be bothered, it tells you everything you need to know. Not no contact, just only if they can be arsed.

Your kids will not lose out on not having contact with adults who are using them to get to their parents in some sort of petty dispute which they can't even be bothered to be upfront with you about.

The whole point is to hurt you and to get you running around after them. Don't play their game. Set your own rules.

Mischance · 08/11/2026 09:36

Honestly - sometimes it is impossible to discern someone's motivation and I wouldn't even waste energy trying. If they are Reform voters I would be very glad to have as little to do with them as possible!

Just go with the flow ......

Nodirectionhome · 08/11/2026 09:36

Ihatelittlefriendsusan · 08/11/2026 09:10

There is definitely somwthing off about their behaviour.

My parents released some of my inheritance to help me buy my home when dd's dad and I split up, but when my sister (and nc with her) moved to a bigger house they gave her the same amount to help with that so all fair etc.

You say things changed 6 years ago, what happened around that time?

COVID. Could it be something connected?

aberturret · 08/11/2026 09:36

Have your sisters not given any more clarity on what’s happened?

If this happened in my family my siblings would be straight on the phone to them to say look, this is unfair on the kids, you either buy for all or none of the GC, unless you want to agree an age cut - off for them all. I would do the same.

Imdunfer · 08/11/2026 09:35

FakeFinances · 08/11/2026 09:13

I was treated differently, not badly but it felt like I had more rules ? They said I had to show a good example as I was so much older and to help more , things like that and it was always equal at Christmas etc and really up until 6 years ago this is what’s so confusing

I think I'd be obtaining a DNA sample from each of them and having it compared with your own. It doesn't follow that your mother is necessarily your mother, it's not unknown for a woman to bring up the product of a husband's affair, her husband's brother's or sister's child, or for unofficial surrogacy to have taken place. Or you could be his brother's child from your mother. If they then later had children that are from both of them it could explain your estrangement from them all.

Maybe 6 years ago they realised how easy DNA matching was becoming to obtain and have rejected you before you find out. I'd put yourself on 23&me to start with.

Bollihobs · 08/11/2026 09:33

We can all speculate between us on their reasons but only they know why so it's them you need to have another conversation with.

Would speaking to your Dad or your Mum alone be more productive maybe? Maybe go round and speak with Dad when you know Mum is out or vice versa. Or one of your sisters, if they have the fuller story (or at least hear what they've been told...)

I would try, as much as possible, to keep your emotions in check when you speak, stay calm and try and just get down to the facts. Obviously you may uncover things that are uncomfortable for you too but I feel you'd rather that than not know. Good luck.

diddl · 08/11/2026 09:33

Well they do seem to have all decided that you are no longer part of the family.

5128gap · 08/11/2026 09:33

How odd. Singling your family out to stop gifts and then going out of their way to tell you they do have money sounds like they are deliberately slighting you, and making sure you know it. Which sounds like an act of aggression or punishment.
Was there an event that was the catalyst for this, a reason they might be angry with you, given they used to buy and then stopped?

AutumnLover1999 · 08/11/2026 09:31

I wouldn't put it past your parents to make their wills favour your sisters too 😔 so I'd be mentally prepared for that too,when the time comes.

Decorhate · 08/11/2026 09:31

Whatever the right or wrongs about asking for money for the day out, sending an actual invoice is bizarre behaviour.

When one SIL was having financial issues, I suggested we did not buy for each others kids at Christmas and my PIL took this as a green light to also stop buying Christmas presents for our kids (though continued birthdays till they became adults.) They still bought for other grandkids but we live on a different country so at least the kids were not exposed to it. The have a very different attitude to family events - don't even send a birthday card to their own son.

I couldn't imagine ever not wanting to mark my kids birthday in some way.

HoppityBun · 08/11/2026 09:30

nomas · 08/11/2026 08:26

Even if OP is doing financially better than her sister, that’s no excuse to exclude her children from presents. Do you honestly think that’s ok?

Your question assumes that @CardiffCate is making a judgment. That the question is saying “are you financially better off because if you are, then the parents’ behaviour would be ok”. The question is neutral. It’s looking for a reason for the parents’ behaviour.

And “honestly” adds nothing unless you’re suggesting there’s something dishonest about @CardiffCate

LetMeStayInBed · 08/11/2026 09:29

I wonder if it stemmed from when they gave your sisters deposits but not you. You already had a house probably because you are ten years older. If you showed any emotion at that they may have turned that into you being grabby or something. It sounds as if you being the oldest and feeling you were treated differently has carried on throughout your life. (How were you treated before having sisters?)
There may be some long past deep resentment - maybe they were quite hard up when you were a child but by the time your sisters came along times were easier so they associate you with hard times.
Like others I think you should take a step back Whatever the reason, I don’t think anyone is going to tell you at this point and that is really unkind. You have your dc and dh live your best life and leave your parents and sisters in your past.

AutumnLover1999 · 08/11/2026 09:27

My late mother in law used to favour my sister in law's son. It got to the point that she'd buy a mountain of gifts for him,then 1 for my son and she'd tell me to bring some unopened gifts of ours for our son so the obvious discrepancy in size of gifts wouldn't be so obvious. I refused 😡