Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not spend the same on my children’s Christmas presents?

38 replies

Arbourimage · 08/11/2026 07:21

How do you deal with Christmas presents for your kids that are still children?
I keep seeing people obsessing about spending more or buying more to ‘even out’ between their younger ones and older siblings.

Am I the only one that doesn’t try to spend the same on the younger one as the older ones?
Surely that’s normal and not unreasonable?

OP posts:
rollerblind · 08/11/2026 07:55

This year I am going to try to loosely stick to a budget, mainly because my son likes expensive things and my daughter loves little bits and bobs like lip balms, squishies etc. So last year I ended up panic buying for my son (ridiculous, I know!) as it looked like my daughter had so much more than him. He wants a curved monitor this year and an expensive hoody so I’ve explained that that’s most of his budget gone and that his sister will look like she’s got more. He understands. I am tracking what I buy for them now.

Arbourimage · 08/11/2026 07:49

Focussingonme · 08/11/2026 07:43

I don't, dd9 and dd4. They get roughly the same number of presents so it's relatively equal with opening as we spread presents through the day but they get what is appropriate for them regardless of cost. I'm also pretty good at bargain shopping so I often don't pay what things are "worth" which makes it harder to judge too. My MIL drives me crazy with insisting on matching spend to the penny. My younger one ends up with a bag of total junk to "make it up" pointless waste and most of it goes to charity in January. I'd much rather one well chosen gift regardless of how much it costs.

I agree it would be so much extra junk to up spending on a little one to match! At a certain point more toys are completely unnecessary.

OP posts:
strictlybusinessuntildecember · 08/11/2026 07:46

I spend more on my eldest - I try and have an even budget but in reality it’s not always achievable. The youngest 2 have a similar budget (twins) but I’m not going to buy more things they don’t need just to even up the spend

Focussingonme · 08/11/2026 07:43

I don't, dd9 and dd4. They get roughly the same number of presents so it's relatively equal with opening as we spread presents through the day but they get what is appropriate for them regardless of cost. I'm also pretty good at bargain shopping so I often don't pay what things are "worth" which makes it harder to judge too. My MIL drives me crazy with insisting on matching spend to the penny. My younger one ends up with a bag of total junk to "make it up" pointless waste and most of it goes to charity in January. I'd much rather one well chosen gift regardless of how much it costs.

blubberball · 08/11/2026 07:39

I try to have it fairly even in terms of what the pile of gifts looks like. Factoring in what they ask for, what they need etc. This year, my youngest is asking for money at the moment. I'm not giving him more than £100 in cash even though I probably would have spent more on gifts he might have wanted. I can't justify giving him more than that when he just spends it on Roblox and stuff

boobot1 · 08/11/2026 07:38

I think it depends on their ages. Very small children dont need much but for older children, I would, they do notice.

YertleTheTurtle · 08/11/2026 07:37

This MN obsession with having to spend identical amounts on kids is truly baffling. The kids (particularly younger ones) won't know or care what things cost if it's things they want/like. Looking back at my childhood I haven't the faintest idea how much my or my siblings gifts cost - and nobody cared.

Buy your DC things a)you can comfortably afford , and b) they like.

EmbracingUncertainty · 08/11/2026 07:35

Not evening them out here, for main present eldest has asked for some Lego that’s costing just over £100, youngest has asked for an ornament he’s seen in a window that I’ve found for £15. He will also get some Lego to go with it but a much cheaper set, and then some stocking fillers each. They don’t have much concept of monetary value of things so seems like pointless consumerism to even things out.

Daisy12Maisie · 08/11/2026 07:27

I have a 19 year old and a 17 year old. Very different situations as the 19 year old is working full time and has a lot of disposable income.
I have got them roughly the same for Christmas but I took the younger one on a shopping spree at the end of September to “kit him out for the school year” so he got a jacket, hoodie, aftershaves etc then. So Christmas looks equal but it’s obvious that I buy more “things” for the younger one at the moment as he only works 12
hrs a week and is at college.

with much younger children they don’t know the value of things so don’t need as
much spent on them.

Eileen101 · 08/11/2026 07:27

I don't even it out, they both have something/things they have asked for or been keen on.
The vast majority of my kids gifts are from vinted as money is tight right now. They don't know any different, or care. They're 9 and 6, so luckily it's all books, games, toys rather than electronics.

Yawningalldaylong · 08/11/2026 07:26

I’ve never tried to keep the spending equal for my children’s presents and they don’t seem to notice. We buy what’s needed over the year, so maybe it evens it self out, but I buy what my children like or need and it’s not about cost. They also understand sometimes things are too expensive. We try to keep Christmas calm anyway, it’s not all about the presents but about having time to watch a movie or bake something. I thought as they got older that may change but their teens and it’s not happened yet.

Bluebeast · 08/11/2026 07:25

Older kids presents cost more. I wouldnt obsess over getting my younger kids 10 more toys they don't need and wont play with just to even it out! YANBU.

EmeraldSlippers · 08/11/2026 07:25

If you are buying them both things that they will enjoy that happen to cost different amounts then it's fine.
Make sure it's not a pattern whereby one child always asks for expensive things and the other for cheaper, because over time and as they grow it will be picked up on. But obsessing about spending exactly the same is silly if everyone will be happy with what they have.