Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel a dinner with my best friend and her hubby who I know has cheated?

243 replies

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 02:40

I have NC for this.

My best friend has just found out her husband has been having an affair. I won’t go into how she found out but she found out as opposed to him owning up to her. It’s over now - I’m unsure if it’s because she found out or if it had ended anyway. She wants to work through it and stay with him and I’m trying to support her but I am so angry with him - like SO angry. I can’t believe he could do this to her because she is genuinely one of the loveliest people you could ever meet and she just doesn’t deserve this. I love her so much that I want to (and to a large extent feel like I have to) support her in what she chooses to do, but I’m just not sure I can be normal around him knowing what he’s done to her. It has totally clouded my view of him and I don’t want to add to her hurt but I can’t see how I’ll be able to act normally around him next time I see him. He doesn’t know I know. My DH and I are usually quite pally with him and would ordinarily send each other jokes etc and I haven’t got in touch with him at all since I found out. We are due to go for dinner all together in a week - planned for a long time - and I’m absolutely dreading it.

AIBU to cancel the dinner? I’m really trying to not make this about me and be there for my friend but I don’t want to make her feel awkward by being off around her DH. She is very much acting like nothing has happened and downplaying things and is trying to move on - which is a whole other issue entirely. WWYD?

OP posts:
Gloriia · 08/11/2026 07:54

Why on earth would you go??
Carry on supporting your friend 1 to 1, see her on her own. If she chooses to stay with an arsehole that's her choice but does mean you have to socialise with him.

Be honest, just say you'd find it far too weird but happy to meet up with her anytime.

Bigtrapeze · 08/11/2026 07:52

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 04:13

Honestly, this feels like a mine field and o genuinely don’t know what to think, say or do. The most important thing to me is her and our friendship, so I don’t want to do anything that could jeopardise that. I also know I need to be careful what I say to her about him because that could also affect our friendship if they are able to move past this.

I’m really worried she’s forgiven too much too quickly. It’s almost like within days of finding out she had decided to make a go of things and that to her, that meant pretending nothing has happened. She’s already asked me to forget she said anything - I said I wouldn’t bring it up unnecessarily but that I couldn’t and wouldn’t forget it had happened and neither should she. I think this is all another reason I’m reluctant to go to the dinner - I think she’ll be acting like everything is fine and normal and not like her husband hasn’t been seeing another woman for the last few weeks/ months.

I really don’t know how to be a good friend here - do I try and play devils advocate and make her understand the enormity of what he’s done or play along with the ‘everything’s fine, pretend nothing’s happened’ line?

This is really difficult, OP. Sometimes being a good friend is a fine line between agreeing with them and not, and I think this is so tough. None of us really know what we would do in her situation. I think I would end things myself, but it hasn't actually happened so who knows? One thing I wouldn't be able to do is keep something of this magnitude from DH. It wouldn't go any further, but I'd tell my friend I needed to tell him as I was really upset and he'd need to know why. I think secrets are corrosive in relationships. I would be massively disappointed in my friend's DH if he did this and I think my poker face would be poor. It wouldn't be the best dinner with that elephant in the room.

I might tell my friend that I totally supported her decision as it is hers to make but that I feel upset with him on her behalf and don't think I could fake it for a dinner just now. I'd suggest we did some stuff together. I'd ask for a bit of time.

I think just cancelling but not saying why is the wrong thing. Would you need to lie to your DH to do that? This man's infidelity has potentially got you avoiding the truth now, and that makes me really cross on your behalf, and your friend's. I think for your foursome to proceed, he might need to apologise to you all for his poor treatment of your friend and promise this was an incident that will never be repeated.

My friend's husband left her, seemingly out of the blue, and it was horrible. We'd all been pretty close and I couldn't even look at him. 5 years on he's remarried, she has another partner and whilst I'm not as close with her ex, obviously, I am genuinely pleased when I see him and I like his new wife, who wasn't involved in their break up. I'm no longer cross with him, which surprised me. Give this a bit of time for you to process. I know it is their business and their marriage, but I don't know that being a good friend is standing by when someone treats them appallingly and pretending it hasn't happened. I think your friend will get this, even if she is doing just that at the moment. I think being able to talk to your DH about this would really help you to work out what to do. My DH knows me inside out and I wouldn't want him not to know something like this had happened. I'd need his take on it.

Boomer55 · 08/11/2026 07:52

chirrupybird · 08/11/2026 06:09

It's up to her if she wants to forgive and forget and if she told you in confidence and wants you to forget about it that's what you do. She may change her mind again fine, but at the minute she wants to give it a go and you quietly sabotaging her attempts to save her marriage by making it obvious you know is not good. If you can't face seeing her husband yet make up an excuse and cancel the dinner until you can control yourself, as you said it's not about you.

This. People have to sort out their own relationships, and their decisions are theirs alone. If she wants support, then just give it. . If she’s chosen to ignore it, then support her in that.

Downplayit · 08/11/2026 07:51

Ive been in a very similar position albeit he knew I knew. If you want to support your friend you have to just go along with it amd smile and grit your teeth. Its her decision and if you create an argument with him then it's just going to make it worse for her. Ultimately if she chose him despite unfaithfulness she will chose him over you. Also its her relationship so you have to respect her choices and be ready to be there if those choices don't work out.

WimpoleHat · 08/11/2026 07:50

I’m really trying to not make this about me

Then don’t. Your has asked you to go - so go. For her. Nobody is saying you have to be best mates with this man, or want to marry him yourself. Or even think that your friend should stay with him. But she does and she wants you to support her.

Also - in all my years, the one thing I have learned is that you never, ever know exactly what goes on in a marriage, no matter how well you think you know the people concerned. So I would just stand by your friend and be led by her.

BrickMaker · 08/11/2026 07:49

I think you should go and support her; I have been in your friend's shoes and she is under an enormous amount of pressure right now. She just needs your presence and support.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 07:46

Skatefordinner · 08/11/2026 07:42

I have been in both sides of those position and it’s really hard.

I can see you are really torn. Absolutely do not distance your self from her first and foremost. If you are close friends of course she needs you at the moment.

Things will run their course on that front and you’ll be there to support her when she hopefully comes to her senses.

I would be going to the dinner. Not because you support / like him and I totally understand how hard it will be to sit there playing happy families but .. whatever your anger is towards him, and however hard it will be to put your game face on and pretend.. this won’t be even 1% of how difficult she’s finding everything right now. I know it will feel false and ultimately hopefully they won’t end up staying together but right now she could probably do with one night out which resembles normality.

It might help to see it as you supporting her in something that (for now) she wants to proceed with. That doesn’t mean you are supporting him. That might make things easier on the night. Either go and find a way to be supportive or find a reason to cancel. It’s in no one’s interest to go and glare / make underhand comments. If you think you can pull it off by reframing things then do it.

She needs you atm. Remember - this is not you supporting that twat. Keep the conversation light/ general. Films, superficial stuff, work.., the lighter stuff that might normally come up anyway.

Don’t drink too much (if you drink) and start yawning / say you are up early as soon as it feels ok to do so.

Totally agree.
By not going or by going and acting strangely all that will you do OP is make things harder and more awkward for your friend.

Unless she cancels you go and support her by making the best of it.
She will feel like absolute sh*t right now so don't do anything your end to make that worse.

Emptyandsad · 08/11/2026 07:44

Supporting your friend through this will require you to do some hard stuff. She says now that she's staying with him, but it's early days. As his betrayal sits with her she may find that she just can't get past it. In the meantime, supporting her means being in the trenches with her, backing up her decisions, no matter how wrong she feels they are. Even if staying with him works, it won't be easy and there will be a lot of shit along the way.

Are you up for it? She will be needing you and you're going to have to sit on your righteous indignation and really love her

Skatefordinner · 08/11/2026 07:42

I have been in both sides of those position and it’s really hard.

I can see you are really torn. Absolutely do not distance your self from her first and foremost. If you are close friends of course she needs you at the moment.

Things will run their course on that front and you’ll be there to support her when she hopefully comes to her senses.

I would be going to the dinner. Not because you support / like him and I totally understand how hard it will be to sit there playing happy families but .. whatever your anger is towards him, and however hard it will be to put your game face on and pretend.. this won’t be even 1% of how difficult she’s finding everything right now. I know it will feel false and ultimately hopefully they won’t end up staying together but right now she could probably do with one night out which resembles normality.

It might help to see it as you supporting her in something that (for now) she wants to proceed with. That doesn’t mean you are supporting him. That might make things easier on the night. Either go and find a way to be supportive or find a reason to cancel. It’s in no one’s interest to go and glare / make underhand comments. If you think you can pull it off by reframing things then do it.

She needs you atm. Remember - this is not you supporting that twat. Keep the conversation light/ general. Films, superficial stuff, work.., the lighter stuff that might normally come up anyway.

Don’t drink too much (if you drink) and start yawning / say you are up early as soon as it feels ok to do so.

saraclara · 08/11/2026 07:42

I can't believe these answers.
OP this is not about you and your feelings. He's cheated on your friend not you.
Your friend wants to forgive him and move on, at least for now.
It's not your job, as her friend, to punish him and moralise. You are not helping your friend if you do this and there's a high chance your friendship will end if you can't step up and support her how SHE wants to be supported.
You really need to get over yourself and step up for your friend.

Well said. So many posters here who seem to think that making it about you, and punishing your friend is the way to go. Because that's what cancelling the meal would be.

Is it going to be fun? No. I'd probably end up letting the other three lead the conversations and sit back a little bit. But if you mean what you said about not making it about you, then you carry on regardless.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 07:40

You say you don't want to make it all about you but by reacting this way and deciding not to go to the dinner that is exactly what you are doing.
Your friend is no doubt still reeling after what happened and them staying together may not last but for the moment she needs things to carry on as normally as possible. As a good friend, your job is to support her in this.

This isn't the school playground here, you are a grown adult and I am sure you can keep your feelings in check for one night and act civilly around her husband, whatever your feelings are.
That is what she needs from you right now; not going sends a clear judgement about her decision to try to save her marriage but doing that is entirely her call. Yes, she's your best friend but you aren't party to every detail of her marriage or the full details of her husband affair.

For now, you need to be guided by her and if she wants you there then just put your big girl pants on and show up, act normally and let her work through what she has to.

This is good practice because she may well stay with him and you may have to be around him for years to come.
It's not your decision what she does.

MerryAquaKoala · 08/11/2026 07:35

BeeHive909 · 08/11/2026 03:34

I wouldn’t go to the dinner but I would also back away from my friend. She’s chosen to stay with him and until you can accept it you can’t be friends. She clearly wants to move on sadly

That's the worst advice ever. Dump her friend because her friends' husband is scum? Nice.

Ophy83 · 08/11/2026 07:33

It may feel less awkward if there was no secret - tell your dh, it isn't fair for him to be the only person at the table unaware of any undercurrents. And ask her to let her dh know that you know. You don't have to discuss the affair at dinner - or ever- but at least no one is pretending it didn't happen.

MerryAquaKoala · 08/11/2026 07:32

It's not about you OP. It's about her. Does she want to have this meal - will it means something to her? I think the only thing is that he doesn't know you know. So she needs to tell him you and your husband (tell your husband) know he's a cheating scum bag. You might find he will cancel it himself then, cheating scum bags aren't known for humility . Still doesn't help your friend much though.

LoudWriter · 08/11/2026 07:31

My advice would be that if you cancel and she thinks it's because you disapprove of her decisions it might put her further back into his arms. She's clearly grasping for some semblance of normality. I don't think it matters if you go or if you cancel if you're really honest with her about uncomfortable you are, but I would do my best to avoid that looking like any judgement on her choice to stay with, or even to leave him if things end up going that way too. I'd personally say something about not feeling able to keep the secret from your own husband and that you might struggle to not seem angry at hers, and give her the choice as to whether it's a good idea to risk it all coming out on the night

Jazz7 · 08/11/2026 07:27

I would definitely go and try to act as you would if you didn’t know. Chances are while initially she tries to forgive and forget it will eat away at her and eventually the marriage will fail.difficult to move past this. She will need you there but don’t get involved or comment beyond telling her it’s her decision and you’re there for her whatever happens. If she manages to keep it going she will appreciate your support all the more and it’s very much her choice not yours to make. Friends cutting her off is the last thing she needs

SALaw · 08/11/2026 07:27

Tell the friend?! This is the consequence of him acting how he’s acted and her sharing that with you. It will clearly have an impact on how you feel about him. I’d just say “I don’t really want to play nice with Bob after what I’ve seen him out you through.”

Hellandbackand · 08/11/2026 07:22

Part of the early stages of a couple dealing with cheating is trying to clutch onto anything that helps life make sense. This meal may be part of that. Your friend is a good one, can you not talk it through with her? She maybe just wants to have a "normal" meal and just pretend or maybe she hasn't thought about the dinner yet.
But if she wants to go ahead I'd say do it for her. You are there to support her. If you didn't particularly like her DH when she first married him, you'd put up with him in a dinner for her sake. So just do that.

pencilpot99 · 08/11/2026 07:08

Difficult dilemma. When I found out about my ex-husband cheating I didn’t tell anyone for 6 months. I couldn’t believe it had happened. We tried counselling etc. I was still in love with the guy — that doesn’t vanish over night. I desperately didn’t want our family to break up. But when he clearly didn’t show any remorse or interest in trying to make it work I knew it was the end. That realisation took time though, over half a year. Give your friend time, but be there for her. She may really be struggling but not want to show it. When you find out you feel like such a failure, and it’s humiliating. I completely understand why, to the outside world, it looks like she’s holding it together and they’re playing happy families. It’s honestly a horrible miserable time and I think she’s really going to need your support and compassion in the months ahead. If I was in your shoes I’d tell my partner, but I can trust mine to be discreet and offer useful advice, obviously I don’t know your OH. And I guess I’d go to the dinner and grin and bear it for my friend. Her husband will probably be able to tell that you know, but who cares.

JLou08 · 08/11/2026 07:07

You are making it about you. He didn't cheat on you. He cheated on your friend and she has decided to forgive him. It's not about your feelings, it's about your friends. We all have to get along with people we don't like sometimes. Suck it up and go to the meal.

rwalker · 08/11/2026 07:05

a big part of being a friend is supporting there choices right or wrong
she’ll have her reasons

Alittlefrustrated · 08/11/2026 07:01

I can't believe these answers.
OP this is not about you and your feelings. He's cheated on your friend not you.
Your friend wants to forgive him and move on, at least for now.
It's not your job, as her friend, to punish him and moralise. You are not helping your friend if you do this and there's a high chance your friendship will end if you can't step up and support her how SHE wants to be supported.
You really need to get over yourself and step up for your friend.
Come on, we all have a game face. I've had to spend time with domestic abusers, sex offenders, addicts etc, in their homes, in order to ensure ongoing access to their partner and children.
Obviously, professionally, I didn't have a choice, as the women and children came first over my dislike and personal feelings.
You do have a choice and have a right to exercise it, but I don't believe you can't put your game face on, and support your friend how she wants to be supported.
She's an adult and has to work through this herself.
Going forward, it will hopefully be easier to prioritise time with just her.

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 08/11/2026 07:00

I'm really surprised you haven't talked to your DH about this. If you don't I could really forsee you ending up having to tell lies and deceive him in your attempts to conceal what is goibg on in your friends marriage.

I honestky think she has put a big burden on you and I would be inclined not to go to the meal and be honest with her that atm you just don't want to be in his company.

ItsWoudHaveNotWouldOf · 08/11/2026 06:57

I'd have to give it a miss until I could temper my reaction to him. I could keep my mouth shut but unfortunately my face does subtitles that would give me away.

MidnightScroller · 08/11/2026 06:52

Havingaswimmoose · 08/11/2026 06:43

I think you need to tell your husband.
He'll find out eventually. Then he'll wonder why you didn't tell him. Let him decide if he wants to be pally with her cheating husband.

Imagine the three of you knowing of the shift in the friendship dynamic and him left in the dark.

Yes I know you're loyal to a confidence for your friend but I'd be more loyal to my own husband.

I agree with this. Whether she stays with him or leaves him your DH should know. What if the cheating prick makes private subtle comments to your DH that indicate somethings still going on - he might miss that if he doesn’t know but would be helpful eyes and ears if he knows. Plus why should the cheat get away with it? He should be held accountable and knowing that you both know and are disgusted but for her sake trying to move on is helpful.
Cancel the husbands. Put on the group chat husbands can chill at home for the night cos the ladies need to let their hair down and take her out by yourself. She needs tlc and celebrating wonderful her. He needs to rot at home for a bit while the news is sinking in and he can worry about what she’s doing/thinking instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread