Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel a dinner with my best friend and her hubby who I know has cheated?

243 replies

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 02:40

I have NC for this.

My best friend has just found out her husband has been having an affair. I won’t go into how she found out but she found out as opposed to him owning up to her. It’s over now - I’m unsure if it’s because she found out or if it had ended anyway. She wants to work through it and stay with him and I’m trying to support her but I am so angry with him - like SO angry. I can’t believe he could do this to her because she is genuinely one of the loveliest people you could ever meet and she just doesn’t deserve this. I love her so much that I want to (and to a large extent feel like I have to) support her in what she chooses to do, but I’m just not sure I can be normal around him knowing what he’s done to her. It has totally clouded my view of him and I don’t want to add to her hurt but I can’t see how I’ll be able to act normally around him next time I see him. He doesn’t know I know. My DH and I are usually quite pally with him and would ordinarily send each other jokes etc and I haven’t got in touch with him at all since I found out. We are due to go for dinner all together in a week - planned for a long time - and I’m absolutely dreading it.

AIBU to cancel the dinner? I’m really trying to not make this about me and be there for my friend but I don’t want to make her feel awkward by being off around her DH. She is very much acting like nothing has happened and downplaying things and is trying to move on - which is a whole other issue entirely. WWYD?

OP posts:
Jellybean23 · 08/11/2026 08:17

Go for your friend’s sake. She desperately wants things to be like they were so this would help her.

WitchesBritches · 08/11/2026 08:17

GarlicNothing · 08/11/2026 04:04

I would tell her you want her to tell her husband you know

Yes, this is what I was thinking too. Supporting your friend in what she decides to do - which may change as they muddle though this - doesn't mean colluding with her in a pretence of marital bliss.

I'd want to feel it was okay to be off with him, or even give him an earful if it came to it. Not to be morally compromised and go home hating myself. That would lead to me resenting her very quickly. If she demands fakery from you, she's not being your friend, is she.

It sounds like you haven't personally been through any of this.

Her friend wants to make it work with her husband (whether we agree that's a good idea or not) & it might throw a complete grenade into the works for the OP to let on that she knows. She needs to play this the way her best friend wants her to play it. It has nothing to do with her, not being a very good friend and everything to do with her desperately wanting to save her marriage.

Cheese55 · 08/11/2026 08:15

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 03:36

This is a totally different perspective from any I’ve thought of, so thank you for this. Honestly, she’s my best friend and has been for the longest time. The thought of backing away (especially when she’s going through this) makes me want to cry to be honest. We are a daily part of each others lives. It also makes me even angrier with him that he is the cause of this. But also… part of me know you’re talking sense because if I can’t move on from this there isn’t much hope really, is there?

I think you're overthinking all of this. Plenty of people stay with unfaithful partners, not sure why but they do. Just get on with it. You dont dump friends because of their partners apart from extreme circumstances, and this isn't one of them.

WitchesBritches · 08/11/2026 08:14

Greenfinch7 · 08/11/2026 03:56

It's absolutely awful to think of backing away from your friend because of this. She needs support, someone who will listen, someone who will continue to love her and trust her and try to understand. No one can know what goes on in another person's marriage, and many people stay with partners who have betrayed them in one way or another- it is not uncommon and things are not black and white in life.

I think I would tell her you want her to tell her husband you know, so that you don't have to be performing a lie every time you see him. If they stick together, after about 10 years you might be able to chat with him again without wanting to kill him...- until then I would avoid things like going out to dinner, which sounds deeply unpleasant.

She is in the very early stage of being in shock and not knowing what to do or what she feels. It takes time- years- to figure out what you think and want after a crisis like this.

Exactly.

she's your best friend, you don't abandon her when she's going through one of the hardest things she'll go through in her life. You don't abandon someone just because they make a different decision than you might make, but as you're not in that position, you don't really know..

there's every chance they won't make it through this as a couple, but whether they do or not, she needs you.

dinner would be very hard when he doesn't know you know. Personally, I wouldn't like him to think she wouldn't tell me & for him to feel very smug about it. Is there any chance your DH could have a conveniently timed work trip which means you can't go to the dinner?? or some of the very plausible excuse to cancel? Like a previous poster said my face doesn't lie I'd find it impossible to act like we did before.

VelociraptorsVelociRapping · 08/11/2026 08:14

I wouldn’t go. If you are right that she is trying to paper over the cracks and downplay everything then she wants you there to help with the overall pretence and I couldn’t collude with that. This kind of betrayal has wide-reaching consequences beyond the marriage and it’s not helpful in the long term to protect either party from that. Cancel the dinner and tell her why.

Dollymylove · 08/11/2026 08:14

You should probably cancel otherwise it will probably turn out to be a very uncomfortable experience. Your DF has made her decision to stay in the marriage and its not for you to decide its the wrong decision. See your friend on her own without her husband if you cant bring yourself to be civil

ithinkthereforeyouarewrong · 08/11/2026 08:13

I would cancel and ask friend to meet up one on one instead.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 08:11

RoundRedRobin · 08/11/2026 08:05

I would cancel.

If her H realises you know he will then use that to gaslight her into thinking she’s in the wrong.

personally my DH would already know but as yours doesn’t, he will also pick up on your attitude and won’t understand what’s going on and could feel negative to you- don’t let a cheater affect your relationship too.

Can grown adults really not keep their feelings in check?
Why does there have to be an atmosphere?
It is possible to just act normally whatever you feel inside and just be there for a friend in her time of need.

The OP isn't a child or a teenager fgs.

Dozer · 08/11/2026 08:10

It’s not ‘controlling’ not to want to hang out with a friend’s H who has just cheated on another, closer friend and one’s H who is unaware of the situation. And not to want to lie that all is well.

I’d make an excuse and not go - far, far too soon.

I’d tell her to confirm to her H that I knew.

& I’d tell DH, in confidence.

Ethelspagetti · 08/11/2026 08:09

If you’re feeling angry then I wouldn’t go. Your friend won’t thank you for being hostile at a dinner she’s looking forward to. Give it some time and you’ll calm down. If your friend has chosen to forgive him then it is her business. Reschedule it for the new year, hopefully you’ll be feeling less emotional about it by then.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 08/11/2026 08:08

If you cancel or act off around him surely your DH will notice and want to know why. It's one of the reasons a lot of people choose someone they are not particularly close to as a confidant for discussing things with. If you want to support her, how ever hard you find it you have to pretend that nothing has happened and behave as normal.

CarolineMJN · 08/11/2026 08:06

I had this situation and I supported her and she chose to stay. Unfortunately I didn’t want anything to do with him and therefore she was welcome but he wasn’t. Part of his control was then he limited her friends who weren’t ’completely Supportive of her decisions’ thereby alienating her from the friends that sided with her and loathed him. He effectively used this to shield himself and eventually they moved 200 miles away to a new area where ‘no one knew and could judge them for a fresh start’. Within 6 months he had shagged someone else and the process started again. Fortunately she reached out and moved back ‘home’ . But the reality was he used it as a power move. If I went for dinner I would feel like I was condoning his behaviour and if I don’t I’m not supporting her. Step back and offer to meet her 1-2-1 for lunch and other stuff.

O00ps · 08/11/2026 08:05

Your friend isn't being fair to you.
Your husband is the only person who doesn't yet know. How will he feel if he finds out later that you all hid it from him and forced him to play along. What would your husband do if he knew? Would he still go and be pleasant with the guy or would he want nothing to do with him?

This dinner will be fake so what is the point of it. A dinner doesn't represent support for your friend. Cancel it while it's all too raw. Support her in ways that don't involve deceiving your own husband.

Beaniebobbins · 08/11/2026 08:05

I think your friend needs support right now so I would go on that basis. Ending a marriage is a process not an event. She might have taken him back but this might not be permanent. She will be struggling with a lot of the feelings you have but it is ten times worse for her.

RoundRedRobin · 08/11/2026 08:05

I would cancel.

If her H realises you know he will then use that to gaslight her into thinking she’s in the wrong.

personally my DH would already know but as yours doesn’t, he will also pick up on your attitude and won’t understand what’s going on and could feel negative to you- don’t let a cheater affect your relationship too.

Wish44 · 08/11/2026 08:02

I have been in your position op. It’s very hard- 3 years later my friend is still with her husband. I find it all so hard but just grim and bare it. Sadly my friendship with my friend has been affected as things just aren’t the same. He will almost certain cheat on her again ( we have both known him longer than they have been together and he has always been a cheater) . I actually think she distances herself from me now as I am one other only people she told and I remind her of it all.

so to all the posters saying dont make it about you - I disagree it is about you too op. Affairs are not isolated things they cause ripples that affect so many people. The fall out is massive and yet the person who had the affair often seems the least affected .

somanychristmaslights · 08/11/2026 08:01

I would say “Katie, could we make the dinner just us 2? I just need some time before I can hang around with Jason again, so maybe we could meet up with the husbands at a later date?”

I would also tell your DH the reason.

jackstini · 08/11/2026 07:58

Definitely be there for her - she really needs you at the moment. She is going through the stages of grief and currently in denial, but may change to anger, sadness or wanting to leave at any point

Has she mentioned the meal yet, does she still want it to go ahead?

How close are you to her H and what is your normal behaviour around him? For example would you usually hug him hello & goodbye? Or are you quite distant and just polite. One will be a lot easier to do whilst pretending everything is fine than the other…

Agree everyone has a game face, but unless you’re a brilliant actress, her H will know something is up, and so will your DH

How close a friend is your DH to him?

She is your best friend and that is the second most important thing. I say second, because the first is your marriage. Would your DH see it as a massive betrayal if he finds out you knew and didn’t tell him? You might have to say to your friend you won’t tell anyone, but if your DH asks anything specific, you are not going to lie to him

Horrible position to be in, I feel for you both

BrickMaker · 08/11/2026 07:57

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 03:36

This is a totally different perspective from any I’ve thought of, so thank you for this. Honestly, she’s my best friend and has been for the longest time. The thought of backing away (especially when she’s going through this) makes me want to cry to be honest. We are a daily part of each others lives. It also makes me even angrier with him that he is the cause of this. But also… part of me know you’re talking sense because if I can’t move on from this there isn’t much hope really, is there?

I know you are angry but 'backing away' when your best friend's world is imploding because you don't agree with her decision is actually pretty controlling. I know it's coming from a place of love. But it's her life, her husband and her family. She isn't trying to save her marriage to HIM she is trying to save her family. And maybe all the mumsnetters will say she should leave, become a single mum etc. And maybe she will one day but it isn't that easy. What people tell other people to do on an anonymous internet forum and what they would actually do themselves is pretty different.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 07:57

Bigtrapeze · 08/11/2026 07:52

This is really difficult, OP. Sometimes being a good friend is a fine line between agreeing with them and not, and I think this is so tough. None of us really know what we would do in her situation. I think I would end things myself, but it hasn't actually happened so who knows? One thing I wouldn't be able to do is keep something of this magnitude from DH. It wouldn't go any further, but I'd tell my friend I needed to tell him as I was really upset and he'd need to know why. I think secrets are corrosive in relationships. I would be massively disappointed in my friend's DH if he did this and I think my poker face would be poor. It wouldn't be the best dinner with that elephant in the room.

I might tell my friend that I totally supported her decision as it is hers to make but that I feel upset with him on her behalf and don't think I could fake it for a dinner just now. I'd suggest we did some stuff together. I'd ask for a bit of time.

I think just cancelling but not saying why is the wrong thing. Would you need to lie to your DH to do that? This man's infidelity has potentially got you avoiding the truth now, and that makes me really cross on your behalf, and your friend's. I think for your foursome to proceed, he might need to apologise to you all for his poor treatment of your friend and promise this was an incident that will never be repeated.

My friend's husband left her, seemingly out of the blue, and it was horrible. We'd all been pretty close and I couldn't even look at him. 5 years on he's remarried, she has another partner and whilst I'm not as close with her ex, obviously, I am genuinely pleased when I see him and I like his new wife, who wasn't involved in their break up. I'm no longer cross with him, which surprised me. Give this a bit of time for you to process. I know it is their business and their marriage, but I don't know that being a good friend is standing by when someone treats them appallingly and pretending it hasn't happened. I think your friend will get this, even if she is doing just that at the moment. I think being able to talk to your DH about this would really help you to work out what to do. My DH knows me inside out and I wouldn't want him not to know something like this had happened. I'd need his take on it.

You couldn't fake a single dinner for your best friend's sake? Really?
If that is what she wanted and needed from you in a terrible moment in her life?

bugalugs45 · 08/11/2026 07:57

God i feel the same , except in my situation it’s my
sister in law that’s had the affair … and there’s young children involved . So far I’ve been polite upon seeing her literally buy contact is minimal and usually over text , we used to be quite close , but I’m dreading Christmas as the thought of sitting down around a dinner table horrifies me but for my brothers and the children’s sake I will do it . My parents feel exactly the same.
No real advice but solidarity with you OP .

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 08/11/2026 07:57

He knows full well that you know, by the way. You’re very close friends, so of course she’s told you what’s happened.

Your friend just wants you to pretend that you don’t.

JustgoawayT · 08/11/2026 07:57

Flabbergasted by people telling you distance yourself from your friend. Wtf the wrong with people?

I agree with pp who said it’s not about you. You’re supporting your friend and she has decided to try to make things work. That means you support her in that and don’t let your personal feelings of anger get in the way or make her life harder.

That said, regarding the dinner, it doesn’t sound practical for it to go ahead with you knowing, your husband not knowing and her husband not knowing you know- so much could go wrong. Talk to your friend about it all and the possibility of bringing it more out into the open- your husband knowing and her husband knowing that you both know. That’s a much healthier and stronger basis for things going forward.

Thepossibility · 08/11/2026 07:55

Pretty much this exact situation caused the loss of my friendship with my best friend. Her DH cheated in the worst way and she decided to forgive him. We went to dinner and it was frosty, I said a couple of things. Honesty I was just so mad and I'm not one for fake smiles and small talk with someone I actively dislike. A scumbag.
She cut things off with me after that because I obviously wasn't going to forgive and forget like they expected me to.
So I'd absolutely advise not to go.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 08/11/2026 07:54

My sister in law’s first husband cheated on her, and just after it all happened, we were talking.
She told me that she wanted to stay with him, because she still loved him. She said that she couldn’t simply switch it off like that.

One of the things that was holding her back from forgiving him was how the rest of the family would ‘be’ about it, and how they would treat him going forward.

I told her everyone is just going to have to get over it. If she can move on, and try to carry on as normal, then we’d have do likewise.
Bless her, she knew that wasn’t truly possible, but that’s how she felt at the time.

She ended it with him, though. She’s a lovely woman, and seeing how much she was hurt was very tough to see.

That was 15 years ago and she’s now remarried to a much nicer man.

Swipe left for the next trending thread