Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel a dinner with my best friend and her hubby who I know has cheated?

243 replies

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 02:40

I have NC for this.

My best friend has just found out her husband has been having an affair. I won’t go into how she found out but she found out as opposed to him owning up to her. It’s over now - I’m unsure if it’s because she found out or if it had ended anyway. She wants to work through it and stay with him and I’m trying to support her but I am so angry with him - like SO angry. I can’t believe he could do this to her because she is genuinely one of the loveliest people you could ever meet and she just doesn’t deserve this. I love her so much that I want to (and to a large extent feel like I have to) support her in what she chooses to do, but I’m just not sure I can be normal around him knowing what he’s done to her. It has totally clouded my view of him and I don’t want to add to her hurt but I can’t see how I’ll be able to act normally around him next time I see him. He doesn’t know I know. My DH and I are usually quite pally with him and would ordinarily send each other jokes etc and I haven’t got in touch with him at all since I found out. We are due to go for dinner all together in a week - planned for a long time - and I’m absolutely dreading it.

AIBU to cancel the dinner? I’m really trying to not make this about me and be there for my friend but I don’t want to make her feel awkward by being off around her DH. She is very much acting like nothing has happened and downplaying things and is trying to move on - which is a whole other issue entirely. WWYD?

OP posts:
MassiveOvaryaction · 08/11/2026 09:12

I wouldn't assume that just because she appears for now to have decided they'll stay together that she's completely forgiven him and got past what he's done.

I think if she's that good a friend you should call her and tell her what worries you about meeting up as a 4. Maybe you could change it to just the 2 of you? Or invite additional friends along to take the pressure off a bit?

Magicpaintbrush · 08/11/2026 09:12

Don't back away from your friend as some people are suggesting (wtf!!) she hasn't done anything wrong. She is going to be in shock right now and will be processing this betrayal for YEARS. Right now she can't imagine a life without him, she may change her mind given time once she's got her head around it. I stayed with my DH after his infidelity and it was the right choice - never seen a man so filled with shame and remorse, and he always put me first after that. It was a turning point and our last few years together before he died of cancer were the best of our married life, we were rock solid. If my friends had backed off during that initial time post discovery though it would have broken me.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 09:11

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 09:10

I wouldn't be able to hold in my opinions for a whole dinner.
I would tell her why though. If my friends don't want me to be loyal and stand up for them they shouldn't be my friend to be honest. If I think someone is treating them badly I won't last long pretending they are forgiven. It is her issue to forgive but that doesn't mean you also have to pander to him. She should also respect your right to decide who is a dick.

Being loyal and standing up for a friend is supporting them in their decision not judging them for it.

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 09:10

I wouldn't be able to hold in my opinions for a whole dinner.
I would tell her why though. If my friends don't want me to be loyal and stand up for them they shouldn't be my friend to be honest. If I think someone is treating them badly I won't last long pretending they are forgiven. It is her issue to forgive but that doesn't mean you also have to pander to him. She should also respect your right to decide who is a dick.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 09:09

I can see from your post that you recognise it has to be your friend's decision as to how she handles this, however much you think she is letting herself in for heartache in the longer term. You are 100% right - the only viable option if you want to remain friends is to support her - if you don't, you will alienate her and nor will you be re-embraced and thanked for your foresight two years down the line if he cheats again.

With that in mind, the only way forward is to tolerate her husband. There is nothing wrong in saying to your friend beforehand: "I feel angry at your husband on your behalf, and be aware that might show in the way I interact with him". You need make no apologies for that! You need do no more than be civil to him, you don't have to be pally.

He is in no position to complain if people are 'off' with him and if he feels genuine remorse he will accept that. If he's not happy, that's not your problem. You can support your friend but it's up to her to navigate things between her husband and herself that might have changed as a result of his affair.

researchers3 · 08/11/2026 09:07

StillTheChickenRun · 08/11/2026 05:15

Your feelings are entirely valid and while you’re supporting your friend, you are still an important person. Don’t put yourself in unnecessary situations you’ll find extremely difficult, it’s not worth it.

If your DH doesn’t currently know, how will you handle his questions about your change in behaviour?

I’d tell your friend you don’t think you’d be able to hide your anger from the whole table and if your DH asked what was going on you wouldn’t want to lie.

FWIW, when a friend of mine was minimising her abusive partner/father of her child, I refused to play along at birthdays etc and absented myself. Years later she said she was hurt by everyone else acting as if nothing was wrong and appreciated my refusal to play nicely with him — despite that being what she said she wanted.

Respect yourself and your feelings.

I agree with this.
Tell your friend you can't be around him right now but you're still there for her.

It's quite likely their marriage won't last and that she doesn't know everything yet.

She'll definitely need you, no matter how it plays out.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 09:07

KiwiFall · 08/11/2026 09:05

In the current situation I couldn’t go and be pally with the husband. But then I’m not one for secrets so I would have told my husband so he could keep the husband busy talking to him so I don’t have to talk to him myself. But I wouldn’t be able to keep my mouth shut and not tell your friends husband that I know and how I feel about him hurting my friend.

I think I would have to just meet up with your friend separately and let the men just meet up. I would be honest with your friend and say you can’t pretend everything is fine given what he’s done to her.

And that would make it all about you and how you feel and would make things worse for your friend.
Maybe think about that.

Ghostlyfeet · 08/11/2026 09:06

This is so sad. I’d be devastated that my husband has cheated and now my best friend is debating whether to still be my friend because of the decisions I’ve made? Decisions that may not even stick. How horrible for your friend.

KiwiFall · 08/11/2026 09:05

In the current situation I couldn’t go and be pally with the husband. But then I’m not one for secrets so I would have told my husband so he could keep the husband busy talking to him so I don’t have to talk to him myself. But I wouldn’t be able to keep my mouth shut and not tell your friends husband that I know and how I feel about him hurting my friend.

I think I would have to just meet up with your friend separately and let the men just meet up. I would be honest with your friend and say you can’t pretend everything is fine given what he’s done to her.

baftaagain · 08/11/2026 09:05

Don't go, it will be hideous.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 09:03

SkateHaddockCod · 08/11/2026 08:58

I don't think enabling her to gaslight herself is actually being a good friend. So I disagree with the view that you should just go along to the dinner and pretend.

In this situation, I'd have a gentle but honest conversation with her and say that you're there to support her first and foremost but it's unrealistic to pretend nothing has happened, especially whilst she's still in the early days of trying to process it all. That him cheating is between them and is their business, but an atmosphere of secrecy and pretending isn't healthy or good for friendships either.

So I would suggest you cancel the dinner and that the two of you go out for a meal on your own so you can check in with her and give her a safe space to talk or not talk about how she's doing. That would be a much more healthy and productive friendship than sitting there helping her to gaslight herself.

She sounds like she's in deep denial and a friend who can gently give her support to process it in a more healthy way would be worth their weight in gold.

The friend might not want to go out with the OP and talk about it all.
Not yet and maybe not ever. She may regret telling the OP at all.

The OP just needs to be guided by her friend and act accordingly. If she wants to keep the friendship.
How her friend is behaving now is not necessarily how she will always behave.

Tamaragoldengirl · 08/11/2026 09:02

I would go. I would be there for my friend and be the friend she needs right here and now. Affairs happens. Also to good people. People survive them. Life is not black and white.

Useyourfork · 08/11/2026 09:02

If I felt as strongly as you then I couldn’t go. I would be honest why. It just isn’t right being asked to play pretend happy families. For goodness sake, having dinner with friends is supposed to be enjoyable.
Be supportive for sure, if she is a good friend she wouldn’t expect you to ‘fake it’ and play along.

justasking111 · 08/11/2026 09:01

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 04:21

I’d show up and just stare at him tbh, you don’t actually know if she will actually be able to stay with him long term. I think affairs just poison a relationship to the point where for most even if they try they would struggle to trust.

This.

She will try hard to forgive. But it's going to be a very bumpy road for her. If you can't act normally then cancel.

Take just her out Christmas shopping and for a lunch would be my advice.

CleanSkin · 08/11/2026 09:01

I’d talk to your friend about how you feel, before going.
Make sure she is aware of your love & support for her & the position she has effectively put you in.
But she will need a friend, a true friend who will be honest with her. Be that friend.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 09:00

Toomanywomen · 08/11/2026 08:56

Similar situation years ago. I refused to socialise with the husband, if I did see him I’d let him know exactly what I thought of him. My friendship suffered massively, she told me she felt unsupported and would hesitate to discuss things with me in future. They stayed together and I had to back down. We’re all fine now but I’d definitely have reacted differently in hindsight.

Thank you for this.

As someone who was in the OP's friend's position at one point, I just needed people to be there for me, support my actions (however misguided they were at the time) and not make things any more difficult than they already were.
I found my way out of the marriage eventually but it took time and I had to work through it.
What would have made it worse would be friends sitting in judgement while I did so.

Whatever the friend has told you, OP, there will be way more going on behind the scenes and there probably will have been for a long time.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 08:59

SL2924 · 08/11/2026 08:53

Some of the advice on here is truly awful. Do not back away from your friend- she needs you! So what if she’s in denial? So what if she’s trying to pretend everything’s ok? That’s a totally normal way to process something so catastrophic happening in your life: give her time. You have no idea how things will work themselves out. And I would go to the dinner. Be civil and just do your best. It’s important for her and for maintaining your friendship. We can all manage a little discomfort from time to time for those we love.

Absolutely. I wonder if she knew how judgemental the friend she confided in is.

SkateHaddockCod · 08/11/2026 08:58

I don't think enabling her to gaslight herself is actually being a good friend. So I disagree with the view that you should just go along to the dinner and pretend.

In this situation, I'd have a gentle but honest conversation with her and say that you're there to support her first and foremost but it's unrealistic to pretend nothing has happened, especially whilst she's still in the early days of trying to process it all. That him cheating is between them and is their business, but an atmosphere of secrecy and pretending isn't healthy or good for friendships either.

So I would suggest you cancel the dinner and that the two of you go out for a meal on your own so you can check in with her and give her a safe space to talk or not talk about how she's doing. That would be a much more healthy and productive friendship than sitting there helping her to gaslight herself.

She sounds like she's in deep denial and a friend who can gently give her support to process it in a more healthy way would be worth their weight in gold.

Toomanywomen · 08/11/2026 08:56

Similar situation years ago. I refused to socialise with the husband, if I did see him I’d let him know exactly what I thought of him. My friendship suffered massively, she told me she felt unsupported and would hesitate to discuss things with me in future. They stayed together and I had to back down. We’re all fine now but I’d definitely have reacted differently in hindsight.

Sophue · 08/11/2026 08:56

KaitlynFairchild · 08/11/2026 03:34

For your friend's sake, I would go. In your place, I wouldn't be happy, and would need to stick to fizzy water all night to avoid saying anything, but at least she would see she has friends who are there for her. If all her friends decide to avoid her and the lying bastard because of the awkwardness, that could leave her isolated - and with him.

I feel the same. If your husband doesn’t know it won’t be awkward for him, just for you. As difficult as it might be for you, it’s showing your friend that you are standing by her even if you don’t agree with her decision.

saraclara · 08/11/2026 08:54

It seems that there are many people (including OP) in this thread who have never held a job where they had to be perfectly pleasant to someone who they hate/are angry with/profoundly disagree with.

Of course anyone can sit politely through a meal with someone they would love to put straight, if they choose to. Especially for someone else's sake. Will it be enjoyable? No. But anyone who says that they wouldn't be able to do this, is putting themselves first and centre, instead of the friend they say they love.

If this was a casual meal, having a well timed cold or stomach upset might be okay. But if this was planned long ago, it's likely to be marking some kind of occasion, so I think you should go, and put on your best performance @Angryfriend33 .

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 08:54

RoundRedRobin · 08/11/2026 08:28

There’s a atmosphere because a husband decided to have sex with another woman.

He betrayed his wife.

Its not up to the op to make things normal.

Let’s not minimise betrayal.

Have you been cheated on? Have you been where the friend is?
It's not about "minimising betrayal" at all or sitting in judgement on what the husband has done.

Of course cheating is absolutely sh*t, we all know it.
But when it happens to you I can tell you from direct experience that you don't always behave the way you think you will.

The OP's friend's behaviour right now will be driven by shock, extreme hurt and fear.

What she seems to need in this moment while she regroups is for the people around her to act normally. It's what she needs and is asking for so her best friend does that without judgment.
Not because she agrees with the husband, not to minimise his behaviour but simply because in this f**king awful moment in her life it's what her friend needs.

Stanstanstan · 08/11/2026 08:54

SL2924 · 08/11/2026 08:53

Some of the advice on here is truly awful. Do not back away from your friend- she needs you! So what if she’s in denial? So what if she’s trying to pretend everything’s ok? That’s a totally normal way to process something so catastrophic happening in your life: give her time. You have no idea how things will work themselves out. And I would go to the dinner. Be civil and just do your best. It’s important for her and for maintaining your friendship. We can all manage a little discomfort from time to time for those we love.

Agreed

SL2924 · 08/11/2026 08:53

Some of the advice on here is truly awful. Do not back away from your friend- she needs you! So what if she’s in denial? So what if she’s trying to pretend everything’s ok? That’s a totally normal way to process something so catastrophic happening in your life: give her time. You have no idea how things will work themselves out. And I would go to the dinner. Be civil and just do your best. It’s important for her and for maintaining your friendship. We can all manage a little discomfort from time to time for those we love.

ginasevern · 08/11/2026 08:52

She's in shock and if her marriage was otherwise happy, then her instinct is to try to save it. When my DH was unfaithful I cried, I raged with anger and threatened to throw him out but deep down all I really wanted was to turn the clock back. I so desperately wanted everything to be like it was before. It took me maybe a year to realise that this was impossible. Your friend is probably in the same place I was. If you refuse to socialise with both of them whilst she's in this "limbo" state, then you are effectively withdrawing support and punishing her for his sins. I honestly think she will see it that way. But I totally get why it would stick in your gullet to go to dinner with the cheating bastard. Difficult.