Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cancel a dinner with my best friend and her hubby who I know has cheated?

243 replies

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 02:40

I have NC for this.

My best friend has just found out her husband has been having an affair. I won’t go into how she found out but she found out as opposed to him owning up to her. It’s over now - I’m unsure if it’s because she found out or if it had ended anyway. She wants to work through it and stay with him and I’m trying to support her but I am so angry with him - like SO angry. I can’t believe he could do this to her because she is genuinely one of the loveliest people you could ever meet and she just doesn’t deserve this. I love her so much that I want to (and to a large extent feel like I have to) support her in what she chooses to do, but I’m just not sure I can be normal around him knowing what he’s done to her. It has totally clouded my view of him and I don’t want to add to her hurt but I can’t see how I’ll be able to act normally around him next time I see him. He doesn’t know I know. My DH and I are usually quite pally with him and would ordinarily send each other jokes etc and I haven’t got in touch with him at all since I found out. We are due to go for dinner all together in a week - planned for a long time - and I’m absolutely dreading it.

AIBU to cancel the dinner? I’m really trying to not make this about me and be there for my friend but I don’t want to make her feel awkward by being off around her DH. She is very much acting like nothing has happened and downplaying things and is trying to move on - which is a whole other issue entirely. WWYD?

OP posts:
Wondering2026 · 08/11/2026 10:22

You’ve had so many responses I know. But I absolutely feel your predicament and it places such a heavy weight on your friendship.

I would speak to your friend about it, and say I will support you, but only you. I do not want to go to this dinner because my vitriol will be written all over my face, and he will know you’ve told me, and he will know I hate him for it. I cannot pretend.

Like another poster told you, it may affect your friendship if you can’t accept it (and I couldn’t). But at least be honest with your friend about it all, that you want to support her and you love her, but you completely disagree with the decision and until there is a time when you can accept it, you absolutely cannot do things with them as a couple.

Also, he will absolutely do this again.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 10:22

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 10:10

Pandering to a man who cheated so he can save face is not what most women sign up for when they make friends with someone. They are there for the women so that she can get the hell away from these controlling men and teach their children to respect themselves.

No. They’re there for her friend to support her in whatever choice she makes. Friendship is not conditional on one party dictating the other’s behaviour and decisions.

diddl · 08/11/2026 10:20

But as an adult, why can't she control her feelings?
I don't get this nonsense about "I just couldn't lie" etc etc.

I think there's a difference though between telling him what you think of him & pretending all is as it was.

Even just being civil/polite will cause an atmosphere when things are usually friendly.

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 10:10

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 09:53

But as an adult, why can't she control her feelings?
I don't get this nonsense about "I just couldn't lie" etc etc.
It's a bit pathetic really
Right now, unless the friend cancels the dinner then it's up to the OP to show up, fake it a bit and support her friend if that's what the friend needs.
It really isn't as hard as everyone here is making it out to be.

Who knows what will happen further down the line but it's the friend who is going through this NOT the OP.

Pandering to a man who cheated so he can save face is not what most women sign up for when they make friends with someone. They are there for the women so that she can get the hell away from these controlling men and teach their children to respect themselves.

Lifealwaysgetsbetter · 08/11/2026 10:05

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 04:13

Honestly, this feels like a mine field and o genuinely don’t know what to think, say or do. The most important thing to me is her and our friendship, so I don’t want to do anything that could jeopardise that. I also know I need to be careful what I say to her about him because that could also affect our friendship if they are able to move past this.

I’m really worried she’s forgiven too much too quickly. It’s almost like within days of finding out she had decided to make a go of things and that to her, that meant pretending nothing has happened. She’s already asked me to forget she said anything - I said I wouldn’t bring it up unnecessarily but that I couldn’t and wouldn’t forget it had happened and neither should she. I think this is all another reason I’m reluctant to go to the dinner - I think she’ll be acting like everything is fine and normal and not like her husband hasn’t been seeing another woman for the last few weeks/ months.

I really don’t know how to be a good friend here - do I try and play devils advocate and make her understand the enormity of what he’s done or play along with the ‘everything’s fine, pretend nothing’s happened’ line?

I’d talk to her and tell her how you feel - that you’re angry with him and want to support her but by meeting him you can’t act normal just now. Your feelings will change if he genuinely is remorseful. Alternatively you could suggest she tells him that you know. There’s nothing wrong with her having told her best friend for support and why should you be forced to pretend everything is fine. Your feelings are completely normal..

if this sounds like too much drama, just make an excuse that you’re not feeling great..

Claptrapp · 08/11/2026 10:02

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 03:38

This all is exactly along the lines of what I’ve been thinking. I don’t think anyone else knows so that shouldn’t be a problem but I don’t want to desert her at an already awful point in her life

I totally disagree with those saying walk away from the friendship. I think if you think you could manage to get through a really uncomfortable evening, then do it because sometimes we have to put others first despite feeling really uncomfortable ourselves. Because that's what you do for people you love.

I think you're an incredible friend, I also think that your friend shouldn't really be asking you to do this as despite her understandably wanting everything to be "normal and how it always was", it won't be, not for a long time, maybe never again, so she shouldn't really be putting you in this position. Hopefully in future you can steer the friendship towards socialising just you and her.

You're a bigger 'man' than me if you can grin and bear it, but if you can endure it for your friend's sake, she's very lucky to have you. Friendships like yours should never be taken for granted. 💐

ETA Don't feel like a bad friend if you can't endure it, just make an excuse and if it keeps coming up, keep making excuses until she takes the hint that you want to see her, not her horrible cheating DH.

RaspberryCoffeePot · 08/11/2026 10:00

Angryfriend33 · 08/11/2026 02:40

I have NC for this.

My best friend has just found out her husband has been having an affair. I won’t go into how she found out but she found out as opposed to him owning up to her. It’s over now - I’m unsure if it’s because she found out or if it had ended anyway. She wants to work through it and stay with him and I’m trying to support her but I am so angry with him - like SO angry. I can’t believe he could do this to her because she is genuinely one of the loveliest people you could ever meet and she just doesn’t deserve this. I love her so much that I want to (and to a large extent feel like I have to) support her in what she chooses to do, but I’m just not sure I can be normal around him knowing what he’s done to her. It has totally clouded my view of him and I don’t want to add to her hurt but I can’t see how I’ll be able to act normally around him next time I see him. He doesn’t know I know. My DH and I are usually quite pally with him and would ordinarily send each other jokes etc and I haven’t got in touch with him at all since I found out. We are due to go for dinner all together in a week - planned for a long time - and I’m absolutely dreading it.

AIBU to cancel the dinner? I’m really trying to not make this about me and be there for my friend but I don’t want to make her feel awkward by being off around her DH. She is very much acting like nothing has happened and downplaying things and is trying to move on - which is a whole other issue entirely. WWYD?

Cancel. Otherwise you are being forced to act unnaturally and why should you. Be honest with your friend. Say you'll see her but not him. If she gets funny about it or he does then just cut them off. You shouldnt be expected to have your strings pulled by somebody else's mess. If necessary, have it out with him and let rip.. They made theor bed and can lie on it and you dont have to get in it with them.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 09:56

RottenApplesSpoilTheLot · 08/11/2026 09:42

This @Angryfriend33 - please support your friend. My BF did exactly the same- and they had a further 25yrs together, she had no regrets about giving the marriage a second chance.

Speaking personally, from a different POV, when my marriage was ending (his choice) and we were trying to remain friendly for the DC, one of my oldest friends was VILE to my husband, rude, refusing to talk to him when he asked how she was etc. I never forgave HER for that. She saw it as "sticking up for me" - what she was actually doing was making a very difficult situation even harder. ExH and I did get through it as friends - 15yrs later we have both moved on and are happy.

Thank you. Exactly this!
I am so glad that when it happened to me, none of my friends or even family sat in judgement particularly for my kids' sake.

They were guided by me and what I needed.

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 09:53

KiwiFall · 08/11/2026 09:39

But If she can’t lie and pretend everything is okay it will be glaringly obvious at the dinner something is wrong. That’s when both husbands will ask what’s wrong. It may then blow up at the dinner. Isn’t that worse given the friend wants everything to go on as if nothing has happened?

But as an adult, why can't she control her feelings?
I don't get this nonsense about "I just couldn't lie" etc etc.
It's a bit pathetic really
Right now, unless the friend cancels the dinner then it's up to the OP to show up, fake it a bit and support her friend if that's what the friend needs.
It really isn't as hard as everyone here is making it out to be.

Who knows what will happen further down the line but it's the friend who is going through this NOT the OP.

Macinae · 08/11/2026 09:48

I think you can maintain your relationship with your friend by seeing her one on one, without having to put yourself through sitting down with her "D"H at a fake happy dinner. It's too soon to expect you to act like everything is normal after sharing this news with you. I agree with PP's who said you can support your friend without being around the husband, certainly for the time being.

RottenApplesSpoilTheLot · 08/11/2026 09:42

ClairDeLaLune · 08/11/2026 09:33

I have been in exactly your position except that the husband knew I knew. I went to the dinner. I did it because it’s what my friend wanted, and I wanted to support her. Twenty years on and they’re still together, we’re still friends, and their marriage seems strong with no repeat of what happened before.

Do I regret my stance? 100% not. It wasn’t about me, it was about her.

This @Angryfriend33 - please support your friend. My BF did exactly the same- and they had a further 25yrs together, she had no regrets about giving the marriage a second chance.

Speaking personally, from a different POV, when my marriage was ending (his choice) and we were trying to remain friendly for the DC, one of my oldest friends was VILE to my husband, rude, refusing to talk to him when he asked how she was etc. I never forgave HER for that. She saw it as "sticking up for me" - what she was actually doing was making a very difficult situation even harder. ExH and I did get through it as friends - 15yrs later we have both moved on and are happy.

graceinspace999 · 08/11/2026 09:40

tartyflette · 08/11/2026 03:34

I’d cancel the foursome but could you and your friend go out together soon, just the two of you?

Yes. I’d endeavour to stay a supportive friend but I’d keep away from him as much as possible without isolating her.

I’ve had several uncomfortable experiences with friend’s husbands trying it on with me so my default position is permanently polite but never pally.

KiwiFall · 08/11/2026 09:39

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 09:07

And that would make it all about you and how you feel and would make things worse for your friend.
Maybe think about that.

But If she can’t lie and pretend everything is okay it will be glaringly obvious at the dinner something is wrong. That’s when both husbands will ask what’s wrong. It may then blow up at the dinner. Isn’t that worse given the friend wants everything to go on as if nothing has happened?

Melsy88 · 08/11/2026 09:38

I'd try to get into the mentality of 'i'm annoyed that this man has hurt my friend but I value her and her decisions enough to support her if she wants to try to move on'.

You can even say that to her. Then you're letting her know that you're on her side and sad that this has happened but respect her enough to let her make the best decision for her.

If you go in all guns blazing, annoyed with her for staying with him etc all you are doing is saying your opinions are more valid than hers. And that may make her pull away from you, and as a minimum be reluctant to tell you if something like this happens again.

I know a couple who came back from a cheating incident. 20 years and 2 kids later and they are one of the happiest couples I know. People can make mistakes and turn things back around.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 08/11/2026 09:38

ClairDeLaLune · 08/11/2026 09:33

I have been in exactly your position except that the husband knew I knew. I went to the dinner. I did it because it’s what my friend wanted, and I wanted to support her. Twenty years on and they’re still together, we’re still friends, and their marriage seems strong with no repeat of what happened before.

Do I regret my stance? 100% not. It wasn’t about me, it was about her.

This man knows the OP knows.
For the OP’s friend’s sake, everyone is just pretending not to. She wants to pretend it never happened.
She’s waist deep in denial.

I’d definitely tell my husband. Why leave him out of this so-called subterfuge.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 08/11/2026 09:35

VelociraptorsVelociRapping · 08/11/2026 08:14

I wouldn’t go. If you are right that she is trying to paper over the cracks and downplay everything then she wants you there to help with the overall pretence and I couldn’t collude with that. This kind of betrayal has wide-reaching consequences beyond the marriage and it’s not helpful in the long term to protect either party from that. Cancel the dinner and tell her why.

When they run up, who knows what will happen?!

Love your username. Love a bit of Storybots.

ClairDeLaLune · 08/11/2026 09:33

I have been in exactly your position except that the husband knew I knew. I went to the dinner. I did it because it’s what my friend wanted, and I wanted to support her. Twenty years on and they’re still together, we’re still friends, and their marriage seems strong with no repeat of what happened before.

Do I regret my stance? 100% not. It wasn’t about me, it was about her.

MoreCheeseEverywhere · 08/11/2026 09:31

BeeHive909 · 08/11/2026 03:34

I wouldn’t go to the dinner but I would also back away from my friend. She’s chosen to stay with him and until you can accept it you can’t be friends. She clearly wants to move on sadly

@BeeHive909 WOW.

One of my oldest and closest friends adopted this approach when my ex cheated on me. Having to cope with the loss of a once dear friend on top of the loss of my marriage was utterly devastating. This is the cruellest advice.

Neuronimo · 08/11/2026 09:27

I'd cancel, but I'd want to put something nice inthe diary for just you and her.

PoliteSquid · 08/11/2026 09:24

I am very outspoken against people like this man. Cheating is a hard red line for me. However, in this circumstance I would go to dinner. This isn’t about you, this is about supporting your best friend who must be feeling incredibly sad and vulnerable. You don’t have to be pally with him, but be civil for your friend’s sake.

I was on a similar situation and other friends asked why I was even speaking to the man. But I saw him everyday on the school run and their very young children would have noticed if I stopped chatting at the school gate! It wasn’t about me, it was about being a constant for my friend and her children.

Bigtrapeze · 08/11/2026 09:20

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 07:57

You couldn't fake a single dinner for your best friend's sake? Really?
If that is what she wanted and needed from you in a terrible moment in her life?

Fake isn't my strongest suit. I think it would be obvious all wasn't well, so I don't think it would be advisable. I think I'd need time for the dust to settle. I don't think I have a friend who would be up for this level of subterfuge either, with only my DH genuinely not knowing something was going on. OP, and you, might be much better at all this than me, so it might be a slightly strained evening but my face would struggle to do cheerful or normal in these circumstances, sadly. If OP finds this hard, I get it.

mmmarmalade · 08/11/2026 09:17

@Angryfriend33 you talk to your friend about this - it's not rocket science! Tell her how much you care about her and how upset you are and about how you will struggle to be around him then ask her how she wants you be about this. I don't see why just the 2 of you can't make the date on your own - surely she can tell her lowlife husband to take a back seat while she prioritises what she wants to do. Has she told her husband that you know about this? I think she should - she's got nothing to be ashamed of... unlike her "DH" DH. I'd feel uncontrollable anger too and wouldn't be able to make small talk but I'd find out what my friend really wants from me. Reacting badly in open conversation with her husband may feel like a criticism of her decision to try and work through it (which you probably have an opinion on that you want to express to her) - it might drive a wedge between the two of you so you've got to ask her how she wants you to (try and) handle it. I feel the pain of your dilemma though.

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 09:15

SkateHaddockCod · 08/11/2026 09:13

I said she (the friend) could talk or not talk about it, but the important point is that the OP is offering a safe space for her away from any further drama of forced meet ups and playing pretend.

Being a good friend isn't just blindly going along with unhealthy behaviour. It's being authentic and supportive but not adding pressure. The planned dinner is a powder keg that could blow up in all their faces. The friend just can't see that now.

Exactly, she just wants to go back to how it was and fake normalcy. It is a reaction to the trauma he has inflicted and will wear off.

SkateHaddockCod · 08/11/2026 09:13

dragonflygold · 08/11/2026 09:03

The friend might not want to go out with the OP and talk about it all.
Not yet and maybe not ever. She may regret telling the OP at all.

The OP just needs to be guided by her friend and act accordingly. If she wants to keep the friendship.
How her friend is behaving now is not necessarily how she will always behave.

I said she (the friend) could talk or not talk about it, but the important point is that the OP is offering a safe space for her away from any further drama of forced meet ups and playing pretend.

Being a good friend isn't just blindly going along with unhealthy behaviour. It's being authentic and supportive but not adding pressure. The planned dinner is a powder keg that could blow up in all their faces. The friend just can't see that now.

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 09:13

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 09:11

Being loyal and standing up for a friend is supporting them in their decision not judging them for it.

I don't agree. At some point she will recognise he is a cheater and that she can't just brush this under the table and "forget" he has fucked up their life. That is when people who have pandered to him despite his awful behaviour will have shown themselves up as people of dubious morals and boundaries.

I would avoid the dinner for sure as it is an unreasonable ask, but letting her know you back her 100% is the main point.