Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end this friendship?

161 replies

Coldcalmcollected · 07/11/2026 17:35

I’m being asked to support someone and I can’t. It’s a long one.

Basically, my friend was in a long-term relationship with my BIL (DH’s brother), they met through me. She has always known that he did not want any more children (he has 2 with his ex-wife). She has, until recently, been fine with it- at least publicly. Obviously, I cannot know if she has secretly harboured other wishes but she has never given this impression (and, in previous relationships says she did not want children, so I’m inclined to think this is a change of heart). According to BIL, he has always been 100% clear that he does not want any more children and has never suggested he might change his mind- until recently she has never suggested she was unhappy with this situation. However, recently she decided she does want children. BIL’s view remained unchanged.

A few months ago friend had an “oops” pregnancy- I believe she deliberately stopped contraception without saying so (I.e. planned a pregnancy) based on something she said to me and my other SIL- but she quickly backtracked when both of us were fairly horrified at the “sometimes you just have to make it happen, if you get what I mean” comment.

I would agree she has the right to stop contraception any time she likes, but she should be honest with her partner as it’s a mutual thing if no contraception is being used. Equally, I think both parties have to accept contraceptive failures do happen. But deliberately not using it without saying so is utterly wrong and a huge betrayal of trust, in my opinion.

BIL had a vasectomy very quickly (privately) after he found out his partner was pregnant- against her wishes- as he was adamant he does not want more children. I think he probably should have done it sooner, but equally don’t think it unreasonable that he trusted his partner to take the agreed contraceptive. He was accepting of a contraceptive failure, though he was honest about the fact that he was not keen to keep the baby. He was obviously prepared to shoulder his responsibility to the baby, despite his lack of enthusiasm. I think this is totally reasonable.

Sadly, friend had a miscarriage at 14 weeks. She was, and is, devastated by the miscarriage. I do feel for her- despite the circumstances- and I know BIL’s palpable relief at the outcome probably made it harder for her. But, equally, I think he is entitled to his own feelings and never pretended he was excited to be a father again. Obviously, I have never said that to her- that is just my thoughts.

Anyway, I’d said to DH about what she’s said and that I thought this was very off. DH also thought that what she said was suspicious. It seems other SIL also told her husband. After he thought about it for a short period, he spoke to his other brother- and both decided to speak to BIL. This was around the same time friend miscarried. He told DH he had some suspicions but given events had decided to give her the benefit of the doubt (especially as it cannot happen again).

Anyway, he was devastated to have his suspicions supported and that his partner would do this- he confronted her. According to him she initially denied it, but eventually said she had accidentally messed up her contraception but had just not said anything, so it wasn’t planned in advance (he doesn’t really believe this and thinks it was a very deliberate choice, probably been the case for some time). However, even if it was a one-off slip, she still chose not to say anything which might have meant BIL would have used a condom or abstained- she apparently admitted to him that she thought he would have done one of those things if he had known the reality of the situation. He has ended their relationship. As they aren’t married, she is going to be in a significantly worse financial situation as she has no claim on any assets or their home.

I am in an awkward situation- I do feel sorry for her as she is understandably struggling with the miscarriage, the end of her relationship but equally think she has behaved terribly towards her ex-partner, who is a member of my family. She’s furious with me/us, but equally wanting support and for me to “speak to” BIL to convince him to give her a second chance.

I genuinely can’t do the latter- I think it’s not only not my place, I believe he is right to end the relationship. I can’t apologise for the former, as I don’t think it was fair to ask me to keep this to myself. In short, I don’t really think I am the right person for her to lean on right now. I think our friendship is essentially over. I think it was over the minute she admitted what she had done- I feel that if she understood me, she should have known what I’d think about her actions, and how I’d feel about being asked to keep it to myself when it is a member of my family impacted. I genuinely do not know why she told us/suggested this if she did not want anyone else to know.

Her mother contacted me to say how much friend is struggling and how worried she is about her mental health, and also how disappointed she is that I haven’t been there more for her. The thing is, my friend just wants to rant about what a POS he is to have dumped her weeks after a miscarriage, making her leave their home etc. our friendship group is split- I’d say 3/4 agree what she did was utterly repugnant, and she put myself and other SIL in an awkward situation by telling us and expecting us to say nothing. The others feel that what she did “wasn’t ideal” but that she doesn’t deserve to lose her relationship, home etc over it and the miscarriage should have bought her some grace. This is going to cause problems in our group. I’m ok with this, although I am
sad as we’ve been friends for a long time, as others are entitled to their views.

I do feel sorry for her regarding the miscarriage, but I also think she is the author of her own misfortune and will have to live with the consequences of her actions. Her actions have absolutely rocked BIL too- he feels utterly betrayed, and is finding the violation of trust really hard to come to terms with. I just can’t pretend I’m ok with what has happened. AIBU?

OP posts:
4500kj · 08/11/2026 11:23

OP is hardly over involved by choice.

1.horrible friend openly admitted her (morally reprehensible) actions in front of OP and SIL. SIL told her husband, so if even if OP hadn’t said anything, the information was still being passed through the family and OP would’ve damaged her own relationship with her husband. I can’t be the only one who sees loyalty to husband > loyalty to friends. Information that isn’t relevant to him (eg jane is considering quitting her job) is none of his business, information about someone knowingly baby trapping his brother? I’d say that’s relevant.

2.horrible friend is still trying to get OP in the middle by contacting BIL on her behalf. I’m sorry she had a miscarriage, but some self reflection here would tell you that this relationship is irreconcilably broken and they are fundamentally incompatible. Friend clearly wants children and BIL had a vasectomy. When friend can be rational, she might realise this breakup is for the best.

MissJoGrant · 08/11/2026 11:04

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 07/11/2026 17:45

I think you’re way too involved here, and that passing on something she told you to your DH was an outrageous betrayal of confidence. Basically, this is the mess you get when you interfere.

It's unreasonable to expect someone to keep secrets like that from their husband/wife, especially when it involves their sibling.

Menier · 08/11/2026 11:02

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 07/11/2026 17:45

I think you’re way too involved here, and that passing on something she told you to your DH was an outrageous betrayal of confidence. Basically, this is the mess you get when you interfere.

This.
Unfortunately given the info in your post you are all too involved, but it's probably too late to do anything about that now.
If the tables were turned how would you feel?

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 10:58

MrsShawnHatosy · 08/11/2026 10:54

Yes you’re right sorry. But she still abused his trust.

Oh, I absolutely agree.

I think really, given the fact that the friend keeps hoping OP will act as a go-between, for everyone's sake, it's best if OP steps back from the friendship and explains she thinks they both need some distance for a while.

Passingthroughagain · 08/11/2026 10:55

Hoardasurass · 08/11/2026 10:45

Well you clearly haven't bothered to read any of the OPs posts otherwise you would know that you've just made up an entire false story.
The ex friend was never married to the bil and made her admission to both of her partners sil and both women told their husbands, it was the two brothers who decided to tell the third brother what his partner did to him.
Why do you want to blame everyone except the only guilty person ie the ex friend

It's not entirely false. The married bit is incorrect, but OP told her DH knowing he would intervene. And OP has judged her friend in every single comment she's put on this thread.

Yes, the friend is the guilty party, no question. She did a really stupid, awful and distrustful thing and it's right the relationship ended. But a bit of compassion wouldn't go amiss either. Her DP dumped her either just before she miscarried or during and then didn't bother to hide his relief that their baby was no more. He's not the prize catch OP seems to think he is.

whippersnapper55 · 08/11/2026 10:55

I suppose it depends on how good friends you are. She did a stupid and dangerous thing but she has paid a heavy price for that and she is struggling. She's not the first, and won't be the last to have an 'accidental' pregnancy - I think the drive to have a baby can be very strong and even stop you thinking rationally. She probably thought once the baby is here, he'll love it and it'll all be ok.

She's lost a baby and that is a difficult loss to bear, especially when you know your partner is relieved and not devastated as you are. If you are close friends, I wouldn't be able to turn away from her at such a difficult time for her. Yes, she made a terrible mistake but that doesn't negate years of friendship. The very best thing about lifelong friends is that they've seen you at your worst, know the things you've said and done that you're not proud of, and they still love you.

I would meet with her and have a heart to heart - tell her what you're struggling with and that you're finding it hard to feel supportive when you feel she has done something really wrong and that it has impacted your husband's family and divided your loyalties. If she's a good friend, she'll be able to see it from your side as well. You can think she's behaved badly and still feel sympathy for the situation she's in.

5128gap · 08/11/2026 10:54

Hoardasurass · 08/11/2026 10:45

Well you clearly haven't bothered to read any of the OPs posts otherwise you would know that you've just made up an entire false story.
The ex friend was never married to the bil and made her admission to both of her partners sil and both women told their husbands, it was the two brothers who decided to tell the third brother what his partner did to him.
Why do you want to blame everyone except the only guilty person ie the ex friend

Marriage/long term committed relationship, tomayto/tomato.
I know well that the brothers were the ones who actually told him. However the OP and other SiL told them, and unless they had no idea of their husbands characters would have had a good idea what the outcome of that would be.
I'm not 'blaming' anyone. Merely pointing out that the OPs friend is asking for her support believing OP to be in her corner. To leave her in the dark as to OPs own actions and views is disingenuous.

MrsShawnHatosy · 08/11/2026 10:54

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 10:36

It seems as though she did tell him. In the OP: until recently she has never suggested she was unhappy with this situation. However, recently she decided she does want children. BIL’s view remained unchanged.

This seems to imply she told him, and he didn't change his mind?

Yes you’re right sorry. But she still abused his trust.

Hoardasurass · 08/11/2026 10:45

5128gap · 08/11/2026 10:28

I don't even see the dilemma here. Surely a person with such a strong sense of ethics as you will be nothing but truthful?
"Sorry (former) friend, but given it was me who made sure your husband knew about this in the first place, I'm hardly likely to advocate for you now. I have judged you seven ways till Sunday, am firmly on your husband's side and proactively made sure he knew what you'd done, in full knowledge he may end your marriage. Knowing this, I'm sure you can see that anything I have to say to BiL about this will not be in your interests".
Problem solved.

Well you clearly haven't bothered to read any of the OPs posts otherwise you would know that you've just made up an entire false story.
The ex friend was never married to the bil and made her admission to both of her partners sil and both women told their husbands, it was the two brothers who decided to tell the third brother what his partner did to him.
Why do you want to blame everyone except the only guilty person ie the ex friend

burnoutbabe · 08/11/2026 10:41

Fuckmyliferightnow · 08/11/2026 10:19

What she did was terrible but, if he really didn’t want kids why wasn’t he using condoms? Leaving the responsibility with the woman was not right, especially when he knew for sure he didn’t want kids and she did.
Her deceit is unforgivable though and I would cut her out.

Would any woman want to have sex with a man is who in Effect saying “I don’t trust you enough so I shall wear a condom”. Surely that’s a mode killer on both sides?

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 10:36

MrsShawnHatosy · 08/11/2026 10:31

As far as he was aware she didn’t want children either. She didn’t tell him she’d changed her mind, so why would he think it necessary for him to use condoms?

It seems as though she did tell him. In the OP: until recently she has never suggested she was unhappy with this situation. However, recently she decided she does want children. BIL’s view remained unchanged.

This seems to imply she told him, and he didn't change his mind?

MrsShawnHatosy · 08/11/2026 10:31

Fuckmyliferightnow · 08/11/2026 10:19

What she did was terrible but, if he really didn’t want kids why wasn’t he using condoms? Leaving the responsibility with the woman was not right, especially when he knew for sure he didn’t want kids and she did.
Her deceit is unforgivable though and I would cut her out.

As far as he was aware she didn’t want children either. She didn’t tell him she’d changed her mind, so why would he think it necessary for him to use condoms?

5128gap · 08/11/2026 10:28

I don't even see the dilemma here. Surely a person with such a strong sense of ethics as you will be nothing but truthful?
"Sorry (former) friend, but given it was me who made sure your husband knew about this in the first place, I'm hardly likely to advocate for you now. I have judged you seven ways till Sunday, am firmly on your husband's side and proactively made sure he knew what you'd done, in full knowledge he may end your marriage. Knowing this, I'm sure you can see that anything I have to say to BiL about this will not be in your interests".
Problem solved.

Fuckmyliferightnow · 08/11/2026 10:19

What she did was terrible but, if he really didn’t want kids why wasn’t he using condoms? Leaving the responsibility with the woman was not right, especially when he knew for sure he didn’t want kids and she did.
Her deceit is unforgivable though and I would cut her out.

OtterlyAstounding · 08/11/2026 10:10

Neighull · 08/11/2026 09:42

I never understand the "if he was that bothered he should have worn a condom" thing because outside of one night stands surely you just trust the person youre with?!

Imagine you have to catch a flight and are planning to get a bus to the airport. But then a very close friend says "dont worry, ill drive you. Pick you up at 9."
Imagine she never shows up because she cant be bothered, its too late for you to catch the bus now and you miss your flight.
Is the normal response to this: "youre an adult, you shouldn't have relied on your friend, you should have taken precautions to get yourself to the airport"?
Come the fuck on 😂
If you're dating someone you expect a modicum of integrity surely

It's more similar to expecting your friend to drop you off at the airport on a daily basis, despite them telling you that they've started to resent doing it and would like to stop, and then being surprised when one day they choose to just leave you in the lurch.

Is it good behaviour on their part? Obviously not. But it's also entitled and foolish of you to keep demanding someone else does everything for you, instead of you arranging transport yourself.

MrsShawnHatosy · 08/11/2026 10:09

NeelyOHara · 08/11/2026 09:57

Yeah, I’d still stick by her if she’s a friend, it sounds like her world has fallen apart.
Also, it seems like you worship your BIL a bit, - he can do no wrong at all.

He hasn’t done anything wrong.

MrsShawnHatosy · 08/11/2026 10:08

acron · 07/11/2026 22:58

On the one hand, BIL was totally clear about not wanting more kids. And your friend tricked him by not using contraception correctly, very deliberately. This is very bad behaviour from her.

That said, she was obviously desperate to have a baby. It’s very easy for those of us who have got children with a partner who did want them, to judge a woman who gets into a situation where she desperately wants kids but is with a partner who doesn’t. It must have been driving her crazy.

And a 14 week miscarriage must be utterly devastating, regardless of the circumstances.

But it doesn’t seem like the best person to support her is you. It’s your dh’s brother, he’s done nothing wrong and he’s taken action to get someone who betrayed him out of his life.

Being desperate for a baby does not justify abusing someone else’s trust and body to get one. Women do not have some sort of inalienable right to have a baby by any means and whatever the cost (and I say this as someone who wanted a baby but couldn’t have one due to infertility). She should have treated him with the respect he deserved as her partner and told him she’d changed her mind about wanting children.

NeelyOHara · 08/11/2026 09:57

Dancingspleen1 · 08/11/2026 05:41

I agree with this 100%
It was a terrible misjudgement on her side - she made a huge mistake but she's facing the ramifications now. She must be in a very dark place having lost her baby, partner and now her friend. I wouldn't turn my back on a friend in these circumstances.

Yeah, I’d still stick by her if she’s a friend, it sounds like her world has fallen apart.
Also, it seems like you worship your BIL a bit, - he can do no wrong at all.

Thundertoast · 08/11/2026 09:55

Cannot believe the people on here who are almost defending her and would be very interested to know if they would feel the same if their current DHs previous partner had done something like this to them, or if a woman did this to one of their sons.

Also I dont agree that the miscarriage outweighs everything, because this woman brought what she did up in a casual conversation like it wasnt a big deal, and now she thinks that she should be able to talk BIL back round.
She has no concept of the gravity of her actions. This isnt someone who was so desperate for a baby she lost her mind, this is someone who felt entitled to a baby. If she actually took any of this seriously she would be leaving BIL and the friends alone as she would understand that of course they wouldnt want anything to do with her. Its all about her and what she wants.

5128gap · 08/11/2026 09:53

I think you've all done enough meddling, don't you? She lost the baby, he's had a vasectomy so there is no chance of a repeat, yet you had to wade in and throw another grenade in, and now the marriage is over.
The last people your SiL should be turning to are ones so unwise and interfering. You will be doing her a great favour by ending the friendship.

Hoardasurass · 08/11/2026 09:48

Rainandhail · 07/11/2026 23:17

Totally agree with these posts.

why on earth are you all so involved in another couple’s contraception issues? You’ve said you can’t get involved in helping your friend repair her relationships but you certainly could get involved when you all informed her husband of something she told you in confidence.

All sounds a bit too righteous.

Edited

The op has done nothing wrong, she told her husband the truth that his brother's partner had admitted to her and other sil that she intentionally came off the pill just to get pregnant without telling her partner and knew that he would never have had unprotected sex with her.
If the ex friend was a man she'd would be facing jail for rape by deception. Let that sink in, what she did is that despicable.
There is no coming back from that level of betrayal to a partner.
Oh and if you want to tell someone something in confidence don't brag about it infront of a witness whose only relationship with you is being the sil of your partner

Neighull · 08/11/2026 09:42

Coldcalmcollected · 08/11/2026 08:11

Well, you are condoning what she did by saying it was actually his fault for not having had a vasectomy and what she did was understandable because she changed her mind about wanting a child and he had not.

The fact he did not have a vasectomy made her deception possible, it did not make it acceptable. That’s like saying leaving a window open makes it absolutely fine for someone to break in and commit robbery because you ought to be have been more careful about leaving windows open. Actually, you couldn’t call it robbery or theft, because you had essentially invited everyone to access your home at will and take whatever they wished because you had left that window open. It’s just nonsense.

If consent is important it is always important, not just when it suits a particular narrative. Reproductive coercion is never ok and should not be normalised as acceptable simply because it would seem many women do it. That is distinctly different from genuine contraceptive failures, which can and do happen and both parties have to accept as a possibility. The fact that many women pass off coercion as a contraceptive failure is reprehensible, but it is not a reason to give it a free pass because a woman is the perpetrator.

I just don’t agree that he was wrong to believe his partner would use the form of contraception they had mutually agreed upon. If she was so upset at contraception being “outsourced” to her, she could have said so and then left it to him to sort out. I suspect she was quite happy to use it until she changed her mind about children.

Until quite recently she was fairly clear about the fact she did not want children- so she did not settle- she was with someone who wanted the same as she did. She always knew that this was the case, she was not lied to. She also knew he did not want to get married again- this wasn’t someone who had been lied to and led on with promised of marriage and children “one day”. This is a case of a woman changing her mind- which is her prerogative, of course- but not in any way comparable to being duped from the outset.

I never understand the "if he was that bothered he should have worn a condom" thing because outside of one night stands surely you just trust the person youre with?!

Imagine you have to catch a flight and are planning to get a bus to the airport. But then a very close friend says "dont worry, ill drive you. Pick you up at 9."
Imagine she never shows up because she cant be bothered, its too late for you to catch the bus now and you miss your flight.
Is the normal response to this: "youre an adult, you shouldn't have relied on your friend, you should have taken precautions to get yourself to the airport"?
Come the fuck on 😂
If you're dating someone you expect a modicum of integrity surely

AlertCat · 08/11/2026 09:36

HRTFT just op posts.

@Coldcalmcollected i agree that you can’t be this woman’s friend any more, but for the sake of your long friendship, I would meet her and hear her out- even if you know you won’t change your mind. I might take some information on counsellors or services to give her as well. Just go and meet her for coffee, you can sympathise with the losses she’s going through without agreeing with her actions, or agreeing to speak on her behalf.

After that, she may have a sense of relief at having been heard, and be more able to come to terms with having gambled so hard and lost everything she had.

Laurmolonlabe · 08/11/2026 09:24

True contraceptive failures do happen, but they are far less common than you would imagine from the amount of people that claim them. There are 2 children from such reported failures in my direct family, neither of which was a true contraceptive failure.

burnoutbabe · 08/11/2026 09:13

ThatLemonBee · 07/11/2026 23:57

Your friend has just lost a baby on her second trimester. Having had a miscarriage before I would say her MH trumps anything right now and if you can’t see that then you were never truly her friend . Bol being upset aside ( and I can completely see why by he did what he did) . She is still in need of true friends . If you cannot be one just leave her be but you have never been a friend in the full sense of the world

But it doesn’t seem like the support her friend wants is to support her in this loss.

its to plead her case to the brother in law?

which is very different.