Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end this friendship?

161 replies

Coldcalmcollected · 07/11/2026 17:35

I’m being asked to support someone and I can’t. It’s a long one.

Basically, my friend was in a long-term relationship with my BIL (DH’s brother), they met through me. She has always known that he did not want any more children (he has 2 with his ex-wife). She has, until recently, been fine with it- at least publicly. Obviously, I cannot know if she has secretly harboured other wishes but she has never given this impression (and, in previous relationships says she did not want children, so I’m inclined to think this is a change of heart). According to BIL, he has always been 100% clear that he does not want any more children and has never suggested he might change his mind- until recently she has never suggested she was unhappy with this situation. However, recently she decided she does want children. BIL’s view remained unchanged.

A few months ago friend had an “oops” pregnancy- I believe she deliberately stopped contraception without saying so (I.e. planned a pregnancy) based on something she said to me and my other SIL- but she quickly backtracked when both of us were fairly horrified at the “sometimes you just have to make it happen, if you get what I mean” comment.

I would agree she has the right to stop contraception any time she likes, but she should be honest with her partner as it’s a mutual thing if no contraception is being used. Equally, I think both parties have to accept contraceptive failures do happen. But deliberately not using it without saying so is utterly wrong and a huge betrayal of trust, in my opinion.

BIL had a vasectomy very quickly (privately) after he found out his partner was pregnant- against her wishes- as he was adamant he does not want more children. I think he probably should have done it sooner, but equally don’t think it unreasonable that he trusted his partner to take the agreed contraceptive. He was accepting of a contraceptive failure, though he was honest about the fact that he was not keen to keep the baby. He was obviously prepared to shoulder his responsibility to the baby, despite his lack of enthusiasm. I think this is totally reasonable.

Sadly, friend had a miscarriage at 14 weeks. She was, and is, devastated by the miscarriage. I do feel for her- despite the circumstances- and I know BIL’s palpable relief at the outcome probably made it harder for her. But, equally, I think he is entitled to his own feelings and never pretended he was excited to be a father again. Obviously, I have never said that to her- that is just my thoughts.

Anyway, I’d said to DH about what she’s said and that I thought this was very off. DH also thought that what she said was suspicious. It seems other SIL also told her husband. After he thought about it for a short period, he spoke to his other brother- and both decided to speak to BIL. This was around the same time friend miscarried. He told DH he had some suspicions but given events had decided to give her the benefit of the doubt (especially as it cannot happen again).

Anyway, he was devastated to have his suspicions supported and that his partner would do this- he confronted her. According to him she initially denied it, but eventually said she had accidentally messed up her contraception but had just not said anything, so it wasn’t planned in advance (he doesn’t really believe this and thinks it was a very deliberate choice, probably been the case for some time). However, even if it was a one-off slip, she still chose not to say anything which might have meant BIL would have used a condom or abstained- she apparently admitted to him that she thought he would have done one of those things if he had known the reality of the situation. He has ended their relationship. As they aren’t married, she is going to be in a significantly worse financial situation as she has no claim on any assets or their home.

I am in an awkward situation- I do feel sorry for her as she is understandably struggling with the miscarriage, the end of her relationship but equally think she has behaved terribly towards her ex-partner, who is a member of my family. She’s furious with me/us, but equally wanting support and for me to “speak to” BIL to convince him to give her a second chance.

I genuinely can’t do the latter- I think it’s not only not my place, I believe he is right to end the relationship. I can’t apologise for the former, as I don’t think it was fair to ask me to keep this to myself. In short, I don’t really think I am the right person for her to lean on right now. I think our friendship is essentially over. I think it was over the minute she admitted what she had done- I feel that if she understood me, she should have known what I’d think about her actions, and how I’d feel about being asked to keep it to myself when it is a member of my family impacted. I genuinely do not know why she told us/suggested this if she did not want anyone else to know.

Her mother contacted me to say how much friend is struggling and how worried she is about her mental health, and also how disappointed she is that I haven’t been there more for her. The thing is, my friend just wants to rant about what a POS he is to have dumped her weeks after a miscarriage, making her leave their home etc. our friendship group is split- I’d say 3/4 agree what she did was utterly repugnant, and she put myself and other SIL in an awkward situation by telling us and expecting us to say nothing. The others feel that what she did “wasn’t ideal” but that she doesn’t deserve to lose her relationship, home etc over it and the miscarriage should have bought her some grace. This is going to cause problems in our group. I’m ok with this, although I am
sad as we’ve been friends for a long time, as others are entitled to their views.

I do feel sorry for her regarding the miscarriage, but I also think she is the author of her own misfortune and will have to live with the consequences of her actions. Her actions have absolutely rocked BIL too- he feels utterly betrayed, and is finding the violation of trust really hard to come to terms with. I just can’t pretend I’m ok with what has happened. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RubyRuse · Yesterday 12:39

Coldcalmcollected · Yesterday 10:39

I’’m not sure why you think it’s a “shame they aren’t on the same page”? She knew, from day one, he did not want children. Neither did she, until recently. I think it would have been much wiser for him to have had a vasectomy, of course, but that doesn’t mean he deserved to be have his trust abused and be subject to reproductive coercion. He had accepted the situation, however unenthusiastically, when he believed it to be a contraceptive failure- and would have been wrong not to, had it genuinely been so. However, I don’t think his ex-partners behaviour should be treated as a minor, understandable, indiscretion on her part. Abusive behaviour is still abusive behaviour regardless of the gender of the perpetrator.

If having children was an absolute must, she should have ended their relationship and found someone who did want to have children. Or at the very least, she should have said she was no longer taking contraception and would not be having a termination if she did get pregnant. He then would have been able to make an informed choice to either take the risk (and accept the consequences) of unprotected intercourse, the risks of sex with a condom, to abstain, or to get a vasectomy. As it was she asked him to have a baby, he said no- she was not overjoyed but said she accepted it. Then lied to him, repeatedly- about contraception and then about it being a “ contraceptive failure”. I’m genuinely not sure how they could ever be on the same page about any of it.

I’ve told her directly, it wasn’t a conversation that was easy but actually, I don’t think “gently” would have helped- she needed to hear the truth. I don’t think it will change anything, as she does not actually believe that she has done anything wrong.

i would say that plenty of women don’t want children- friend was one of them until recently, when she changed her mind. I think he’ll stay single for a while as he has been completely gutted by the deception and betrayal of trust. I don’t think many have understood the psychological impact this sort of abusive behaviour has on someone, that betrayal of trust, the willingness to lie to your face and keep up a deception…. It’s really significant.

Edited

This is very articulately put @Coldcalmcollected, you are completely in the right and I am shocked that any comments are excusing her manipulative and dishonest behaviour. Even if she had made a mistake, and regretted it, the fact she still trying to emotionally blackmail you into trying to win your BIL back… shows this isn’t just a woman desperate for children but actually quite a devious and untrustworthy person.

As you say, had your BIL removed a condom and stealthed her, giving her an STD or an unwanted pregnancy in the process, there would be cries of police and rape! She is abusing her position as a fertile woman to try and coerce him into a future he was transparent about not wanting. She is absolutely not the victim here.

WhatNoRaisins · Yesterday 11:31

With any relationship where one wants a child and the other one doesn't it's more likely than not on borrowed time.

Lemieux7 · Yesterday 11:27

The thing is, if she wants a baby so much then she is not with the right person anyway - have you not told her this?

Coldcalmcollected · Yesterday 11:21

Crunchymum · Yesterday 10:55

Such a horrid situation.

Yes the friend was totally, 100% in the wrong but she has now lost her baby, her relationship, her financial security (and that includes her home?) and her friendship and support network. I think the friend has suffered for her choices and I'd be incredibly concerned about the welfare of a person who had gone through all this. I wouldn't, in good conscience, be able to cut her off.

she hasn’t lost all her support network- it is reduced a little- and she is staying with her mum.

Yes, she has lost her financial security in some sense- she has a job but it is not particularly well paid. BIL earns significantly more and so obviously she had a lifestyle that she could not afford without him. They don’t have joint finances, as they weren’t married. She won’t starve, but things will be very different for her. They lived in his home, due to the nature of ownership and the fact that she did not contribute to upkeep etc (absolutely correctly, as she had no stake in it), she won’t have any financial interest in it.

as I have said to someone else, the main issue is that I think her behaviour is abusive. If it was the other way around, I very much doubt I’d be encouraged to standby and be supportive of BIL if he had been abusive to my friend. I’m not clear why the fact she is a woman makes abuse excusable and understandable.

OP posts:
Coldcalmcollected · Yesterday 11:06

Malasana · Yesterday 10:46

I agree with you. I wouldn’t abandon my friend however much I disagreed with what she did. She’s in a horrible situation and that it was of her making wouldn’t make me leave her to it.
OP can you separate your friend from your BIL and be there for her?

No, because she can’t accept that she was wrong, or that I won’t try to get BIL to forgive her/speak to her.

The problem I have is that, whilst I absolutely accept she is suffering, I also regard her behaviour as abusive. I would not be able to turn the other cheek and ignore what was happening if BIL had been abusing her. Nor would I be able to support BIL if he had been abusive to my friend. I doubt many would expect me to, even if he had a serious health problem occur at the same time. I just don’t understand why this is viewed differently.

Maybe some do see it as some sort of minor indiscretion on her part, but I don’t. And the impact on BIL hasn’t been minor either. I would find it hard to support her, given all of this. As it happens, we have spoken and agreed we can’t see eye to eye on this and we need to leave it there. I can’t agree with her and I can’t support her in the way she wants/is asking me to.

OP posts:
Crunchymum · Yesterday 10:55

Such a horrid situation.

Yes the friend was totally, 100% in the wrong but she has now lost her baby, her relationship, her financial security (and that includes her home?) and her friendship and support network. I think the friend has suffered for her choices and I'd be incredibly concerned about the welfare of a person who had gone through all this. I wouldn't, in good conscience, be able to cut her off.

Malasana · Yesterday 10:46

Overflowingbasket · 07/11/2026 18:13

I agree with this. Tbh none of you come out of this looking good.

My view, whatever the rights and wrongs of how she became pregnant - and men having sex with women do have to accept they might get pregnant - she is suffering terribly now. She is grieving a much wanted baby, the loss of her relationship and the loss of her home. As well as it, it looks like, some of her friendships. This is a hugely destructive and traumatic amount of loss for anyone to go through all at once and in one stroke. Her mother is right to be worried about her.

I certainly would not get involved in trying to recover her relationship, but I would absolutely be there for her as a friend.

I agree with you. I wouldn’t abandon my friend however much I disagreed with what she did. She’s in a horrible situation and that it was of her making wouldn’t make me leave her to it.
OP can you separate your friend from your BIL and be there for her?

Coldcalmcollected · Yesterday 10:39

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · 15/11/2026 19:15

It's a shame they aren't on the same page. And it's unforgivable to interfere with contraception. However if he was this adamant he didn't want more children to the point of being relived when his partner miscarries then he should have had the vasectomy before she could get pregnant. Contraception does genuinely fail.

I'd say he's probably better roff alone because not many women are willing to be with a man with kids but won't give them one. Unless they already have them of course.

I hope your friend heals, mentally and physically.

If you don't want to continue the friendship tell her mother, but gently.

I’’m not sure why you think it’s a “shame they aren’t on the same page”? She knew, from day one, he did not want children. Neither did she, until recently. I think it would have been much wiser for him to have had a vasectomy, of course, but that doesn’t mean he deserved to be have his trust abused and be subject to reproductive coercion. He had accepted the situation, however unenthusiastically, when he believed it to be a contraceptive failure- and would have been wrong not to, had it genuinely been so. However, I don’t think his ex-partners behaviour should be treated as a minor, understandable, indiscretion on her part. Abusive behaviour is still abusive behaviour regardless of the gender of the perpetrator.

If having children was an absolute must, she should have ended their relationship and found someone who did want to have children. Or at the very least, she should have said she was no longer taking contraception and would not be having a termination if she did get pregnant. He then would have been able to make an informed choice to either take the risk (and accept the consequences) of unprotected intercourse, the risks of sex with a condom, to abstain, or to get a vasectomy. As it was she asked him to have a baby, he said no- she was not overjoyed but said she accepted it. Then lied to him, repeatedly- about contraception and then about it being a “ contraceptive failure”. I’m genuinely not sure how they could ever be on the same page about any of it.

I’ve told her directly, it wasn’t a conversation that was easy but actually, I don’t think “gently” would have helped- she needed to hear the truth. I don’t think it will change anything, as she does not actually believe that she has done anything wrong.

i would say that plenty of women don’t want children- friend was one of them until recently, when she changed her mind. I think he’ll stay single for a while as he has been completely gutted by the deception and betrayal of trust. I don’t think many have understood the psychological impact this sort of abusive behaviour has on someone, that betrayal of trust, the willingness to lie to your face and keep up a deception…. It’s really significant.

OP posts:
Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · 15/11/2026 19:15

It's a shame they aren't on the same page. And it's unforgivable to interfere with contraception. However if he was this adamant he didn't want more children to the point of being relived when his partner miscarries then he should have had the vasectomy before she could get pregnant. Contraception does genuinely fail.

I'd say he's probably better roff alone because not many women are willing to be with a man with kids but won't give them one. Unless they already have them of course.

I hope your friend heals, mentally and physically.

If you don't want to continue the friendship tell her mother, but gently.

croydon15 · 14/11/2026 19:46

I think you handled it very well OP.

jacks11 · 14/11/2026 16:24

WhatNoRaisins · 14/11/2026 14:21

I think that you've done the best you can to treat her kindly whilst sticking by your own morals and principles OP. She doesn't sound like a well person and I'd be careful around her as some of what she says sounds quite manipulative.

Thank you. I think she is just not seeing reality at the moment. Maybe she never will, but I hope at some point she might reflect on it. Though I guess it usn

WhatNoRaisins · 14/11/2026 14:21

I think that you've done the best you can to treat her kindly whilst sticking by your own morals and principles OP. She doesn't sound like a well person and I'd be careful around her as some of what she says sounds quite manipulative.

SylvanMoon · 14/11/2026 13:42

I think you've been a very good friend to her OP by having such a frank and empathetic conversation with her. And I think you are right that at least for now your friendship is over. It may be that in time she understands the enormity of the betrayal she did to her partner and to you, but that may not be enough to repair your friendship with her.

EdgyNewt · 14/11/2026 11:35

@Coldcalmcollected You acted in the best way for the scenario. You helped her try and see sense but she has chosen to still believe that she was right.

She would probably benefit from counselling as she clearly isn't right in the head but you are right to walk away from this friendship as she is not behaving like a friend.

DahliaDelights · 14/11/2026 11:27

That must have been a very difficult conversation for you OP, sorry its ended that way but if she wont take any responsibility then its the only way.

Coldcalmcollected · 14/11/2026 11:08

Quick update for anyone interested.

i met with ex-friend at her request, I think it probably was the right thing to do. Our friendship is definitely at an end, sadly. I just don’t think we are ever going to see eye to eye on this.

i am sorry she’s had a miscarriage, and for the pain that is causing her. I expressed this to her and am glad she is getting support from her mum and some friends.

unfortunately, she cannot accept my stance that I won’t be intervening with BIL on her behalf (if I was her friend I would, “to make up for allowing it to get out”) and she does not feel she did anything “all that bad” and that this has been blown out of all proportion. She says she needs him “now more than ever” and she wants to be able to grieve with him, that he’s over-reacting because he’s upset about the miscarriage. She wants to go back to living in his home and “living my life”. I said that I just don’t think she’s ever going to get what she wants from him in that regard, and that she would be better focussing on the support she does have and perhaps some counselling would help. She wouldn’t let it go- if she could just see him, he’d want to be there for her, she misses their home and their life. I think she’s living in a fantasy, where it all works out in the end somehow. The reality is that at the moment her ex really doesn’t want to speak to her, far less be her rock and source of comfort. I understand why she wants that (and the cynic in me wonders if some of this is about financial stability), but it’s not a realistic prospect. I honestly don’t think he feels very distressed by the miscarriage, he comes across as mainly relieved- he is very upset about what his ex-partner did and sad that their relationship is over. He’s very angry too. I said that I did not think she would benefit much from being in contact just now, as he is not likely to be a source of sincere sympathy and I’m sure she would not want to hear what he had to say, nor benefit from it.

She asked where that left us and would I try to help her as she asked- I explained that I believe what she did was utterly repugnant and a form of abuse (reproductive coercion), certainly a total betrayal of her partner’s trust- and had BIL done something of similar gravity to her, I would have told her too. Furthermore, if the shoe was on the other foot, I would not be encouraging her to go back into a relationship with him, nor intervening on his behalf with her because I would never encourage someone to continue/restart a toxic and coercive relationship. I wouldn’t be trying to excuse or minimise his actions either, so I can’t in all conscience do that for her. I said I think that she needs to accept that the relationship with BIL is over and that it probably was at the point that they wanted very different and irreconcilable things- and definitely the minute she violated his trust.

I said I’m sorry that she feels I let her down, but that I think I did what I felt was right in a difficult position- and I don’t think I’d change my actions if I could do it over again. I also said that I felt let down too, and that she’d not really been a good friend either. Why tell me, knowing that he’s my BIL and she’d be asking me to keep something really awful (that his partner had betrayed him) and had it come out that I knew and said nothing, she also is aware it could have impacted on my relationship with DH? I said I didn’t think it was right of her to put me in that position. She just said she didn’t think it was a big deal, but I thought it was and so shouldn’t have said anything because she’s my friend. If she didn’t think she’d done anything wrong, why was it a problem that BIL found out?

In the end, I said that we would just have to agree to disagree but I can’t do what you want me to or support you in the way you’re asking, and I can’t agree that what you did was something I can condone or ignore- though I do hope you’re ok in time. But, I think it’s probably best that we leave things here. She says she feels she deserves more than that and stormed out.

Ultimately, she just does not accept that what she did was wrong in any way. I honestly would never have thought this of her and I’m surprised she thinks I would be ok with it. I think we’re just not compatible as friends any longer.

i’m sure some won’t agree that what she did was wrong, and many will think I should have kept it to myself. I don’t think turning a blind eye to any form of abusive behaviour is ok, whoever the perpetrator may be- and had my BIL been abusing her in any way, I would not have looked away, nor would I have reassured him it was fine and just to carry on. I’m sorry that she has had a miscarriage, but it doesn’t negate or erase what she has done in any way. Nevertheless, I hope she gets the help she needs and recovers fully from it.

OP posts:
croydon15 · 09/11/2026 21:10

I would end the friendship OP and certainly not mediate with your BIL, once the trust has gone the relationship is finished.

Fuckmyliferightnow · 08/11/2026 22:06

@MrsShawnHatosyif a man doesn’t want children, he should also take responsibility and use contraception, not just leave it up to the woman.

Passingthroughagain · 08/11/2026 16:07

I don't think anyone has said that what she did was okay but that doesn't mean we all want to crow over her situation now. She has lost her baby, lost her home and lost her relationship. She's paying a very high price and it's not a bad thing to have compassion for a woman who's miscarried, regardless of the circumstances.

Cosyblankets · 08/11/2026 16:01

What she did would be the equivalent of a man lying about having a vasectomy and the girlfriend getting pregnant.

That would not have been OK would it?

Throwmoneyatit · 08/11/2026 14:55

Cannot believe these responses!!! No, women absolutely cannot pretend we're on contraception and have our partner trust this to be the case, to then not use it and get pregnant because that's what we want. So what, fuck the man?? Fuck whatever he wants because a woman has to be able to do whatever she wants, even if it does mean bringing a baby that is unwanted by one of their parents???
Fucking outrageous replies. Lots of people on here should be really ashamed of yourselves. You're all a disgrace.

InessaMou · 08/11/2026 12:18

LoveWine123 · 07/11/2026 21:45

Well they are all involved because OP’s friend involved them when they told them what she had done.

Just because someone tries to involve you, doesn't mean you have to allow yourself to get involved.

Also, I don't think the wider friend circle were involved to begin with? Neither was the mother.

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 12:04

I think in situations that can't be made right all that's left to do is to behave in a way that you can live with afterwards. There is potential for you to be a supportive and kind friend but that doesn't mean being roped into her lies or pleading with her boyfriend to take her back if those actions don't feel right. Helping someone doesn't always mean doing what they want.

SockPlant · 08/11/2026 11:50

I am not sure I am the best person to help her through this, for her sake. I do hope she gets the support she needs, as I know she is devastated regarding her miscarriage.

you sound kind, OP, so i would just say this either to your friend if you can, or to her mother if you don't feel you can.

SockPlant · 08/11/2026 11:33

Bluntly, it’s not the OP’s business. I don’t disagree that what the SIL did was ethically wrong, but her husband was also irresponsible about contraception in the circumstances.

Most people want men to pull-up their rapey friends - telling rape jokes, "persuading" uwilling women to have sex with them, pestering women.

And this is the same. This woman commmitted a gross betrayal of her partner, and now reaps what she sowed. She told someone that she did something unforgiveable to her partner. And rightly that person has passed on the information. I would have done the same.

The miscarriage is very unfortunate, especially for this woman who went to awful lengths to get pregnant, but it is no more than a distraction. She told a massive lie, and he ended the relationship. Should he have stayed unti she was in a better place mentally? (IMO: no) She is using her flying monkey (mum) to try to coerce someone (OP) to do something they don't feel is right.

tbh BIL should have had a vasectomy long ago - but he didn't and he was, according to OP, prepared to step up to his respoinsibility. He is not in the wrong here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread