Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 'Full time' should mean less hours?

187 replies

Foreverbear · 07/11/2026 16:24

I keep thinking this.

Full time in my organisation is 37 hours (public sector) but like many places the pay hasnt kept up with inflation. They cant afford to pay more, I get that. But people arent happy and if they cant afford to increase salaries, why not just reduce the number of hours equivilent to a full time salary?

That way our hourly pay would go up without increasing the wage bill.

Obviously output would then be lower, but I feel like in a lot of areas this could we where we could start to lean into AI to cover the shortfall, or just accept that service levels will drop and prioritise.

If people had the same salaries but more time (say 30 hours working week instead of 37), they could use the extra time to do a whole load of other things that would benefit society as a whole or save the individual money:

  • Use public transport to commute
  • Not have to reply on wraparound care
  • Proper homecooked meals instead of quick dinners out of exhaustion
  • Excercise or other hobbies good for mental health
  • A side hustle if they want/need more money.

Am I batshit to think this could work in some organisations and make people much happier??

OP posts:
intrepidpanda · 07/11/2026 18:14

This wouldn't work for everyone but should be an option.
I believe you can choose to reduce hours and employer must give it serious consideration (but they can still say still say no)
My days work is more money than my commute.
I have no children
I already cook homecooked meals
I have weekend free for hobbiesand exercise, also have an active job
Side hustle is unlikely to pay as much as my day at work

OtterlyMad · 07/11/2026 18:13

LondonPapa · 07/11/2026 18:05

I keep hearing the job market is terrible but for whom?

I don’t see a bad job market from where I am.

There has been news of redundancies at several high profile employers including Barclays, Jaguar Landrover, Canva, Clearscore, Virgin Media, Whitbread, etc. plus hiring freezes at many NHS trusts and universities. My LinkedIn has been flooded with people who are looking for work after “corporate restructuring” (aka offshoring and AI integration).

DuckonaBike · 07/11/2026 18:13

It wouldn’t be easy to introduce in every sector, but it’s certainly got potential. And as others have said there’s evidence that cutting hours a bit doesn’t actually reduce productivity.

Foreverbear · 07/11/2026 18:12

Monty36 · 07/11/2026 18:06

It is not ignorant. It is practical.
I am aware some public sector have trialled working four days instead of five.
Companies who run things like bin collections would not pay people the same money to do less work. And then hire more people and have to pay these extra people. If they did their contract with the LA would have to change. And it would be more expensive. Ditto elsewhere too.

I really do not want to pay a public sector worker for five days but working four days because they want to do a side hustle.

I suspect, as I have already mentioned hours may well eventually reduce, and pay improve. But not by a go slow, or doing fewer hours for the same pay.
I do not also think many would suddenly become healthier or exercise or any of that because they are doing four days and not five. I am afraid.

I am open other opinions. But not to personal insults. Thanks.

But we arent doing less hours for the same pay in real terms. In real terms we are getting less pay therefore doing less hours.

OP posts:
EatMoreChocolate44 · 07/11/2026 18:12

Yes OP, some Scandinavian countries have trialled a 4 day week or 30hrs over 5 days and many found productivity was just as good and employees were happier. My husband works in the IT sector. Their small company couldn't afford to give pay raises so their employees all got an additional 5 days annual leave. I think it's a great idea. I work a 4 day week myself (I'm a teacher so I unfortunately I loose a day's pay) and my mental health is so much better for it.

Runningupthecurtains · 07/11/2026 18:11

What happens to part time workers? Do we get our hours cut too or are we expected to suck up crap pay?

PigeonsAmongstTheCats · 07/11/2026 18:10

A couple of businesses I know well have tried this but the stipulation was that the extra day off would be a midweek day. People created such a drama over it that they dropped the idea.

SoManyTshirts · 07/11/2026 18:10

If the productivity gains of working a four day week have been proven, is there solid evidence that part-time workers are more productive? That could be a great boost for flexibility.

Foreverbear · 07/11/2026 18:09

Its interesting to read its worked well in a few companies. I know it wouldnt work in every industry - nurses and doctors for example, but perhaps if enough of the rest of society had more time to take care of their mental and physical health it might put less pressure on those services in turn? Its probably a bit pie in the sky and wishful thinking and like others have pointed out, theres little incentive on employers who know they can get away with these pay freezes.

OP posts:
shuggles · 07/11/2026 18:09

@glitterpaperchain What exactly sounds lazy about making meals from scratch, exercising, and starting a side hustle?

Just start a side hustle bro! Just make more money bro! A side hustle works for tech bros, bro!

Everyone says just start a "side hustle" but it's simply not possible to magically create a second job out of thin fucking air. What makes you think that's possible?

shuggles · 07/11/2026 18:07

LongDarkTeatime · 07/11/2026 17:30

I voted YANBU as it’s a fair idea.
BUT, the NHS would fall apart if all the non-medics went from 5 to 3.5 days a week to reflect their wage loss since 2010 (medics have won pay rises through strikes).

The "wage loss since 2010" argument is bullshit because it implies that it's specific to NHS workers.

Salaries for ALL workers across ALL sectors have effectively fallen since the great recession, after inflation is taken into account. It is NOT specific to the NHS or medical professions.

Monty36 · 07/11/2026 18:06

glitterpaperchain · 07/11/2026 17:47

Sorry but this is an incredibly ignorant take. There is an awful lot of research done on exactly this and how things would work. In many cases it would create more jobs, so practical things like your example of bin collections would still be done, but by more people each working fewer hours. Just because you haven't thought through solutions to these issues doesn't mean there aren't any.

And OP is absolutely not trying to justify being lazy. What exactly sounds lazy about making meals from scratch, exercising, and starting a side hustle? You sound like an incredibly jaded retiree. I'm sorry you had a difficult working life but that doesn't mean we shouldn't ever try to make things better.

It is not ignorant. It is practical.
I am aware some public sector have trialled working four days instead of five.
Companies who run things like bin collections would not pay people the same money to do less work. And then hire more people and have to pay these extra people. If they did their contract with the LA would have to change. And it would be more expensive. Ditto elsewhere too.

I really do not want to pay a public sector worker for five days but working four days because they want to do a side hustle.

I suspect, as I have already mentioned hours may well eventually reduce, and pay improve. But not by a go slow, or doing fewer hours for the same pay.
I do not also think many would suddenly become healthier or exercise or any of that because they are doing four days and not five. I am afraid.

I am open other opinions. But not to personal insults. Thanks.

LondonPapa · 07/11/2026 18:05

OtterlyMad · 07/11/2026 16:29

It would definitely make employees happier but there is no incentive for employers to do it, the job market is terrible at the moment so organisations can pay a shit wage while maintaining the same working hours and still have hundreds of applications for every vacancy.

I keep hearing the job market is terrible but for whom?

I don’t see a bad job market from where I am.

shuggles · 07/11/2026 18:05

@IDontHateRainbows Sounds great but for those o us struggling to get all the work done in a normal 5 day 37 h week , would this not just lead to a backlog of work? And my employer can't afford to take on any more staff meaning it wouldn't lead to job creation.

They could afford to employ you for 37 hours and have you work more hours than that, but they're just greedy and they don't want to.

Your manager receives a performance-related bonus for cutting costs, such as getting staff to do work above and beyond their normal contracted hours.

shuggles · 07/11/2026 18:03

@Foreverbear The majority of full time positions require work that is well above and beyond a 40 hour week.

I'm not lazy thanks. I work really fucking hard

You work really hard, but you're only working 37 hours a week? How did you come to that conclusion?

If people had the same salaries but more time (say 30 hours working week instead of 37), they could use the extra time to do a whole load of other things that would benefit society as a whole or save the individual money:

People do submit flexible working requests to reduce their working hours (like doing a 4 day week of 30 hours for example).

Why don't you just submit a flexible working request and say you want to work 30 hours across 4 days?

TheBrambleDormouse · 07/11/2026 18:03

Crushed23 · 07/11/2026 16:32

I think some people’s response to stagnant wages has been to “quiet quit”, which is effectively the same. Doing less work for the same money. I know people who take all their sick days every year, effectively increasing their annual leave/reducing the number of weeks worked. Others spend time on their side hustle while WFH for their main hustle, to increase earnings.

Workers have woken up to the fact that they are dispensable to their employer and increasingly find ways to claw back what they’re not getting (i.e. sufficient pay rises).

I am not proud of it as I have always had a good work ethic, but I have done some version of this. Especially since my POE treated me like crap anyway. I had it drilled into me that you do NOT ring in sick, unless you're half dead but I rang in sick a couple of weeks ago just because I felt a bit knackered/under the weather.
They used to get 100% now they get roughly 30. I do the bare minimum.

notacooldad · 07/11/2026 18:02

How will that work for doctors/ nurses / teachers etc where hours are majorly busy and not enough to cover the work anyway?

Clearly it is not going to work for every sector.
It could work for some roles, others it wont.

JustAnotherWhinger · 07/11/2026 17:57

BIL’s company brought in a 9 day fortnight a couple of years ago and it’s made a huge difference to morale and staff retention. Their output actually went up after it.

Interestingly they’ve found that not having a fixed day off also worked better. They initially tried people having a set day, but find that a moving day (rotates through the week so one fortnight you have a Monday, the next one a Tuesday and so on) actually works better for people as it feels more like a bonus free day off.

Zanatdy · 07/11/2026 17:56

because it still costs to do that.

0psiedasiy · 07/11/2026 17:51

I work in a 24 hour service we couldn’t just not show up, we would have to employ more people which would cost more….

IDontHateRainbows · 07/11/2026 17:50

Sounds great but for those o us struggling to get all the work done in a normal 5 day 37 h week , would this not just lead to a backlog of work? And my employer can't afford to take on any more staff meaning it wouldn't lead to job creation.

glitterpaperchain · 07/11/2026 17:47

Monty36 · 07/11/2026 17:28

I am sure you aren’t. But your proposal is to try to justify being so. Swearing at me does not make your argument stand up any more.
I understand many people work hard, and may feel they should earn more. During my working life I know I worked hard too. And our work area went years without any pay rises or promotions whatsoever.
At some point hours will reduce perhaps, and pay improve. But you will not get anyone to sanction an approach to work which is to work less for the money you presently are paid. That attitude is not helpful to society.
You make assumptions about a shorter week for the same money meaning everyone is happier. Or even environmentally friendly. I doubt any of that would happen at all.
Businesses would charge more for having to cram into four days what they did in five. Eg. Your bin collection. The number of bins needing collection would not reduce. But the vehicles to collect and personnel would be working longer to do so. Ditto your supermarket even. All sorts of places.
Sorry OP but it is wistful thinking.

Also, I would be careful of saying you can do in four days what you can do in five. Many will point and wonder if you should be paid for four days instead.

Edited

Sorry but this is an incredibly ignorant take. There is an awful lot of research done on exactly this and how things would work. In many cases it would create more jobs, so practical things like your example of bin collections would still be done, but by more people each working fewer hours. Just because you haven't thought through solutions to these issues doesn't mean there aren't any.

And OP is absolutely not trying to justify being lazy. What exactly sounds lazy about making meals from scratch, exercising, and starting a side hustle? You sound like an incredibly jaded retiree. I'm sorry you had a difficult working life but that doesn't mean we shouldn't ever try to make things better.

dizzydizzydizzy · 07/11/2026 17:44

DC1’s full time work is 9 days every fortnight, so every other weekend is 3 days.

Tortephant · 07/11/2026 17:41

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · 07/11/2026 16:52

A couple of council’s have discussed moving to a 4 day week for 5 day pay.
It’s a way of trying to retain or attract staff when wages they can pay aren’t competitive.
We really struggle to recruit and retain in my area as private sector pay far more and lots of local government perks like wfh are now in private sector too. Talking around £20,000 difference in pay.
There’s also the issue that lowest paid now get national living wage where I work as it’s a council commitment. This has meant there’s virtually no difference between wages for bottom 3 or 4 grades. In practice it means cleaner and the supervisor who has to train people, sort rotas are on same wage.
Cleaner and some people in my team with degrees doing complex work are on under £1 an hour difference. A colleague has applied for and got a demotion as money wise it’s virtually same and his work life will be so much easier at lower grade.

We really struggle to recruit and retain in my area as private sector pay far more and lots of local government perks like wfh are now in private sector too. Talking around £20,000 difference in pay.

Yes, and public sector get the great pensions - earn less now and have far more to spend in retirement. you can't have both!

BestMugPlease · 07/11/2026 17:40

Crushed23 · 07/11/2026 16:32

I think some people’s response to stagnant wages has been to “quiet quit”, which is effectively the same. Doing less work for the same money. I know people who take all their sick days every year, effectively increasing their annual leave/reducing the number of weeks worked. Others spend time on their side hustle while WFH for their main hustle, to increase earnings.

Workers have woken up to the fact that they are dispensable to their employer and increasingly find ways to claw back what they’re not getting (i.e. sufficient pay rises).

I worked with people like this. We had to work harder to make up for their laziness.