Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 'Full time' should mean less hours?

187 replies

Foreverbear · 07/11/2026 16:24

I keep thinking this.

Full time in my organisation is 37 hours (public sector) but like many places the pay hasnt kept up with inflation. They cant afford to pay more, I get that. But people arent happy and if they cant afford to increase salaries, why not just reduce the number of hours equivilent to a full time salary?

That way our hourly pay would go up without increasing the wage bill.

Obviously output would then be lower, but I feel like in a lot of areas this could we where we could start to lean into AI to cover the shortfall, or just accept that service levels will drop and prioritise.

If people had the same salaries but more time (say 30 hours working week instead of 37), they could use the extra time to do a whole load of other things that would benefit society as a whole or save the individual money:

  • Use public transport to commute
  • Not have to reply on wraparound care
  • Proper homecooked meals instead of quick dinners out of exhaustion
  • Excercise or other hobbies good for mental health
  • A side hustle if they want/need more money.

Am I batshit to think this could work in some organisations and make people much happier??

OP posts:
Monty36 · 08/11/2026 10:30

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 09:35

In every job I have had you are paid for your time and to meet targets. Targets matter and failure to hit them more than once or twice will lead to disciplinary. They are not optional.

Indeed.

lazyarse123 · 08/11/2026 10:04

I'd be wary of wanting AI to do part of a job because it won't be long before it's doing all of it. Then you'll have all the time you want but without the money.

OneNewLeader · 08/11/2026 10:03

There was a study that supported people reducing to 4 days a week (in predominantly office based jobs) that showed a minimal decline in productivity. But for many businesses/orgs they have a mixed workforce, some on shifts, who do work/ are needed for all the hours they are paid for. So how would that work?

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 09:56

Monty36 · 08/11/2026 09:54

Well yes, of course you are expected to achieve and not just turn up and sit there !

I was responding to the claim targets are flexible if you don't meet them. Not in my experience

Monty36 · 08/11/2026 09:54

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 09:35

In every job I have had you are paid for your time and to meet targets. Targets matter and failure to hit them more than once or twice will lead to disciplinary. They are not optional.

Well yes, of course you are expected to achieve and not just turn up and sit there !

Didimum · 08/11/2026 09:54

Monty36 · 08/11/2026 09:31

In many jobs you are contracted for your hours. You are paid for your time.
The assumption being that hopefully people have some initiative and if one task is completed, there is always work to do.

Certainly in many jobs completion of a task and reaching a target is very fluid and not a rigid one. You are paid for your time. And expected to do a job of work within it.

You’re misunderstanding me. The current system is that in all jobs you are contracted hourly. The actual reality is that you/the organisation is trying to meet a target – whether that is X profit made, X patients seen, X units moved – whatever.

Hours worked is arbitrary to a target being met. And really bloody arbitrary when all these targets seem to be coincidentally and satisfactorily appeared to be seen to be met at 37 hours, regardless of specific industry or specific target.

The actual, tangible elements you are working with are a target and the productivity of your workers. When studies have evidenced that productivity peaks, plateaus and wanes at a certain number of hours a week, it’s time to move on from the archaic system of ‘contracted hours’.

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 08/11/2026 09:50

I wish i could do all my work for the week in one day. Who is employing you to do that where? It wont be frontline NHS or in the immediate support services.

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 09:44

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 08/11/2026 09:41

What does ‘lack of productivity’ in the public sector’ even mean? The facts are that we are working a damn sight harder than people were in the 00s and 90s, and that was a damn sight more than in the 60s. In the NHS more people are going through the system being treated in less time, with more acuity and fewer staff. That’s why things like a weeks stay in hospital after childbirth, for mumps, having your tonsils out or for a broken leg are all laughable dreams nowadays. Maternity units now are closing. Whatever the government says in their facts and figures is a lie, everyone who actually works knows this.

You cannot keep just demanding more work for less from public sector workers forever. Already Band 1 on the NHS has gone and I think the Band 2 on the NHS is going as soon as the new minimum wage increase comes in. I am already being paid the same as cleaners for very skilled work which requires me to engage in a year long training package with courses and qualification requirements and pathways, how much longer do you think I’m going to keep reading about how the median wage is now nearly £40k while watching the minimum wage go up and being treated like dirt by the public and media? What kind of people do you want to attract into the NHS? More foreigners with less and less ability to communicate? The tide has turned on cheap foreigners because they are causing social problems. The youngsters i work with are already angry and getting more so. There is talk of healthcare staff striking, because we are not your slaves.

Edited

Yes I jumped to private sector and my job is way easier

topcat2014 · 08/11/2026 09:42

Trainspotter12 · 07/11/2026 16:39

I can do all my work in about one day a week, it’s actually surprisingly draining given that I have to still be there the rest of the time.

Being underemployed is grim!

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 08/11/2026 09:41

BrinkWomanship · 08/11/2026 08:44

Lack of productivity in the public sector already costs the tax payer approximately £80-84bn annually, or 3% of GDP. I know there are some roles/parts of the public sector that are stretched and flat out but we all know of parts that are not.

AI has a cost too - and it will get increasingly expensive as we become ’hooked’ on it; this is built into pricing models.

Economics simply doesn’t work the way OP would like it to unfortunately. A better question would be how can we equip workers to have the right systems, processes, skills and attitudes to fully utilise their own and their role’s potential to achieve the required outcomes?

What does ‘lack of productivity’ in the public sector’ even mean? The facts are that we are working a damn sight harder than people were in the 00s and 90s, and that was a damn sight more than in the 60s. In the NHS more people are going through the system being treated in less time, with more acuity and fewer staff. That’s why things like a weeks stay in hospital after childbirth, for mumps, having your tonsils out or for a broken leg are all laughable dreams nowadays. Maternity units now are closing. Whatever the government says in their facts and figures is a lie, everyone who actually works knows this.

You cannot keep just demanding more work for less from public sector workers forever. Already Band 1 on the NHS has gone and I think the Band 2 on the NHS is going as soon as the new minimum wage increase comes in. I am already being paid the same as cleaners for very skilled work which requires me to engage in a year long training package with courses and qualification requirements and pathways, how much longer do you think I’m going to keep reading about how the median wage is now nearly £40k while watching the minimum wage go up and being treated like dirt by the public and media? What kind of people do you want to attract into the NHS? More foreigners with less and less ability to communicate? The tide has turned on cheap foreigners because they are causing social problems. The youngsters i work with are already angry and getting more so. There is talk of healthcare staff striking, because we are not your slaves.

Dicedpumpkin · 08/11/2026 09:37

The link between hours and output really fascinates me as we arent machines that just consistently output stuff. I dont even output the same day to day.

I think it works better for some jobs than others.

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 09:35

Monty36 · 08/11/2026 09:31

In many jobs you are contracted for your hours. You are paid for your time.
The assumption being that hopefully people have some initiative and if one task is completed, there is always work to do.

Certainly in many jobs completion of a task and reaching a target is very fluid and not a rigid one. You are paid for your time. And expected to do a job of work within it.

In every job I have had you are paid for your time and to meet targets. Targets matter and failure to hit them more than once or twice will lead to disciplinary. They are not optional.

Monty36 · 08/11/2026 09:31

Didimum · 08/11/2026 08:05

Largely, this isn’t true though – you are paid to get a job done and reach a target. The hours it takes to do that are arbitrary.

In many jobs you are contracted for your hours. You are paid for your time.
The assumption being that hopefully people have some initiative and if one task is completed, there is always work to do.

Certainly in many jobs completion of a task and reaching a target is very fluid and not a rigid one. You are paid for your time. And expected to do a job of work within it.

Monty36 · 08/11/2026 09:17

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 08:23

South Cambridgeshire District Council has done it for years. Productivity has risen.

It was highly criticised. Even by this Government. Key services failed. Of course the staff were happy not to have to go into work for five days.
Measuring work, the Council said they had met all their work requirements, but this is absurd. They did not. And in any event, in that environment there is always work to do. In a Council you are not like a factory where you are churning out widgets. And that is it. The work is far more fluid and measuring it less rigid.
What people knew was that there was nobody to contact, nobody answered the phone to handle queries, nobody was there one day out of the five.
Rent and council tenants were a significant problem. Sometimes with vulnerable people left high and dry.
This Labour Government wrote to the Council explaining they were unhappy.

BreatheAndFocus · 08/11/2026 09:04

Obviously output would then be lower…

Not necessarily. In places where they trialled a 4 day week, productivity actually went up. They also benefited from less sickness and absence.

sillycoldmondays · 08/11/2026 09:00

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 08:57

My desk job cannot be replaced by AI.

For now. But it’s developing quickly. Or perhaps your hours could be reduced to a day a week with the right processes. Lots of people think AI is so great but it’s a threat to most jobs that don’t have a people element to them.

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 08:57

sillycoldmondays · 08/11/2026 08:55

If councils can use AI to replace some of your work they will look to replace to all of it very quickly. I wouldn’t be so keen on that being an option.

My desk job cannot be replaced by AI.

sillycoldmondays · 08/11/2026 08:55

If councils can use AI to replace some of your work they will look to replace to all of it very quickly. I wouldn’t be so keen on that being an option.

Clarabell77 · 08/11/2026 08:55

Ileithyia · 07/11/2026 17:09

There have been several trials of a 4 day working week, 28/30 hours for no reduction in pay, and it’s always resulted in a more motivated, more productive workforce. YANBU

Came on to say this.

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 08:53

Lack of productivity in the public sector is largely driven by a lack of investment. I have worked in the public sector and now in the private sector doing the same job, they are worlds apart.

In the public sector I had old software and cheap IT equipment. The poor systems meant everything took much longer. I used a scanner a lot. In the public sector this meant using a photocopier to scan that often broke and always had people waiting to use it. In the private sector I now use a decent scanner on my desk. No waiting, never breaks.

It's lots of things like that that reduces productivity. I achieve more in the private sector and don't actually work as hard. Because we are given the tools to do our job. Rather than constantly having to make do.

BrinkWomanship · 08/11/2026 08:44

Lack of productivity in the public sector already costs the tax payer approximately £80-84bn annually, or 3% of GDP. I know there are some roles/parts of the public sector that are stretched and flat out but we all know of parts that are not.

AI has a cost too - and it will get increasingly expensive as we become ’hooked’ on it; this is built into pricing models.

Economics simply doesn’t work the way OP would like it to unfortunately. A better question would be how can we equip workers to have the right systems, processes, skills and attitudes to fully utilise their own and their role’s potential to achieve the required outcomes?

mum2jakie · 08/11/2026 08:43

YourJoyousDenimExpert · 08/11/2026 08:31

I imagine it could work in some departments at LAs - but not in the patient facing teams in the NHS as the staffing costs would increase to cover the same volume of appointments etc.

NHS is separate to the LA, so not affected.

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 08:32

Dozer · 08/11/2026 08:19

Contracts don’t offer pay rises, based on inflation or anything else. If the organisation can fill vacancies and retain most people then they don’t need to pay more.

That ignores morale and performance, which often aren’t measured, and the extent to which pay affects those things is debated.

People feeling underpaid affects morale and performance. If people feel fairly paid, extra pay does not impact morale or performance.
Morale in my company is through the floor because pay rises are tiny as they have no issues recruiting people. But they have big issues retaining experienced staff.

YourJoyousDenimExpert · 08/11/2026 08:31

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 08:23

South Cambridgeshire District Council has done it for years. Productivity has risen.

I imagine it could work in some departments at LAs - but not in the patient facing teams in the NHS as the staffing costs would increase to cover the same volume of appointments etc.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 08:23

YourJoyousDenimExpert · 08/11/2026 08:18

I thought some organisations (private sector) already do this? Maybe go and work for one of them?
There is no chance it will happen in the public sector. I’m full time in public sector at 37.5 hours. There are flexible working options but nobody I work with has enough time to do all their work as it is- so it would not work to allow people to keep their salaries at the same level for fewer hours. I manage most of the things on your list already - but admit I am not juggling wraparound care as my children are older.

South Cambridgeshire District Council has done it for years. Productivity has risen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread