Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 'Full time' should mean less hours?

187 replies

Foreverbear · 07/11/2026 16:24

I keep thinking this.

Full time in my organisation is 37 hours (public sector) but like many places the pay hasnt kept up with inflation. They cant afford to pay more, I get that. But people arent happy and if they cant afford to increase salaries, why not just reduce the number of hours equivilent to a full time salary?

That way our hourly pay would go up without increasing the wage bill.

Obviously output would then be lower, but I feel like in a lot of areas this could we where we could start to lean into AI to cover the shortfall, or just accept that service levels will drop and prioritise.

If people had the same salaries but more time (say 30 hours working week instead of 37), they could use the extra time to do a whole load of other things that would benefit society as a whole or save the individual money:

  • Use public transport to commute
  • Not have to reply on wraparound care
  • Proper homecooked meals instead of quick dinners out of exhaustion
  • Excercise or other hobbies good for mental health
  • A side hustle if they want/need more money.

Am I batshit to think this could work in some organisations and make people much happier??

OP posts:
Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 15:24

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · 08/11/2026 15:17

The if you don’t like it just move on posts are missing the point.
There’s whole sections of local government where they struggle to recruit and retain staff.
If you follow your council website you’ll see same roles advertised regularly either because low pay, rubbish hours or workload or combo of all 3.
The pension is nothing compared to civil service. As civil service are in regions often they are competing for same people.
We regularly lose staff to civil service, starting salary is £16,000 more for very similar role and much better pension.
Gaps are filled by inexperienced or newly qualified staff who understandably can’t shift the work in the same way or by expensive locums or sending to external firms.
It’s not as simple as don’t do the work lots is a statutory requirement or essential to protect people eg childcare legal work is often sent to external barristers or firms at £££ as they can’t attract or retain experienced qualified solicitors to work full time in a difficult role (massive caseloads, distressing images) paying under £40,000.
Like the example above of a firm giving extra holiday as they couldn’t afford a pay rise, cutting hours is one way to increase hourly pay. Where I work is 37, nearby councils are 35. Moving to 35 would probably mean they meet minimum wage or living wage next time it increases rather than having to find money to give lots of staff a pay rise as they had to earlier this year.

What’s your actual point?

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · 08/11/2026 15:17

The if you don’t like it just move on posts are missing the point.
There’s whole sections of local government where they struggle to recruit and retain staff.
If you follow your council website you’ll see same roles advertised regularly either because low pay, rubbish hours or workload or combo of all 3.
The pension is nothing compared to civil service. As civil service are in regions often they are competing for same people.
We regularly lose staff to civil service, starting salary is £16,000 more for very similar role and much better pension.
Gaps are filled by inexperienced or newly qualified staff who understandably can’t shift the work in the same way or by expensive locums or sending to external firms.
It’s not as simple as don’t do the work lots is a statutory requirement or essential to protect people eg childcare legal work is often sent to external barristers or firms at £££ as they can’t attract or retain experienced qualified solicitors to work full time in a difficult role (massive caseloads, distressing images) paying under £40,000.
Like the example above of a firm giving extra holiday as they couldn’t afford a pay rise, cutting hours is one way to increase hourly pay. Where I work is 37, nearby councils are 35. Moving to 35 would probably mean they meet minimum wage or living wage next time it increases rather than having to find money to give lots of staff a pay rise as they had to earlier this year.

Sweetandsaltycaroline · 08/11/2026 15:00

I know there are studies that working efficiently for 4 days doesnt lessen productivity compared to 5....obviously it somewhat depends on the industry and cant be a universal trend. DH and I have our own business and trialled a 4 day week. The longer weekends were nice but in the end the stress and build up of work on the other 4 days outweighed the benefit.

Id be cautious of bringing Ai to do some tasks, because I can imagine instead of giving everyone a shorter week, a business could say AI has reduced the amount of staff needed, and there would be fewer people....doing the same hours as before

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 14:52

Foreverbear · 08/11/2026 10:52

I wondered when the 'public sector is full of slackers' crew would pitch up 😂

Hardly a surprise given the entire crux of the OP

Worstoffenders · 08/11/2026 14:50

You aren’t happy with the status quo in your current job. So either start looking for another one or I’m afraid you’ll have to suck it up!

LadyGaGasPokerFace · 08/11/2026 14:38

I work in the private sector. Jobs have been lost and have had a pay freeze for the past 3 years. We then got 2% increase. Yes, I do less. I do my hours, make sure I take my breaks and when I’m asked to do something that someone more senior does, I deny I know how to do it. I can do it, but I won’t.
My DDs are older, one at college, one in year 11, so I’m looking at moving on anyway.

Surroundedbyfools · 08/11/2026 14:33

Good in theory but reality is ur just expected to squeeze 37 hours of work into 30 hours.

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 14:33

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 14:28

Ordering biscuits?
You mean you had a supplier who delivered biscuits with other goods rather than having in every office someone who popped out to the shop to buy some biscuits when they were needed for a meeting?

I remember offices before suppliers were really a thing for this kind of purchase. I like getting money fron the petty cash tin and popping out for half an hour or more to buy a couple of packs of biscuits. It was a bit if a skive. That skive no longer exists.

No, I am being silly, the rubbish collection was outsourced

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 14:28

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 14:11

No, we outsourced that to a private sector company.

Ordering biscuits?
You mean you had a supplier who delivered biscuits with other goods rather than having in every office someone who popped out to the shop to buy some biscuits when they were needed for a meeting?

I remember offices before suppliers were really a thing for this kind of purchase. I like getting money fron the petty cash tin and popping out for half an hour or more to buy a couple of packs of biscuits. It was a bit if a skive. That skive no longer exists.

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 14:11

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 13:55

@RaggedRocks is talking rubbish.

No, we outsourced that to a private sector company.

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 13:56

It's a right wing talking point that the public sector is full of staff who hardly do anything.
When the truth is staff are run of their feet and struggling with antiquated computer systems and cheap software that makes their job harder.

BeLemonMoose · 08/11/2026 13:55

@RaggedRocks is talking rubbish.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 12:23

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 11:59

I worked at a town hall once. So much time spent form filling to get more biscuits.

I expect they made you redundant pretty swiftly if that was the extent of your duties.

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 11:59

I worked at a town hall once. So much time spent form filling to get more biscuits.

IDontHateRainbows · 08/11/2026 11:18

shuggles · 07/11/2026 18:05

@IDontHateRainbows Sounds great but for those o us struggling to get all the work done in a normal 5 day 37 h week , would this not just lead to a backlog of work? And my employer can't afford to take on any more staff meaning it wouldn't lead to job creation.

They could afford to employ you for 37 hours and have you work more hours than that, but they're just greedy and they don't want to.

Your manager receives a performance-related bonus for cutting costs, such as getting staff to do work above and beyond their normal contracted hours.

well they don't as it's public sector and I am a manager myself so definitely no bonus! and yes they should be employing 2 or 3 people to do my job but being public sector this would only be funded by tax increases.

I know the image of public sector is everyone sitting around talking about what they watched on telly and doing sod all, but it's not true where I work.

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 11:15

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 08/11/2026 11:06

Nice wind up. You won’t get computers doing the job for you at no cost. You will actually have to pay the real cost of the production of energy and of the water that they require, and then double because the American companies have complete control of the means of production, and then double again because no one else can afford anything and the economy collapses.

As for public sector ‘slackers’ … well as I said it’s a wind up. But I wish you would come into the hospitals and send your kids to school with labels on so that we could actually commit the crime of which we are constantly accused against you and yours, and get away with it because the police, law courts and all council staff are similarly unbothered.

Edited

I am talking about the town hall slackers, not the hospital workers or teachers. I have seen how hard the latter work.

intrepidpanda · 08/11/2026 11:13

LongDarkTeatime · 07/11/2026 18:47

  1. No where did it say it was just NHS (read the history, that was the 1st accusation)
  2. No where did it say everyone works in the NHS
  3. the original comment solely gave an example from A4C and the possible impact of the OP’s suggestion on the NHS. Discussing THAT is the point of this thread.
Edited

Go on read the opening words of her post. Hate that

DeftGoldHedgehog · 08/11/2026 11:09

YANBU. Many employers have gone down to four days successfully.

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 08/11/2026 11:06

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 10:51

Hopefully, AI will replace all you public sector slackers and the insane council tax rises will stop.

Nice wind up. You won’t get computers doing the job for you at no cost. You will actually have to pay the real cost of the production of energy and of the water that they require, and then double because the American companies have complete control of the means of production, and then double again because no one else can afford anything and the economy collapses.

As for public sector ‘slackers’ … well as I said it’s a wind up. But I wish you would come into the hospitals and send your kids to school with labels on so that we could actually commit the crime of which we are constantly accused against you and yours, and get away with it because the police, law courts and all council staff are similarly unbothered.

Foreverbear · 08/11/2026 10:57

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 10:54

So if you can do the job in less hours. Do that and then the council can not replace the next one of you that leaves, thus saving us, your bosses money?

Not the full scope of the current job, no. But they cant afford to pay the full scope anymore, clearly as seen in our real terms pay cuts. Hence I think the scope and therefore hours should decrease so that pay per hour remains at the same level.

OP posts:
RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 10:54

Foreverbear · 08/11/2026 10:52

I wondered when the 'public sector is full of slackers' crew would pitch up 😂

So if you can do the job in less hours. Do that and then the council can not replace the next one of you that leaves, thus saving us, your bosses money?

Foreverbear · 08/11/2026 10:52

RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 10:51

Hopefully, AI will replace all you public sector slackers and the insane council tax rises will stop.

I wondered when the 'public sector is full of slackers' crew would pitch up 😂

OP posts:
Foreverbear · 08/11/2026 10:51

For my work specifically, yes we have targets and deadlines that we are absolutley expected to meet or else there is a big problem. But meeting those arent the entirety of my job - we also have 'slower time' things we are working towards with less pressure on when they are acheived and a backlog of things that would be brilliant to get done but not the top priority by any stretch. We have busy periods when are all killing ourselves to meet said targets and then once a certain date is passed we move into a different phase of work that is less intense, then move back into hectic mode again. It was very similar in my last role actually even though that was in the private sector.

I am not suggesting for one minute that we abandon our deadlines and responsibilities to our customers, those kinds of tasks would have to be prioritised during the hours worked.

But why should we all put up with being paid less to deliver the same? Surely if they are cutting our pay in real terms then they shoud look at ways of cutting the workload accordingly. Better tech, etc.

Obviously I know im living in la la land and this will never happen because capitalism. Its not about a happier, productive workforce or fairness and never will be. But if I was in charge its what I would do!

OP posts:
RaggedRocks · 08/11/2026 10:51

Hopefully, AI will replace all you public sector slackers and the insane council tax rises will stop.

CeciliaMars · 08/11/2026 10:43

As a teacher who uses every second of my working day to get jobs done, I'm always interested by the notion that companies can go down to 4-day weeks and people can get the same amount of work done in 4 days as they were previously doing in 5. Doesn't that mean there wasn't enough work to spread over 5 days to start with and people were not working at capacity?

Swipe left for the next trending thread