Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my son isn't fat

210 replies

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 15:09

I know lots of parents are in denial about this sort of thing but I honestly don't think I am. He is 18 years old, wearing size medium t shirts and 34 inch waist trousers. He weighs 11 stone and I'm not sure exactly how tall he is, less than 6ft but not much less. He runs 10k 2 times a week and 5k 2 times a week. My MIL thinks he is fat (for context my MIL is a size 18).

OP posts:
somanychristmaslights · 07/11/2026 20:50

Even if he’s not fat, he’d still saying that is bang out of order! I’d be saying something along the lines of pot calling the kettle black.

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 20:47

Oxaloacetate · 07/11/2026 20:14

Something new is being developed - it’s in the works. It includes certain measurements that split people into ‘clinical obesity’ and ‘preclinical obesity’ which essentially defines if your weight over the BMI boundary is due to something that is clinically significant to your health or not. It looks at actual risk to health rather than just weight.

The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology Commission released it last year.

Boreded should read this one

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 20:45

Boreded · 07/11/2026 19:27

Well, that’s nice for you, but unfortunately the medical profession and decades of peer-reviewed research would suggest you’re wrong. Nobody claims BMI is a perfect measure of individual health, but its limitations are already well understood and accounted for. I’m not entirely sure why you think pointing them out is some sort of revelation that has escaped the attention of medical researchers.

the nhs is decades behind, it’s woeful.

Oxaloacetate · 07/11/2026 20:14

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 17:51

yes, I have visible abs and have weight trained for 18 years, I also run 4 times a week.

You’re basing this on BMI and it’s totally ancient, the NHS need to stop using it.

Something new is being developed - it’s in the works. It includes certain measurements that split people into ‘clinical obesity’ and ‘preclinical obesity’ which essentially defines if your weight over the BMI boundary is due to something that is clinically significant to your health or not. It looks at actual risk to health rather than just weight.

The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology Commission released it last year.

Newsenmum · 07/11/2026 19:45

is he slim all over but carry a tiny bit on his belly?
anyway not that it matters, wtf is wrong with this women why is she telling you this?

Boreded · 07/11/2026 19:27

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 18:06

nope I still disagree, all it takes into account is height and weight, there’s so many more variables than that even without muscle.

Well, that’s nice for you, but unfortunately the medical profession and decades of peer-reviewed research would suggest you’re wrong. Nobody claims BMI is a perfect measure of individual health, but its limitations are already well understood and accounted for. I’m not entirely sure why you think pointing them out is some sort of revelation that has escaped the attention of medical researchers.

Namezerchangezer · 07/11/2026 19:15

I bought my 16 year old size 34 waste trousers for school this year and they are massive on him, he’s 5 11 and has always had a good amount of meat on him. Fat isn’t a slur we are all different sizes, it’s not a measure of someone’s value.

Chilihealer · 07/11/2026 19:01

Next time maybe just say ‘yeah he is isn’t he, he must get it from your side’. Should put a stop to it all, sometimes you just have to respond to rude with rude. I wouldn’t say those measurements equal fat personally and he’s definitely healthy running 4 times a week, tell her to fuck off.

DuckFilledPlatitude · 07/11/2026 18:33

His BMI is within a healthy range, plus it sounds as though his lifestyle generally is healthy, so what your MIL thinks is a. incorrect and b. none of her business anyway.

Soontoomuch · 07/11/2026 18:26

My DH is 6ft and weighs11st 8lbs and is skinny (over 80ys)

Notanotherslice · 07/11/2026 18:25

My husband looked overweight with size 34 trousers but it depends on the person. I think my son could pull it off as he is taller.

user293948849167 · 07/11/2026 18:22

Doesn’t sound like he is no but unless he’s quite a heavy build 34” waist is on the big side for an 18 year old.
For context my DH is 6ft fairly athletic build and weighed around 11 stone when he was in his 20s and looked slim, now more like 12.5 stone but doesn’t look fat at all (he is 45). Usually takes a medium in tops and 34” waist (used to be 32” until about 10 years ago).

twoyearsleft · 07/11/2026 18:10

ACR7 · 07/11/2026 17:45

My husband is 6ft 4 and a 34 inch waist. He’s nowhere near fat.

I expect my son will expand out once he reaches fully fledged adulthood at 21. I wouldn’t expect him to look fat with a 34” waist either because of his height.

He’d be fat with that waist if only 5ft 9” though.

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 18:06

Boreded · 07/11/2026 18:02

You’ve been weight training for 18 years and are clearly more muscular than average, making you precisely the sort of person for whom BMI is less reliable. That doesn’t change the fact that it’s a useful screening tool for the majority of the population. You’re demonstrating a well-recognised limitation of BMI, not a reason for the NHS to abandon it.

nope I still disagree, all it takes into account is height and weight, there’s so many more variables than that even without muscle.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 07/11/2026 18:05

bigboykitty · 07/11/2026 15:28

He can't be fat at 11 stone and approx 5'10 given that he's really active. Maybe shut your MIL up by saying 'no MIL, it's you who's fat. Please don't bring it up again unless you'd like another truth bomb about your own weight issues'.

Yeah this.

Boreded · 07/11/2026 18:02

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 17:51

yes, I have visible abs and have weight trained for 18 years, I also run 4 times a week.

You’re basing this on BMI and it’s totally ancient, the NHS need to stop using it.

You’ve been weight training for 18 years and are clearly more muscular than average, making you precisely the sort of person for whom BMI is less reliable. That doesn’t change the fact that it’s a useful screening tool for the majority of the population. You’re demonstrating a well-recognised limitation of BMI, not a reason for the NHS to abandon it.

Boreded · 07/11/2026 18:00

Wicked123 · 07/11/2026 17:52

It’s not a good benchmark for anyone - muscle is heavier than fat, BMI can put someone muscular as obese based purely on height and weight but not knowing what their body composition is at all.

But it is a reasonable benchmark for the majority of people. It becomes less reliable for particularly muscular individuals, which is precisely what the poster you’re disagreeing with has already acknowledged. You’ve taken an exception that they’ve explicitly recognised and used it to claim BMI isn’t useful for anyone, which simply isn’t true.

NoHangoversToday · 07/11/2026 17:58

DH is 6 foot and weighs bang on 11 stone.

Our GP has advised he put on weight as he looks very thin. he does have a long thin frame, thin long arms and legs. He's 73.

11 stone and almost 6 foot? I can't see any situation where that is 'fat'.

Wicked123 · 07/11/2026 17:52

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · 07/11/2026 15:10

What is his BMI? It is not a good measure for athletes but is generally a good ball park for regular folk

It’s not a good benchmark for anyone - muscle is heavier than fat, BMI can put someone muscular as obese based purely on height and weight but not knowing what their body composition is at all.

Thedam · 07/11/2026 17:52

Boreded · 07/11/2026 17:34

And she can actually see her son, we can’t. He could well be chubby, we just can’t determine that as all of the numbers indicate he is in the healthy weight range and waist size is acceptable.

Odd for her to take the comments of strangers so seriously

Edited

yes… imagine if the responses had been - “yeah your mil is right, he’s fat”… the OP would have then agreed with mil and suggested he diet presumably!

ThatChirpyScroller · 07/11/2026 17:51

twoyearsleft · 07/11/2026 17:20

You’re in the overweight category. Are you saying your 194 pounds is mainly muscle?

yes, I have visible abs and have weight trained for 18 years, I also run 4 times a week.

You’re basing this on BMI and it’s totally ancient, the NHS need to stop using it.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 07/11/2026 17:45

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 07/11/2026 17:14

The plan is to use this thread to work out how much to have a go at MIL when I see her tomorrow.

I agree words need to be had but get DH to do it. She might think you are being an over protective mum rather than realising she's an interfering busy body.

TweakTrick · 07/11/2026 17:45

Douglasmummy · 07/11/2026 16:18

really? My 18 year old has a 30 waist and is 5'10. He is very skinny. His BMI has always s hovered just above underweight. It's difficult to find him trousers. I can't see how 2 sizes up is fat?

Edited

Same. My 22 year-old has a 29/30 waist and is 5 foot 10. He’s unbelievably thin and really self-conscious. He would love to be bigger and he eats a lot but he just can’t put on the weight. He has joined the gym so he’s hoping that will make a difference.

fiorentina · 07/11/2026 17:45

I mean I know from experience that you can be skinny fat, eg a bit flabby or have a bloated stomach even though you’re skinny, but he doesn’t sound that way.

My MIL frequently comments on other people’s weight despite not being tiny herself, as MN constantly says it seems to be a generational thing but it’s still rude and these days deeply inappropriate.

ACR7 · 07/11/2026 17:45

twoyearsleft · 07/11/2026 15:15

I would say waist 34 is entering being a bit fat.

My 18 yr old is 6ft 4” with a 30” waist.

My husband is 6ft 4 and a 34 inch waist. He’s nowhere near fat.