Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want the city of Edinburgh council to ban deadly Voi e-bikes

34 replies

CurdinHenry · 07/11/2026 14:12

I left my accommodation an hour ago and have narrowly avoided been hit twice by men speeding along the pavement

They disn't even acknowledge me despite certainty of serious injury if I hadn't leapt aside

If anyone out there is hurt please sue their arses off I'll be a witness for how bad it is - there's no way they don't know

Very glad indeed to have moved south, annoyed that my visitor levy isn't paying for my safety in any obvious way

OP posts:
FloorWipes · 08/11/2026 08:49

I haven't have any specific issues with the Voi bikes. The number of deliveroo/Uber eats/juts eat bikes jumping red lights etc I find more of a problem.

I think overall Edinburgh is dealing with a major systemic issue with our road network breaking down. Many pieces of infrastructure are reaching such an age that they are needing major work leading many roads and bridges being shut over long periods. The traffic situation has deteriorated massively. This had also made some parts of the public transport network basically unviable to use, with massively extended journey times. I think the extreme levels of tourism must also be a contributing factor. Travel has become so challenging that I can absolutely understand people seeking alternative modes and routes. And there are many places where bikes and cars don't mix well on the roads, given the age and geography of the city, and the cycle network is obviously far from complete though attempts are being made.

It's tough. We need the Council to bring in some system optimization people or something because, although there are a lot of aspects of this can't be helped, like Victorian infrastructure, I don't think they are managing it as well as they could be.

But eliminating the Voi bikes seems silly. They are considered a success and are being extended. Transport is so challenging for people that need to be places and this is an option! We need better policing of the traffic, including on the roads themselves.

Knowthatfeeling · 08/11/2026 08:59

So many Voi bike users in Edinburgh seem to have a death wish. Encountered one last weekend- driving along, turned a corner and was confronted by one riding at high speed towards us on the wrong side of the road, looked completely off his face. Had to swerve to avoid him.

I would like to see helmets mandatory for e bikes; also a ban on using them if intoxicated; and rules of the road actually enforced. I have also seen groups of under 16s riding them incredibly dangerously - under 16s are not supposed to use them but again this is not enforced. They really are a menace, and I say this as a cyclist.

balkanscot · 08/11/2026 09:17

I used JustEat bike scheme during lockdown, before the scheme got scrapped due to high levels of vandalism, as many other people did, but even in those challenging circumstances it wasn’t such mayhem. Admittedly, there was less road traffic during then but I liked the scheme and it was mainly non-electric bikes (there were a few on offer but I never took them up).

Re: delivery riders on ebikes, yes, they can be a real menace, too, but I feel they are not so bumblingly oblivious.

I was in London recently and I continuously had to have my wits with me walking on the pavement/using pedestrian crossings due to countless Lime and other scheme ebikes zooming all over the place without a second thought for pedestrians.

ChilledProsecco · 08/11/2026 09:23

I was nearly taken out by a Deliveroo e-biker on Shandwick place - he was going through a pedestrian crossing with the green man on. Total lunatic.

And I’m fed up with the Neds on scooters & e-bikes at Cramond too - a total to the kids, dogs, walkers & joggers.

There’s no enforcement- so they just continue.

LeopardOnEverything · 08/11/2026 09:56

Not you again! "Deadly" is a bit dramatic. Voi bikes haven't actually killed anyone AFAIK.

Myheartwillalwaysbebelfast · 08/11/2026 13:56

CurdinHenry · 07/11/2026 19:53

Yes but voi seems to be council endorsed

It's far from a perfect scheme but the benefits far outweigh any negatives.
Especially when the issue is all kinds of bikes causing issues so getting rid would only improve it very slightly not enough to give up the benefits of the scheme.

Mossyfox · 08/11/2026 13:59

TheFishFish · 07/11/2026 18:58

I hope you want cars banned too.

Cars aren't usually speeding along the pavement.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 08/11/2026 15:39

LeopardOnEverything · 08/11/2026 09:56

Not you again! "Deadly" is a bit dramatic. Voi bikes haven't actually killed anyone AFAIK.

There are concerns nationally about the serious injuries caused by e-bikes, plus the reduction in walking rates caused by dangerous pavements.

There is a need for much tighter restrictions on use, fines for illegal/dangerous use and insurance.

Ukkake · 08/11/2026 16:33

I don’t know what the point of mentioning ‘men’ was.
Rather than banning everything these days, we need to work on another solution. If we ban the government funded e-bikes, what do we do with the privately owned bikes?
Perhaps compulsory basic training or a type of licensing might help.

They do have a use but I agree they can be dangerous but banning them won’t achieve much.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page