Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be jealous of older generations who were able to buy houses because their bosses exaggerated their salaries?

631 replies

HonestTealPoster · 07/11/2026 09:05

Yesterday I was at the spa and got talking to a man who was older than me (I’m 33 and I’d put him in his early 50s at most).

He told me that when he was in his 20s, he and his friend were able to buy properties in the area of South London where I grew up.

Despite not earning particularly much at the time, his boss wrote a letter stating that he earned £90,000 a year! He openly admitted that he wasn’t earning anywhere near that amount but the letter helped him secure a mortgage. He also received £5,000 from his grandmother towards the purchase.

I’d heard stories about people being able to do things like this years ago but I’d never actually met someone who’d benefited from it!

I was genuinely gobsmacked. Imagine being able to get on the property ladder like that.

AIBU to feel rather envious of how much easier some people had it when it came to buying their first home?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
CountryCob · 07/11/2026 12:11

Don't believe everything random strangers tell you. That person may never have bought a house and the letter described is not typical of the time.

TheAmberKoala · 07/11/2026 12:09

AMillionTomorrows · 07/11/2026 09:09

YANBU. You can be jealous but it’s not going to help you. If you want to live like people in their 50s did 30 years ago, get rid of your mobile phone and internet, get a landline, stop eating out and buying take away coffees, ditch the avocado toast, netflix, Disney and Amazon Prime, your car, and your foreign holidays. You’ll probably save up quicker.

The get rid of your phone thing is a ridiculous comparison. I literally couldnt do my job without my phone. Im also in my 50s and having a mobile is no different in cost to having a landline was. Having netflix is relatively cheaper than hiring new release VHS tapes from blockbuster in the early 90s.

Funnywonder · 07/11/2026 12:07

Growlybear83 · 07/11/2026 11:47

There was also the issue of banks and building societies mis-selling endowment policies in the 1980s. I still have the diagram that the manager from our bank drew when he was trying to convince us thst an endowment mortgage was a wonderful thing and would leave us with a huge lump sum when the mortgage was paid off. In common with many people, we believed what we were told and there was no internet to do our own research or forums to seek advice. When we started to get the predicted value of the endowment 15 years later we started to get concerned but the bank reassured us that it was on track for a couple more years, and then we realised thst we would be in trouble if we didn’t do something. It turned out that the full endowment we had been told we had taken out was actually a low cost endowment, which had no chance of ever paying off the capital sum. Fortunately because I had kept the original diagram and letters from the bank from when we first took out the mortgsge, we were able to claim compensation successfully and we got enough back to repay the mortgage at the end of its term, but never got to see the best egg we had been promised when we took out the mortgage.

We had an endowment mortgage. Actually three endowment policies for one mortgage due to a house move etc. Those letters, warning about a shortfall, dropping on the doormat every few months were terrifying. They became increasingly more urgent. I remember we joked because one company’s letterheads were brown and we called them the ‘brown trouser time’ warnings, because if we didn’t laugh, we’d cry. We did have a shortfall at the end of the term but we had taken advice and saved separately to cover it. But we weren’t high earners by any stretch of the imagination and it was bloody tough.

Lampsandlightsandotherthings · 07/11/2026 12:07

This is a ridiculous anecdote. He’s not that old for starters and even if, if what he bragged about was true, he’d have to remortgage at interest rate intervals and probably moved a few times needing to back up claims. Implying people just bs’d their way into mortgages is not quite reality.

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 12:06

Just to add it was much easier to buy a house. But it was much easier in 2000 to buy a house,when we bought our current house. It is in the last ten years it has become very hard.

Wadsworthy · 07/11/2026 12:02

AIBU to feel rather envious of how much easier some people had it when it came to buying their first home?

YABU.

I bought my first home when salaries needed to be proven by 6 months of payslips, and I could only borrow 1.5 or at most 2 x my salary. And then interest rates shot up to 15%

My first house had no hearting or hot water. I worked 1 FT job + 2 part-time jobs to afford to put in modern plumbing.

HappyViewer · 07/11/2026 11:58

HonestTealPoster · 07/11/2026 11:56

I don’t disagree that the purpose of inflating his salary was presumably to qualify for borrowing he wouldn’t otherwise have been offered. That’s the advantage I’ve been referring to throughout this exchange.

But qualifying for a larger mortgage doesn’t automatically tell us whether the resulting repayments were manageable for him. The figures you’ve provided illustrate one possible scenario not the reality of his particular circumstances.

I understand perfectly well why you wouldn’t envy the prospect of taking on potentially unaffordable debt. But that’s not what I’ve said I envied.

You seem to be evaluating whether you’d personally have wanted his mortgage, whereas I’ve been commenting on the fact that he apparently gained access to homeownership through an arrangement that wouldn’t withstand today’s scrutiny. Those are two different observations and I don’t think we actually need to disagree about the financial risks to recognise that distinction.

Your feelings of jealousy are valid, It was easier for a lot of people then.

HonestTealPoster · 07/11/2026 11:56

5128gap · 07/11/2026 11:50

The only reason he would need to inflate his salary would be to borrow more than he would have been permitted on his actual salary. If he was after a comfortably affordable mortgage there was no need to lie.
The figures are just an example to illustrate the reality of what a person lying they were on £90k to afford the sort of mortgage available on that income would likely be facing, to demonstrate that its not a position I'd be jealous of.

I don’t disagree that the purpose of inflating his salary was presumably to qualify for borrowing he wouldn’t otherwise have been offered. That’s the advantage I’ve been referring to throughout this exchange.

But qualifying for a larger mortgage doesn’t automatically tell us whether the resulting repayments were manageable for him. The figures you’ve provided illustrate one possible scenario not the reality of his particular circumstances.

I understand perfectly well why you wouldn’t envy the prospect of taking on potentially unaffordable debt. But that’s not what I’ve said I envied.

You seem to be evaluating whether you’d personally have wanted his mortgage, whereas I’ve been commenting on the fact that he apparently gained access to homeownership through an arrangement that wouldn’t withstand today’s scrutiny. Those are two different observations and I don’t think we actually need to disagree about the financial risks to recognise that distinction.

OP posts:
MrMarkhamsFanClub · 07/11/2026 11:55

I really don't know of anyone who did this - 'older generation' or not - and i don't believe this fraudulent behaviour was widespread.
What I was always jealous of was 100% mortgages, no deposit required. Although on a mortgage rate of 16% when i bought my first home perhaps it might have brought its own challenges.
Different times, different circumstances bring their own set of problems we would all do well to acknowledge.

Eta typo

Patatiipatata · 07/11/2026 11:51

gibletsarerank · 07/11/2026 10:47

@Patatiipatataoh yes it’s absolute shit show but the gains some experienced are insane. Houses that were 50k ish in the 80s well over 1m now.

Yes if I had to choose one thing that was a terrible mistake it would be allowing interest only mortgages. That and selling off council property

5128gap · 07/11/2026 11:50

HonestTealPoster · 07/11/2026 11:24

But you’ve now assumed he purchased in the 1980s, borrowed £225,000 and was paying 15% interest, despite none of those details having been established. He appeared to be in his early 50s and told me he purchased in his 20s, which would place the purchase considerably later than the period you’re using for your calculations.

I agree that the repayments in your hypothetical scenario would be substantial but that doesn’t tell us what this particular man actually borrowed or paid.

And I think we’re returning to the same distinction. My envy was about his apparent ability to access homeownership through an arrangement that wouldn’t withstand today’s scrutiny, not about whether taking on his particular mortgage was financially comfortable or advisable.

I’m not suggesting his experience was universally representative or that irresponsible lending was without consequences. I’m simply questioning why hypothetical repayment calculations are being treated as evidence of circumstances neither of us actually knows.

The only reason he would need to inflate his salary would be to borrow more than he would have been permitted on his actual salary. If he was after a comfortably affordable mortgage there was no need to lie.
The figures are just an example to illustrate the reality of what a person lying they were on £90k to afford the sort of mortgage available on that income would likely be facing, to demonstrate that its not a position I'd be jealous of.

Growlybear83 · 07/11/2026 11:47

There was also the issue of banks and building societies mis-selling endowment policies in the 1980s. I still have the diagram that the manager from our bank drew when he was trying to convince us thst an endowment mortgage was a wonderful thing and would leave us with a huge lump sum when the mortgage was paid off. In common with many people, we believed what we were told and there was no internet to do our own research or forums to seek advice. When we started to get the predicted value of the endowment 15 years later we started to get concerned but the bank reassured us that it was on track for a couple more years, and then we realised thst we would be in trouble if we didn’t do something. It turned out that the full endowment we had been told we had taken out was actually a low cost endowment, which had no chance of ever paying off the capital sum. Fortunately because I had kept the original diagram and letters from the bank from when we first took out the mortgsge, we were able to claim compensation successfully and we got enough back to repay the mortgage at the end of its term, but never got to see the best egg we had been promised when we took out the mortgage.

Funnywonder · 07/11/2026 11:46

FKAT · 07/11/2026 11:07

The moral of this thread is that 50 year old blokes who frequent spas on a weekday will tell any old bullshit to gullible younger women.

There is no way on earth that a bank would think that a 20 something bloke in the 90s was on £90k. That would have been more than the Prime Minister.

I agree. Not sure why the OP thinks this is any less ‘anecdotal’ than the other tales she’s apparently heard. I mean, unless he produced paperwork from inside his towelling robe, then it’s safe to assume he may well have been exaggerating.

MsMelly · 07/11/2026 11:45

I’m early 50’s. No fraud here to get a mortgage in the 90’s. I’m rocked to the core being described as “the older generation “. I had no idea we were viewed as “older “.

Lifeomars · 07/11/2026 11:45

saraclara · 07/11/2026 11:28

We had a beanbag, a bed and a cooker, when we moved into our first, two bed terraced, home. My monthly salary was £220 and the mortgage and endowment policy that had to accompany it came to £190. Feb 1978.

I was going to post a photo of the first page of my household finance book, which I still have, but despite blocking the rest of the items out, I thought it probably wasn't a good idea.

We really weren't living in clover.

Edited

we didn't have central heating, no carpet (we painted the floorboards and put a large rug down) no freezer, just a small fridge with an ice box, single glazing, no car, saved up to get a land line installed and had a second hand black and white TV. Thing was that everybody we knew were in similar circumstances, nobody had much and nobody expected to have every thing all at once. One of my mates had deck chairs in her living room as they could not afford chairs and a sofa. We had to work and save, I do think that things are difficult for young people today and the main reason for this is the extortinate price of property and sky high rents

CookerHat · 07/11/2026 11:44

A pp nailed it when they said for some reason we’re not allowed to acknowledge that it’s more difficult to get on the housing ladder these days. People using the the argument that they had to pay 15% interest, well yes but that would still have been cheaper than than paying 4% in the same house that was bought today for three times the price!

No one can deny that house prices have sky rocketed so then you can’t argue that today’s generation are not in a worse situation. My house has gone up by £60k in about 10 years without any adjustments to it. That will be the same up an down the country and whilst it makes no odds to me, in that if I wanted to move, that house would be mor expensive too, it does impact first time buyers as they would need to find an extra £60k more than what we had to, simply due to timing. So anyone thinks they younger generation don’t have it harder needs to give their head a wobble!

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 11:41

Oxymorons · 07/11/2026 11:35

Yes. We bought a house in 1988 his employer exaggerated his overtime earnings, because we couldn't afford the house without it. It was common. Negative equity was common, with friends having to wait 15 years before they could sell. Mortgage rates went up to 15 per cent. Our mortgage became more than the whole of my husband's salary. I had to get a cleaning job on top of my full time job. A lot of people on these mortgages paid higher interest for the privilege of being able to include overtime etc on the original mortgage, all sold by unscrupulous brokers, banks and building societies. Our mortgage even then, was £804 a month.

Also - I was working doing a job with the title "admin officer" which was identical to the man next to me his job title "project manager"! at nearly twice the salary. There is still inequality in pay between the genders of course
I am not belittling what you are saying OP, I know it's hard currently, some people did make lots of money buying property in the past, but a lot of people lost their houses too.

You used a dodgy mortgage broker presumably? Because banks and building societies asked for wage skips.

The late eighties was the time of job title inflation. In my workplace before then most people who managed staff were called supervisors, To have manager in your title you were pretty senior. Then everyone started getting manager in their job title instead of a pay rise. Even people who didn't manage staff.

Project managers previously managed big infrastructure projects. Then yes people who would have been called admin started to get called project managers.

It's why when people say things like my father in the eighties was only a supervisor and earned gazillions it's meaningless. Job titles from then till now are not comparable,

Sillyme1 · 07/11/2026 11:40

We bought out house in 1982 and yes it was cheap compared to today, but it was almost a slum. I had a toddler running around on bare floorboards, a garden full of old cookers and glass and we have virtually replaced everything in the house, walls, floors, electric etc which we mostly did ourselves. I don’t think we had it particularly easy, all our clothes were from jumble sales and we never went out. A treat was a weekly bottle of cider between us! Our income was pretty low too.

HappyViewer · 07/11/2026 11:39

Growlybear83 · 07/11/2026 11:28

A purchase price of £225,000 in the 1980s woukd have bought an incredibly huge, top of the market house. For contrast, we paid £35,000 in 1982 for a reasonably large four bedroom house in south London.

The dates sound more like latish 1990’s or early 2000’s if he’s is early 50’s.

I bought my third house in 2001 for 300k so it doesn’t sound impossible.

MadameEtourdie · 07/11/2026 11:37

Suspicioustoenails · 07/11/2026 09:16

Oh give over

Things have changed and the massive gap between salaries and house prices can't be solved by saving the price of a Netflix subscription and a few lattes.

Edited

My grandma used to say “look after your pennies and your pounds will look after themselves.”
There is some truth in it, I have discovered.

Badvocthebad · 07/11/2026 11:37

I knew someone who did this in the early 2000s.
Didn't end well...
They lost the house because - surprise! - they couldn't actually afford it.
They ended up in negative equity and had to live with their parents for a time.

Oxymorons · 07/11/2026 11:35

Pleasealexa · 07/11/2026 09:18

It was idiotic behaviour by Lenders and caused the financial crash in 2008 due to Sub prime mortgages.

Perhaps a few people were winners but most people didn't think it was sensible to exaggerate your salary, if you intended on paying it back.

Yes. We bought a house in 1988 his employer exaggerated his overtime earnings, because we couldn't afford the house without it. It was common. Negative equity was common, with friends having to wait 15 years before they could sell. Mortgage rates went up to 15 per cent. Our mortgage became more than the whole of my husband's salary. I had to get a cleaning job on top of my full time job. A lot of people on these mortgages paid higher interest for the privilege of being able to include overtime etc on the original mortgage, all sold by unscrupulous brokers, banks and building societies. Our mortgage even then, was £804 a month.

Also - I was working doing a job with the title "admin officer" which was identical to the man next to me his job title "project manager"! at nearly twice the salary. There is still inequality in pay between the genders of course
I am not belittling what you are saying OP, I know it's hard currently, some people did make lots of money buying property in the past, but a lot of people lost their houses too.

Zov · 07/11/2026 11:35

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 11:25

Being envious of one man is fine. Being envious of all older people is not,
I got £709 inheritance when both my parents died. We paid money out for my in-laws funeral and inherited nothing. Lots of young people will get big inheritances.

When I got a mortgage you needed wage slips,that was forty years ago. There were dodgy mortgage brokers who charged high interest rates who were known to do dodgy practices like accept a letter. They did so because they made a lot of money through the higher interest rates and/or commission.

I am jealous of young people. I had no support once I left home at 18. My life would have been so much easier with the level of support taken for granted these days. I am disabled and the level of support for disabled people in the past was atrocious. I would at minimum have got DLA.

This.

I have never had an inheritance. Not one single bean. My grandparents and parents lived in rented accommodation, and had no assets. I wasn't even left enough to pay for and organise my parents funerals. Same story with DH. We both had to pay for our parents funerals, as our siblings - (we have 1 each, both a few years younger,) did fuck-all to help and contributed fuck-all.

It makes my blood boil when younger people assume we all had it easy back in the day. Not all younger people do, (my 2 DC don't,) but the ones who haven't researched things properly, and educated themselves on the subject, assume everyone over 55 has had a piss easy life.

I don't know whether to laugh or cry, when I hear this, and think of how DH and I struggled so much financially during the 1990s and the noughties, with horrific mortgage rates, and the 1990s recession and the late noughties credit crunch... whilst raising our 2 children, and giving them everything they needed...

Lifeomars · 07/11/2026 11:35

While i am not going to say this never happened this is the first i have ever heard of it and even if if there were a few rare cases it would be an idiotic thing to do. Apart from being fraud the person buying a property they do not have the income to pay for is just asking for trouble. We had to submit pay slips and bank statements and a letter from the employer (all on paper of course as it was the olden days) and while i guess these could be faked, altered or just false information I've never known it to happen. Why be jealous about what is essentially an illegal act?

Sherararara · 07/11/2026 11:29

Boohoo