Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable for not making more effort with my pregnant sister-in-law?

85 replies

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:00

I'm trying to work out whether I'm being unreasonable or whether I'm right to feel the way I do. I'd appreciate some outside perspective because I feel like there's an expectation on me to make more effort with my sister-in-law, despite the history between us.

For context, she's my husband's younger brother's wife. They live about an hour away from us. I married my husband in 2023, and she married his brother two years earlier. Our relationship has always been a bit up and down. We had a major falling-out several years ago, and although things have been civil at times since, we've never been particularly close.

She's someone who can be perfectly pleasant on occasion, but she can also be quite dismissive and, at times, rude. When we're in the same room, she'll often make very little effort to have a conversation and seems to expect everyone else to carry it. We don't impose ourselves on her or expect her to go out of her way for us.

There have been a few incidents over the years that have stuck with me. Two recent ones. When I was around 33 weeks pregnant, her husband was staying at our house following an argument between them. Another sister of my husbands was also staying with us at the time. Rather than messaging me or my husband to say she was coming over, she contacted this relative to say she was coming over, despite the fact that we own the house. Why are you telling guests (yes, I know she's related to them to) that you're planning a surprise visit before telling us?

At around 35 weeks pregnant, one week shy of term my husband and I visited their house. She and her sister barely made any effort to speak to me throughout the visit. I was heavily pregnant and felt quite uncomfortable and ignored. She did send an apology afterwards, but by then the damage had already been done and it felt hollow.

Another thing I've noticed is that my own siblings have always been perfectly welcoming towards her. Whenever they've visited, they've made conversation, included her and treated her nicely, regardless of any issues I've personally had with her. I've never expected them to treat her differently because of my relationship with her.

After having my daughter, I initially did try to maintain contact and tried to remember that there were times that she did make effort. I even kept her updated when I was in hospital with an infection. However, over time, I stopped initiating conversations because I felt there was very little interest in how I was doing or how I was coping as a new mum and in that moment of postpartum sensitivity I remember her rudeness and the things she;s done over the years.. She rarely checks in, and get the impression that she only messages because my mother-in-law has prompted her. I've overheard my MIL encouraging her to contact me, and then, almost immediately afterwards, I'll receive a message.
I always respond when she contacts me, and I've thanked her for invitations to her house. I haven't ignored her or deliberately made her feel unwelcome. I've just stopped being the one to initiate everything.

Shortly after I had my daughter, my sister-in-law found out she was pregnant too. It was unexpected, and her relationship with her husband has historically been quite turbulent, with frequent arguments and difficulties. My husband hopes that having a baby might help them settle down and bring them closer together.

Since becoming pregnant, she's randomly messaged me asking about nappies and has also asked whether she can visit. I did find this a little surprising because they haven't historically made much effort to visit us and she's hardly ever asked about my daughter. I also wondered whether the renewed interest was genuine or whether she simply sees an opportunity for us to bond now that we're both having daughters around a similar age.

I appreciate that I might be reading too much into this. Perhaps pregnancy has made her think differently about family relationships, and perhaps she genuinely does want to reconnect. I don't want to assume the worst. But I also don't think having children of the same gender and similar ages automatically creates a close relationship or means the past should be forgotten.

The other issue is my mother-in-law. She insists that I should make more effort with my younger brother-in-law and his wife because I'm married to the eldest son. I feel as though there's an unspoken expectation that I'm responsible for maintaining family relationships and keeping everyone connected, particularly because my husband and his younger sister, who lives with us, aren't particularly talkative with his brother.

For context, my husband and I own our home, and we also have my mother-in-law, father-in-law and my husband's younger sister living with us. I contribute half the household bills, and we allow my husband's siblings to come and go as they please. I've never made them feel unwelcome or as though they're imposing on us. I feel I already contribute a lot to the family, both practically and financially, and I don't understand why I'm also expected to take responsibility for relationships that aren't mine alone to maintain.

My MIL has also suggested that my husband and I having a baby, after being married for two years, might have prompted my brother-in-law and sister-in-law to reflect on their own lives and start moving forward with their relationship. If that's true, then I'm genuinely happy if we've had a positive influence on them. However, I sometimes feel that this creates yet another expectation for me to include them, build a bond and help everyone move forward together.
I don't think that's my responsibility. Whatever changes they make in their marriage or family life need to come from them.

My husband is aware of the issues and agrees that his brother's wife can be rude and never made much effort with the family and he's seen this for almost 6 years, so it predates me. He's witnessed some of the behaviour himself and understands why I've become reluctant to initiate contact. He also thinks some of her rudeness during my pregnancy was down to jealousy that we'd been married for half the time they have and already starting a family.

I should also mention that my husband has helped his brother financially over the years, and I've noticed little comments from my sister-in-law towards him that I find quite unpleasant. I sometimes wonder whether there's an element of jealousy, as my husband has historically been more financially comfortable than his brother.

To be clear, I have absolutely nothing against her being pregnant. I genuinely wish her well, and I don't want to make what could already be an emotional time any harder for her. If she visits my house, I'm polite, welcoming etc.

I just don't feel I should suddenly have to pursue a close relationship because she's pregnant. I went through pregnancy, childbirth and the early stages of motherhood without feeling much consideration or support from her, so I don't see why I'm now expected to put in extra effort simply because her circumstances have changed.

My husband and I are also hoping to start trying for another baby in the new year. We're both excited about expanding our family and would love for our daughter to have siblings. I genuinely enjoyed pregnancy and am looking forward to that next chapter. I want to focus on my own family and the life we're building rather than feeling as though I constantly need to build bridges and buddy with my husbands brother's wife who hasn't historically shown much interest in doing the same. She might want to do that now but it's too late.
I don't want a falling-out, arguments at family gatherings. I'm happy for our children to know each other, spend time together and as cousins. I just want to maintain a polite, respectful relationship without feeling obliged to initiate conversations, constantly check in or manufacture a closeness that isn't naturally there.

So, am I being unreasonable for not making more effort now that she's pregnant?

OP posts:
mumumental · 07/11/2026 09:29

Wow. Long post.

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 09:26

ConfusedSoShutUp · 07/11/2026 09:16

It seems to me you are being lined up as the matriarch of the family/replacement matriarch To be all welcoming, all relationship-overseeing, all bountiful. But maybe without all the siblings knowledge/buy in

You can say no.

You can define the relationships you have with people.

I would drop the visit thing. Her husband was at yours post argument. She communicated with one of the siblings (OK, etiquette -wise not the right one) but give her a break on this one during an argument with her husband. Let this go.

Well, the whole point of my post, which seems to have become a little derailed by people assuming I’m some sort of weird goblin standing at the front of my house shouting “DO NOT ENTER”, is that the house situation is actually a relatively small part of a much bigger issue.

Generally, I’m not particularly precious about people coming over. I just think that when I work incredibly hard to maintain a home, coming home from work at 30 weeks pregnant to find more people there, when neither my husband nor I had any idea they were coming, is understandably a little off-putting especially in a house full of guests. Especially when, ultimately, the responsibility for cleaning up, sorting out food and making arrangements if people decide to stay over falls on me.

But that’s not really the point I was trying to make.

I don’t want to be the matriarch. I don’t want to be the person who constantly bends over backwards to accommodate everyone, particularly people who have never really extended the same consideration to me. It’s exhausting, and I’m tired of feeling like that responsibility automatically falls on my shoulders.

I also have a long and complicated history with my SIL. There have been things in the past that have genuinely hurt me, (which I've not mentioned here) and I suppose what I was really looking for was a bit of reassurance that it’s okay to feel that way. That pregnancy doesn’t suddenly erase years of complicated history, and that just because she's having a baby, I don’t have to pretend that everyone is suddenly going to become best friends.

I’m not trying to create conflict or dictate how anyone behaves. I just want to know that it’s okay to have boundaries, to protect my own peace and to not feel obligated to suddenly take on a role that I never wanted in the first place.

OP posts:
Busybeemumm · 07/11/2026 09:25

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:44

they aren't telling the people that live here either. the only person they told was a guest - my husband's other sister - who came from out of town and who, by the way, also has the courtesy to tell my mil she's coming over. I'm sorry but in our culture it's weird. Our house belongs to my husband, his parents and his younger sister. If you don't live here, yes you do need to tell people who live in the house that you plan to visit.

Similarly, I live away from my parents. I give my parents the courtesy of telling them I plan to visit.

Maybe in your in laws household they don't feel the need to inform or ask to visit unlike in your family.

Although you own the home and in-laws are living with you (you own the home) however from your DH siblings pov you are all living together and consider it their family/parents home hence don't feel the need to announce their plan to visit.

Maybe living with in-laws isn't right for you and you all need your own space.

ConfusedSoShutUp · 07/11/2026 09:16

It seems to me you are being lined up as the matriarch of the family/replacement matriarch To be all welcoming, all relationship-overseeing, all bountiful. But maybe without all the siblings knowledge/buy in

You can say no.

You can define the relationships you have with people.

I would drop the visit thing. Her husband was at yours post argument. She communicated with one of the siblings (OK, etiquette -wise not the right one) but give her a break on this one during an argument with her husband. Let this go.

nomas · 07/11/2026 08:56

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:18

As I mentioned in the post.

My husbands parents live with us. so does his sister. his brother and wife historically have come and gone as they please and never even tell us they're coming over.

Your PIL should move back to their own home and get carers.

I think the frustration and suffocation of this situation might be getting to you.

They have all forgotten that this isn’t their family home, that it’s your home.

nomas · 07/11/2026 08:54

LipglossAndLies · 07/11/2026 08:38

Well they live their its their home too, they are children who need to tell you, they are adults. If tou are so annoyed abiut it then they cna love back into their house and have anyone drop by then.

Just don't understand why you are so irate over people coming over withiut informing you. This way of thinking treats your mil and pil etc. Like lodgers.

Are you for real? People on MN get irate about people knocking on their door and you’re expecting OP to be fine with people dropping over unannounced all the time. Is it because she’s South Asian that you think she should have no agency in her own home?

nomas · 07/11/2026 08:52

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:29

they don't tell my mil or fil either. they just come and go as they please.

That is very rude of them.

Your DH needs to be clear with them that is this his and your house and his parents just live there, they do not own it, they don’t rent it, and they need to respect that.

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:51

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 08:47

Whatever the ufll details of the house incident, it's not a reason to fall out with SIL.

that's not why I fell out with her.

OP posts:
nomas · 07/11/2026 08:50

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:40

When did i say anything about 'asking permission'. Listen, I'm from an asian background. where we come from no it is not considered normal to turn up at your mil/fil/sil/bil house without letting anyone there know that you are coming. she told someone who lives in another country and was staying as a guest that she plans to come without telling the people who actually live in the house that she's planning to come. It's considered very entitled and my mother in law and sister in law who live here felt the same way,

I think your MIL and PIL need to get back in their box, they are living rent free in your house and have the audacity to expect you to manage their family.

Who does the cooking and cleaning?

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 08:47

Whatever the ufll details of the house incident, it's not a reason to fall out with SIL.

Arbourimage · 07/11/2026 08:45

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:40

When did i say anything about 'asking permission'. Listen, I'm from an asian background. where we come from no it is not considered normal to turn up at your mil/fil/sil/bil house without letting anyone there know that you are coming. she told someone who lives in another country and was staying as a guest that she plans to come without telling the people who actually live in the house that she's planning to come. It's considered very entitled and my mother in law and sister in law who live here felt the same way,

You quite clearly expect her to ask your permission, you seem to be on a power trip as far as this girl is concerned and it’s really not clear that she has done a whole lot “wrong” to deserve your reactions.

TraitorOrFaithful · 07/11/2026 08:44

I think you are being a little bit unreasonable OP. You don't need to be super close friends, but it would be nice to be friendly with her, and a new baby is often something that brings families together. None of the things she's done sound that bad. Why not respond to her pleasantly?

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:44

HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · 07/11/2026 08:36

I don't understand why they would tell you as they are telling the people that also live there. Presumably, the in-laws that live there don't need permission to invite people over or do they? If they were just guests there i would understand but as its their home too I didn't agree.

they aren't telling the people that live here either. the only person they told was a guest - my husband's other sister - who came from out of town and who, by the way, also has the courtesy to tell my mil she's coming over. I'm sorry but in our culture it's weird. Our house belongs to my husband, his parents and his younger sister. If you don't live here, yes you do need to tell people who live in the house that you plan to visit.

Similarly, I live away from my parents. I give my parents the courtesy of telling them I plan to visit.

OP posts:
Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 08:43

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:40

When did i say anything about 'asking permission'. Listen, I'm from an asian background. where we come from no it is not considered normal to turn up at your mil/fil/sil/bil house without letting anyone there know that you are coming. she told someone who lives in another country and was staying as a guest that she plans to come without telling the people who actually live in the house that she's planning to come. It's considered very entitled and my mother in law and sister in law who live here felt the same way,

Yet that someone was IN THE HOUSE.

It's not like she messaged someone in a different country saying she was coming to the house.

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:40

Arbourimage · 07/11/2026 08:34

You seem overly irate about this.
There are several other people in the home she’s visiting. You’re latching onto quite minor things because you don’t like her.
Does her SIL want her to visit? Does her MIL want her to visit?
I just don’t see why she needs to ask your permission. If other people are living in the home they are allowed to have visitors, particularly a family member.

When did i say anything about 'asking permission'. Listen, I'm from an asian background. where we come from no it is not considered normal to turn up at your mil/fil/sil/bil house without letting anyone there know that you are coming. she told someone who lives in another country and was staying as a guest that she plans to come without telling the people who actually live in the house that she's planning to come. It's considered very entitled and my mother in law and sister in law who live here felt the same way,

OP posts:
LipglossAndLies · 07/11/2026 08:38

Well they live their its their home too, they are children who need to tell you, they are adults. If tou are so annoyed abiut it then they cna love back into their house and have anyone drop by then.

Just don't understand why you are so irate over people coming over withiut informing you. This way of thinking treats your mil and pil etc. Like lodgers.

HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · 07/11/2026 08:36

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:18

As I mentioned in the post.

My husbands parents live with us. so does his sister. his brother and wife historically have come and gone as they please and never even tell us they're coming over.

I don't understand why they would tell you as they are telling the people that also live there. Presumably, the in-laws that live there don't need permission to invite people over or do they? If they were just guests there i would understand but as its their home too I didn't agree.

Arbourimage · 07/11/2026 08:34

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:28

it's not her sister who lives with us. it's our house, we live with my husbands parents and his younger sister. this is his younger brothers wife, the point i was making is that they regularly come and ago without telling anyone they are comign.

You seem overly irate about this.
There are several other people in the home she’s visiting. You’re latching onto quite minor things because you don’t like her.
Does her SIL want her to visit? Does her MIL want her to visit?
I just don’t see why she needs to ask your permission. If other people are living in the home they are allowed to have visitors, particularly a family member.

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:32

Goldengirl123 · 07/11/2026 08:15

Reading between the lines, I’m thinking that maybe you are the problem. You keep mentioning about owning your own home. What’s that got to do with it?

I'm mentioning it because there's a difference between this being my husband's and my own home, which we've opened up to his parents as a favour, and it being his siblings' childhood home where they can simply come and go as they please. We have our own household and our own family, but we've made space for his parents and accommodated the wider family. I'm not saying his siblings aren't welcome, but I don't think that means our home should automatically be treated as a place they can turn up whenever they like without consideration for us. That's the point I was making, not that owning a home makes me better than anyone.

OP posts:
ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:30

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 08:25

I think you have mis matched expectations of intergenerational living. The issue here is with FIL and MIL for not telling you. SIL shouldn't have to personally inform you because you own the house.

You invited the in-laws in, did you not have these kind of conversations setting ground rules first?

and it's not just that me and my husband own the house. it is our house. our inlaws live with us because it financially works out better for them. the point that I'm making is that they don't tell people when they're coming and going

OP posts:
ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:29

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 08:25

I think you have mis matched expectations of intergenerational living. The issue here is with FIL and MIL for not telling you. SIL shouldn't have to personally inform you because you own the house.

You invited the in-laws in, did you not have these kind of conversations setting ground rules first?

they don't tell my mil or fil either. they just come and go as they please.

OP posts:
ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:28

Arbourimage · 07/11/2026 08:25

I can’t really see why the relationship is so awful or why you think she’s behaved so badly.
You weren’t overly close before and she’s starting to reach out to you more now you will both have babies close in age. I don’t really get the big deal.
Some of the things you are holding onto seem unnecessary too, if her sister lives with you why would she need to ask your permission to come and see her?
You complain if you feel there’s an expectation that you should make more effort in the relationship because you are married to the older brother but then you clearly think you are in charge more by expecting her to ask your permission for things.

it's not her sister who lives with us. it's our house, we live with my husbands parents and his younger sister. this is his younger brothers wife, the point i was making is that they regularly come and ago without telling anyone they are comign.

OP posts:
Arbourimage · 07/11/2026 08:25

I can’t really see why the relationship is so awful or why you think she’s behaved so badly.
You weren’t overly close before and she’s starting to reach out to you more now you will both have babies close in age. I don’t really get the big deal.
Some of the things you are holding onto seem unnecessary too, if her sister lives with you why would she need to ask your permission to come and see her?
You complain if you feel there’s an expectation that you should make more effort in the relationship because you are married to the older brother but then you clearly think you are in charge more by expecting her to ask your permission for things.

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 08:25

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:23

We bought our house some time ago and welcomed my elderly mother-in-law and father-in-law into our home while their own property is rented out. So, whilst they live with us, it is still our home.
I'm not saying anyone needs to ask permission to visit, but I don't think it's unreasonable to expect a bit of common courtesy and a heads-up when people are planning to come over. There's a difference between asking permission and simply letting someone know you're coming.
At the end of the day, it's our home, and yes, I do think letting us know beforehand would be nice before one decides to drop by at 11pm in the night. It's about basic respect and consideration, not permission.

I think you have mis matched expectations of intergenerational living. The issue here is with FIL and MIL for not telling you. SIL shouldn't have to personally inform you because you own the house.

You invited the in-laws in, did you not have these kind of conversations setting ground rules first?

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:23

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 08:20

And...?

Owning the house doesn't mean it isn't their home. Do you expect MIL, FIL and sister to ask for permission every time someone comes over?

Edit for grammar.

Edited

We bought our house some time ago and welcomed my elderly mother-in-law and father-in-law into our home while their own property is rented out. So, whilst they live with us, it is still our home.
I'm not saying anyone needs to ask permission to visit, but I don't think it's unreasonable to expect a bit of common courtesy and a heads-up when people are planning to come over. There's a difference between asking permission and simply letting someone know you're coming.
At the end of the day, it's our home, and yes, I do think letting us know beforehand would be nice before one decides to drop by at 11pm in the night. It's about basic respect and consideration, not permission.

OP posts: