I'm trying to work out whether I'm being unreasonable or whether I'm right to feel the way I do. I'd appreciate some outside perspective because I feel like there's an expectation on me to make more effort with my sister-in-law, despite the history between us.
For context, she's my husband's younger brother's wife. They live about an hour away from us. I married my husband in 2023, and she married his brother two years earlier. Our relationship has always been a bit up and down. We had a major falling-out several years ago, and although things have been civil at times since, we've never been particularly close.
She's someone who can be perfectly pleasant on occasion, but she can also be quite dismissive and, at times, rude. When we're in the same room, she'll often make very little effort to have a conversation and seems to expect everyone else to carry it. We don't impose ourselves on her or expect her to go out of her way for us.
There have been a few incidents over the years that have stuck with me. Two recent ones. When I was around 33 weeks pregnant, her husband was staying at our house following an argument between them. Another sister of my husbands was also staying with us at the time. Rather than messaging me or my husband to say she was coming over, she contacted this relative to say she was coming over, despite the fact that we own the house. Why are you telling guests (yes, I know she's related to them to) that you're planning a surprise visit before telling us?
At around 35 weeks pregnant, one week shy of term my husband and I visited their house. She and her sister barely made any effort to speak to me throughout the visit. I was heavily pregnant and felt quite uncomfortable and ignored. She did send an apology afterwards, but by then the damage had already been done and it felt hollow.
Another thing I've noticed is that my own siblings have always been perfectly welcoming towards her. Whenever they've visited, they've made conversation, included her and treated her nicely, regardless of any issues I've personally had with her. I've never expected them to treat her differently because of my relationship with her.
After having my daughter, I initially did try to maintain contact and tried to remember that there were times that she did make effort. I even kept her updated when I was in hospital with an infection. However, over time, I stopped initiating conversations because I felt there was very little interest in how I was doing or how I was coping as a new mum and in that moment of postpartum sensitivity I remember her rudeness and the things she;s done over the years.. She rarely checks in, and get the impression that she only messages because my mother-in-law has prompted her. I've overheard my MIL encouraging her to contact me, and then, almost immediately afterwards, I'll receive a message.
I always respond when she contacts me, and I've thanked her for invitations to her house. I haven't ignored her or deliberately made her feel unwelcome. I've just stopped being the one to initiate everything.
Shortly after I had my daughter, my sister-in-law found out she was pregnant too. It was unexpected, and her relationship with her husband has historically been quite turbulent, with frequent arguments and difficulties. My husband hopes that having a baby might help them settle down and bring them closer together.
Since becoming pregnant, she's randomly messaged me asking about nappies and has also asked whether she can visit. I did find this a little surprising because they haven't historically made much effort to visit us and she's hardly ever asked about my daughter. I also wondered whether the renewed interest was genuine or whether she simply sees an opportunity for us to bond now that we're both having daughters around a similar age.
I appreciate that I might be reading too much into this. Perhaps pregnancy has made her think differently about family relationships, and perhaps she genuinely does want to reconnect. I don't want to assume the worst. But I also don't think having children of the same gender and similar ages automatically creates a close relationship or means the past should be forgotten.
The other issue is my mother-in-law. She insists that I should make more effort with my younger brother-in-law and his wife because I'm married to the eldest son. I feel as though there's an unspoken expectation that I'm responsible for maintaining family relationships and keeping everyone connected, particularly because my husband and his younger sister, who lives with us, aren't particularly talkative with his brother.
For context, my husband and I own our home, and we also have my mother-in-law, father-in-law and my husband's younger sister living with us. I contribute half the household bills, and we allow my husband's siblings to come and go as they please. I've never made them feel unwelcome or as though they're imposing on us. I feel I already contribute a lot to the family, both practically and financially, and I don't understand why I'm also expected to take responsibility for relationships that aren't mine alone to maintain.
My MIL has also suggested that my husband and I having a baby, after being married for two years, might have prompted my brother-in-law and sister-in-law to reflect on their own lives and start moving forward with their relationship. If that's true, then I'm genuinely happy if we've had a positive influence on them. However, I sometimes feel that this creates yet another expectation for me to include them, build a bond and help everyone move forward together.
I don't think that's my responsibility. Whatever changes they make in their marriage or family life need to come from them.
My husband is aware of the issues and agrees that his brother's wife can be rude and never made much effort with the family and he's seen this for almost 6 years, so it predates me. He's witnessed some of the behaviour himself and understands why I've become reluctant to initiate contact. He also thinks some of her rudeness during my pregnancy was down to jealousy that we'd been married for half the time they have and already starting a family.
I should also mention that my husband has helped his brother financially over the years, and I've noticed little comments from my sister-in-law towards him that I find quite unpleasant. I sometimes wonder whether there's an element of jealousy, as my husband has historically been more financially comfortable than his brother.
To be clear, I have absolutely nothing against her being pregnant. I genuinely wish her well, and I don't want to make what could already be an emotional time any harder for her. If she visits my house, I'm polite, welcoming etc.
I just don't feel I should suddenly have to pursue a close relationship because she's pregnant. I went through pregnancy, childbirth and the early stages of motherhood without feeling much consideration or support from her, so I don't see why I'm now expected to put in extra effort simply because her circumstances have changed.
My husband and I are also hoping to start trying for another baby in the new year. We're both excited about expanding our family and would love for our daughter to have siblings. I genuinely enjoyed pregnancy and am looking forward to that next chapter. I want to focus on my own family and the life we're building rather than feeling as though I constantly need to build bridges and buddy with my husbands brother's wife who hasn't historically shown much interest in doing the same. She might want to do that now but it's too late.
I don't want a falling-out, arguments at family gatherings. I'm happy for our children to know each other, spend time together and as cousins. I just want to maintain a polite, respectful relationship without feeling obliged to initiate conversations, constantly check in or manufacture a closeness that isn't naturally there.
So, am I being unreasonable for not making more effort now that she's pregnant?