Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree with them holding a grudge for so long when dh forgave me !

303 replies

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:32

Years and years ago I met now dh, things were good but when I got pregnant we split up. We were separated for 2 years. It was me that ended it.
He saw DS regularly and so we did chat a bit. He was alway lovely his family however given any chance would tell me how much they hated me for what I did and how unhappy he was back at home etc.

He got a new job , met someone and then rented a flat. I went round one day to drop DS off and noticed a couple of things that obviously belonged to who he was seeing (apparently his family set him up with someone they knew so they were over the moon about the relationship). I suddenly realised that I had made a massive mistake so told him - and asked him could we try again. He said yes straight away. His family were livid. Told me I was manipulative when in reality I just suddenly realised what I’d lost.

This was so long ago and they still go on about it ? Comments that he’s still ‘under a spell’.

This year we are invited for Christmas and I’m dreading it as it seems to be mentioned at any opportunity. That I cast him aside and then ruined his be relationship. It doesn’t help the woman he was set up with is still a family friend and so they have this issue I think that they were better suited somehow? Always saying how much they had in common how nice she was and telling him he just got blinded by looks and picked the one who will make his life harder than it needs to be ???

Dh says he doesn’t care what they say that he made his choice based on how he felt and what was best for DS. That I need to learn to ignore them but I think he needs to speak to them prior to us going there so they stop going on about nonsense from the past ?

OP posts:
TittyForlorn · 07/11/2026 12:40

Ilady · 07/11/2026 12:27

I think that you're pregnancy may not have been planned at 20/21 and your now husband might not have been much older than you. Then having hg and pnd after the birth left your physical and mental health in a bad place.
You ended things with him, moved home and probably had a lot of support from your parents then to get you through this.
Meanwhile his mother was encouraging him to have a new relationship with a woman she knew who could have been a family friend daughter.

After 2 years you and him got back together and he ended things with his then girlfriend. You decided to get back together because you had a child and you wanted to try to give your relationship a chance.

Your relationship is now good. You decided as a couple not to have another child because of the hg and pnd you had in the past and your husband had a vastomey.

Since then your mil has made comments about you and what happened then. Along with this she made comments about his ex girlfriend like he should have stayed with her. Does his mother not realise that if they had stayed together that they may have never got married or had kid's?
Maybe this lady may not have wanted kids or could not have kid's.
The truth is he might not have had a wonderful life with her despite what you're mil thinks.

At this stage you need to tell your husband to chat to his mother now about her smart comments about what happened in the past. You don't want to hear them and it particularly unfair on your child to hear this as well.
Tell him if you hear another comment you, him and your child are coming home and it will be no contact with any of you then.
If his mother has a sister ask her sister about mil and her past. Maybe you could make a smart comment about your mil past that would upset or embarrass her.
After 15 years of her making comments she deserves this.

Did you use AI for this?

HRTtoHeart · 07/11/2026 12:43

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 11:14

I was 21

That makes a huge difference - you were just a kid.

If you'd broken his heart in your 30s and messed him around and only wanted him back when he'd found someone new, I'd not forgive you if I were his family.

But we all fuck stuff up when we're very young. We make an absolute hash of things, don't know ourselves and have a lot of growing up to do.

His family are out of order taking it out on you after 15 years. I'd pull right back.

Janetwin · 07/11/2026 12:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Grapewrath · 07/11/2026 12:45

His family don’t have to forgive you, or like you
His family still don’t get to talk to you like shit or go on about something that happened 15 years ago
You need to have the conversation with DH that you won’t be tolerating it and won’t spend your Christmas listening to it. Not your problem if Mil is ill when she’s very much still a twat

Additup · 07/11/2026 12:48

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · 07/11/2026 11:21

I think the thing with this is, it depends whether it has completely blown over (as OP is telling us) or whether the family see something we obviously can't.

Their behaviour in talking about it is disgraceful, no doubt. But....

DSis was left, actually also around 15y ago as it happens, by BIL. She was devastated. She came to stay with DH and me and just couldn't stop crying.

Then after a bit, she picked herself up. Got a super new job abroad earning £££. Suddenly BIL decided he'd made a mistake 🙄

He did a big love bombing campaign, won her back, they had 2 DCs. All happy etc.

But. I can see that's left scars, on her. She's never quite as secure in the relationship as she makes out. And I personally think BIL is a dick and would 100% dump her again for a younger model.

I absolutely don't say anything, not my place, but no I haven't forgiven him and won't.

That's fair enough and I can completely see where you're coming from.

I suppose the issue is have with OPs experience is the way her in-laws are behaving. They are fully entitled to feel the way they do, but don't seem to have got the memo about not openly judging your child's choice of partner.

ReachBeachFairGlum · 07/11/2026 13:01

Additup · 07/11/2026 12:48

That's fair enough and I can completely see where you're coming from.

I suppose the issue is have with OPs experience is the way her in-laws are behaving. They are fully entitled to feel the way they do, but don't seem to have got the memo about not openly judging your child's choice of partner.

Yes, I agree with both of you.

The OP's in laws are behaving appallingly in continuing to go on about this 15 years later, and to be so clear that they dislike the OP (whether justified or not). You just don't do that for the same if family harmony and relations.

However, OP's attitude of, "I've never apologised and I never will because I was extremely unwell at the time" also stinks. Yes, she was suffering, and yes it may actually be completely understandable - if unfortunate - that it all played out the way it did. But to continue to be so utterly self-centred now to the point she can't reflect on how difficult the situation must ALSO have been for others and seek to build bridges does not speak well of her at all.

The best thing to do, in my opinion, would have been (and may still be) to seek out MIL one-on-one at some appropriate point for coffee or lunch and explain a) what happened in extremis; b) that you know it looks horrendous that you only asked for him back when he was with someone else because it makes it look like you only wanted him because someone else had him, but that although you can't convince her that's not the case, the proof will be in all the coming years now that your head is on straight; and c) acknowledge, despite your own suffering, how difficult it must have been for her to see her son so hurt and that you want to build bridges, even if it takes time. Clear the air, essentially.

Even if you don't feel you owe her explanations, this is something you can do to try to make the life of your family and the man you love happier and easier, so why wouldn't you?

JayJayj · 07/11/2026 13:11

Firstly, I would not be going, neither would my child.

If you are “happy” to go. Your husband needs to speak to them before and let them no, that the first bad comment, underhand comment, or anything negative brought up about you, his wife, you will all be leaving straight away.
And that stands for any time you are together from now on.

And stick to it.

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

ReachBeachFairGlum · 07/11/2026 13:01

Yes, I agree with both of you.

The OP's in laws are behaving appallingly in continuing to go on about this 15 years later, and to be so clear that they dislike the OP (whether justified or not). You just don't do that for the same if family harmony and relations.

However, OP's attitude of, "I've never apologised and I never will because I was extremely unwell at the time" also stinks. Yes, she was suffering, and yes it may actually be completely understandable - if unfortunate - that it all played out the way it did. But to continue to be so utterly self-centred now to the point she can't reflect on how difficult the situation must ALSO have been for others and seek to build bridges does not speak well of her at all.

The best thing to do, in my opinion, would have been (and may still be) to seek out MIL one-on-one at some appropriate point for coffee or lunch and explain a) what happened in extremis; b) that you know it looks horrendous that you only asked for him back when he was with someone else because it makes it look like you only wanted him because someone else had him, but that although you can't convince her that's not the case, the proof will be in all the coming years now that your head is on straight; and c) acknowledge, despite your own suffering, how difficult it must have been for her to see her son so hurt and that you want to build bridges, even if it takes time. Clear the air, essentially.

Even if you don't feel you owe her explanations, this is something you can do to try to make the life of your family and the man you love happier and easier, so why wouldn't you?

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

OP posts:
SylvanMoon · 07/11/2026 13:27

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

Of course you don't "need" to apologise for something that was beyond your control, nor do you need to feel guilty for it. But what @ReachBeachFairGlum and other PP have been suggesting is that you apologise for how your actions made them feel by explaining why you behaved in the way you did. Saying "I'm sorry that you were all so hurt by the actions that happened at the birth of DS. It was a result of xyz etc." is very different than you saying, "I'm so sorry. I was wrong. etc etc". They are being intransigent in forgiving you, but you and your DH are also being intransigent in not understanding how your actions were (erroneously) perceived by them and how that affected them.

squarecrow · 07/11/2026 13:29

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · 07/11/2026 11:21

I think the thing with this is, it depends whether it has completely blown over (as OP is telling us) or whether the family see something we obviously can't.

Their behaviour in talking about it is disgraceful, no doubt. But....

DSis was left, actually also around 15y ago as it happens, by BIL. She was devastated. She came to stay with DH and me and just couldn't stop crying.

Then after a bit, she picked herself up. Got a super new job abroad earning £££. Suddenly BIL decided he'd made a mistake 🙄

He did a big love bombing campaign, won her back, they had 2 DCs. All happy etc.

But. I can see that's left scars, on her. She's never quite as secure in the relationship as she makes out. And I personally think BIL is a dick and would 100% dump her again for a younger model.

I absolutely don't say anything, not my place, but no I haven't forgiven him and won't.

I have similar with my DSis’s husband. He started an emotional affair, spent loads of their joint savings on the OW and they separated. Then DSis decided to take him back. I haven’t forgiven him either, but she is a grown woman and made her own decision to take him back.

Like you, I don’t say anything to either of them because I respect that other people make their own choices as they are entitled to do.

Janetwin · 07/11/2026 13:33

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

Then you’re at an impasse. You know the solution, you refuse to apologise. And yes, if your stubbornness has lasted 15 years, it’s not weird that their grudge has lasted 15 years also.

Scarlettpixie · 07/11/2026 13:33

I rarely say this but if they won't stop with this, I wouldn't be going.

TittyForlorn · 07/11/2026 13:33

Calliopespa · 07/11/2026 11:35

I'm afraid I kind of agree with this OP.

You are putting a lot of this on them but you did behave oddly, which you admit but put down to MH issues. Could you not just apologise referencing that you were in a bad place?

How would you feel if this happened to your DS? The grabbing him back once they settled him with someone else no doubt was particularly hard to watch, and then the vasectomy. I can see why they might feel you have played this quite selfishly...

People assessing and judging the OP’s behaviour are missing the point. When I read her first post, I also thought “She only wanted him back once she knew someone else had him”. I imagined this had happened about six months ago, so saw why it was raw for the family. But ultimately I also thought that the OP’s partner is a grown man and that it’s his decision.

Then I read that it’s been 15 years. 1) If OP was going to start thinking “the grass is greener”, she’d have done it by now. But more importantly, the family either need to have decided to accept their son/brother has made his decision and that they’re keeping quiet, or that they can’t deal with it and won’t see them.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 13:35

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

You definitely don't need to apologise.
They are obviously aware of what happened and they still chose to be awful to you for all these years despite you being so young at the time and having PND.

Apologising now will make them feel like their behaviour has been justified when it wasn't.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 13:39

SylvanMoon · 07/11/2026 13:27

Of course you don't "need" to apologise for something that was beyond your control, nor do you need to feel guilty for it. But what @ReachBeachFairGlum and other PP have been suggesting is that you apologise for how your actions made them feel by explaining why you behaved in the way you did. Saying "I'm sorry that you were all so hurt by the actions that happened at the birth of DS. It was a result of xyz etc." is very different than you saying, "I'm so sorry. I was wrong. etc etc". They are being intransigent in forgiving you, but you and your DH are also being intransigent in not understanding how your actions were (erroneously) perceived by them and how that affected them.

No they are clearly just an odd bunch.

OP was only 21 and had PND ,they were older and should have been more forgiving and also more wise, instead they chose to behave in this disgraceful way for 15 years. They are obviously aware of the reasons for why it happened and instead chose to hold a grudge and behave this way.

pikkumyy77 · 07/11/2026 13:40

Janetwin · 07/11/2026 13:33

Then you’re at an impasse. You know the solution, you refuse to apologise. And yes, if your stubbornness has lasted 15 years, it’s not weird that their grudge has lasted 15 years also.

There is no reason to believe that this apology tour would be a solution. You have no evidence to believe that. They are angry with OP over a lot if things including her dh’s choice to limit his fertility with a vasectomy to protect his WIFE’s health. How is her apology for her PND and near death experience during her pregnancy supposed to fix that?

TittyForlorn · 07/11/2026 13:43

Janetwin · 07/11/2026 13:33

Then you’re at an impasse. You know the solution, you refuse to apologise. And yes, if your stubbornness has lasted 15 years, it’s not weird that their grudge has lasted 15 years also.

Is it a “solution”, though? Is MIL going to say “Oh Marigold, I’ve been waiting15 years to hear you say that!”, throw her arms around her and declare all is forgiven? Or is it just going to seem a bit bizarre a decade and a half after the event?

kkloo · 07/11/2026 13:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No it doesn't. I wouldn't apologise for it either if it were me.

It's the in-laws that are showing a 'personality type', overbearing, horrible people, and even OPs son has heard all about it, that is not normal behaviour.

She should NOT apologise, they will feel that their behaviour was justified when it definitely wasn't.

Harry12345 · 07/11/2026 13:45

Soontobe60 · 07/11/2026 07:57

If I was the mother of a son whose pregnant girlfriend left him then decided she wanted him back because he was with another woman then I would likely find it very hard to forgive that woman. His family may well have had to support him through the fall out of you leaving, him being estranged from his new born child, he may well have been at his lowest for some time. That will never go away for his family. He may well be all loved up with you, but they are not.
it's up to you to build bridges with his family, not him.

It’s none of your business, young couples break up and get back together all the time, all that matters is her partner has forgiven her and they’re been together for 15 years, if you can’t move on and respect your sons choices you’re not the nice mother you think you are

ByUniqueViper · 07/11/2026 13:51

You either ask your husband to say something to them or next time they raise this infront of you just say when is this going to stop. It was a bad time in your relationship but you've both put it behind you and are happy in your life and relationship so you would like them to stop with the digs! Stand up to them. Are they perfect. Have they never made a mistake in life?

kkloo · 07/11/2026 13:51

Soontobe60 · 07/11/2026 07:57

If I was the mother of a son whose pregnant girlfriend left him then decided she wanted him back because he was with another woman then I would likely find it very hard to forgive that woman. His family may well have had to support him through the fall out of you leaving, him being estranged from his new born child, he may well have been at his lowest for some time. That will never go away for his family. He may well be all loved up with you, but they are not.
it's up to you to build bridges with his family, not him.

If I was the mother of a son whose 21 year old pregnant girlfriend left him I'd think either she was very unhappy in the relationship or something was going on for her. I'd hope that she was ok, especially as she was the mother of my grandchild.

If she wanted him back maybe I would be a bit concerned that she could break his heart again, however I'd be happy if they were happy and hope that they could make their family work out.

Miss1983 · 07/11/2026 13:54

Honestly do not think u are being unreasonable his family are disgusting for continuing this poor treatment towards u. At 21 u went through a lot of issues and u made the best decisions based on what u had at the time. His mother is too invested in his private life and it seems that will not change.

The fact u are considering to attend shows thats despite the ill treatment u still have respect for his family or at least want to keep the peace but at what cost if it it is causing u harm?

Please protect your peace however that looks for you but do not feel obliged to spend time with nasty people who berate u.

From experience with nasty mother in law it rarely gets better and u just end up feeling even more low and drained. I dont understand why they put everything on you its none of their business if u chose not to have anymore children or ur husband getting the snip. Also if they had such an issue with you both getting back together and want u apart it does t make sense for them to push the narrative of more grandchildren. They're just too disrespectful the less they know about ur lives the better.

Removing yourself from the situation is the best option in my opinion. Maybe they actually are acting this way so u actually stay away.. maybe by staying away they will berate u in ur absence and ur husband will step up a bit more and give them a good talking to who knows?

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 13:57

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

Gosh you have your poor husband over a barrel! No wonder they have such animosity. The fact you cannot apologise for the hurt and pain that arose from your actions says so much about you unfortunately. Such hurt and pain you were not a witness to, but they were.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:01

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 13:57

Gosh you have your poor husband over a barrel! No wonder they have such animosity. The fact you cannot apologise for the hurt and pain that arose from your actions says so much about you unfortunately. Such hurt and pain you were not a witness to, but they were.

Edited

Your post says a lot about you!

Op was 21, was pregnant, very unwell and then had PND, she does not need to apologise. She was been treated appallingly by absolute weirdos and you're making out she deserved it.

Their son got dumped big whoop, most families have helped their son/daughter through a break up. You're talking about her like she did something completely unspeakable.

Decent people would have treated the OP with some respect over the years seeing as she's the mother of their grandchild and their son got back with her and was happy.

Janetwin · 07/11/2026 14:03

TittyForlorn · 07/11/2026 13:43

Is it a “solution”, though? Is MIL going to say “Oh Marigold, I’ve been waiting15 years to hear you say that!”, throw her arms around her and declare all is forgiven? Or is it just going to seem a bit bizarre a decade and a half after the event?

“Is it going to be bizarre?” Good question. I guess it depends on how clearly any of them can see the real issue at this stage. We possibly don’t have the full picture but from what OP has given us, she’s annoyed at their reaction to her behaviour 15 years ago and has not addressed it with them. So I can only imagine there’s years of baggage there to unpack.

Whether she should try to address it now or not really depends on whether she sees the real problem as being the break up and timing of her and her partner’s reunion OR his family’s reaction. If she thinks the latter is the “main” problem then she probably shouldn’t raise the subject.

Swipe left for the next trending thread