Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree with them holding a grudge for so long when dh forgave me !

303 replies

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:32

Years and years ago I met now dh, things were good but when I got pregnant we split up. We were separated for 2 years. It was me that ended it.
He saw DS regularly and so we did chat a bit. He was alway lovely his family however given any chance would tell me how much they hated me for what I did and how unhappy he was back at home etc.

He got a new job , met someone and then rented a flat. I went round one day to drop DS off and noticed a couple of things that obviously belonged to who he was seeing (apparently his family set him up with someone they knew so they were over the moon about the relationship). I suddenly realised that I had made a massive mistake so told him - and asked him could we try again. He said yes straight away. His family were livid. Told me I was manipulative when in reality I just suddenly realised what I’d lost.

This was so long ago and they still go on about it ? Comments that he’s still ‘under a spell’.

This year we are invited for Christmas and I’m dreading it as it seems to be mentioned at any opportunity. That I cast him aside and then ruined his be relationship. It doesn’t help the woman he was set up with is still a family friend and so they have this issue I think that they were better suited somehow? Always saying how much they had in common how nice she was and telling him he just got blinded by looks and picked the one who will make his life harder than it needs to be ???

Dh says he doesn’t care what they say that he made his choice based on how he felt and what was best for DS. That I need to learn to ignore them but I think he needs to speak to them prior to us going there so they stop going on about nonsense from the past ?

OP posts:
squarecrow · 07/11/2026 15:18

Applesonthelawn · 07/11/2026 15:01

I think the tone of your OP is the reason why the vote is so evenly split. You suddenly regretted dumping him when you realised he had someone else and was moving on. You weren't concerned about him, so obviously his family would be concerned. It reads like an admission that you were playing games with him and doesn't reflect well on you.
If, on the other hand, you had gone through a difficult period and could justify the change that happened in you, it could come across completely differently.
Some people are giving you the benefit of the doubt on that, others less so.
His family will always side with him.

His family aren’t siding with him because they’re undermining a decision he made which is none of their business 15 years down the line. You would have to have the patience of a saint to put up with that from your parents all this time.

ETA imagine OP’s husband had a job he seemed to be happy with, then changed to something else because it paid better. 15 years later his parents are still going - the other job would have been much better, you’d have been happy there, we don’t think this other career you chose is good enough, who talked you into it? Was it that friend of yours so and so, what a manipulative arsehole that friend is, why did you listen to him about your career, you should have listened to us BLAH BLAH BLAH. It’s not supportive at all.

Bunnychubbers · 07/11/2026 15:13

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 13:17

I do accept that the situation was difficult for them and heartbreaking for dh. It’s not that I don’t feel bad, I do but I don’t think I need to apologise for something that was beyond my control. Dh has told me I must never say sorry and he would not let me feel guilty in any way.

I completely disagree with this. Mental health does not absolve you from responsibility if you’ve treated someone like shit, even if you weren’t in your right mind at the time. Yes, the in laws should’ve got over it by now but you don’t sound like a particularly pleasant or insightful person going by your attitude here.

Applesonthelawn · 07/11/2026 15:01

I think the tone of your OP is the reason why the vote is so evenly split. You suddenly regretted dumping him when you realised he had someone else and was moving on. You weren't concerned about him, so obviously his family would be concerned. It reads like an admission that you were playing games with him and doesn't reflect well on you.
If, on the other hand, you had gone through a difficult period and could justify the change that happened in you, it could come across completely differently.
Some people are giving you the benefit of the doubt on that, others less so.
His family will always side with him.

LoveItaly · 07/11/2026 14:58

JayJayj · 07/11/2026 13:11

Firstly, I would not be going, neither would my child.

If you are “happy” to go. Your husband needs to speak to them before and let them no, that the first bad comment, underhand comment, or anything negative brought up about you, his wife, you will all be leaving straight away.
And that stands for any time you are together from now on.

And stick to it.

Fair enough if the OP doesn’t want to go, but the child has two parents and neither should be vetoing the other one.

FridayPieday · 07/11/2026 14:58

Don't go. You don't want to. It's not going to be fun. So don't
Let your husband go with DS if he likes.
But if they can't be civil you should excuse yourself from their company.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:56

Roseshavethorns · 07/11/2026 14:45

What jumped out to me was your DH said he restarted the relationship with you because that's what was best for his son. He didn't say you are the love of his life and he couldn't live without you, just that he did what was best for his son..
If I was dh's mum I would hear that as he gave up his own happiness for the sake of his son. As much as that makes him a fantastic dad, as a mother, it would be devastating.
She obviously saw him in his new relationship and, presumably, saw he was happy. I can understand why she feels the way she does.
I think your DH has to clear the air with his Mum and tell her he chose you and you make him happy (presuming that's true) and he has to ask her to stop the comments.
To be honest I can understand how his mum feels. You hurt her child. How is she supposed to forgive or forget that?

You left out that he said he made his choice based on how he felt also.

And he already has told them to stop but it doesn't work and they carry on.

Most mothers would forgive, OP was 21, she was very unwell and she's the mother of her grandchild.

This family were awful to her from the start, saying she was exaggerating her illness and just had an eating disorder, that's the reason they treat her so badly, they're just horrible people.

SisterMidnight77 · 07/11/2026 14:56

Something being ‘out of your control’ (which we have to take your word for) is not a reason to refuse to apologise. People apologise for things genuinely out of their control all the time.

OutAndAbouting · 07/11/2026 14:53

crowsfeet57 · 07/11/2026 11:51

As the mother of sons I would have felt this way too. But I would have moved on for the sake of my son and after 15 years I wouldn't even think about it any more. It's batshit to keep harping on about ancient history.

Edited

'Harping on' @crowsfeet57?. Does the fact that history is 'ancient' make it irrelevant? After all, what have the Romans ever done for us?

(Quote - Monty Python. Couldn't resist it.)

History is never unimportant. It is what guides, moulds and develops us and our world, always learning from it. To say otherwise is batshit.

Lamelie · 07/11/2026 14:52

Soontobe60 · 07/11/2026 07:57

If I was the mother of a son whose pregnant girlfriend left him then decided she wanted him back because he was with another woman then I would likely find it very hard to forgive that woman. His family may well have had to support him through the fall out of you leaving, him being estranged from his new born child, he may well have been at his lowest for some time. That will never go away for his family. He may well be all loved up with you, but they are not.
it's up to you to build bridges with his family, not him.

I agree but... but OP was suffering from what sounds like pretty severe PND. I feel for them all, but now PIL should stfu.

Roseshavethorns · 07/11/2026 14:45

What jumped out to me was your DH said he restarted the relationship with you because that's what was best for his son. He didn't say you are the love of his life and he couldn't live without you, just that he did what was best for his son..
If I was dh's mum I would hear that as he gave up his own happiness for the sake of his son. As much as that makes him a fantastic dad, as a mother, it would be devastating.
She obviously saw him in his new relationship and, presumably, saw he was happy. I can understand why she feels the way she does.
I think your DH has to clear the air with his Mum and tell her he chose you and you make him happy (presuming that's true) and he has to ask her to stop the comments.
To be honest I can understand how his mum feels. You hurt her child. How is she supposed to forgive or forget that?

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:27

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:22

Did someone announce you judge and jury, to state who is and who is not deserving of a relationship?

I think there is a lot more than this than meets the eye. If I had acted like this I would be humble and apologetic for the hurt caused by my actions, irrespective of the cause of them. That is the decent and morally correct thing to do. The fact that OP never did this - and doubles down about why she will never do this - speaks a lot about her character. Character is immutable, it is the thing that defines your values. That is why they dislike her.

No, they aren't deserving of a relationship with t heir grandchild when they are so awful to the OP and about her. He shouldn't have to hear that crap.

They are awful people,they weren't even nice to her when she was pregnant ffs, saying she just had an eating disorder and was exaggerating her sickness.

Maybe if they had been a decent family OP wouldn't have broke up with precious baby boy in the first place.

Absolutely no chance would I apologise after they treated me like that when I was unwell.
Were they apologetic and humble after they had been so awful to her when she was pregnant?
Their morals are in the gutter, along with their characters.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:23

MrsRupert · 07/11/2026 14:20

Both where young and OP was very ill, malnourished, HG, PND.
What help did the in-laws give ? Nothing. They dismissed it all and instead set up their son with someone else.
Irs been 15 years, OP and her DH are happily still together. The in-laws need to wind their neck in. They dont like OP, fine but constantly bringing it up in front of their grandson is vile. As is trying to get OP to have another child. She was good enough for that though wasn't she ?
I wouldnt go OP and your DH needs to properly set them straight. If they dont stop with the comments id go No contact.

And as well as being dismissive when she was pregnant and saying she had an eating disorder, they still want to set him up with the ex and have always told him when she was single over the years, meaning they want him to break up his family and get back with the ex, batshit behaviour.

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:22

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:18

That doesn't say anything about her, they are clearly arseholes.

They certainly weren't deserving of a relationship with her son, their grandchild and OP should have cut them out years ago.

Awful people.

We do know that they think the other girl he was seeing was deserving of their son, seeing as they still try to set their son up with her 15 years later even though it would mean breaking up his family.

Not normal behaviour.

Edited

Did someone announce you judge and jury, to state who is and who is not deserving of a relationship?

I think there is a lot more than this than meets the eye. If I had acted like this I would be humble and apologetic for the hurt caused by my actions, irrespective of the cause of them. That is the decent and morally correct thing to do. The fact that OP never did this - and doubles down about why she will never do this - speaks a lot about her character. Character is immutable, it is the thing that defines your values. That is why they dislike her.

MrsRupert · 07/11/2026 14:20

Both where young and OP was very ill, malnourished, HG, PND.
What help did the in-laws give ? Nothing. They dismissed it all and instead set up their son with someone else.
Irs been 15 years, OP and her DH are happily still together. The in-laws need to wind their neck in. They dont like OP, fine but constantly bringing it up in front of their grandson is vile. As is trying to get OP to have another child. She was good enough for that though wasn't she ?
I wouldnt go OP and your DH needs to properly set them straight. If they dont stop with the comments id go No contact.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:18

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:15

To them she is not the DIL they think is deserving of their son. You sometimes reap what you sow.

Edited

That doesn't say anything about her, they are clearly arseholes.

They certainly weren't deserving of a relationship with her son, their grandchild and OP should have cut them out years ago.

Awful people.

We do know that they think the other girl he was seeing was deserving of their son, seeing as they still try to set their son up with her 15 years later even though it would mean breaking up his family.

Not normal behaviour.

pikkumyy77 · 07/11/2026 14:17

So what? They don’t like the fact that like a lot of young couples their son and his gf had a rocky start? So what? 15 years is long enough to get over themselves and stop trying to break them up.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:16

Minasama · 07/11/2026 14:13

Of course his family feel that way but they are unwise and unreasonable to express it.
As you say, you need to move forward.

Your behaviour does sound absolutely awful OP! I hope you behave better towards him and your child in future.

After 15 years?
When OP was so young, and unwell when this happened?

I don't think this is a situation where it would be like 'of course his family feel that way'.

I think most would be cautious when they got back together but would have gotten over it after a while when the relationship was going well, and wouldn't think of the past at all.

BoredZelda · 07/11/2026 14:16

Soontobe60 · 07/11/2026 07:57

If I was the mother of a son whose pregnant girlfriend left him then decided she wanted him back because he was with another woman then I would likely find it very hard to forgive that woman. His family may well have had to support him through the fall out of you leaving, him being estranged from his new born child, he may well have been at his lowest for some time. That will never go away for his family. He may well be all loved up with you, but they are not.
it's up to you to build bridges with his family, not him.

It’s 15 years ago. Give it up. I think they’ve established it’s a good relationship.

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:15

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:14

They are just in-laws from hell, that much is obvious, who the hell goes on like that, including saying all of this so that the grandchild hears?

I think your morals are way off.

To them she is not the DIL they think is deserving of their son. You sometimes reap what you sow.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:14

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:12

I am not excusing the in laws I just think there is waaay more to this than meets the eye. Someone who does not have the moral fibre or capacity to apologise for such pain is a 'wrong un' and would remain such in my eyes...

They are just in-laws from hell, that much is obvious, who the hell goes on like that, including saying all of this so that the grandchild hears?

I think your morals are way off.

Minasama · 07/11/2026 14:13

Of course his family feel that way but they are unwise and unreasonable to express it.
As you say, you need to move forward.

Your behaviour does sound absolutely awful OP! I hope you behave better towards him and your child in future.

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:12

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:10

No it isn't. You might be able to say that if she asked for another chance and then dumped him shortly after, ruining their relationship, but that's not what happened, obviously there was still love between them and they're still together 15 years later.

A realisation that she had lost someone she had pushed away is not 'calculated'. A realisation just happens.

I think most people are quite forgiving of 21 year olds in general yes, and if a young couple break up and get back together the in-laws don't hold grudges 15 years later and behave like those loonies, in-laws from hell!!

I am not excusing the in laws I just think there is waaay more to this than meets the eye. Someone who does not have the moral fibre or capacity to apologise for such pain is a 'wrong un' and would remain such in my eyes...

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

kkloo · 07/11/2026 14:10

BingoJingo · 07/11/2026 14:04

It is all very very calculated, when she saw he was with someone else she had a spark of realisation, how very convenient: I suddenly realised that I had made a massive mistake so told him - and asked him could we try again.

So this was not an organic change nor an evolution of feelings, but a realisation that she had lost someone that she had herself pushed away. It is manipulative IMO and the leopard does not change its spots. Do we forgive 21 year old men as easily? I think not.

No it isn't. You might be able to say that if she asked for another chance and then dumped him shortly after, ruining their relationship, but that's not what happened, obviously there was still love between them and they're still together 15 years later.

A realisation that she had lost someone she had pushed away is not 'calculated'. A realisation just happens.

I think most people are quite forgiving of 21 year olds in general yes, and if a young couple break up and get back together the in-laws don't hold grudges 15 years later and behave like those loonies, in-laws from hell!!

MrsColinRobinson · 07/11/2026 14:10

kkloo · 07/11/2026 13:39

No they are clearly just an odd bunch.

OP was only 21 and had PND ,they were older and should have been more forgiving and also more wise, instead they chose to behave in this disgraceful way for 15 years. They are obviously aware of the reasons for why it happened and instead chose to hold a grudge and behave this way.

I agree with this entirely. Everyone calling for OP to apologise don't seem to have read how badly this family treated OP during and after her pregnancy. Do they have nothing to apologise for when they failed to provide kindness and support for the mother of their grandchild?

After that treatment followed by indignation about OP not producing another baby for them, I'd struggle to appease them too.

If they can carry this on for 15 years I can't imagine them actually responding particularly positively to an apology or move forward.