Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree with them holding a grudge for so long when dh forgave me !

303 replies

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:32

Years and years ago I met now dh, things were good but when I got pregnant we split up. We were separated for 2 years. It was me that ended it.
He saw DS regularly and so we did chat a bit. He was alway lovely his family however given any chance would tell me how much they hated me for what I did and how unhappy he was back at home etc.

He got a new job , met someone and then rented a flat. I went round one day to drop DS off and noticed a couple of things that obviously belonged to who he was seeing (apparently his family set him up with someone they knew so they were over the moon about the relationship). I suddenly realised that I had made a massive mistake so told him - and asked him could we try again. He said yes straight away. His family were livid. Told me I was manipulative when in reality I just suddenly realised what I’d lost.

This was so long ago and they still go on about it ? Comments that he’s still ‘under a spell’.

This year we are invited for Christmas and I’m dreading it as it seems to be mentioned at any opportunity. That I cast him aside and then ruined his be relationship. It doesn’t help the woman he was set up with is still a family friend and so they have this issue I think that they were better suited somehow? Always saying how much they had in common how nice she was and telling him he just got blinded by looks and picked the one who will make his life harder than it needs to be ???

Dh says he doesn’t care what they say that he made his choice based on how he felt and what was best for DS. That I need to learn to ignore them but I think he needs to speak to them prior to us going there so they stop going on about nonsense from the past ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MysticHalfWitch · 10/11/2026 07:52

I don’t think you did anything wrong! You ended a relationship you weren’t happy in. You didn’t prevent your husband seeing your son and it appears you had an amicable co-parenting relationship. I’m so sorry about some of the responses you’re getting here, you made a mistake and he was happy to get back together. You’ve committed no crime!

I’ve had people finish with me because it wasn’t right and I don’t hate them! I’ve been hurt and devastated, but they treated me with respect so why the hate?

None of that is even taking into account the horrendous time of it you were having.

I liked a previous poster’s suggestion of ‘let’s not do this now; it’s Christmas’ but next year get some firm boundaries in place.

kkloo · 10/11/2026 00:41

EvieBB · 10/11/2026 00:06

To be fair, I haven't read the full thread...but after just reading ops opening post Id be pretty pissed off if my Dil treated my son like that and never once apologised. Once she did then fine I'd absolutely move on and put it behind me. (I don't dint have a son btw, just dd's).
Your pulse comment was abusive btw! Shame on you.

How did she treat him?
She ended the relationship when she was very unwell, and then later asked him if he would give things another chance. That's it.

Her DH told her she must never say sorry so he clearly is more mature and rational than the rest of them.

Not only were they not due an apology, they also didn't deserve an apology anyway, they are a toxic bunch, telling the OP they hated her every chance they got when she had PND, saying she was exaggerating her illness and just had an eating disorder, dismissing mental illness, and all the crap they've said to her for the past 15 years, including trying to manipulate her into having another baby, telling the DH every time his ex is single because they want him to break up his family and leave the OP, and also making sure their grandson hears all this vitriol about his mother over the years.

kkloo · 10/11/2026 00:32

moderate · 09/11/2026 20:33

I agree with pretty much everything you've written here. I still don't see where JenniferBooth got "the bar is higher for women" from though.

I see it as a reasonable inference, in my experience it's very common that the ones who are so judgemental and unforgiving of women are pretty much always softer on men. Genuinely have never known otherwise.

That poster is old enough to have a daughter in a relationship for 16 years and yet still treats what happened as something that the OP 'did' to her partner that she should have made amends to the in-laws for when the poor girl was a very young mum who was extremely unwell and clearly struggling to cope and that their behaviour is somehow justified all these years later because she didn't.

EvieBB · 10/11/2026 00:06

To be fair, I haven't read the full thread...but after just reading ops opening post Id be pretty pissed off if my Dil treated my son like that and never once apologised. Once she did then fine I'd absolutely move on and put it behind me. (I don't dint have a son btw, just dd's).
Your pulse comment was abusive btw! Shame on you.

Harry12345 · 09/11/2026 23:34

seahorsessky · 09/11/2026 20:14

Not their grandchild, is he? Is that right, OP? If they feel he, and they, missed out on having a family and feel OP hurt/emotionally abused him, and they feel he was forced into permanently giving up that chance, and there was another woman they felt really loved their son and would be good for them, well, we don't know if that's right, or fair, but parents who believe their child has been hurt will react this way, especially if MIL is worried about dying (not sure if you say how ill she is, or at least is worried about being) and having no family going on. Personally, I'd not keep arguing on Xmas, but then maybe that's easy for me to say when I'm not in that situation

You’d hold a grudge about something that happened 15 years ago and your son had moved on from? It’s mine if your business and that makes you an overbearing toxic mil

moderate · 09/11/2026 20:33

kkloo · 09/11/2026 19:50

The timescale...........the OP was recovering from being seriously unwell during pregnancy and then having PND. Things like that by their very nature do take time to recover from, and it's not some poor behaviour on the womans part.

In the meantime her and ex seemed to get on well, and he saw his child. He also seemed to pick himself up and got a new job, flat and a new girlfriend. OP wasn't doing anything to him at that time, she just wasn't in a relationship with him.

The poster also said in an earlier comment something about how they supported their son for 2 years and missed out on their grandchild, yet by the sounds of it they must have seen him seeing as they were telling the OP they hated her every chance they got, and how they couldn't be expected to 'suddenly' forget all that and forgive.

"Suddenly".........it's 15 years later FGS, they've raised their son together since he was a toddler, they've got married, the DH is happy with the OP, literally nothing sudden about it, so to suggest that the OP shouldn't expect them to forgive at this point is ridiculous.

I agree with pretty much everything you've written here. I still don't see where JenniferBooth got "the bar is higher for women" from though.

kkloo · 09/11/2026 20:27

@seahorsessky He is. OPs DH is the father. She even said in the OP that he saw their DS while they were split.

seahorsessky · 09/11/2026 20:14

Lampsandlightsandotherthings · 07/11/2026 07:43

Either you say, aren’t you pleased your son is happy, and your grandchild raised by his dad. Clearly you don’t like me, I will bow out of family gatherings, if that pleases you.

Or your dh explains, and tells them that his wife has made him very happy eat some shut the fuckupcakes or I’ll be round here a lot less. There are some things parents do that you silently ignore, and then there are things that are his responsibility to keep his marriage a place of peace and love.

Not their grandchild, is he? Is that right, OP? If they feel he, and they, missed out on having a family and feel OP hurt/emotionally abused him, and they feel he was forced into permanently giving up that chance, and there was another woman they felt really loved their son and would be good for them, well, we don't know if that's right, or fair, but parents who believe their child has been hurt will react this way, especially if MIL is worried about dying (not sure if you say how ill she is, or at least is worried about being) and having no family going on. Personally, I'd not keep arguing on Xmas, but then maybe that's easy for me to say when I'm not in that situation

OneandFiveOnly · 09/11/2026 20:02

EvieBB · 08/11/2026 21:24

Gosh .....you sound like you know MIL. You don't so can't make those assumptions and only have one side of the story.

I can make a pretty easy assessment based on everything the OP has said. The woman TO THIS DAY is still trying to matchmake her MARRIED son with his ex because she’s holding a grudge. That sling is toxic behaviour.

It’s pretty easy to spot - you just need to have a pulse.

kkloo · 09/11/2026 19:54

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 19:30

What was it OP did over a period of years? Suffered from PND? Or maintained a separation from her child’s father? Which of those things is less forgivable than cheating?

Yep those, and then recovering from her illnesses and raising her baby. What a truly awful person. Such unforgivable things to do 🙄

kkloo · 09/11/2026 19:50

moderate · 09/11/2026 14:52

She was quite clearly contrasting the timescale rather than the act.

And even so, the "that" in "I've no idea where you got that from" still applies to "the behaviour bar is higher for women".

The timescale...........the OP was recovering from being seriously unwell during pregnancy and then having PND. Things like that by their very nature do take time to recover from, and it's not some poor behaviour on the womans part.

In the meantime her and ex seemed to get on well, and he saw his child. He also seemed to pick himself up and got a new job, flat and a new girlfriend. OP wasn't doing anything to him at that time, she just wasn't in a relationship with him.

The poster also said in an earlier comment something about how they supported their son for 2 years and missed out on their grandchild, yet by the sounds of it they must have seen him seeing as they were telling the OP they hated her every chance they got, and how they couldn't be expected to 'suddenly' forget all that and forgive.

"Suddenly".........it's 15 years later FGS, they've raised their son together since he was a toddler, they've got married, the DH is happy with the OP, literally nothing sudden about it, so to suggest that the OP shouldn't expect them to forgive at this point is ridiculous.

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 19:30

moderate · 09/11/2026 14:52

She was quite clearly contrasting the timescale rather than the act.

And even so, the "that" in "I've no idea where you got that from" still applies to "the behaviour bar is higher for women".

What was it OP did over a period of years? Suffered from PND? Or maintained a separation from her child’s father? Which of those things is less forgivable than cheating?

moderate · 09/11/2026 14:52

kkloo · 09/11/2026 14:38

She quite clearly said she forgave her daughters boyfriend for cheating, but had he done what the OP did then she wouldn't be quite as 'sanguine'.

She was quite clearly contrasting the timescale rather than the act.

And even so, the "that" in "I've no idea where you got that from" still applies to "the behaviour bar is higher for women".

kkloo · 09/11/2026 14:38

moderate · 09/11/2026 14:32

I don’t agree. Nowhere did @saraclara state or imply that cheating was better or worse than what OP went through, and nowhere did she judge the woman in her story more harshly than the man.

She quite clearly said she forgave her daughters boyfriend for cheating, but had he done what the OP did then she wouldn't be quite as 'sanguine'.

moderate · 09/11/2026 14:32

kkloo · 09/11/2026 11:01

She quite clearly got it from your post.

I don’t agree. Nowhere did @saraclara state or imply that cheating was better or worse than what OP went through, and nowhere did she judge the woman in her story more harshly than the man.

kkloo · 09/11/2026 11:01

saraclara · 09/11/2026 00:09

I've no idea where you got that from.

She quite clearly got it from your post.

kkloo · 09/11/2026 11:00

PurpleAxe · 09/11/2026 08:01

I am not clear on what it was you 'did'?

You broke up with someone, and then you got back together?

Yep.... and apparently all the abuse is deserved.

Oh she did also 'ruin' his other relationship when she asked him to get back with her, hence why all these years later they still tell OPs DH when the ex is single in case he wants to ditch his family and get back with her.

Oh and she also refused to give in to their manipulative bullshit when they tried to get her to have another baby to make amends because her DH missed out.

They are overbearing, toxic, control freaks.

ithinkthereforeyouarewrong · 09/11/2026 10:58

Could you try leaning into it? Like when someone makes a shitty comment laugh and you and dh say “ahh yes the annual look at what you did 15 years ago chat. Best decision we ever made and here we are as strong and happy as ever “
if they can’t get a rise out of you they may stop. Plus it’s much nicer for your child to hear.

PurpleAxe · 09/11/2026 08:01

I am not clear on what it was you 'did'?

You broke up with someone, and then you got back together?

saraclara · 09/11/2026 00:09

JenniferBooth · 08/11/2026 17:51

So cheating is less abhorrent than what OP went through Just reads to me that the behaviour bar is higher for women.........as usual!

I've no idea where you got that from.

kkloo · 08/11/2026 22:00

EvieBB · 08/11/2026 21:24

Gosh .....you sound like you know MIL. You don't so can't make those assumptions and only have one side of the story.

Of course we can unless the OP has made up the things that in-laws say, and there's no reason to suspect that she has.

Anyone who says those things is toxic, telling a young mother you hate her every chance you get, trying to set her husband up with his ex from 15 years ago....they're toxic.

moderate · 08/11/2026 21:39

MarigoldPersephonesCookie · 07/11/2026 07:38

MIL is in poor health so we can’t really not go, I’m trying to work out how to arrange it so that it isn’t a topic of conversation/argument starter as 1) no good for anyone and 2) with MIL ill I’d like it to be as nice as possible (she is usually one of the most vocal about what happened though so that’s tricky)

Edited

Yeah I think “MIL is in poor health so we can’t really not go” is your mistake here.

Your DH needs to her that you will see her over the festive period but that if she raises the subject you will all simply leave and go home. As such, you are not prepared for the day of your visit to be Christmas Day itself, lest it get spoiled for your DS.

Let her feel the consequences of her behaviour.

EvieBB · 08/11/2026 21:24

OneandFiveOnly · 08/11/2026 16:43

You cannot have authentic honest conversations with the kind of person the MIL appears to be.

She’s toxic, disingenuous, underhanded, disrespectful, manipulative, has no self control and seems to be wedded to making people around her feel uncomfortable.

A conversation with this type of person is, at best, re—arranging deckchairs on the Titanic.

Gosh .....you sound like you know MIL. You don't so can't make those assumptions and only have one side of the story.

JustFrustrated · 08/11/2026 19:02

Sorry where was DH in the two years?

when you were suffering with HG he can’t have supported you, same with the PND else why would you run somewhere you could be supported?

Did he fight to see his son? Fight for you?

a lot of blame here on a young woman, at the time, who was drastically unwell… and no questioning on where her DH was in the support scale…

I know if that had been me, my DH would have been supporting me so hard even at the depths of illness I wouldn’t have considered running from him.

ArtisticSwimmerinLaneOne · 08/11/2026 18:56

If distance wasn’t an issue, I would invite them for a pub lunch or restaurant meal in public as a foursome in November.
If they bring the subject up there again - then you can both address it in no uncertain terms, that this is the end of the matter.
If they don’t raise it during the meal, your DH can clearly and unmistakeably state your position going forwards at the end of the meal. they are not to raise the subject again, it’s been 15 years, there were underlying reasons at that time and you are both happy. And in no uncertain terms, for them to be aware, that going forwards from now, if they raise it ever again then you will immediately leave without question.