Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Piers Morgan and the media figures who repeatedly gave Thomas Markle a platform should be held accountable?

167 replies

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:16

For years, Thomas Markle was given a platform to publicly attack his daughter, with Piers Morgan among those amplifying his grievances. Piers even acknowledged that Markle was paid for his appearance on Good Morning Britain.

Now, in light of the deeply disturbing allegations against Markle and his arrest, I think serious questions need to be asked about the media’s role in promoting and financially rewarding him.

At what point does giving someone a platform become irresponsible? And shouldn’t those who repeatedly profited from this spectacle be reflecting on their part in it?

OP posts:
SENsupportplease · 06/11/2026 21:18

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:41

Who said serious questions should only be asked now?

The media’s treatment of Meghan was open to criticism long before these allegations emerged. The fact that recent developments have prompted renewed scrutiny doesn’t mean those concerns didn’t exist previously.
There’s a difference between an event prompting people to revisit past conduct and that event being the reason the conduct was questionable in the first place.

My argument is that repeatedly amplifying and financially rewarding someone’s public attacks on an estranged family member raises legitimate questions about editorial judgement, irrespective of what subsequently emerges about that individual. The allegations provide the context for revisiting those decisions, not retrospective proof that the journalists involved knew something they couldn’t reasonably have known. I’m not sure why that distinction keeps being interpreted as an expectation of clairvoyance.

You have tied the two together in your OP. “Now, in light of the… allegations… serious questions need to be asked”

Why are the two related? In doing so you’ve confused the issue and implied that media scrutiny should be related to the allegations. Did you raise the issue prior to this?

There was no context needed to suggest scrutiny of editorial judgements. And it shouldn’t require allegations which have no bearing on the original editorial decisions.

You have used your thread to suggest scrutiny of PM. Have you ever done the same for OW given the platform provided to amplify and financially reward MM and H’s public attacks on their families? Perhaps you should take a more balanced view of the media as a whole in giving anyone a financially rewarding platform for criticism, including MM.

SENsupportplease · 06/11/2026 21:10

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:39

Of course the same principles apply. I have no difficulty with the media’s handling of Harry and Meghan’s interviews, documentary or other public statements being subjected to ethical scrutiny. Why would I?

The distinction is that Harry and Meghan were speaking publicly about their own experiences, whereas Thomas Markle was repeatedly given opportunities to discuss and criticise his estranged daughter. That doesn’t automatically make either form of coverage beyond criticism.

And no, this isn’t an argument based solely on hindsight. I’ve already explained that the ethics of repeatedly amplifying and financially rewarding someone’s public attacks on a family member can be questioned irrespective of subsequent criminal allegations.

I’m advocating consistent standards of editorial responsibility not special treatment for particular individuals. Why is questioning the media’s treatment of Meghan so frequently interpreted as suggesting that Harry and Meghan themselves should be immune from scrutiny?

There is no distinction (btw you sound eerily like chat gpt). MM and H were given platforms to criticise their families, TM was given a platform to do the same. You are using semantics to pretend “speaking publicly” isn’t the same as “given opportunities”, and “own experiences” isn’t the same as “criticise his daughter”.

How would you categorise Harry’s book? A platform to criticise his family perhaps?

Rachelshair · 06/11/2026 20:58

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:42

There’s a considerable difference between offering someone a right of reply and repeatedly inviting them onto national television to air their grievances against a family member. The latter is very much giving someone a platform.

And nobody is suggesting that journalists should have known about the allegations. The question is whether the media’s treatment of Meghan, including the repeated amplification and monetisation of her father’s public attacks on her, was ethically defensible in the first place. The fact that these allegations emerged years later doesn’t somehow make that earlier conduct beyond scrutiny.

Your first post said they should be held accountable "in light of the allegations" though, and now you're saying that the allegations have nothing to do with it.
Which is it?
What about the media that "platformed" Meghan to attack her in-laws? Surely they should be held accountable too "in light of the allegations" if you are critiquing ethics?

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:52

Overflowingbasket · 06/11/2026 20:47

You are utterly ridiculous OP. In your opening OP you link his earlier appearances with the sex abuse charges, yet instantly tried to row back on this.

Everything, everything you have said is a confused, and your case is frankly daft.

I’ve neither denied the connection nor attempted to row back on it. I’ve repeatedly explained the distinction between the allegations prompting renewed scrutiny of past media conduct and those allegations being the basis for questioning whether that conduct was ethical.

The media’s treatment of Meghan was open to criticism long before these allegations emerged. Nothing I’ve said suggests that journalists should have known about, or anticipated, the alleged offences.

You’re perfectly entitled to disagree with my argument but simply declaring it ridiculous, confused and daft doesn’t explain where the reasoning supposedly fails.

If you have a substantive objection, by all means articulate it. Personal insults aren’t particularly persuasive.

OP posts:
TheBayHorse · 06/11/2026 20:51

Harry and Meghan have had ample opportunities to air their grievances against family members. Why shouldn't others be offered the same opportunity?

Overflowingbasket · 06/11/2026 20:47

You are utterly ridiculous OP. In your opening OP you link his earlier appearances with the sex abuse charges, yet instantly tried to row back on this.

Everything, everything you have said is a confused, and your case is frankly daft.

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:45

MagnoliaParks · 06/11/2026 20:38

I’m saying they should be allowed to freely choose who they platform. Any interference in this would interfere with freedom of speech. Because where do you stop. No one allowed to critique a family member, then no one allowed to critique the royal family at all. And then not the government.

Media companies don’t operate in a vacuum - they are driven by viewership, but I think they should be free to do that (or indeed deviate from it if they want to).

I’m not advocating for unethical journalism, I’m just saying I don’t think this example is unethical journalism.

But nobody is arguing that media organisations shouldn’t be free to make editorial decisions. You’re treating criticism of how that freedom is exercised as though it’s an attempt to restrict the freedom itself.

There’s no slippery slope from questioning the ethics of repeatedly paying someone to publicly attack an estranged family member to prohibiting criticism of the Royal Family or government. Those are entirely different propositions.

Freedom of expression and editorial accountability aren’t mutually exclusive. Journalists can have the freedom to publish something while still being expected to justify their editorial decisions and adhere to professional standards.

And I agree that media organisations don’t operate in a vacuum. That’s why their influence and the potential consequences of their coverage deserve scrutiny.

If you don’t consider the repeated platforming and monetisation of Thomas Markle’s grievances unethical, that’s a perfectly legitimate disagreement. But that’s a discussion about journalistic ethics not freedom of speech.

l think we’ve established that we agree media organisations should have editorial freedom. Where we differ is in our assessment of how responsibly that freedom was exercised in this particular instance.

OP posts:
AnAutumnCrow · 06/11/2026 20:43

Well, it’ll all come out in the judicial process now, won’t it?

Statements and court appearances will be required, possibly in various jurisdictions.

Goodness.

DaisyDooley · 06/11/2026 20:43

God, chill out @WryJadeWren
Piers Morgan has done nothing wrong.
There's no ‘accountability’ in interviewing someone who wants to be interviewed.
He is allowed to give his opinions on his daughter’s behaviour.
Nobody was forced to watch him.
When the vast majority of posters disagree with you that should really tell you something.

BoredZelda · 06/11/2026 20:41

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:32

Where have I suggested that journalists should have been able to predict the allegations?

You’re arguing against a position I haven’t taken. My point concerns the ethics of repeatedly platforming and financially rewarding someone for publicly attacking a family member, not whether journalists should possess clairvoyance.

It’s entirely possible to question the media’s conduct without suggesting they knew about, or were responsible for, the alleged offences. I’d have thought that distinction was fairly straightforward but apparently not.

But your argument is that they should apologise “in light of” the situation now.

The thinly veiled racism they used to report on Meghan, including using her family, were always a problem. The now stuff is irrelevant.

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:41

SENsupportplease · 06/11/2026 20:35

If this is your argument then what does that have to do with the allegations against him as mentioned in your OP? Why only now should serious questions be asked?

Who said serious questions should only be asked now?

The media’s treatment of Meghan was open to criticism long before these allegations emerged. The fact that recent developments have prompted renewed scrutiny doesn’t mean those concerns didn’t exist previously.
There’s a difference between an event prompting people to revisit past conduct and that event being the reason the conduct was questionable in the first place.

My argument is that repeatedly amplifying and financially rewarding someone’s public attacks on an estranged family member raises legitimate questions about editorial judgement, irrespective of what subsequently emerges about that individual. The allegations provide the context for revisiting those decisions, not retrospective proof that the journalists involved knew something they couldn’t reasonably have known. I’m not sure why that distinction keeps being interpreted as an expectation of clairvoyance.

OP posts:
Somersetbaker · 06/11/2026 20:41

Crudd99 · 06/11/2026 20:04

She had a letter saying her dad was a pedophile. She could of opened her mouth 8 years ago. She didn't. You stated in your OP that should PM and the like should be held accountable. THEY DIDN'T KNOW MM DID. She could of spoken up to protect any children her father could of had access to. SHE DIDNT.
MM didn't have a problem bad mouthing the RF , telling her 'truth' but was silent about HER family even though children could of been at risk. She's sat on it for 8 years protecting her own children whilst not bothering about the threat to other children. If she'd of gone public it would of been investigated. Who knows what her fathers done in 8 years moving from poor country to poor country. She kept quiet.

She was given the information by the police, it's not like she stumbled on a cache of wank-mags behind the wardrobe. What better way is there to get any evidence destroyed than notifying someone that they are suspected?

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:39

SENsupportplease · 06/11/2026 20:33

Does the same logic apply to the amplification and monetisation of Harry and Meghan’s attacks on their family?

Or does this only apply with hindsight when someone is a suspected paedo and abuser?

Of course the same principles apply. I have no difficulty with the media’s handling of Harry and Meghan’s interviews, documentary or other public statements being subjected to ethical scrutiny. Why would I?

The distinction is that Harry and Meghan were speaking publicly about their own experiences, whereas Thomas Markle was repeatedly given opportunities to discuss and criticise his estranged daughter. That doesn’t automatically make either form of coverage beyond criticism.

And no, this isn’t an argument based solely on hindsight. I’ve already explained that the ethics of repeatedly amplifying and financially rewarding someone’s public attacks on a family member can be questioned irrespective of subsequent criminal allegations.

I’m advocating consistent standards of editorial responsibility not special treatment for particular individuals. Why is questioning the media’s treatment of Meghan so frequently interpreted as suggesting that Harry and Meghan themselves should be immune from scrutiny?

OP posts:
MagnoliaParks · 06/11/2026 20:38

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:32

But you’re describing editorial discretion while simultaneously arguing that platforms shouldn’t exercise it. Deciding who gets airtime based on anticipated viewership, public interest and commercial value is quite literally picking and choosing. Media organisations do this constantly.

Where we differ is your apparent assumption that audience demand is sufficient justification for a particular editorial decision. Something attracting viewers doesn’t necessarily make it ethical, responsible or in the public interest. Popularity and public interest aren’t interchangeable.

Nor am I suggesting that people making allegations, challenging powerful individuals or expressing unpopular views should be denied a platform. The issue is how editorial decisions are made, whether appropriate scrutiny is applied and what responsibilities broadcasters have towards those affected by their coverage.

The fact that an audience exists for something doesn’t absolve a media organisation of responsibility for choosing to broadcast it. And surely that’s precisely why journalistic standards exist in the first place? Otherwise, are we really suggesting that anything which attracts enough viewers is justified simply because it’s commercially successful?

I’m saying they should be allowed to freely choose who they platform. Any interference in this would interfere with freedom of speech. Because where do you stop. No one allowed to critique a family member, then no one allowed to critique the royal family at all. And then not the government.

Media companies don’t operate in a vacuum - they are driven by viewership, but I think they should be free to do that (or indeed deviate from it if they want to).

I’m not advocating for unethical journalism, I’m just saying I don’t think this example is unethical journalism.

Hugasaurusrex · 06/11/2026 20:36

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:46

And never have I seen so many people confuse examining two related issues with conflating them.

The allegations against Thomas Markle and the media’s treatment of Meghan are separate matters. I’ve never suggested otherwise.

What I’m questioning is whether those who repeatedly amplified and financially rewarded his public attacks on his daughter should face scrutiny for their editorial decisions. That question stands independently of the allegations.

Recognising a connection between two issues is not the same as equating them.

I agree with you @WryJadeWren

Piers Morgan had a weird obsession with MM and he used her very at that time throughly unpleasant, now full on appalling, father against her to feed his continued obsession.

AnAutumnCrow · 06/11/2026 20:35

LoopyLooooo · 06/11/2026 19:21

No, the only person to blame is the filthy paedophile himself in cases like this.

Yes. And all the people who knew and covered it up are vile. All of them. Including family members. And the child sex abuse cover-up apologists on threads like this are not much better.

SENsupportplease · 06/11/2026 20:35

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:18

Once again, nobody is suggesting that Piers Morgan or anyone else should have known about allegations that hadn’t yet emerged publicly. My argument concerns the ethics of repeatedly giving someone a platform and financially rewarding them for publicly attacking their own daughter. That conduct can be scrutinised independently of the subsequent allegations.

As for your claim that Meghan was “gaslighting” the British media and public, what evidence do you have that she knowingly deceived anyone about these allegations? There’s a rather significant difference between possessing information, choosing not to discuss something publicly and deliberately misleading people. You’re treating those as interchangeable without establishing the facts.

Why does a discussion about the media’s treatment of Meghan so consistently become an exercise in finding ways to blame Meghan herself?

If this is your argument then what does that have to do with the allegations against him as mentioned in your OP? Why only now should serious questions be asked?

TarraDiddles · 06/11/2026 20:35

Crudd99 · 06/11/2026 19:46

But MM attacks on the RF were OK? The Oprah interview? She knew the RF wouldn't reply but she still did it.

Agreed. She also still did it in the alleged full knowledge of what is now coming to light about her own father. She would have been better taking a leaf out of the book of the family she married into - keep your (hypocritical) trap shut!

SENsupportplease · 06/11/2026 20:33

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:42

There’s a considerable difference between offering someone a right of reply and repeatedly inviting them onto national television to air their grievances against a family member. The latter is very much giving someone a platform.

And nobody is suggesting that journalists should have known about the allegations. The question is whether the media’s treatment of Meghan, including the repeated amplification and monetisation of her father’s public attacks on her, was ethically defensible in the first place. The fact that these allegations emerged years later doesn’t somehow make that earlier conduct beyond scrutiny.

Does the same logic apply to the amplification and monetisation of Harry and Meghan’s attacks on their family?

Or does this only apply with hindsight when someone is a suspected paedo and abuser?

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:32

MagnoliaParks · 06/11/2026 20:27

I’ve not said you shouldn’t criticise. I encourage you to.

What is platformed, and more important who gets paid to stand on their platform, will depend on viewership and public interest.

Piers Morgan isn’t ever going to have me on his channel no matter how valid my views are because nobody cares. If a platform thinks the public will care enough to pay big money - go for it. If no one watches it’ll fall flat on its face. If people do watch, they were probably right to platform them.

I’m not saying no accountability, I’m saying the platform shouldn’t pick and choose. Look at what’s playing out with the celebrity injunction at the moment. What if the victims weren’t allowed a platform because it’s a campaign against one person?

Sometimes the campaigns will be wrong and sometimes they will be right.

But you’re describing editorial discretion while simultaneously arguing that platforms shouldn’t exercise it. Deciding who gets airtime based on anticipated viewership, public interest and commercial value is quite literally picking and choosing. Media organisations do this constantly.

Where we differ is your apparent assumption that audience demand is sufficient justification for a particular editorial decision. Something attracting viewers doesn’t necessarily make it ethical, responsible or in the public interest. Popularity and public interest aren’t interchangeable.

Nor am I suggesting that people making allegations, challenging powerful individuals or expressing unpopular views should be denied a platform. The issue is how editorial decisions are made, whether appropriate scrutiny is applied and what responsibilities broadcasters have towards those affected by their coverage.

The fact that an audience exists for something doesn’t absolve a media organisation of responsibility for choosing to broadcast it. And surely that’s precisely why journalistic standards exist in the first place? Otherwise, are we really suggesting that anything which attracts enough viewers is justified simply because it’s commercially successful?

OP posts:
Fatsnowflake · 06/11/2026 20:31

She probably couldn't have opened her mouth if nothing was proven. If the police had this information and didn't act on it, presumably there was not enough evidence. She can't just publicly accuse him if there hasn't been a judicial process and neither can she conduct her own investigation. I think she should be left alone. She hasn't committed a crime.

MissFancyDay · 06/11/2026 20:31

Why does a discussion about the media’s treatment of Meghan so consistently become an exercise in finding ways to blame Meghan herself?

Because it's her, frankly, bizarre behaviour that's to blame for most of what the media write.

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:28

HeddaGarbled · 06/11/2026 20:23

The pair of them attributed the rift to the actions of the British media. That was gaslighting.

That’s not what gaslighting means.

Attributing a family rift, in whole or in part, to media intrusion doesn’t establish that other factors weren’t involved. Family relationships can deteriorate for multiple reasons simultaneously.

More importantly, you’ve still not established that Meghan or Harry knowingly concealed allegations of abuse, let alone that they deliberately misled the public about them.

You’re treating your interpretation of their public statements as evidence of intentional deception. Those are two very different things.

Disagreeing with someone’s account of a family breakdown doesn’t automatically make that account gaslighting.

OP posts:
seahorsessky · 06/11/2026 20:27

OutOfTheOtherSide · 06/11/2026 19:27

I have seen some very odd thinking on Mumsnet, but this is up there with the best. What a weird take on a story about an alleged paedophile.

Journalists clearly need better crystal balls so they can predict anyone they interview's future.

Batshit.

And she talked about being a Daddy's girl on a 2022 Netflix show-so neither Piers Morgan, nor anyone else, would assume she thought there was anything wrong with him then. If someone described herself that way, you would not think she'd had a letter like she allegedly got.

MagnoliaParks · 06/11/2026 20:27

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 20:09

Freedom of speech doesn’t confer an automatic entitlement to a paid platform on national television. Nor does questioning editorial decisions amount to advocating censorship.

Media organisations already exercise editorial discretion every day. They decide whom to interview, whose views to amplify, how stories are framed and which narratives are commercially valuable. Those decisions are not somehow beyond ethical scrutiny simply because freedom of speech exists.

And whether you approve of Piers Morgan’s coverage of other issues is entirely beside the point. A journalist can provide a valuable platform for one discussion while exercising questionable judgement in another.

I’m not arguing that certain voices should be silenced. I’m arguing that the decision to repeatedly amplify and financially reward someone’s public attacks on a family member is a legitimate subject for scrutiny.

Freedom of speech includes the freedom to criticise how media platforms exercise their considerable influence. It doesn’t mean freedom from accountability.

I’ve not said you shouldn’t criticise. I encourage you to.

What is platformed, and more important who gets paid to stand on their platform, will depend on viewership and public interest.

Piers Morgan isn’t ever going to have me on his channel no matter how valid my views are because nobody cares. If a platform thinks the public will care enough to pay big money - go for it. If no one watches it’ll fall flat on its face. If people do watch, they were probably right to platform them.

I’m not saying no accountability, I’m saying the platform shouldn’t pick and choose. Look at what’s playing out with the celebrity injunction at the moment. What if the victims weren’t allowed a platform because it’s a campaign against one person?

Sometimes the campaigns will be wrong and sometimes they will be right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread