Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Piers Morgan and the media figures who repeatedly gave Thomas Markle a platform should be held accountable?

167 replies

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:16

For years, Thomas Markle was given a platform to publicly attack his daughter, with Piers Morgan among those amplifying his grievances. Piers even acknowledged that Markle was paid for his appearance on Good Morning Britain.

Now, in light of the deeply disturbing allegations against Markle and his arrest, I think serious questions need to be asked about the media’s role in promoting and financially rewarding him.

At what point does giving someone a platform become irresponsible? And shouldn’t those who repeatedly profited from this spectacle be reflecting on their part in it?

OP posts:
Audmar · 08/11/2026 10:18

“When you say that Meghan should have ensured that the allegations against her father were followed up , what exactly do you mean by ‘followed up’.?
Are you suggesting she should have personally investigated the allegations, reported them to the relevant authorities , pressured those authorities to act, or somehow guaranteed a particular outcome ?”

I see the Straw Man fallacy is being utilized, (when someone exaggerates or distorts an argument to an absurd degree).

Audmar · 08/11/2026 10:05

Someone on X put this together, statements from Meghan and Harry since they learned about allegations of child sexual abuse by Meghan’s father.

“Do as I do, not as I say,” right ? I know she gets accused of word salad in her speeches, I guess empty words can be added to that. These are her very own words, on public record, on video. I’m there are plenty more.


January 9th 2023 - CBS, Harry ‘Silence is betrayal”

July 6th 2020 - video broadcast, Queens Commonwealth Trust, ‘Meghan
"In people's complacency, they're complicit. ‘

July 6th, 2020 - video broadcast, Queens Commonwealth Trust.
“It's not enough to be a bystander and say, 'Well, it wasn't me.'

August 21st 2020 - video broadcast - Meghan,

‘if you are complacent you are complicit’

June 4th 2020_ Meghan
‘"The only wrong thing, is to say nothing’

July 14th 2020, Meghan, “UN girl-up leadership,
“we have to speak up for ourselves and we have to speak out for others who struggle to be heard"

July 14th 2020, Meghan , UN girl up summit’
”Compassion means seeing the pain and suffering of others and knowing that it's our duty to try to help relieve it.”

January 8th 2023, ITV, Harry,
"Silence only allows the abuser to abuse, right?”

May 2023, Foundation women of vision award ceremony, Meghan
‘“The narrative on repeat that surrounded me allowed me to recognize that part of my greater value and purpose in life was to advocate for those who felt unheard, to stand up to injustice, and to be not afraid of saying what you know is true, and what is just, and what is right.”

May 2023, Meghan,
‘“If you know there is something wrong and you're using your voice to advocate for what is right, that really land and resonate with people.”

November 2021, Meghan
‘“Even before I had any sort of privilege in my life, when my life and my lifestyle were very different, I always just stood up for what’s right.”

November 2021, Meghan,
“At a certain point, no matter how difficult it is, if you know the difference between right and wrong, you must stand up for what's right.”

Lampzade · 08/11/2026 09:46

Audmar · 08/11/2026 09:11

There are two happenings in this

  1. Meghans father has been exposed as a sexual predator of young children. Meghan had absolutely nothing to do with that and is not responsible.
  2. Meghan was told her father was a sexual predator of young children, 8 years ago, she clearly believed it. She, as a champion of women and children’s rights, with a huge global profile, absolutely has some responsibility for making sure those allegations were followed up, she did nothing according to her own statement.

Its just a big red herring to claim / pretend others are blaming her for her fathers actions, that is not the case, I haven’t seen anyone claim that. Posters are trying to obfuscate the facts.

The criticism of her comes down to the reality that she has looked the other way and for taking a hands off approach to understanding how the authorities were treating the allegations, and then to use something as awful as child sex abuse, by her own father, as an opportunity to take a swipe at the media.

She is in a very different position to any of us trying to report something like that, she has a high profile influence, and has many friends and contacts in very powerful positions..

When you say that Meghan should have ensured that the allegations against her father were followed up , what exactly do you mean by ‘followed up’.?
Are you suggesting she should have personally investigated the allegations, reported them to the relevant authorities , pressured those authorities to act, or somehow guaranteed a particular outcome ?
Being an advocate for women’s rights does not mean assuming responsibility for investigating every allegation involving a family member.
Advocacy is about supporting women’s rights , justice and accountability, it does not confer investigative powers or make someone responsible for the actions of others.
Before questioning her commitment to women’s rights , perhaps we should first establish what responsibility you believe she actually had in this situation

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 09:17

Audmar · 08/11/2026 09:11

There are two happenings in this

  1. Meghans father has been exposed as a sexual predator of young children. Meghan had absolutely nothing to do with that and is not responsible.
  2. Meghan was told her father was a sexual predator of young children, 8 years ago, she clearly believed it. She, as a champion of women and children’s rights, with a huge global profile, absolutely has some responsibility for making sure those allegations were followed up, she did nothing according to her own statement.

Its just a big red herring to claim / pretend others are blaming her for her fathers actions, that is not the case, I haven’t seen anyone claim that. Posters are trying to obfuscate the facts.

The criticism of her comes down to the reality that she has looked the other way and for taking a hands off approach to understanding how the authorities were treating the allegations, and then to use something as awful as child sex abuse, by her own father, as an opportunity to take a swipe at the media.

She is in a very different position to any of us trying to report something like that, she has a high profile influence, and has many friends and contacts in very powerful positions..

None of us know what she has or hasn't done. Clearly she wasn't a fan of her father but was so hounded for that she hasn't discussed it at all.
You don't get access to it all after you bully the person.

Audmar · 08/11/2026 09:11

There are two happenings in this

  1. Meghans father has been exposed as a sexual predator of young children. Meghan had absolutely nothing to do with that and is not responsible.
  2. Meghan was told her father was a sexual predator of young children, 8 years ago, she clearly believed it. She, as a champion of women and children’s rights, with a huge global profile, absolutely has some responsibility for making sure those allegations were followed up, she did nothing according to her own statement.

Its just a big red herring to claim / pretend others are blaming her for her fathers actions, that is not the case, I haven’t seen anyone claim that. Posters are trying to obfuscate the facts.

The criticism of her comes down to the reality that she has looked the other way and for taking a hands off approach to understanding how the authorities were treating the allegations, and then to use something as awful as child sex abuse, by her own father, as an opportunity to take a swipe at the media.

She is in a very different position to any of us trying to report something like that, she has a high profile influence, and has many friends and contacts in very powerful positions..

Sophue · 08/11/2026 09:09

Overflowingbasket · 06/11/2026 20:47

You are utterly ridiculous OP. In your opening OP you link his earlier appearances with the sex abuse charges, yet instantly tried to row back on this.

Everything, everything you have said is a confused, and your case is frankly daft.

Totally agree with you.
Just a thought-OP are you Megan?😂

MrsEmmelineLucas · 08/11/2026 08:50

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 08:48

Confident MM is not a sex tourist.
Really unsure why so many people think this is her fault somehow or shows anything other than what a douche her dad is.

Absolutely. She's not responsible for his behaviour and must be devastated by these events.

LumberPainJackie · 08/11/2026 08:48

Audmar · 07/11/2026 08:02

Could the same not be said for Meghan ?

Personally I would be disgusted if my dad or brother or partner was hopping off to S.E.Asia, solo, multiple times per year, because yes we all know that most go there for the sex trade, which unfortunately is widely tolerated in these countries. It doesn’t necessarily mean they are going there to abuse underage children though.

Confident MM is not a sex tourist.
Really unsure why so many people think this is her fault somehow or shows anything other than what a douche her dad is.

sittingonabeach · 08/11/2026 08:43

DaisyDooley · 06/11/2026 19:40

Have you started weekend drinking really early??
Do you also think everyone who employed or interviewed Russel Brand should also be ‘held accountable’?

Utterly Ridiculous.

Some employers should be held accountable for employing RB and turning a blind eye to some of his behaviour.

MrsEmmelineLucas · 08/11/2026 08:10

Lampzade · 08/11/2026 07:56

So the question is only legitimate if it doesn’t lead to the scrutiny of the Royal Family
That is precisely the point . You cannot decide that the question is illegitimate simply because you suspect that the person asking the question might reach a conclusion that you don’t like . Asking what the palace knew ( or the media for that matter ) is not an accusation it is a reasonable question which should be answered .
The institution should not be exempt from scrutiny

I never said once that the RF should be exempt from scrutiny!
That's quite a stretch!! 😂

JustMyView13 · 08/11/2026 08:04

Audmar · 07/11/2026 13:33

Not really, it’s being used as a byline (by Meghan fans) to minimize and mitigate the fact that Meghan is the one who knew about these serious allegations and who appears to have done nothing.

Edited

The police told her they were investigating. What specifically was she supposed to do? And what would you have done differently in that situation?

It’s kinda weird how we still hold women to account and to blame for the actions of men. I’ve seen so many people openly suggest she’s done something wrong whilst saying nothing specific about her father. She changed her surname as part of an attempt to create distance and still people refer to her as markle.

Lampzade · 08/11/2026 07:56

MrsEmmelineLucas · 07/11/2026 18:09

This ⬆️.
"Legitimate question" for those desperate to blame the RF!

So the question is only legitimate if it doesn’t lead to the scrutiny of the Royal Family
That is precisely the point . You cannot decide that the question is illegitimate simply because you suspect that the person asking the question might reach a conclusion that you don’t like . Asking what the palace knew ( or the media for that matter ) is not an accusation it is a reasonable question which should be answered .
The institution should not be exempt from scrutiny

Somersetbaker · 07/11/2026 20:59

Audmar · 07/11/2026 13:33

Not really, it’s being used as a byline (by Meghan fans) to minimize and mitigate the fact that Meghan is the one who knew about these serious allegations and who appears to have done nothing.

Edited

Or the police who passed on the information, then conveniently lost their copy. As for Moron he's still upset that she told him to fuck off when he tried it on with her.

MrsEmmelineLucas · 07/11/2026 18:09

Audmar · 07/11/2026 13:33

Not really, it’s being used as a byline (by Meghan fans) to minimize and mitigate the fact that Meghan is the one who knew about these serious allegations and who appears to have done nothing.

Edited

This ⬆️.
"Legitimate question" for those desperate to blame the RF!

Audmar · 07/11/2026 13:33

Lampzade · 07/11/2026 12:39

Asking what the Palace knew and whether anything was done with that knowledge is a perfectly legitimate question given the seriousness of the offences

Not really, it’s being used as a byline (by Meghan fans) to minimize and mitigate the fact that Meghan is the one who knew about these serious allegations and who appears to have done nothing.

Lampzade · 07/11/2026 12:39

Asking what the Palace knew and whether anything was done with that knowledge is a perfectly legitimate question given the seriousness of the offences

Audmar · 07/11/2026 12:02

So funny how the Palace are now being dragged into the Markle mess.

So far, the only person who has publicly admitted knowing, and believing, allegations of CSA, is Meghan Markle. Harry seems to be letting her sink or swim, he has not said one word in support of his wife, while it is pretty controversial and seedy and the majority of the public are very critical of the length of time she has known this, it is more than surprising he hasn’t made a statement, didn’t he put out a statement to refute someone saying he whacked his uncle Andrew along with wild public statements that his family, the institution and the racist British public were out to get him.

Seems he is not going anywhere near this one, same as he never said a word about his Uncle Andrew, all the while he was criticizing his sister in law for not being overjoyed at being asked to share a lipgloss with his wife, and some other irrelevant minutiae .

Hoardasurass · 07/11/2026 11:32

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:53

Meghan speaking publicly about her own experiences and media organisations repeatedly inviting her estranged father to air grievances about her are not directly equivalent situations. And the Royal Family choosing not to respond publicly is not the same as being denied the opportunity to respond.

That said, I’m perfectly happy for the Oprah interview to be scrutinised on its own merits. My argument isn’t that Meghan should be exempt from criticism. It’s that the media’s editorial decisions regarding her father deserve scrutiny too.

Why does questioning the treatment of Meghan invariably seem to turn into a discussion about what Meghan herself supposedly did wrong?

Ok I see your a hypocrite thanks for explaining that.
As for why does her past behaviour get brought up when her treatment is discussed thats simple. Nothing happens in a vacuum ie her chosen behaviour directly impacted and directed both the media and public response to her. People are doing to her exactly what you are doing to her father and journalists who platformed him and yet you only want it to go one way.
Sorry but it just doesn't work like that we hold everyone to the same standards and she and her media supporters don't get a free pass just because her father is allegedly (i expect he will be convicted he hasn't yet) a pedophile.

Karma2023 · 07/11/2026 11:23

I’m questioning the ethics of those who helped amplify and monetise Thomas Markle’s public attacks

So anyone who does this should be criticised? Harry said the RF were to blame for the estrangement with Megan's Dad, which is why Piers and others platformed him. Had H&M been truthful or at least NOT blamed the Royal Family he would not have got airtime.

None of the Markle family (and Harry by association) come out of this sordid saga well. I don't think you can blame the Press because they chased a story that clearly wasn't as how H&M presented.

Whatafustercluck · 07/11/2026 11:19

I think you're entirely right to question how the media repeatedly places one person's version of the truth ahead of another's. This is done purely for hits and sales, especially as people tend to love a common enemy and so often get it wrong. This argument stands alone and is entirely justified.

However, making the point now and in the context you have detracts from this valid argument by conflating two separate issues. Journalists didn't have a crystal ball and couldn't possibly have known that TM was capable of this. That does not negate the argument that they shouldn't present one person's views as fact and assist a horribly one-sided narrative.

I have voted yabu for this reason.

Hoardasurass · 07/11/2026 11:13

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:36

I agree with your final point and I think that’s an important part of this discussion. Meghan was subjected to years of public attacks, with media figures repeatedly giving her father a platform to air his grievances against her.

I’m not suggesting anyone should have predicted the allegations. My concern is that the treatment of Meghan was questionable in its own right, long before these allegations emerged. And I suspect you’re right that there will be very little reflection, let alone any acknowledgement of the role certain media figures played in perpetuating that hostility towards her.

Honestly she was her own worst enemy.
If she and Harry hadn't gone on the attack against his family with such glee and abandon of all sense, then appeared to do the same with her family she would get so much sympathy about her dad, but no it was all attack from them so they created the situation where her father was given a platform due entirely to Harry and her own behaviou.
The old saying live by the sword die by the sword comes to mind

Lampzade · 07/11/2026 11:10

If Meghan was made aware of these allegations in 2018, some may find it difficult to believe that Kensington Palace, senior royals and the media were entirely unaware of the allegations surrounding Thomas Markle dating back to 2018
After all, the Daily Mail journalist Caroline Graham was so close to Thomas Markle that she actually lived in close proximity to him at one point . Their relationship was clearly more than a passing acquaintance . Given this level of proximity it is reasonable to question how much was known, by whom and when .
I suspect that there are a few individuals who will be quaking in their boots at this present moment. A lot more is going to come out now that Thomas Markle has been arrested .

Hoardasurass · 07/11/2026 11:03

WryJadeWren · 06/11/2026 19:24

I’m not conflating the two. I’m questioning the ethics of media figures repeatedly giving someone a platform, financially rewarding them and amplifying their public attacks on a family member.

The allegations raise a separate and much more serious issue, but they also provide an opportunity to scrutinise the media ecosystem that elevated him. Examining that doesn’t mean suggesting those media figures knew about, or were complicit in, the alleged abuse.

Those are two entirely different arguments.

Do you include Oprah whinfry(sp) etc who allowed Harry and Megan to do the exact same?

If not your a hypocrite

WarmHiker · 07/11/2026 11:01

And PP are right. Harry and Meghan are actually complicit. They knew and did nothing. All so that they could protect her image and keep the grifting going. After all, if they had actually confronted the issue, they wouldn’t have been able to con the public with their lifestyle guff and talentless babble.

WarmHiker · 07/11/2026 10:58

What evidence do you have to accuse Piers Morgan of knowing that Thomas Markle was a paedophile?