Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He needs to step up more, he knew I had a child. aibu?

742 replies

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:45

I have a 5 year old little girl from a previous relationship who’s absolutely lovely and the light of my life. I met DP (soon to be DH) when DD was 2. He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him. We’ve had our struggles over the years due to monetary issues etc, but DD has never been an issue.

I’ve always wanted DD to have a family around her. She sees her dad half the week and is with me half the week. DP is very much orientated to doing what he wants when she is here. I’ve told him I expect him to take part in family activities such as kids days out or even just having late nights together on the couch watching films. He does this occasionally but not every time she’s here. I feel like he’s divorcing himself from being a parental figure when she’s here. To be fair to DP, he does cook for her and occasionally plays with her. But DD absolutely loves him and always wants to play with him - more often than not, DP will have work to do or want to read/chill out and redirects her to play with me.

He’s lovely to her. But he disagrees with some of my decisions as a parent. Just basic things like, he tells me that he doesn’t think that he should be doing bedtime stories with her and that’s “our time”, he says that he won’t look after her on his own if I want to go to the gym or see a friend… it feels like a very “us vs him” situation. Recently my ex has changed the schedule and we have DD every weekend. I like to keep DD up later on Fridays and have a pizza and tv night, but DP doesn’t want to do it. He will go on his phone or do something else. He’s never stopped me doing it but I’d like him to be more involved.

Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back?

Or if I ask if he wants to go for meal with DD, he says no thanks, 5pm is too early for me

We use his iPad to play games on and when he comes home from work he expects to be handed it back so he can use it… I just think, don’t you care a child is playing? Can’t you use it when she’s asleep?

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses to be… but tonight I’ve had a text from him saying that he’s seeing his friends tomorrow and then needs to go and see his elderly mum on Sunday. So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

He’s said to me before he loves DD, but his connection to her is through me, he can’t be expected to be a parent when he’s not. I asked what would happen if DDs dad died. He said obviously that would be different and he’d step up, but he doesn’t need to now.

He says that he can’t sacrifice his whole life to being a stepdad and needs to maintain his friendships and family. He moved to my area so I get this, and we live together so it doesn’t feel like we need to “make an effort” to spend time together. I asked him what he preferred time with me or time with us.., i was upset when he said me on my own.

Am I expecting too much from him?

OP posts:
Wadsworthy · 06/11/2026 20:21

Elveera · 06/11/2026 17:46

You make him sit in the back seat?!

My first thought too. It’s much less safe for her and really uncomfortable for him!

bettyrubble99 · 06/11/2026 20:21

What a shit show your marriage will be.......

ItsCloudyToday · 06/11/2026 20:20

You are being unreasonable to an (large) extent. But he is also telling you that he doesn’t want to be a stepdad so has no business getting into a relationship with a woman with a child.

PepsiBook · 06/11/2026 20:19

She already has a dad, she doesn't need a second. You are a single parent.

Notimeforaname · 06/11/2026 20:18

You are wrong.
You are asking too much.
She is not his daughter.
She has a father.
He has told you he doesn’t want to be more involved.
Leave him alone.

OopsIDidntDoItAgain · 06/11/2026 20:17

Anything he does should really be because he's chosen to do it.

And I am not saying you should just accept what you're given. If you feel you and your DD deserve more then you should absolutely end this relationship. You should not compromise on how you feel your child should be treated.

However, forcing someone to be a parent when they don't want to be is never going to work. He is showing you quite clearly that he does not want to be her third parent. Some are fine with that, others find it unacceptable.

If you find that unacceptable then absolutely leave. But don't try and force it, why would you want someone doing this stuff for your DD not through wanting to but by feeling pressured? You want him to enjoy your DD, not resent the situation.

OneHazelBird · 06/11/2026 20:17

He does need to be involved and not act like a single man….

But you are her parent and it’s important that you guys have 1-1 time together without him.

She has a dad and he should absolutely not be going to parents evening etc.

It sounds like you have an unhealthy dependence on him and don’t like going things on your own.
Perhaps he’s only just realising this which is why he’s started taking a step back.

If you want to save this relationship then it’s time you start being more independent.

WimbyAce · 06/11/2026 20:17

She has a very involved dad already which is great, she does not need another one. I think you are being unreasonable in your expectations. You only have her part time and you want him to look after her while you go out? You need to be arranging going out on those days you don't have her.

Mossyfox · 06/11/2026 20:16

Your expectations are too high. He isn't her father.

Rosesandthorns66 · 06/11/2026 20:13

You sound controlling.

tenderbee · 06/11/2026 20:12

InterestedDad37 · 06/11/2026 20:02

This seems very much doomed to failure. Put your daughter first. Don't get married. He is still a single man and clearly wants to stay that way.

Exactly, and they should stop living together, because it's still almost the same if they're living together. She can keep the relationship if he's that dear to her, but they need to stop living together.

Keepingthingsinteresting · 06/11/2026 20:12

Itsu · 06/11/2026 18:18

The car thing is not a regular occurrence at all. It’s just an example!

I just don’t feel like we’re a unit at all. He’s happily out doing his own things, but when dd isn’t here he will spend time with just me?

he has said that he finds this age harder as she’s very active and needs a lot of input. He thinks that days should be fun for all of us, eg he said he’s not coming to say a theme park paw patrol, but would do a day out to a Forrest etc. but dd should come first? She’s only 5

I can see you are upset, but I wouldn’t want to go to paw patrol park, why can your dad not do things you’ll all enjoy, it doesn’t help kids to think the world revolves around them.

The reality is she isn’t his kid, he doesn’t want to be a dad ( that’s ok, she has one of those)& you either get over it or break up. Either is fine, but you need to change as asking him to is wildly unreasonable

didnttellasoul · 06/11/2026 20:11

Smartiepants79 · 06/11/2026 20:07

She’s 5. Not old enough to understand anything about the complexities of the adult relationships that she has been put smack in the middle of. This man is being presented to her as a third parent. She’s not old enough to understand the nuances of why he’s not actually (and doesn’t want to be) her second dad.
He’s perfectly entitled to not want to be her other parent but I don’t think that this relationship is a good fit if that if the case.

This man is being presented to her as a third parent.

Yes, by OP. Not him. OP just needs to stop pretending trying to get him to be a parent; he isn’t. Nor does he need to be. She has two, involved parents.

Blueflipflops · 06/11/2026 20:11

Oh dear! This is not going to end well!

And as for…Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back!!!

OopsIDidntDoItAgain · 06/11/2026 20:09

Also as a step mother myself I'm sorry I wouldn't have enjoyed having DSC every weekend either when they were little and I'd have definitely arranged some stuff of my own to do during that time so I got a break. I'm not saying every time, but I don't think he's wrong for wanting to do something else for the odd weekend.

I have DC of my own now who are obviously here every weekend so weekends are now all family time really but sorry to say it just is different when it's DSC. I would not have spent every single weekend doing stuff with DSC Saturday and Sunday being told I can't even arrange to see my own mates or mother.

Smartiepants79 · 06/11/2026 20:07

DonnyBurrito · 06/11/2026 19:39

Surely she will be old enough to realise she has two biological parents who love her and care for her in the exact same way her half sibling will have two parents who love and care for them?

Why does OPs daughter need three parents...?

She’s 5. Not old enough to understand anything about the complexities of the adult relationships that she has been put smack in the middle of. This man is being presented to her as a third parent. She’s not old enough to understand the nuances of why he’s not actually (and doesn’t want to be) her second dad.
He’s perfectly entitled to not want to be her other parent but I don’t think that this relationship is a good fit if that if the case.

Newsenmum · 06/11/2026 20:07

You dont need to ‘stay single’ but if your man wont properly commit he needs to be a man you see as just a boyfriend when dd isnt around and no way do you marry him. Also would you have another kid? Will he treat joint kid differently?

Moveoverdarlin · 06/11/2026 20:07

Talk about alarm bells. He’s not in the slightest bit interested in family life. This won’t change.

HellonHeels · 06/11/2026 20:05

Hard to believe this is true but if it is and you love your DD as much as you claim why the hell are you ever putting her in the front seat?

Pallisers · 06/11/2026 20:04

this isn't going to work. You expect him to act like a dad when your dd is with you and he doesn't want to. There is no right or wrong here but this is not going to work out. Another woman with a child might be perfectly happy with his level of involvement but you aren't. Another man might be happy to be daddy during half the week but he isn't. I don't think this relationship is right for either of you and your daughter will pick up on the tension of you thinking he is failing her - or begin to believe it herself.

I also wouldn't even think of having children with this guy - he has no interest in it right now.

OopsIDidntDoItAgain · 06/11/2026 20:04

So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

Well yeah ... She's your DD.

I'm on the fence as some of this I'm on your side, others I'm with him.

Like watching her when you go to the gym, if we are talking once or twice a week when he's at home anyway but he just won't watch her then yeah I think that's unreasonable. If you're expecting him to come home from work early or you're talking 5 days a week then no.

Making him sit in the back seat is unreasonable. He's an adult, she's a child. I wouldn't have that.

Wanting his own iPad back when he gets home from work is not unreasonable either, having work to do in the evenings, not wanting to spend every single weekend doing "family" things is not either. He should be present sometimes but he should also be allowed opportunity to see his friends and mother.

At the end of the day she is your daughter.

You can't also expect him to basically act like her dad but have no say in how you parent either. That is incredibly hypocritical. If you want it, you want it all and that includes considering his points about how you choose to parent. If you don't want to do that then I say get on with parenting your own child 🤷‍♀️

Newsenmum · 06/11/2026 20:04

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:49

Only if I’m driving from somewhere where I’ve taken her out before I got to him!

I dont think the carseat is a big deal. I wouldnt marry a guy who wasnt committed to being a family. Also op monetary issues are the number 1 reason for divorce.

InterestedDad37 · 06/11/2026 20:02

This seems very much doomed to failure. Put your daughter first. Don't get married. He is still a single man and clearly wants to stay that way.

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 20:02

Plmnki · 06/11/2026 20:00

The fact you have ignored the huge number of people who have pointed out that (a) your expectations are unrealistic and (b) you are not compatible speaks volumes for your attitude.

He would be mad to marry you.

put your child first and stay single.

Yes, it’s ironic the OP is complaining that her fiancé isn’t putting her daughter first, when in fact she’s the actual parent and isn’t putting her daughter first.

tenderbee · 06/11/2026 20:02

Itsu · 06/11/2026 17:45

I have a 5 year old little girl from a previous relationship who’s absolutely lovely and the light of my life. I met DP (soon to be DH) when DD was 2. He was always accepting and loving towards her and I loved that about him. We’ve had our struggles over the years due to monetary issues etc, but DD has never been an issue.

I’ve always wanted DD to have a family around her. She sees her dad half the week and is with me half the week. DP is very much orientated to doing what he wants when she is here. I’ve told him I expect him to take part in family activities such as kids days out or even just having late nights together on the couch watching films. He does this occasionally but not every time she’s here. I feel like he’s divorcing himself from being a parental figure when she’s here. To be fair to DP, he does cook for her and occasionally plays with her. But DD absolutely loves him and always wants to play with him - more often than not, DP will have work to do or want to read/chill out and redirects her to play with me.

He’s lovely to her. But he disagrees with some of my decisions as a parent. Just basic things like, he tells me that he doesn’t think that he should be doing bedtime stories with her and that’s “our time”, he says that he won’t look after her on his own if I want to go to the gym or see a friend… it feels like a very “us vs him” situation. Recently my ex has changed the schedule and we have DD every weekend. I like to keep DD up later on Fridays and have a pizza and tv night, but DP doesn’t want to do it. He will go on his phone or do something else. He’s never stopped me doing it but I’d like him to be more involved.

Another thing he dislikes is that I put DDs seat in the front seat and he has to sit in the back?

Or if I ask if he wants to go for meal with DD, he says no thanks, 5pm is too early for me

We use his iPad to play games on and when he comes home from work he expects to be handed it back so he can use it… I just think, don’t you care a child is playing? Can’t you use it when she’s asleep?

DP will come to parents evenings and is very present when he chooses to be… but tonight I’ve had a text from him saying that he’s seeing his friends tomorrow and then needs to go and see his elderly mum on Sunday. So a whole weekend acting like a single man whilst I look after dd…

He’s said to me before he loves DD, but his connection to her is through me, he can’t be expected to be a parent when he’s not. I asked what would happen if DDs dad died. He said obviously that would be different and he’d step up, but he doesn’t need to now.

He says that he can’t sacrifice his whole life to being a stepdad and needs to maintain his friendships and family. He moved to my area so I get this, and we live together so it doesn’t feel like we need to “make an effort” to spend time together. I asked him what he preferred time with me or time with us.., i was upset when he said me on my own.

Am I expecting too much from him?

If you dance to the tunes of some people here, your child will resent you as an adult. Living with someone who only gives you a fraction of themselves only when it is convenient for them is unhealthy for a child, she is even too young to be carrying that baggage of rejection, it will affect her in many ways!! If he doesn't live with you it is different, but he lives with you, he cannot treat your child the way he's doing, he cannot!! If you have children with him, he will treat his children more favourably than your own. He's already clear where he stands, he probably thought he's cut out for fathering another man's child and he realised he is not and stopped playing for the gallery, which is good, yours is to make a decision, a hard one at that. If you stay, your child will say you chose a man over her and she will be right. She is just 5 for goodness sake, how long will she live like this?

YABU & YANBU

YABU for few reasons:

  1. Putting her car seat in front, I don't find it cute for any reason.
  2. I don't allow my kids to play on my tablet for long, how much more their dad's, I don't allow it either.
  3. This man doesn't want to father your child, you can see it already, but you're not accepting it, stop forcing your child on someone that doesn't want to be a part of their lives, your child is going to get hurt! Leave that man alone!

YANBU for:

  1. Having expectations that your partner would step up in responsibilities to your child, I think it's only natural as he is in your life, you care about him, your child will natural want him to be a part of her life too.

My 2cents is leave this man alone and go!!! Being a single parent comes with a lot of cons, this is one of it, meeting someone who will love you and your children wholesomely is not easy.

If you still want to keep this man, then, you cannot get married to him and he cannot live in your house, start living alone and see each other occasionally, at least you'll stop carrying mental and physical load for one more person, and stop having expectations that help is in the house when you never get the help, so your mind and body will reprogram fast.