Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be unreasonable to have a play date with child who's being "mean" to DC?

9 replies

Ohohi · 06/11/2026 17:40

DC is 5 and in Y1.

There is another child in his year who he went to nursery with, they are the only ones who went to the same nursery. They've never been super close but have on occasion played together and never heard anything negative.

I am quite friendly with their mum just down to the fact we already knew each other when the kids started school so we sort of gravitated to each other at the gate.

She keeps suggesting we get the kids together outside of school at one of our houses for a coffee and play however in the last couple of weeks DS has been saying that "X is being mean".

He won't tell me in what way X is apparently being mean and he doesn't want me to ask teachers, just keeps saying it. He's never upset about going to school and it only comes up every now and then.

I can't decide whether it might actually be good for them to get together outside of school or whether it would be awful to do to DS if this other boy genuinely is being mean. But then they are 5, I can't imagine he is being that awful, probably just things like not sharing or not letting DS play a game or whatever. DS has a best friend at school who he also occasionally comes home and says isn't his friend anymore because of X Y Z trivial thing, then next day they are stuck together again.

Good idea or bad idea?

OP posts:
Chickadiddy · 06/11/2026 17:42

But does he want a playdate with this child?

Ohohi · 06/11/2026 17:45

He hasn't asked and I haven't yet suggested it, I just wonder whether it might help break any sort of simmering tension between the boys to have a meeting outside of the school environment.

OP posts:
WiltedLettuce · 06/11/2026 18:42

Good idea. If there are tensions in school at this age, often getting the kids together outside school can sort them out. My DC had one boy in his class who he disliked and found 'annoying', but we ran into the family in the playground and the boys played together and have been friends since.

Even if the playdate is a disaster, it will be useful to be able to observe the dynamic between them and exactly where things are going wrong.

sprigatito · 06/11/2026 18:47

At 5, I would probably do a playdate, supervise it very closely and try to gauge what is actually going on. If the other child is indeed “mean”, you can either address it with the parent or just avoid in future. As long as your DS doesn’t say “ no, I don’t want to” when you suggest it, I think it’s ok at this age for the impetus to come from you rather than him (obviously if he actively hates the idea, I wouldn’t do it!)

Ohohi · 06/11/2026 19:57

WiltedLettuce · 06/11/2026 18:42

Good idea. If there are tensions in school at this age, often getting the kids together outside school can sort them out. My DC had one boy in his class who he disliked and found 'annoying', but we ran into the family in the playground and the boys played together and have been friends since.

Even if the playdate is a disaster, it will be useful to be able to observe the dynamic between them and exactly where things are going wrong.

Thanks, this is what I was thinking, it might help given they are still so young.

If he was 15 and this kid was actually bullying him then obviously I wouldn't expect them to spend time together! But at 5 I wonder if it would help break the ice a little so to speak!

I'll mention it to DS and see what his reaction is.

OP posts:
MyLimeGuide · 06/11/2026 20:22

What? Why would you arrange a play date with a kid who is being mean to your child? To me this is crazy, hasn't he mentioned any other kids that are actually nice to him you could arrange play dates with? I have horrendous memories of being a kid and having so many forced play dates with these nasty girls in my class because my parents were friends with their parents. Don't do it!!

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 16:37

Ohohi · 06/11/2026 17:40

DC is 5 and in Y1.

There is another child in his year who he went to nursery with, they are the only ones who went to the same nursery. They've never been super close but have on occasion played together and never heard anything negative.

I am quite friendly with their mum just down to the fact we already knew each other when the kids started school so we sort of gravitated to each other at the gate.

She keeps suggesting we get the kids together outside of school at one of our houses for a coffee and play however in the last couple of weeks DS has been saying that "X is being mean".

He won't tell me in what way X is apparently being mean and he doesn't want me to ask teachers, just keeps saying it. He's never upset about going to school and it only comes up every now and then.

I can't decide whether it might actually be good for them to get together outside of school or whether it would be awful to do to DS if this other boy genuinely is being mean. But then they are 5, I can't imagine he is being that awful, probably just things like not sharing or not letting DS play a game or whatever. DS has a best friend at school who he also occasionally comes home and says isn't his friend anymore because of X Y Z trivial thing, then next day they are stuck together again.

Good idea or bad idea?

That sounds absolutely absurd

Darragon · 08/11/2026 09:38

Ohohi · 06/11/2026 19:57

Thanks, this is what I was thinking, it might help given they are still so young.

If he was 15 and this kid was actually bullying him then obviously I wouldn't expect them to spend time together! But at 5 I wonder if it would help break the ice a little so to speak!

I'll mention it to DS and see what his reaction is.

Based on one person’s anecdote? Here’s a more common anecdote for you op. My mum was friends with Judy. Judy’s daughter Jasmine was always nasty to me. My mum organised playdates so she could hang with Judy. Jasmine had more opportunities to be shitty to me. I hated these “playdates”. My mum didn’t have my back or listen to me about it because she was too self absorbed. I know at least two other adults where similar happened.
*Names changed.

WiltedLettuce · 09/11/2026 10:33

Darragon · 08/11/2026 09:38

Based on one person’s anecdote? Here’s a more common anecdote for you op. My mum was friends with Judy. Judy’s daughter Jasmine was always nasty to me. My mum organised playdates so she could hang with Judy. Jasmine had more opportunities to be shitty to me. I hated these “playdates”. My mum didn’t have my back or listen to me about it because she was too self absorbed. I know at least two other adults where similar happened.
*Names changed.

Edited

One playdate to assess the dynamic between the children closely supervised by a mum who has your back is entirely different from having the unpleasant kids of your parents' friends foisted on you again and again so the adults can hang out.

Part of helping your children develop social skills is teaching them how to set boundaries and respond to those who don't treat them appropriately. And you can't do that if actually they're never put in situations where they might need to develop coping skills. That's different from repeatedly abandoning your kids in the company of toxic and unpleasant people.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page