Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have an honest yet polite conversation with son's girlfriend

252 replies

momtoboys · 06/11/2026 14:51

My oldest son (27) has had the same girlfriend for 7 years. They live together, about 4 hours from us, which is very close to her family and likely where they will stay in the future. We are very close to my son, speak frequently, group chat almost every day, etc.

This is the first year that they are doing the alternating holidays. Thanksgiving (we are in US) at her family, Christmas at ours. She is smart, capable, well educated, high earning, and so many things that my son loves about her. She is very close to her mom and I have been regaled for years of stories from my son about how judgmental they are and that she and her mom spend all of their time judging people and making fun of people between themselves. She does not seem to want to develop a relationship with our family. She comes to visit a few times a year, we greet them happily, offer food, drink, regular visitor stuff. She is gracious, says no thank you and disappears to their bedroom mostly only to appear when they are going out. The few times she does sit with us after dinner or while sitting relaxing, she is texting the entire time. I have attempted to initiate conversation only to have her answer inquiries with one word or perhaps one sentence answers. Most of the time she doesn't even look up from her phone. My son and I had a conversation about this several months ago which went really well, I thought. I told him that we are happy that he has found someone he loves, but as his mother I am worried that he may marry someone that doesn't like his family. He said "what has she done that makes you think she doesn't like you?" My response was "nothing, but she certainly hasn't done anything to make us think she does". He said that was another way to look at things and he hadn't thought of it that way. I think he must have said something to her because for the first time ever she texted me unprompted and sent a photo of my son.

I am dreading Christmas. I know this is my problem but I am convinced that she will spend her time texting her mother listing all the ways I fail as a cook, decorator, house cleaner, etc. I get tired just thinking of topics to talk to her about.

Is it unreasonable to want to attempt to have a conversation with her about how I would like to get to know her better and maybe develop some sort of relationship?

OP posts:
MadMadaMim · 08/11/2026 11:54

momtoboys · 06/11/2026 16:01

@pinkdelight - I know this probably sounds terrible but I would have no problem if she didn't come at all. Except I wouldn't want to have that become the norm when they have children because we would probably see them less. The atmosphere in the whole house is off when she is there. My other sons (I have four more) all call her "the queen or the dutchess".

You refer to her as 'the same girlfriend for 7 years' which is weird. She's his partner. They live together. Even 'they've been together for 7 years' or ''girlfriend of 7 years'

But also, this post says a lot!!! People aren't blind. They pick up vibes. If you'd prefer to never see her, she knows this. So when she's at your place, she hides away and makes sure you're not uncomfortable in your own home because of her. And she knows how the rest of your family feel towards her.

Your son hit the nail in the head. What has she done to make you think she doesn't like you? She hasn't. You've decided she doesn't like you.

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 12:08

Why try to force her into joining in? If I were her I would feel really uncomfortable about that.

Okay I’m AUDHD but I can imagine wanting to spend time away from the in-laws. I would be using the room as a bolthole. Fortunately the people I know accommodate that happily because they understand.

I’m sure OP would complain if she refused to come at all. Interesting that a lot of posters are suggesting things not for the sake of fostering a good relationship as such but as preparation for if they have children.

Telling the DS to tell her not to scroll is wrong. Tell her yourself if you feel she must be told,

Let her be in her room if she wants. She may hate Christmas and be just trying to get through it as best she can. Or she may have picked up on the fact that his brothers and the OP slag her off which means she wants to spend even less time with them.

The fact OP seems to think it’s funny that her other sons call this young woman names is an issue - you can bet she knows that they do that.

If I was her I would be considering whether the relationship was right for her.

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 12:15

EndlessTreadmill · 06/11/2026 20:12

This. To be honest she sounds like a bit of a bitch and nothing you do will ever be up to scratch just because it’s not her family, so don’t bother.
My main concern would be the level of respect she has for your son. Because if she really loves and respects him, then that usually extends to his family. If she is looking down her nose at you, then what does that say about what she thinks of him, and he shouldn’t stand for it.
And don’t expect to be having an equal share in the grandchildren come the time….

I wonder why she is with someone who drags her to family who slag her off behind her back and only really want a relationship in case they have children.

Its perfectly reasonable to want your own space when you are doing a duty visit to people who call you names (please don’t think she doesn’t know - unless she’s thick as pigshit she will be aware of the hostility). And if she does know, then she’s probably not going to want you all to spend lots of time with any future kids when she knows what you think of her.

I don’t understand why people can’t just leave her alone as she’s not bothering anyone. Let her have her space and the family can carry on without her.

If someone tried to ask me to help wrap something or ask me for recipes just as a way of dragging me in, I would think they were slightly insane!

DaringQuoter · 08/11/2026 12:57

Surely the majority of sons partners/wives have tricky relationships with their MIL. There’s usually undercurrents. I was frankly quite jealous of my ex’s close relationship with his mother and I don’t think that’s unusual. I always wanted him to put me first. Now I have my own DIL I make a big effort to include her and make her feel as welcome as my son when they visit.
They also live near her family and I know they see a lot more of them than us.
I’m just glad they love each other and are happy together. She is, however, polite and respectful and I think that’s as good as it gets. I certainly don’t expect more from her.

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 13:14

There's potentially a compromise to be found. I completely understand why a visitor might need some downtime during the day but to offer no more than monosyllabic responses to someone hosting you is very rude.

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 14:42

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 13:14

There's potentially a compromise to be found. I completely understand why a visitor might need some downtime during the day but to offer no more than monosyllabic responses to someone hosting you is very rude.

Wouldn’t you be monosyllabic to people who are calling you names behind your back? People can pick up on this sort of thing

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 14:48

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 14:42

Wouldn’t you be monosyllabic to people who are calling you names behind your back? People can pick up on this sort of thing

It's hard to say what came first. I expect that the OP would claim that she was monosyllabic and moody first and that's why the others are calling her names behind her back but who knows? I'd still feel like a crappy person for accepting hospitality from another whilst behaving like a moody teenager though.

grinandslothit · 08/11/2026 15:08

momtoboys · 06/11/2026 16:01

@pinkdelight - I know this probably sounds terrible but I would have no problem if she didn't come at all. Except I wouldn't want to have that become the norm when they have children because we would probably see them less. The atmosphere in the whole house is off when she is there. My other sons (I have four more) all call her "the queen or the dutchess".

You really are something else I'm just laughing as I read this
I could imagine being a guest in your home and I'm not some naive 27-year-old
I would take delight in winding you up and you would never know what hit you it
be just wonderful and satisfying
That said I suspect the real problem is here that you're still too enmeshed with your son your 27-year-old son who has been on his own for a long time you are not the main character in his life anymore nor should you be you know I'm a bit suspect of the daily contact is that something he actually wants or is he just doing it because he doesn't want your wrath because you seem like that type of person

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 15:09

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 14:48

It's hard to say what came first. I expect that the OP would claim that she was monosyllabic and moody first and that's why the others are calling her names behind her back but who knows? I'd still feel like a crappy person for accepting hospitality from another whilst behaving like a moody teenager though.

But she’s choosing to keep out of the way in a situation she clearly doesn’t enjoy. That is a compromise. The family clearly doesn’t want her there so if she keeps upstairs then they can carry on their celebration without her.

I would feel crappy having to stay with in-laws that slagged me off and that were interested in me only because there may be grandchildren in the future. The OP even admits that she doesn’t know if the DIL is moaning to her mother.

The DS is getting away with a lot here - it sounds like he bitches to his mother about her and her mother, the mother would rather she didn’t come, the brothers call her names - he is not saying to his family ‘she’s not comfortable about this but wants to spend Christmas with me so she is dealing with it as well as she can’. Or even tell his family ‘if you don’t like it, we can spend Christmas elsewhere’.

I am someone who needs a bolthole - people who love me understand and accommodate that.

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 15:15

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 15:09

But she’s choosing to keep out of the way in a situation she clearly doesn’t enjoy. That is a compromise. The family clearly doesn’t want her there so if she keeps upstairs then they can carry on their celebration without her.

I would feel crappy having to stay with in-laws that slagged me off and that were interested in me only because there may be grandchildren in the future. The OP even admits that she doesn’t know if the DIL is moaning to her mother.

The DS is getting away with a lot here - it sounds like he bitches to his mother about her and her mother, the mother would rather she didn’t come, the brothers call her names - he is not saying to his family ‘she’s not comfortable about this but wants to spend Christmas with me so she is dealing with it as well as she can’. Or even tell his family ‘if you don’t like it, we can spend Christmas elsewhere’.

I am someone who needs a bolthole - people who love me understand and accommodate that.

I think if you are going to go to someone's home as a guest you at least owe it to your hosts to attempt some sort of civil conversation and some polite answers to appropriate questions. Part of being in an adult romantic relationship is making some level of effort with your partner's friends and family.

If you can't do those things then it's better to decline the invitation.

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 15:32

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 15:15

I think if you are going to go to someone's home as a guest you at least owe it to your hosts to attempt some sort of civil conversation and some polite answers to appropriate questions. Part of being in an adult romantic relationship is making some level of effort with your partner's friends and family.

If you can't do those things then it's better to decline the invitation.

Edited

Or the DS could try to ensure she is comfortable. He sounds like he’s very enmeshed with his family but bitches about her being close to her mother. The OP’s posts sound quite dismissive of her and I wonder how much of this is led by him.

if he’s bitching to his family about her, there is a good chance he will be bitching to her about his family.

WhatNoRaisins · 08/11/2026 15:40

I don't think that DS has helped matters by telling his family about how his girlfriend and her mum slag people off. Even without that her behaviour speaks for itself and I'm not sure what the answer is apart from behaving well yourself and encouraging the other sons to not say unkind things.

DaringQuoter · 08/11/2026 20:26

I’m sorry OP, but she has no interest in getting to know you better. She loves your son, not you. She lives a long way away from you and this suits them both.
I imagine daily chats with your son are a source of amusement to them both.
They’re happy ; accept her the way she is and leave them both alone!

HeyThereDelila · 08/11/2026 20:56

I mean, I’d have been a lot more blunt and told her to her face how rude she’s being in your house by being on her phone constantly.

I appreciate you don’t want to fall out with her if she ends up married to your son, but she’s being immature and disrespectful. Maybe nobody has ever told her answering with one word answers and being on her phone and hiding away in a bedroom is rude, but it is, and you should.

Tell her and DS if she doesn’t change her ways she’s not invited back.

HeyThereDelila · 08/11/2026 20:58

DaringQuoter · 08/11/2026 20:26

I’m sorry OP, but she has no interest in getting to know you better. She loves your son, not you. She lives a long way away from you and this suits them both.
I imagine daily chats with your son are a source of amusement to them both.
They’re happy ; accept her the way she is and leave them both alone!

Seriously? What? The OP doesn’t have to put up with this incredibly rude behaviour in her own house.

ThatFlakyHam · 08/11/2026 23:02

Least said soonest mended. Look to the future and consider what effect anything that you do or say might have if they have children together. Just bite your tongue and let it be. You feel things could be better or differrent, but if you want to see your son and any future grandkids, dont give her any reason to not come or exclude you.

My (much younger than me) wifes mother and her step father were very difficulty with me because they didnt want the relationship. Partly as i had been married (and had a motorbike) Her very wise Gran was brilliant, she noted what was going on, took me to one side one day and said i know whats going on, dont do or say anything, take it on the chin for now and just leave it to me. Over time she gently fixed all the issues. Today 39 years later her mother has remairried twice more and my relationship with her mother is actually better than that oif her own sons.

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 08:48

HeyThereDelila · 08/11/2026 20:56

I mean, I’d have been a lot more blunt and told her to her face how rude she’s being in your house by being on her phone constantly.

I appreciate you don’t want to fall out with her if she ends up married to your son, but she’s being immature and disrespectful. Maybe nobody has ever told her answering with one word answers and being on her phone and hiding away in a bedroom is rude, but it is, and you should.

Tell her and DS if she doesn’t change her ways she’s not invited back.

I doubt you would, and if you did then you would be ensuring that things will be very awkward in future. If they do go on to have children then you can expect not to see much of them.

Why is she the only one expected to force herself to make conversation and be physically present with people who dislike her the entire time? She is there because it’s her partner’s family and she feels obligated.

I would put money on the fact that DS is playing both sides against the other. If he is thst close to his family then he could defend her to them.

Why isn’t it a good compromise to let her hide herself away when she feels like it? If it was a visit for a few hours I could understand why people think that is rude but staying with people is always more intense.

DaringQuoter · 09/11/2026 09:40

Seriously? What? The OP doesn’t have to put up with this incredibly rude behaviour in her own house.

Of course she does if she wants to see her son. If she challenges the girlfriend and causes conflict her son will not side with her. The OP only tells her side of the story - we already know that the other sons call the girl unpleasant names. OP risks losing any opportunity of seeing future grandchildren and alienating them.

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 09:52

DaringQuoter · 09/11/2026 09:40

Seriously? What? The OP doesn’t have to put up with this incredibly rude behaviour in her own house.

Of course she does if she wants to see her son. If she challenges the girlfriend and causes conflict her son will not side with her. The OP only tells her side of the story - we already know that the other sons call the girl unpleasant names. OP risks losing any opportunity of seeing future grandchildren and alienating them.

Is that rude like the OP saying her sons call her names and she would rather she didn’t come?

momtoboys · 09/11/2026 14:59

Fiddy1964 · 08/11/2026 05:27

I was in exact same position with my eldest son. They went on to marry and I felt I tried really hard to connect with my daughter in-law. Felt that she just did not like me and barely ever spoke to me.
Their marriage only lasted 2 years. I always felt they were missmatched but never ever said anything to my son as i respected that this was the woman he loved.
Now my son is with a new partner & its like chalk & cheese. She is such a warm loving person and a chatterbox like myself. She has brought out a very fun loving side to my son who always seemed to have a very serious old head on his shoulders. It has been an absolute pleasure to watch their relationship develope.
I never ever disliked my previous daughter in-law and only wished we had developed a closer bond at the time.

Thank you for this post. It's nice to think someone has felt the same way.

OP posts:
momtoboys · 09/11/2026 15:01

nc43214321 · 07/11/2026 20:27

Well you have never told him what you have written here, when he asked you what has she done that makes you think she doesn’t like you? You said nothing!!!! Nothing that you have pointed out here 🤣🙄 she will just be the same tbh. Personally sounds all very passive aggressive! Are you jealous or just don’t think she is right for the family? Unfortunately this isn’t going to end well I don’t think.

Edited

I could be both jealous and sad she may not be a fit for our family. Clearly I was wrong for considering having a discussion with the GF.

OP posts:
momtoboys · 09/11/2026 15:03

Pallisers · 08/11/2026 00:41

After 7 years and her manners haven’t improved? Initiating a polite conversation is a way of flagging that she needs to get a grip and make an effort. Another example of how entitled, rude and ignorant some people can be.

well in fairness 7 years in and the family are still calling her names behind her back so that hasn't improved either.

Again, I have NEVER called her names behind her back, told my other sons that I do not want to hear that around me. I cannot control what my ADULT sons say amongst themselves.

OP posts:
momtoboys · 09/11/2026 15:07

Dery · 08/11/2026 09:51

“momtoboys · Yesterday 12:58
MaryBeardsShoes · Yesterday 07:28
So your family is also bitchy and judgemental 🤣
momtoboys · 06/11/2026 16:01
** - I know this probably sounds terrible but I would have no problem if she didn't come at all. Except I wouldn't want to have that become the norm when they have children because we would probably see them less. The atmosphere in the whole house is off when she is there. My other sons (I have four more) all call her "the queen or the dutchess".
Hide quote history
🤣. Touché! In my defense, I do not call her that and I do my best to stop my adult sons from doing it!”

@momtoboys - you’ve laughed about it but i think this is SO significant. You posted at the outset as if you’ve just been lovely and welcoming but if this is how your family talk about your son’s GF then she may sense a vibe. It’s tricky. I think best to crack down on your family bitching about her, say nothing to her but perhaps see if your son can encourage her to be around you more. Could you do an activity which requires her to join in - it’s easy to tap out of a chat but perhaps a board game or an outing or something?

I was laughing about your calling me out on my family being judgmental, not about her nickname. I can understand why you thought that.

OP posts:
momtoboys · 09/11/2026 15:10

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 14:42

Wouldn’t you be monosyllabic to people who are calling you names behind your back? People can pick up on this sort of thing

AGAIN - I have NEVER called her names behind her back, nor do I slag her off the family members, as a previous poster said. I take responsibility for not knowing the best way to handle this situation but I will not take the blame for something I do not do.

OP posts:
nc43214321 · 09/11/2026 15:13

Sounds like you have trained your boys well 🙄 I actually feel sorry for the girl and would advise her to run whilst she can!