Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have an honest yet polite conversation with son's girlfriend

252 replies

momtoboys · 06/11/2026 14:51

My oldest son (27) has had the same girlfriend for 7 years. They live together, about 4 hours from us, which is very close to her family and likely where they will stay in the future. We are very close to my son, speak frequently, group chat almost every day, etc.

This is the first year that they are doing the alternating holidays. Thanksgiving (we are in US) at her family, Christmas at ours. She is smart, capable, well educated, high earning, and so many things that my son loves about her. She is very close to her mom and I have been regaled for years of stories from my son about how judgmental they are and that she and her mom spend all of their time judging people and making fun of people between themselves. She does not seem to want to develop a relationship with our family. She comes to visit a few times a year, we greet them happily, offer food, drink, regular visitor stuff. She is gracious, says no thank you and disappears to their bedroom mostly only to appear when they are going out. The few times she does sit with us after dinner or while sitting relaxing, she is texting the entire time. I have attempted to initiate conversation only to have her answer inquiries with one word or perhaps one sentence answers. Most of the time she doesn't even look up from her phone. My son and I had a conversation about this several months ago which went really well, I thought. I told him that we are happy that he has found someone he loves, but as his mother I am worried that he may marry someone that doesn't like his family. He said "what has she done that makes you think she doesn't like you?" My response was "nothing, but she certainly hasn't done anything to make us think she does". He said that was another way to look at things and he hadn't thought of it that way. I think he must have said something to her because for the first time ever she texted me unprompted and sent a photo of my son.

I am dreading Christmas. I know this is my problem but I am convinced that she will spend her time texting her mother listing all the ways I fail as a cook, decorator, house cleaner, etc. I get tired just thinking of topics to talk to her about.

Is it unreasonable to want to attempt to have a conversation with her about how I would like to get to know her better and maybe develop some sort of relationship?

OP posts:
StoatMilk · 06/11/2026 16:38

ApiratesaysYarrr · 06/11/2026 14:57

Also perhaps have a conversation with all family (including her) to say "We'd like some phone free time (maybe a few hours in the morning, or after 8pm) to have some family time" - this only works if your family will sit together and chat/play games.

Phone free…. Awful suggestion she’s not 13 even if she’s acting like a grumpy teen

Piglet89 · 06/11/2026 16:39

Christ alive she is SOOOOOOOO rude!!!

Mumofoneandone · 06/11/2026 16:41

Sorry, but she sounds horrible, very rude and lacking in manners when staying with you.
The name your other sons have for her is very telling!
I hope your son really sees the light and finishes with her and finds a much nicer person to be with!
Be polite to her by all means, but don't go out of your way to accommodate her.

CelticTok · 06/11/2026 16:42

You mention that she texted you off her own back recently, and it might be because your son had had a word. So instead of dreading Xmas, try to be positive - it might be better this next time that you see them.

Nothavingagoodvalentinesday · 06/11/2026 16:45

She is being extremely rude and there is nothing wrong with you feeling this way. You can’t make her behave better but you can stop thinking it is because of any failing on your part.

WitchesBritches · 06/11/2026 16:47

didntlikeanyofthesuggestions · 06/11/2026 14:55

Could you accidentally drop her phone in a jug of water when she first arrives?

I wonder if they have a swimming pool then you wouldn't need to stop at dropping the phone in...

Tolkienista · 06/11/2026 16:48

Definitely don't go go for the honest conversation, I really think it could backfire on you. Bite your tongue, fear the worst and it will probably be a lot better than you think. The constantly on her phone is (in my opinion) a young person thing.

ACynicalDad · 06/11/2026 16:50

The only person who can have this conversation is your son. Can you go out and do an activity together? I'm thinking wreath making or something she can't do with her phone in her hands.

WitchesBritches · 06/11/2026 16:50

MissMoneyFairy · 06/11/2026 15:04

Why is your son not telling her no phone after dinner, he tells you that she and her mum gossip and laugh about people, it doesn't matter, if that's the sort of woman he wants in his life that's his problem, not yours, don't give her hradspace, just enjoy your Christmas, it doesn't matter if she doesn't like you, she may be educated but she sounds ignorant.

Because she's an adult???

He could talk to her about how rude it comes across, but he can't tell her no phones after dinner like she's a 10 year old!

Newgirls · 06/11/2026 16:52

Hang on - there are a lot of you - 2 parents plus 4 sons? Perhaps she needs a bit of a break from you all when she’s over. Especially if there’s some sexist vibe about her being a duchess. I imagine the banter in your home is totally normal for you but it doesn’t sound very welcoming really!

5128gap · 06/11/2026 16:56

I wouldn't have a conversation with her. It will be excruciating for you both. Because you can't plan to get to know someone, it has to happen organically through exposure to each other and being together in naturally occurring situations. Unfortunately in your case, it hasn't really took off in the way you hoped, because the 'her' you're getting to know is distant and not overly interested, so you might have to accept that. This is the DiL you've been given, and you need to do the best you can with what you have.
When she's in the room with you, I'd make some effort to draw her into the chat, but if she prefers her phone, then I'd not be worrying about it. I'd just chat to my son.
Relax in your in home with your family. Don't put her behaviour or trying to win her round front and centre. She's just one person, and provided she's not disruptive, she's just 'there' and you can carry on as normal.
As for bad mouthing people with her mum, that's not a nice trait, but if that's what they do, you could be practically perfect in every way and she'd find something to say. So just carry on being your natural self and try not to care what they might be saying.

HollyhockDays · 06/11/2026 16:56

There’s two issues here - she’s gossipy with her mum and you’re worried you’ll be the butt of that. There’s not a lot you can really do about that.

Secondly, bring a rude guest. You can either tell your son to tell her to be more sociable and put her phone away. Or tell her yourself. If she retreats to her room knock and tell her there’s a family walk / games session / movie marathon and would she like to join you.

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 17:04

HollyhockDays · 06/11/2026 16:56

There’s two issues here - she’s gossipy with her mum and you’re worried you’ll be the butt of that. There’s not a lot you can really do about that.

Secondly, bring a rude guest. You can either tell your son to tell her to be more sociable and put her phone away. Or tell her yourself. If she retreats to her room knock and tell her there’s a family walk / games session / movie marathon and would she like to join you.

Oh god don’t do this! She presumably loves the OP’s son but that doesn’t mean she should have to join in the family jollity if she doesn’t want to.

Also telling her to get off her phone is as rude as being on it.

If I was her and was spoken to like that I just would never visit.

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 17:07

ACynicalDad · 06/11/2026 16:50

The only person who can have this conversation is your son. Can you go out and do an activity together? I'm thinking wreath making or something she can't do with her phone in her hands.

The only thing worse that forced household jollity is forced jollity via outside activities

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 17:08

Mumofoneandone · 06/11/2026 16:41

Sorry, but she sounds horrible, very rude and lacking in manners when staying with you.
The name your other sons have for her is very telling!
I hope your son really sees the light and finishes with her and finds a much nicer person to be with!
Be polite to her by all means, but don't go out of your way to accommodate her.

Perhaps she is aware of how vile the other sons are about her and how her partner talks to his mother about how she gossips with hers - in which case who can blame her?

MeridianB · 06/11/2026 17:20

I suspect it’s nothing to do with you and your family, but more likely that she simply doesn’t care. She sounds rude and immature. It must be really frustrating that your son doesn’t see this bad behaviour for what it is.

I definitely think you’d be hugely escalating things by talking to her about it or banning phones. She would make a big issue out of it and expect your son to back her.

Agree with asking her what special food she would like or anything she’d like to do at Christmas - just be relaxed and breezy.

katepilar · 06/11/2026 17:21

FamingolosForDays · 06/11/2026 16:33

I think this is a really thoughtful idea. Food is the way to the heart!

I have read a story about a MIL /wife who used to ask people about how they used to spend Christmas as children and what they enjoyed. She than chose to recreate some of that for that person which worked for their family.

Writing it down I am not sure I personally would actually like that myself.

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 17:23

katepilar · 06/11/2026 17:21

I have read a story about a MIL /wife who used to ask people about how they used to spend Christmas as children and what they enjoyed. She than chose to recreate some of that for that person which worked for their family.

Writing it down I am not sure I personally would actually like that myself.

I agree - that sounds weird!

Luckyforsome23 · 06/11/2026 17:27

Try texting her your questions

katepilar · 06/11/2026 17:33

I feel for you, OP. I hate people being on phones. I get you cant relax around her. I dont think its necessarily that she doesnt like you personally, she may have generally bad manners.

HappyViewer · 06/11/2026 17:33

She could be socially anxious or very introverted. I used to hate visiting my in-laws, not because they weren’t nice but because of the back to back socialising in a big group.

Pinkflamingo10 · 06/11/2026 17:42

You say she’s well educated but she seems to have missed out on learning basic manners.
you could have a “phone creche” basket where at all the phones go over dinner time, or over family board game time etc

BillieWiper · 06/11/2026 17:47

But why does it bother you really?
She lives hours away and you barely see her?
Why would the fact that one guest you know is really insular and doesn't say much won't say much?
Just forget she's there if she's being that quiet and retreating to separate areas of the building.
You can't force him to make her different. Nor do you have to love her or have things in common.

But until she's literally telling you to go fuck yourself you just need to try and grin and bear it. If she was really loud and overbearing and dominated every conversation that would actually be far worse.

It's your home, your Xmas. You enjoy it and one slightly grouchy guest shouldn't be enough to spoil the fun.

I should know, I spent decades hosting my mum's horrible mates who had no family and were rude, demanding or sulky. But don't let them piss on your parade!

Just be welcoming and joyful and frankly screw anyone who's not feeling it. 😂😜

Daygloboo · 06/11/2026 17:49

momtoboys · 06/11/2026 14:51

My oldest son (27) has had the same girlfriend for 7 years. They live together, about 4 hours from us, which is very close to her family and likely where they will stay in the future. We are very close to my son, speak frequently, group chat almost every day, etc.

This is the first year that they are doing the alternating holidays. Thanksgiving (we are in US) at her family, Christmas at ours. She is smart, capable, well educated, high earning, and so many things that my son loves about her. She is very close to her mom and I have been regaled for years of stories from my son about how judgmental they are and that she and her mom spend all of their time judging people and making fun of people between themselves. She does not seem to want to develop a relationship with our family. She comes to visit a few times a year, we greet them happily, offer food, drink, regular visitor stuff. She is gracious, says no thank you and disappears to their bedroom mostly only to appear when they are going out. The few times she does sit with us after dinner or while sitting relaxing, she is texting the entire time. I have attempted to initiate conversation only to have her answer inquiries with one word or perhaps one sentence answers. Most of the time she doesn't even look up from her phone. My son and I had a conversation about this several months ago which went really well, I thought. I told him that we are happy that he has found someone he loves, but as his mother I am worried that he may marry someone that doesn't like his family. He said "what has she done that makes you think she doesn't like you?" My response was "nothing, but she certainly hasn't done anything to make us think she does". He said that was another way to look at things and he hadn't thought of it that way. I think he must have said something to her because for the first time ever she texted me unprompted and sent a photo of my son.

I am dreading Christmas. I know this is my problem but I am convinced that she will spend her time texting her mother listing all the ways I fail as a cook, decorator, house cleaner, etc. I get tired just thinking of topics to talk to her about.

Is it unreasonable to want to attempt to have a conversation with her about how I would like to get to know her better and maybe develop some sort of relationship?

Id just try to have as much communication with your son as possible and forget about her. She sounds rude and ignorant and underdeveloped psychologically. Not much you can do.

Overflowingbasket · 06/11/2026 17:50

She and her family sound really unpleasant. Constantly judging other people is a sign of a really nasty character. Your son should prepare himself for the time that will come when he is the one being judged. That's my rule with people like this. Its foolish to think that oneself will be the exception who does not get judged by people like this. I have learnt not to form close relationships with such people.

You can't make her be friendly and she is not someone to seek as a friend. Be polite but be glad that such an unpleasant personality is keeping herself unengaged and just get on with enjoying chatting with your son.

Swipe left for the next trending thread